- driver C who drives fast yet safe (over the speed limit like most drivers) but has to deal with:
- driver D who drives the speed limit in the fast lane, changes lanes without signaling, is essentially clueless, and forces C drivers to navigate around them.
Stunts at any speed is bad, sure, but speed can't automatically be assumed to be stunts. That's the flaw.
And can car computers tell if blinkers are on? At some point, changing without signaling is likely to be trackable if it isn't already. Ultimately, clueless driving will leave trackable indicators. This is driving, it's behavior based, and the outcomes are observable.
At any rate, I hope this makes usage-based insurance more common. I currently use MetroMile as my car insurer, which charges per mile of car usage. I'm a city-driver, my miles are insanely low. I'm glad to be benefiting from smarter, behavior-based insurance even if it is in its infancy.
You're assuming the insurance company has perfect information.
That's the problem with all of this. The insurance company isn't in the car. They don't know why you're doing what you're doing.
And the problem is you get what you measure. Changing lanes without signalling will make an accident more likely 85% of the time but make it less likely 15% of the time. If you're penalized 100% of the time then all the people who were doing the right thing in every case will now, in order to keep their insurance rates low, start doing the wrong thing 15% of the time.
Unless you don't actually tell them what you expect them to do. Then you end up creating a whole new class of crazy folklore about what to do to lower your insurance rates that people follow religiously even when it's obviously irrational.
If you want a computer to decide how to drive then get a self-driving car.
The problem is, speed limits in the US are often underposted to raise revenue and/or give the police an excuse to stop almost any driver. Certain studies have shown that drivers doing 4-to-10 MPH over the speed limit are among the safest. The slower ones are often either not paying attention, actively obstructing traffic, or impaired.
I'd be more likely to accept behavior-based insurance rates if they're based on sound traffic engineering principles rather than politics.
But there's already telltales for that: if a driver consistently drives more than 10 mph over the speed limit, they'll eventually get caught and ticketed.
That's where age & experience come into play. If a driver has 20 years of experience with no tickets nor accidents, does any of the other stuff really matter? It's not just observable, it's proof - instead of assumption.
Knowing people engage in behavior objectively quantifiable as more risky is also strong evidence of increased level of risk for that driver, not an assumption that the given individual will have a given outcome.
There is a subtlety here in correlation and causation.
>I'm sure there's people out there that drive like maniacs 90%+ of the time and haven't had an accident, but that doesn't mean they aren't significantly more likely to do so in the future.
It's not 'they', it's 'their cohort', and the apparent risk can be very sensitive to the level of detail and factors accounted for - such as nut allergies.
As long as we know the ruler IS bent - because we need some way to charge people appropriately for insurance.
I would argue it is both: the "drive like a maniac" cohort is likely to see a higher incident rate across the population, and that a given individual exhibiting "drive like a maniac" behavior is more likely to have an incident themselves vs. a given individual that does not "drive like a maniac."
This is driving in the open world, not art you create in your basement. Drivers are not fully in control of their environment, and riskier driving behaviors are risky even for fantastic drivers because they cannot account for how others will react to their "mania", to keep the vocabulary consistent.
You could chart the relationship between levels of mania and some of the unaccounted factors, like driving skill or restraint. Slippery slope ends up in a trap of having to account for everything for the sake of fairness.
yeah, sure. i totally believe that. ever actually deal with an insurance company? they pretty much do whatever the hell they want unless there's enough people willing to sue in a class action suit. this goes for consumer, business, financial, whatever.
when this becomes mainstream i will go with alternative insurance providers that do not track my driving habits even if it comes at a huge premium.
Okay fine, please explain to me how you think they would be worse with behavior-based rates than they are today. If they're just looking to bump rates for everyone on a flimsy pretext, there is nothing stopping them from pushing the price envelope as high as they can right now. Well, except the competitive environment they operate in, of course, which isn't going away even with behavior-based rates. They already do whatever they want, so this lets them do it more? It seems unlikely to me, and my early experience is incredibly positive.
Behavior-based rates can at least remove some of the mystery behind rates rather than add to it. Behavior is personally trackable, shareable, and demonstrable. Ultimately, it's a way to increase price discrimination, something I'm a fan of.
I would hate to be a good driver and be penalized for bad software/hardware. Given the track record of the auto companies (on which the insurance companies will rely), I think it's a given the software will be really shitty.
Edit: it wasn't actually teleporting, but it had me driving across fields, mountains, rivers, and the boarder all in about 1 or 2 minutes.
If the driver A drives at a speed limit, but is drunk, or 90 years old, or playing with their phone all the time, or just got their licence two days earlier, they might be actually much more likely to get into an accident than someone who is going faster than the speed limit but is in perfect mental and physical condition.
I'm not trying to excuse speeding, I'm just saying there's a hundred other factors that are just as important when judging how good a driver someone is. And I feel like insurance companies won't care - they will use the sensor data to say "hey, you accelerate really fast from the traffic lights, that must mean you are a really shitty driver and you have to pay more than other drivers!"
If there is valid statistical evidence that a certain group of people (male teenagers with divorced parents, single women in their 40's earning more than $60k a year, divorced white men in Massachusetts, whatever) is likely to behave in riskier behavior for whatever reason, you can bet an insurance company somewhere has the data and is charging accordingly.
Much better to do it on an person by person basis.
I personally agree. I think charging males more (for example) was only done because we had no way of getting more individualized data. It is all very crude and probably will be an outdated concept in 20 years.
*It is illegal to discriminate based on sex for auto insurance purposes in many countries as well as Montana. Insurance companies in most US states take your credit score into consideration (if you don't pay your credit card bill you pay more for car insurance) but this practice is illegal in a handful of states. Massachusetts is one of them, if I recall correctly.
Is that true? Can they charge me a different rate because of my race or religion?
This is a good overview:
http://nakedlaw.avvo.com/consumer-protection/why-is-it-legal...
Consider the extreme case: let's say technology allows an external observer to directly read your thoughts as they happen.[2] Hey, people that think worse things are riskier, so what's the problem if they get higher rates? If you don't want higher rates, don't think about cutting through traffic and running red lights!
I just hope no one breaches that database and learns what you think of Suzy...
[1] as a safe driver long resentful of the statistics of my demographic
[2] Because of the "control/choice" issue, assume there's a difference between deliberate and unchosen thoughts and the device only takes the former.
Sure, not every thought about murder leads to murder, and not every red light you run leads to an accident. But people that run more red lights have more accidents, and people who think about bad things more (let's posit) will do more bad things.
"Oh, you only think about murder 3 times a week? Discount!"
Still ready to let your thoughts about Suzy get archived on some hard drive?
(Imagine e.g. someone in Florida being rated for hurricane insurance on the mistaken assumption they lived in Kansas, or a cab driver rated as if the car was just used for a daily commute.)
That insight in no way contradicts the principle that a completely predictable event is not insurable, or that insurance allows distribution of the costs of an event across a class.
But I still think it's fair to call someone a freeloader if they deliberately get mixed in with a low risk class while knowing they're higher risk.
Edit: And you're right, that in the case of perfect RAA, the concept of insurance breaks down because it means you know people either will or won't experience the insured event.
However, I realized a problem.
Currently, all insurers are looking at the same demographic data. If this scheme is put into practice, then insurers will have a proprietary information on an individuals' driving habits, letting them offer discounts to good drivers. This leads to a situation where to switch to a different insurer will always cost more for a good driver, so few drivers will switch. This means that trying to switch insurers will become a signal of bad driving, so insurers will charge more to new customers. This leads to fewer and fewer people switching insurance companies, leading to decreased competition.
Interestingly enough, Geico was started by someone who successfully predicted that government employees would be less risky (the GE stands for Government Employees):
Because it's a competitive market, and if they don't offer competitive rates, other insurers will take all their market share.
I'm really not seeing how this isn't obvious. If there's a clearly more efficient way of doing insurance rates, companies can either adopt it, or die at the hands of the ones who do.
Unless, of course, the federal government mandates that insurers cover all drivers at the same rates, regardless of pre-existing reckless driving habits.
Well ratcheting premiums upward is not the only way to increase profit. Same premiums with reduced number of claims at adds to the profit too.
Even just "number of miles driven" is a strong signal.
Sort of the inverse of the self driving car problem - they follow all of the rules, all the time, and are more accident prone, even though they're not at fault for the accident.
I suppose the more important argument is not about "what's the quality of the model?" vs. "what goal is the insurance company trying to accomplish with better risk pricing?"
With respect to speed, safety comes from matching your speed to that of the surrounding traffic, even if the surrounding traffic is on average exceeding the posted limit. Road-raging vigilante behaviors by drivers intent on enforcing their (incorrect) ideas about safety (i.e., deliberately driving slowly or occupying a passing lane to try to force passing traffic to slow) is actually far more dangerous and in many states is illegal and ticketable.
And in all 50 states it is now some type of infraction to be anywhere but the rightmost lane when travelling slower than other traffic, even if by "slower" you mean "exactly the posted limit". This year-old article has some notes on the left-lane stuff, including the fact that yes, you could be ticketed for doing 65 in a 65 if the passing traffic is doing 80 and your slower driving is interfering with that:
http://www.vox.com/2014/6/16/5804590/why-you-shouldnt-drive-...
And also points out what was already well-known to everyone except vigilante traffic rangers: that doing only the speed limit, when everyone else is faster, is demonstrably unsafe.
CVC 21654:
(a) Notwithstanding the prima facie speed limits, any vehicle proceeding upon a highway at a speed less than the normal speed of traffic moving in the same direction at such time shall be driven in the right-hand lane for traffic or as close as practicable to the right-hand edge or curb, except when overtaking and passing another vehicle proceeding in the same direction or when preparing for a left turn at an intersection or into a private road or driveway.
(b) If a vehicle is being driven at a speed less than the normal speed of traffic moving in the same direction at such time, and is not being driven in the right-hand lane for traffic or as close as practicable to the right-hand edge or curb, it shall constitute prima facie evidence that the driver is operating the vehicle in violation of subdivision (a) of this section.
(AKA "Slower traffic, keep right" law)
Here is a specific law in Utah, for example: http://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title41/Chapter6A/41-6a-S704.html?v...
Several states have laws stating that slower traffic must keep to the right, but it's not necessarily dependent upon speed limit.
What's really frustrating and unsafe though is when drivers try to merge onto the freeway going 35 or 45 and traffic is going 70 in a 70 or 75 zone.
It brings in more profit than making B alone pay extra. All that it requires is some half-assed justification, which can easily be fabricated.
Discriminating against customers on the basis of driving habits that they have control over, like how fast they drive, or how hard they swerve, is completely fine.
If driver A drives safely at the speed limit, and driver B constantly pulls stunts at speeds well over the speed limit, B is much more likely to get into an accident than A. Why should A have his premiums raised just to subsidize B's voluntary driving habits?
By making B pay for the costs of his unsafe driving habits, and rewarding A for his safe driving habits, this feels like a great marketplace improvement.