But the wierd thing is that in terms of cargo tons carried, the larger ships pollute less only because the marginal cost of fuel of carrying another container is lower than the marginal cost of adding another ship.
So the crappy polluting ships are having an unknown effect on the oceans but having less and less of an effect as more and more cargo is carried by fewer and fewer ships.
Everyone and his mother focuses on cars. Even a 50% reduction on new cars will take DECADES until a meaningful impact on the total car emissions! Old cars get resold to Africa or other poorer continents, so the impact of new cars is next to zero!
Meanwhile, the container, cruise and other heavy ship industry belches emissions on multiple orders of magnitude than these savings. Fix fifteen fucking ships and you save in a single year more pollutants than you could save in a decade by stripping 10% of worldwide car emissions.
However, car emission testing programs already exist which force the driver to do repairs to their existing car.
Pollution deaths are still mostly a local/regional problem, so fixing ship emissions is a problem for port cities, while fixing car emissions is a problem for everyone who lives near a major road.
> However, car emission testing programs already exist which force the driver to do repairs to their existing car.
Repairs, yes. But repairs only set the car back to whatever standard applied when it got introduced. Retrofitting is theoretically possible, but at a huge expense to the car owner. And tbh I rather see huge shipping co.s having to pay for upgrading their ships than the often poor people stuck owning a beat-up car.
> while fixing car emissions is a problem for everyone who lives near a major road.
Problem is that the only real fix is diverting the traffic or eliminating it altogether. Due to the high percentage of old cars on the road new emissions standards are useless for immediate fixes.
"Recently, officials in Milan temporarily barred cars from the city; in Rome, too, persistent smog has forced the authorities to limit the use of private vehicles. Back in March, Paris was enveloped in a gray cloud of choking fumes that obscured the Eiffel Tower for hours and briefly earned the French capital the title of the world’s most polluted city, beating out even Beijing. An air quality expert in Britain reported that much of it was “stale diesel” from traffic emissions generated in European cities."
Indeed, but no matter how you look at the data (and where), stuff like banning cars from roads is a placebo measure, given the slow share of cars in said pollutants.
The most problematic point, very often overlooked, is that factory chimneys (and, to a lesser degree, ship chimneys) belch their smoke in higher air, which means that the pollutants in the smoke can fly for hundreds of kilometers before coming down on the earth and causing problems.
Also, the entire purpose of a chimney is to spread the emissions over a larger area...
> the dispersion of pollutants at higher altitudes can reduce their impact on the immediate surroundings. In the case of chemically aggressive output, a sufficiently tall chimney can allow for partial or complete self-neutralization of airborne chemicals before they reach ground level. The dispersion of pollutants over a greater area can reduce their concentrations and facilitate compliance with regulatory limits. [0]
It is certainly true that stack emissions can have a significant health impact (for example coal power stations in China). But there are also places where the effect is less significant as the ambient level is considered to be safe. Vehicle emissions can cause local levels to be much higher.
I agree that certain sources are popularly ignored, but that is not a reason to also ignore vehicle emissions.
The problem is: vehicles have a freaking high life time if they're not destroyed in accidents. Even if all new cars by tomorrow were electric, it'd take years for these new cars to replace the old cars (and thus solving the problem of local pollution).
To make stuff worse, old cars are usually exported to Africa (http://www.zeit.de/auto/2010-01/auto-export-afrika) where they basically run until they cannot be patched up any more and of course, once e.g. a soot filter breaks down in Africa, no one will replace it.
All this "uuh our vehicles must be cleaner" is just bla bla of the industry to sell more new (and, because of more complex technology, more expensive!) cars. The actual impact of these measures is next to zero because of a car's afterlife in Africa or wherever.
Mandating proper emission filtering on all factories around a city helps immediately, mandating stricter emissions on new cars does nothing at all.
Only if you grow a unit of mass of wood at the same rate at which you burn it. Otherwise the stove actively transfers carbon from forests to atmosphere.
Kraków in Poland is ranked as one of the worst cities in Europe in terms of air quality with these pellets as a leading cause.
Source: http://www.krakowpost.com/6285/2015/11/krakows-air-quality-a...
If so, whatever is true of wood stoves is true of them, as far as carbon neutrality. It's the same resource. I guess burning wood is 'carbon neutral'? I guess, unlike fossil fuels, it is 'sustainable', in the sense that more can be grown?
It can still be awfully polluting. I think most modern pellet burning stoves actually emit less pollution than burning straight wood, because they burn more efficiently. But 'less' does not mean 'not'.
(was: citation needed)
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10716102
"15 Biggest Ships Create More Pollution Than All Cars in the World (2013)"
http://www3.epa.gov/climatechange/ghgemissions/sources/agric...
I also wonder about humans vs agriculture for gas emissions. What's worse?
The problems are ships (which burn stuff that's essentially waste and generally have no form of emissions treatments [1]), locomotives (these burn diesel, but again, the vast fleet of old diesel locos doesn't carry any adequate filters [2]), wood furnaces (in poor countries, where anything that burns is used to heat and cook [3]), and factories where no money is available to get their emissions under control ([3]).
Also, to clarify, I'm not after greenhouse gases, but after the stuff that actually kills people. Greenhouse emissions are nasty but as others have noted, agriculture is to blame here and not cars or anything else.
[0]: http://www.gizmag.com/shipping-pollution/11526/
[1]: see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuel_oil#Environmental_issues
[2]: http://www.russfrei-fuers-klima.de/themen/schienenverkehr/ (german unfortunately)
[3]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2013_Eastern_China_smog#Causes (though I have to admit, it's coal, not wood, but the result is the same)