News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by hwstar on Monday January 04, 2016 @02:33PM (#10837903)
It shouldn't be called retirement. It is probably more like a temporary hiatus.

Also, it isn't just 20-somethings. US employment has been somewhat of a raw deal in the last 15 years for all age groups. Some people have realized that working to live just isn't worth it.

There's a lot of bullshit work assigned in a typical corporate job, and this 'impedance mismatch' forces some people with financial strength to quit and do what they really want to do in life even if that means living on a much lower annual income.

Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by krisdol on Monday January 04, 2016 @02:56PM (#10838062)
They're defining retirement as "you don't have a job and aren't looking for one", which is an egregious stretch of a definition. They're not financially independent or retired, they've given up looking for work worth doing.
Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by loki540 on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:15PM (#10838208)
No, that's not it - of the people 20-24 who "don't have a job and aren't looking for them", the number of people who said it was because they were retired doubled. Other answers were "disabled" and "staying at home". That being said, I don't see how anyone can retire at 20-24 - if it was 30-34 it'd make a lot more sense. . .
Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by nostrademons on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:51PM (#10838479)
There's no category for "I believe that the notion of 'lifetime employment until age 65, upon which you get to enjoy the life you've saved up for if you still have the health for it' is outdated, and choose to take my retirement in chunks of a year or two interspersed by periods of productive, lucrative work."

One of the side effects of moving to a fluid labor market is that you can basically get a job whenever you want. Moreover, you're forced to, and you're forced to stay up-to-date with market conditions so you can get a new job at any time. If you have to make this bargain anyway, who's to say that those jobs need to be contiguous? Why not take a job paying $90K for two years, live as if you had a job paying $60K, and then take a year off to travel?

My wife and I both did variants of this (her: bond trader => Peace Corps, me: financial software => startup => Google => startup), but we took our downtime in socially sanctioned, labeled ways and so don't fit into the "retired" statistics. But what about, say, the friend of mine who interned on a salmon fishing boat, took a job in economic consulting, did a multi-year sex tour of Southeast Asia, and now runs a hedge fund there? Or the friend of mine who runs a profitable SaaS remotely and is now doing Hacker Paradise, traveling the world? Where do they fit into the employment statistics? "Retired" is a lot better descriptor than "disabled" or "staying at home".

The numbers in the BLS report were on the order of 1-2%; I could easily believe that 1-2% of 20-24 year olds are doing gap years, or have software businesses that generate passive income, or have worked for a year or two at a lucrative profession and now saved up enough to travel the world.

Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by DannoHung on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:24PM (#10838273)
Were those the only buckets? It might simply be confusion if they wanted to answer: "Can't find a job worth a damn"
Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by pjc50 on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:31PM (#10838325)
I suspect it's more like "2% of people are cynical enough about the survey to tick 'retired' just to mess with the data".
Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by mrec on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:04PM (#10838116)
If they're neither working nor financially independent, what are they living on? Not a rhetorical question; I don't live in the US, and am a bit vague about its welfare system.

Is this essentially about people moving back in with family?

Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by prostoalex on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:30PM (#10838310)
Most likely they live with other family members, either parents or elderly family who wouldn't mind a helping hand around the house in exchange for free rent.

Previous generations had two reasons to move out and rent on their own - marriage and health insurance. Nowadays Americans are marrying at much lower rate, and parents can keep kids on their insurance until the age 26.

So maybe this is the new normal, and the previous status quo of 20-something moving out and getting a job immediately was a distortion.

Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by IkmoIkmo on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:27PM (#10838296)
Can be anything.

For one, they could actually be looking at jobs but passively. i.e. if you check the newspaper or websites for jobs, but didn't apply to any, you're not counted as 'looking for a job', so you're not unemployed either even though you obviously are. Passive job search is not included in the figures.

Other than that, note that unemployment is measured in periods of 4 weeks. i.e. if you have a consulting gig for 8 months, and are then out of a freelance job for 5 weeks (after which you get another gig), and get interviewed during that time, you'd be unemployed, despite the fact you may have earned a normal annual income that year.

Anyway, that's just to say that unemployment numbers may be off. It doesn't answer your question yet.

But indeed there are also people who can't provide for themselves and are considered unemployed. A lot of them live at their parents, another significant chunk is simply living on debt. Creditcard debt is huge in the US.

Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by fapjacks on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:17PM (#10838220)
We have nothing approaching basic income or housing that anybody could live off reasonably. Either these kids are living with parents, living off parent's money, or are living out of their cars. There is no in between here. I suspect that it's the former, which is really giving an awful impression about what is possible in the States. The vast majority of Americans need to work their asses off just to make rent. If you don't do that, you are either living off someone else's money, or don't have a house. End of story.
Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by drzaiusapelord on Monday January 04, 2016 @04:00PM (#10838561)
>We have nothing approaching basic income or housing that anybody could live off reasonably.

State welfare programs, section 8, food stamps, "earned income credit", medicaid, SSI, TANF, SNAP, etc. There's lots of aid in the US. Over 100m people nationally are on some level of means tested welfare. That's pushing one third of this nation. National spending accounts for $1T in welfare spending. That's slightly less than Mexico's entire GDP; a country of 122m.

http://object.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/pubs/pdf/PA694.p...

The narrative of the US not having any welfare is asinine. In fact, the spending is staggering. When I lived in poorer neighborhoods in Chicago, most of my neighbors were on a fair amount of welfare to the point where they never had to bother getting a job. If you're willing to live in an urban area and live a modest lifestyle its largely trivial to game welfare benefits for a living.

Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by jrjarrett on Monday January 04, 2016 @05:22PM (#10839177)
>>>We have nothing approaching basic income or housing that anybody could live off reasonably.

>State welfare programs, section 8, food stamps, "earned income credit", medicaid, SSI, TANF, SNAP, etc. There's lots of aid in the US.

I question this response with the qualifier of "living off reasonably."

I'm certainly lucky enough not to need any of that, but from what I understand, it's barely subsistence existence.

Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by krisdol on Monday January 04, 2016 @06:01PM (#10839437)
I really don't think that cato is in the ballpark of being an objective source on welfare, though I don't have a reason to disagree with the number you mentioned. I'm having trouble calculating a max SNAP/food stamps benefit that would exceed $194/month for an individual in urban NYC. Is that modest? Sure, I bet there are some people who are satisfied living off of public welfare alone. They exist in every country, and probably in greater numbers in more-socialized countries. I'm unconvinced that the problem is big enough to warrant cutting any public-welfare programs. Some level of "mooching" is expected.

For me, when I was growing up on food stamps and welfare as a refugee, I know that it wasn't a level of living my family wanted to settle at. Evidently, neither does most of the country. The assistance helped us get settled and avoid a situation that surely would have resulted in us being thrown to the streets.

Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by noddingham on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:26PM (#10838290)
Exactly. I don't care what they are saying, they are simply clever enough to say "retired" instead of admitting what their situation really is.
Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by sp332 on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:16PM (#10838210)
Nope, that's the definition for being out of the workforce. They asked those people why they weren't looking, and 2% of them said that they were retired.
Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by bryanlarsen on Monday January 04, 2016 @04:08PM (#10838621)
That's the definition in the article for "out of the workforce".
Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by jazzyk on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:04PM (#10838115)
A lot of people found a way to live on low income obtained from parents, disability benefits, temp jobs, renting out grandma's apartment, etc. Sharing apartments or living with their parents, etc.

Given that a lot of job growth in the economic "recovery" (especially for younger people) has been in the minimum wage range, I don't blame them. If you can't even pay the most basic bills from a minimum-wage job to live independently, why bother?

Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by thecosas on Monday January 04, 2016 @02:58PM (#10838075)
Could also just be a statistical anomaly. Saying it doubled in that age range, it could even come down to "this is what I wish the situation was".

Thew title of this post is a little misleading and the wrong question to ask.

Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by such_a_casual on Monday January 04, 2016 @02:50PM (#10838018)
> It shouldn't be called retirement.

In personal finance it's called, "Financial Independence." Which basically means you aren't necessarily done working for the rest of your life, just that working has become completely optional.

more info: https://www.reddit.com/r/financialindependence

Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by jazzyk on Monday January 04, 2016 @02:57PM (#10838065)
"...you aren't necessarily done working for the rest of your life, just that working has become completely optional"

Optional - as long as you live in your parents' basement and don't want to start a family. :-)

Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by toomuchtodo on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:47PM (#10838452)
> Optional - as long as you live in your parents' basement and don't want to start a family. :-)

I think this is where there's a fundamental disconnect in cultures.

I'm 33, my wife 31. We're about to have kids, and we've strongly considered moving in with my parents, not only to spend more time with them, but also to provide care when necessary as well as have their help watching and raising our children.

Just because we're well off (we're financially independent) doesn't mean we need an expensive mortgage in the suburbs to raise our family, nor does it mean we can't live with family or have them live with us.

America is far more broken than I expected.

Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by snowwrestler on Monday January 04, 2016 @05:30PM (#10839232)
No one needs to move to the suburbs and take on an expensive mortgage to raise a family. An apartment or small condo is a fine place to raise a family, and millions of Americans do just that.

It's just a cultural thing: many Americans prize their independence and privacy, so grown kids want to get away from their parents.

And vice versa, by the way! My parents definitely would not want me to move my family to their house--they love us and enjoy visits, but are enjoying their own independent lives too.

Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by jazzyk on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:56PM (#10838527)
I come from a culture with close multi-generational ties, so I don't think there is anything wrong with your potential decision at all - if it is your _choice_, not _necessity_
Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by toomuchtodo on Monday January 04, 2016 @04:27PM (#10838778)
I definitely agree it should be by choice, but that's only going to change in the US if workers start fighting for higher wages, more labor regulation, and other initiatives that value labor above capital.

Otherwise, prepare to move to the basement.

Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by krisdol on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:01PM (#10838088)
Dependence is the new independence!
Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by lfam on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:23PM (#10838271)
My friends called it "pretirement".
Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by a-priori on Monday January 04, 2016 @04:21PM (#10838727)
The premise of "financial independence" is that you save enough enough money and reduce your expenses enough that you can live for the rest of your life on your investments. Whether you choose to retire or not is up to you, but the point is that you are 'independent' of sources of income to fund your lifestyle. For example, you could reduce your working hours to spend more time on family or hobbies, or take long unpaid sabbaticals, or bootstrap a business, or just quit working entirely.

It turns out that you can safely withdraw 3% a year indefinitely (from a portfolio composed of a mix of stocks and bonds in low-fee index funds) without reducing the the value of the investments in the long run. A higher rate of 4% will decline on average over time but can be enough to survive multi-decade retirements, so that's often a more realistic target. There are tools (e.g. http://www.firecalc.com/, http://www.cfiresim.com/) to run simulations based on historical market data.

At 4% you need a portfolio equal to 25 years worth of expenses. Let's say you spend $60k a year in today's dollars. This works out to a monthly budget of $5k. If you can save $1.5M then that will pay your expenses for 30 years, without any other income, with a 94% chance of success. At 3% you need 33 years of expenses, or $2.0M, and that has a 100% chance of success. This is all based on past data of course (past performance does not imply future performance and all that).

These are large sums of money, but it's possible for most professional workers, and especially couples, to accumulate them if they are fairly frugal and make a decent income. The time required entirely depends on what portion of your income you can save (see http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2012/01/13/the-shockingly-sim...). Assuming a constant income, as well as constant expenses while working and after, if you save 50% of your household income it will take 17 years to reach the 4% level. So start at age 30 and you'll be done by 47.

Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by geodel on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:33PM (#10838331)
Sometimes I wonder whether the next generation will even have parents who have houses with basements available for free/cheap. Maybe basements would be rented out to support family expenses. Or their parents could be living in much smaller places with no basements. Lately I have seen a few ads where owners are looking to rent out basements to families as cheaper alternative to apartments rather than as something where single folks would stay for short durations.
Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by SonicSoul on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:50PM (#10838476)
There's a lot of bullshit work assigned in a typical corporate job

What jobs don't have that? As if startups magically solved this problem by giving employees nothing but innovative thought provoking problems and everything else is handled by worker elfs. No, every place has its share of bs work. the difference is that a portion (majority?) of corporate folks stopped caring to actually solve problems. Instead they do the minimum to keep their jobs. You can do the same thing every day, waste 30% of time chatting with coworkers, another 30% on the net, and then complain about how boring your job is. I've yet to see corporations that didn't have good problems to solve.

Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by cobaltblue on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:58PM (#10838544)
Almost every not-typical-big-corporate job has less bullshit work assigned than the lot of BS assigned to typical big corporate job workers. Startups and even mid-size companies don't magically solve the problem of having to do BS work, there's typically just a lot less of it. When what you do or don't do is all up to you, the portion of BS work goes to 0 because you don't want to do it so you don't. Companies fall on a BS scale that correlates to their size and determines how much BS work you don't want to do that you have to do anyway (or rather, you always have a choice, but if you don't do it then you're fired/the company goes out of business/a customer is pissed off and sues you/etc. which makes it not much of a choice at all).
Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by SonicSoul on Monday January 04, 2016 @04:20PM (#10838722)
I've worked at larger co's (1k+ employees) where BS work was actively eradicated in order to have breathing space to move forward and innovate. This is possible but requires vigilant management and hiring the kind of people that want to make a difference. There's more red tape at corps which may be part of the BS you're pointing out but even that was actively fought. I see it similar to technical debt. It's easy to accumulate if you're not careful and easy to live with at first but will slowly come back and take you down.
Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by cobaltblue on Monday January 04, 2016 @04:30PM (#10838807)
I would describe your experience as atypical, wouldn't you? Just like Valve's nearly-flat management is atypical and requires a certain mesh of personalities and pruning to work at all. Counterexamples exist, it's not a perfect correlation, but unless they're plentiful they don't really change the typical.
Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by SonicSoul on Monday January 04, 2016 @04:47PM (#10838941)
You do have a point. I suppose that is why you generally make more working at a corp, to either deal with the BS or ideally figure out a way to solve it which is never easy. All I was saying is that there are ways around it and long term solutions that work if you're willing to sink your teeth in and try to improve the status quo. The feeling of looking back and seeing that 80% of BS from last year was eliminated can be quite satisfying even if you're not at a game changing startup.
Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by NoMoreNicksLeft on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:31PM (#10838320)
What's the alternative, "mooching to live"?
Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by hwstar on Monday January 04, 2016 @04:58PM (#10839020)
Working long enough to save enough money to have good investments to live off of so that you can say "screw you" to employers which offer mediocre jobs and working environments.
Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by Nadya on Monday January 04, 2016 @05:03PM (#10839059)
Financial Independence and accepting to live off $22-35k annually. Unless you have a larger investment pool or a well-above-average and stable ROI to increase that beyond 35k...
Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by tastynacho on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:09PM (#10838152)
> There's a lot of bullshit work assigned in a typical corporate job

yeah its called being young and being inexperienced. Gotta put the time in before you're qualified to enjoy the meat..

Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by creshal on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:20PM (#10838243)
Which was true for the last generation, when you were supposed – and did – put up with the bullshit, because the company would care for you and offer you employment until retirement, and afterwards offer an adequate pension.

Nowadays, in far too many companies all you get for hard work is getting downsized. I can't blame people for not wanting to put up with that, and there's not nearly enough reasonable companies around.

Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by CountSessine on Monday January 04, 2016 @05:34PM (#10839264)
Which was true for the last generation, when you were supposed – and did – put up with the bullshit, because the company would care for you and offer you employment until retirement, and afterwards offer an adequate pension.

I'm 40 now and I certainly didn't get a company to "care for" me; that promise went away generations ago. The last time anyone was hiring on those terms was maybe the 70's. Three generations have gone by since anyone pretended that lifetime employment is actually still a thing.

Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by hsitz on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:43PM (#10838411)
You sound like a twenty-something whose historical perspective is lacking. It's been several generations, probably more, since that kind of job (expected lifetime employment with pension) has been widespread.
Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by hsitz on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:37PM (#10838370)
You sound like a twenty-something whose historical perspective is lacking. It's been at least several generations, probably more, since that kind of job (expected lifetime employment with pension) has been widespread.
Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by sp332 on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:17PM (#10838221)
And with no guarantee of upward mobility, why would someone put up with it?
Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by CountSessine on Monday January 04, 2016 @05:28PM (#10839224)
Switching companies every 3 or 4 years is the new normal - you can't expect to ever get promoted within the same company. There's still upward mobility - its just that it's within an industry, not an individual company.
Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by sp332 on Monday January 04, 2016 @06:53PM (#10839788)
But I'm still a lot less likely to accept crap work just to hope that I get promoted later. The expected value of the upside is smaller, so should the downside be.
Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by CountSessine on Monday January 04, 2016 @07:07PM (#10839877)
Agreed, but is that necessarily a bad thing?

If your labour has market value and you're taking crap from your employer, shop around for a new job. The other way of saying that we don't have lifetime employment anymore is that we don't have to suffer through lifetime employment anymore.

You don't have to tolerate stultifying bureaucracy. You don't have to suffer nitwit bosses. You don't have to deal with impossible coworkers. With an open labour market, you can work where you like.

A couple of days ago someone posted patio11's blog article on his experience working in Japan as a salaryman. The other side of the security of lifetime employment over there is that you have to tolerate horrible working conditions at your lifetime employer, and the labour market is so rigid that if you ever leave your employer, no one else will ever hire you.

Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by pc86 on Monday January 04, 2016 @04:05PM (#10838604)
Nothing is guaranteed, so I'm not sure what the lack of one has to do with anything.
Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by twothamendment on Monday January 04, 2016 @03:25PM (#10838286)
Working to live just isn't worth it? What does that leave you with?

When I started working I worked jobs I didn't want to do for the rest of my life, but it wasn't just about the money. I leaned skills, learned to work and learned I better find a new, better job - even if it is only slightly better. Some jobs only leave you with one important thing - a work ethic, and that is what gets you a better job, someday. I know, I'm just one person, but that is my story and I'm sticking to it. Maybe it will only get one person off their butt and doing something they don't enjoy.

Re:Why Are 20-Somethings Retiring? by creshal on Monday January 04, 2016 @04:06PM (#10838612)
How long are people going to pretend that the lack of full employment for now close to 40 years everywhere across the globe is the fault of people being "too lazy" to work?

You can't fix globalization and automation with personal work ethics.