Much better to do it on an person by person basis.
I personally agree. I think charging males more (for example) was only done because we had no way of getting more individualized data. It is all very crude and probably will be an outdated concept in 20 years.
*It is illegal to discriminate based on sex for auto insurance purposes in many countries as well as Montana. Insurance companies in most US states take your credit score into consideration (if you don't pay your credit card bill you pay more for car insurance) but this practice is illegal in a handful of states. Massachusetts is one of them, if I recall correctly.
Is that true? Can they charge me a different rate because of my race or religion?
This is a good overview:
http://nakedlaw.avvo.com/consumer-protection/why-is-it-legal...
If there is valid statistical evidence that a certain group of people (male teenagers with divorced parents, single women in their 40's earning more than $60k a year, divorced white men in Massachusetts, whatever) is likely to behave in riskier behavior for whatever reason, you can bet an insurance company somewhere has the data and is charging accordingly.