Regardless, it would be interesting to start with CO2 rather than coal. But can it be sucked up from the atmosphere efficiently and in mass quantities?
1. CO2 dissolves into their fluids
2. The CO2 is almost immediately next to the places that is going to use it
3. Since the Calvin Cycle is distributed, they don't have to collect and concentrate the CO2
4. A lot of surface area on the cellular level to absorb CO2.
I'm reading http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/prospects-for-dire... and it's unfortunate that "Each machine would require roughly 1.1 megajoule of electricity for pumping and compressing per kilogram of CO2 captured."
Making a power plant as large as a small forest is just unrealistic, and would not come close to being powerful enough.
That's why I suggested carbon from coal instead of CO2 - it's just not practical to get it from air.
All we really have to do is reduce CO2 emissions, it's not necessary to eliminate them.
It's not easy to get co2 in bulk, and methanol has no advantages over methane (for this process). You need the exact same amount of carbon.
Electrical transmission will lose you anywhere from 1%-1.5% per 100 miles depending on the voltage you step up to. Transmitting from the Sahara to the places where the load is gets you to rather large resistive losses.
Also, there are generation losses. A traditional heliostat boiler + turbine will get you about 15-20% effficiency. then you have to shunt the waste heat somewhere in a place with very little fresh water. Oops. PV doesn't get you much better, with about 18% efficiency, but you do solve the need for coolant, at the cost of another problem: Sahara dust on your panels.
The OP talks about using the thermal output from heliostats directly, which would probably (like you, I haven't done the math) be more efficient in fuels production than 15-20%, although you do have the coolant problem again.
One of us should do the math :) Until then, my intuition is that liquid fuels production from such a remote location would probably be more efficient.
http://mobile.abc.net.au/news/2015-11-12/renewable-hydrogen-...
The mere fact that LNG (liquid natural gas, at -180 degrees Celsius) is already being shipped across the worlds oceans today, supports the notion you are questioning.
And so what? I said that, did you not read what I wrote?
I'll quote it for you: "this will greatly reduce CO2 emissions, even though it's not completely zero."
> more efficient
That is way underestimating it, it's a fraction of the CO2 output of any other fuel. By far most of the energy comes from the sun, only a small amount comes from the coal. And it's pollution free since all the heavy metals in coal are captured at the source.
It also fits in well with existing technology since there don't exist any other ways of transporting fuel in bulk except hydrocarbons. There simply doesn't exist any other way of doing it.
Have you ever heard the saying "The perfect is the enemy of the good?"
Trying to be eliminate CO2 entirely is impossible, if you hold out for that you'll do nothing whatsoever.
But don't make electricity, make hydrocarbons using the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fischer%E2%80%93Tropsch_proces...
Ship water and coal, and return with mixed hydrocarbons, then distribute them all over the world. You thermalize (rather than electrolyze) the water to get hydrogen, then react it with the carbon from the coal.
Build a large pipeline to the nearest port to transport the material rather than trucking it.
The leftover oxygen can be sold, or more likely just released.
Since hydrogen releases much more energy (per atom) than carbon when burned, and since since hydrogen outnumbers the carbon in the final product, this will greatly reduce CO2 emissions, even though it's not completely zero.
Capturing heat from the sun is much easier and cheaper than electricity.