News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Walmart Pay by Keverw on Thursday December 10, 2015 @12:28PM (#10711886)
Looks like Walmart doesn't take Apple Pay or Android pay after a quick Google search. After the whole CurrentC thing, I don't think I'd trust any store owned payment apps. I thought the whole goal of Apple Pay was to simplify things, then all these stores want to make their own versions. To much fragmentation in the mobile payment space, better to just carry a regular major credit card, at least it's accepted almost everywhere universally.
Re:Walmart Pay by Shivetya on Thursday December 10, 2015 @02:34PM (#10712816)
I have read more than one article that many don't use Apple pay either. I have it and honestly have no reason to use it because credit cards just work. It would be one thing if fraud was prevalent and using your credit card was difficult but that has never been the case.

I still don't understand the business case other than trying to open a new revenue stream because it certainly wasn't solving a problem

Re:Walmart Pay by mikeash on Thursday December 10, 2015 @03:29PM (#10713216)
I use Apple Pay sometimes. It's somewhat easier than using a card, which is a nice little advantage.

Unfortunately, Apple Pay is suffering from the wrong end of network effects. Support is far from ubiquitous, so you don't know whether any given transaction will support it. You can look for the NFC logo, but some places with the logo still don't support it. At that point, it's easier to whip out the card by default. If I've been to a place before and know they take it, I'll usually use it, but there aren't many such places for me.

Re:Walmart Pay by Symbiote on Friday December 11, 2015 @05:07AM (#10716239)
Apple Pay in the UK is limited to £30 (like all contactless transactions). Is it the same in the US?

Because I don't see how the phone can be much quicker when plastic cards support the same contactless transactions, and have no buttons to fiddle with.

Re:Walmart Pay by mikeash on Friday December 11, 2015 @09:02AM (#10717123)
I'm not aware of any limits in the US, but it could just be that I haven't spent enough money in a transaction to encounter them.

The phone can be quicker than a plastic card because the phone is more convenient to reach. It's just in my pocket. Reach in, thumb on home button, put near terminal, approved, put phone away. With a card, I have to get it out of my wallet too. Not a big deal, but not as smooth. (Plus, with today's addictive smartphones and short attention spans, half the time my phone is already in my hand at this time.)

Strictly speaking you can leave the card in your wallet and just hold the whole wallet to the terminal. But this only works if you have exactly one contactless card (or if you don't care which card pays). Unfortunately the US is moving away from such cards. I used to have two or three, but I just checked my wallet and out of the eight payment cards I have in there, none of them support NFC. Sad.

Re:Walmart Pay by Zikes on Thursday December 10, 2015 @02:42PM (#10712877)
Presumably it's more secure as it shouldn't expose your credit card number to the point of sale. Given the number of major hacks in that area in recent years, that should really be the #1 touted feature of such "X Pay" systems.
Re:Walmart Pay by RussianCow on Thursday December 10, 2015 @02:46PM (#10712913)
EMV chips more or less solve this problem, though, they just haven't caught on here in the US yet.
Re:Walmart Pay by jonknee on Thursday December 10, 2015 @03:56PM (#10713392)
They're slow though. EMV is being rolled out in the US and it will fail because it's slower than a swipe or a tap.
Re:Walmart Pay by serge2k on Thursday December 10, 2015 @07:36PM (#10714731)
It won't fail, because the card companies want it and you aren't going to be given the option to swipe.

The US is way behind on this, it's ridiculous.

So is chip + signature, but that's a different argument.

Re:Walmart Pay by joosters on Thursday December 10, 2015 @04:19PM (#10713555)
When chip+pin rolled out in the UK, it noticeably sped up checkouts, it is certainly faster than signing.
Re:Walmart Pay by jonknee on Thursday December 10, 2015 @04:26PM (#10713596)
The US does a lot of swipe+pin or just swipe, but the EMV process itself takes a long time (regardless of a PIN or signing afterwards):

http://www.lowcards.com/emv-transactions-slow-37884

Compared to Apple/Android Pay it's painfully slow, but it's also noticeably slower than swiping.

Re:Walmart Pay by rconti on Thursday December 10, 2015 @05:41PM (#10714129)
Yup. Comment below yours says EMV is fast, but it's just not. You need to stand there and wait with your card in the read for for the processing step. Maybe not 5 seconds, but a non-trivial amount of time. With a swipe, you'd have your card back in your wallet as the authentication was completing.

If we had chip+pin it would be a different story, but because we have to sign, the EMV+sign process is slower than swipe+sign.

Re:Walmart Pay by joosters on Thursday December 10, 2015 @04:58PM (#10713804)
That page is just plain wrong. You can put the card into a reader, type your PIN in, and get your card back almost straight away. 5 seconds is possible if you don't forget your PIN!

The process can be slower if the retailer uses an older system that hasn't got a permanent network connection. With some ancient terminals, you could hear a modem dialing up and talking to the bank. That was slow, but luckily those kind of terminals are now rare.

Re:Walmart Pay by mikeash on Thursday December 10, 2015 @07:55PM (#10714806)
When swiping, my process is: swipe, put card back in wallet, put wallet back in pocket, wait for transaction to complete, go. (About 90% of my card transactions don't require a signature, because they're below the threshold for that.)

When using a chip, my process is: insert card, wait for transaction to complete, remove card, put everything away, go.

You'll notice that putting stuff away happens in parallel with the transaction in the first case, but they're in series in the second case.

It may be reasonably quick, but it's still noticeably slower than swiping. It's not a big deal, but it's just one of those little annoyances.

Re:Walmart Pay by profmonocle on Thursday December 10, 2015 @05:40PM (#10714126)
This is anecdotal, of course - but it's been much slower than swiping at every store I've used it at. These stores were using the exact same terminals for swiping just a few months ago, so it's not the network. Hopefully it's just crappy hardware in the terminals that's not optimized for EMV.

Edit: Swiping used to take 1-2 seconds to process, EMV seems to take about 10.

Re:Walmart Pay by mdp on Thursday December 10, 2015 @05:54PM (#10714219)
That page is specifically talking about EMV in the US, and for whatever reason, I've never seen a EMV 'dip' that takes less than 5-10 seconds here. Target for example has consistently been around 10 seconds every time I've used EMV there and I doubt they are using dial-up.
Re:Walmart Pay by jonathankoren on Thursday December 10, 2015 @05:55PM (#10714231)
I've yet to have to put in a pin when I've used my chipped credit card in the US. In fact, I don't even know what the pins are on my credit card, just my debit/atm card.

Worse yet, not all the chip enabled readers have the chip part enabled. So you can stick your card in, wait, and then realize you have to swipe. Otherwise, you swipe, get the suprisingly aggressive BZZZRT sound, and then use the chip reader and wait at least 5 seconds while it authenticates.

I'll time it at the local Target. It's slow.

Re:Walmart Pay by jonknee on Thursday December 10, 2015 @06:22PM (#10714380)
It's not wrong, it really is slow. It may be different in other places, but in the US it is slow. Still depends on the store (besides network connections there are tons of different hardware setups), but it is never as fast as swiping.

In terms of speed from fastest to slowest: Apple/Adroid, swipe, swipe and sign, swipe and PIN, dip and sign.

Re:Walmart Pay by ctdonath on Thursday December 10, 2015 @05:25PM (#10714019)
In many places in USA, chip cards take significantly longer than swiping - like 10-30 seconds.
Re:Walmart Pay by jonknee on Thursday December 10, 2015 @06:24PM (#10714390)
It's really astonishing that the credit card companies thought that mandating a much slower process was going to work. Should be a huge boon for Apple/Android Pay though.
Re:Walmart Pay by serge2k on Thursday December 10, 2015 @07:37PM (#10714737)
What's astonishing is how far behind the rest of the world the US is in adopting the technology.
Re:Walmart Pay by ctdonath on Friday December 11, 2015 @02:17PM (#10719187)
That's a problem with being first adopter: the considerable investment in early infrastructure leaves you with early infrastructure which is hard & expensive to replace, contrasted with later adopters who take advantage of scale, lessons, and bypassing incremental steps.
Re:Walmart Pay by cballard on Thursday December 10, 2015 @06:25PM (#10714398)
What is the purpose of the signature, anyways? Mine never looks anywhere close to the same as before, and most of the readers at the bad grocery store next to my apartment just select seemingly random pixels anyways when you touch it.

Is this seriously a security measure? Even if it did matter, it's on the back of the card anyways, for someone to copy!

Why not just get rid of it?

Re:Walmart Pay by usaphp on Thursday December 10, 2015 @03:04PM (#10713047)
All of my credit card companies and banks issued me new "chipped" cards within a month or so without my request, so I am guessing they are tryingto take it serious now
Re:Walmart Pay by abakker on Thursday December 10, 2015 @03:13PM (#10713111)
FWIW, the transaction time using the chip to authorize vs apple pay is night and day. The Apple pay swipe is quick and you can put the phone back in your pocket. The chip card has to linger through the authorization process and makes the whole thing feel slow.
Re:Walmart Pay by jcheng on Thursday December 10, 2015 @03:22PM (#10713167)
EMV liability shift is why both banks and retailers suddenly got serious: http://www.emv-connection.com/understanding-the-2015-u-s-fra...
Re:Walmart Pay by Swizec on Thursday December 10, 2015 @03:11PM (#10713104)
The funny part with those chips in the US is that on most terminals I've used you can just click "Yes" instead of entering your PIN number. This gives you the option to sign for it. So it really doesn't solve the problem at all.

Afaik you can't do that in Europe. At least I've never heard of it being possible.

Re:Walmart Pay by mynameisvlad on Thursday December 10, 2015 @04:15PM (#10713522)
That's because US EMV is Chip+Signature not Chip+PIN (which is pretty stupid, why not go all out). Properly written readers should go directly to signature entry and bypass the PIN screen altogether since IIRC there's a flag on the card which tells it if it supports PIN or Signature.
Re:Walmart Pay by mahyarm on Thursday December 10, 2015 @04:08PM (#10713475)
There is EMV & Sign mode, and EMV & PIN mode, and it's set on the card and marked as 2 different transactions types by the bank.

Most american banks are issuing EMV & Sign cards, which means no PIN. You can set a PIN, but it's not a default flow and you have to call in to get it set.

Re:Walmart Pay by ersii on Thursday December 10, 2015 @04:42PM (#10713704)
You can do that with EMV terminals in Europe. I've done it repeatedly in Sweden. You hit the yellow button labeled "Signature" and they'll want to see an ID before they accept the signature.

And we're Chip+PIN here in general. But all merchants provide the Chip+Signature option.

Re:Walmart Pay by pbhjpbhj on Thursday December 10, 2015 @05:04PM (#10713853)
Our chip & pin does signature authorisation but the bank charges about 5 times the normal transaction rate.
Re:Walmart Pay by deong on Thursday December 10, 2015 @05:02PM (#10713842)
Iceland just started requiring PINs earlier this year.
Re:Walmart Pay by LastMuel on Thursday December 10, 2015 @03:23PM (#10713172)
That's one issue. I still cannot seem to get my mind around another, though.

Conceptually, I don't grasp how possibly exposing my PIN number at a point of sale is MORE secure. I just can't get past the idea that I'm now using the number I use to withdraw funds at an ATM at MORE places than just at my bank.

Re:Walmart Pay by emilecantin on Thursday December 10, 2015 @03:54PM (#10713380)
Your PIN is actually checked locally by the card before it signs the transaction. Sure, you're vulnerable to a POS system stealing your PIN, but they can't really do anything with it unless they also have your card's private key, which is pretty much impossible to get off the card without destroying it. This is a huge improvement over what it was before, where you only had to copy the mag stripe info to clone the card.
Re:Walmart Pay by makomk on Thursday December 10, 2015 @08:25PM (#10714945)
Someone can take that PIN and the magstripe data obtained from the card and use it to withdraw your money from ATMs that don't support Chip and PIN.
Re:Walmart Pay by kalleboo on Friday December 11, 2015 @01:34AM (#10715729)
Which is why we need to get this adoption completed ASAP so we can eliminate the magstripes on our cards.
Re:Walmart Pay by Swizec on Thursday December 10, 2015 @03:48PM (#10713336)
You're not exposing the PIN number. Properly designed card readers make the dialpad hard to read for anyone looking over your shoulders (you obscure it with your hand and there's a guard thingy around so they can't see your fingers).

And the machine itself checks the PIN against the chip. No sending anywhere, no checking by the clerk.

You only have to trust the machine itself. If you don't, you're fucked anyway because who says a hacked machine will only charge as much as it says it will?

Card+signature is security by "something you have", Card+PIN is "something you have and something you know". That's much more secure.

A signature isn't "something you know" because it's written on the card anyway. If it's not written on the card, then using the signature doesn't do anything in the first place. And nobody checks those signatures anyway. This is why for large purchases they ask to see your ID.

Re:Walmart Pay by jonknee on Thursday December 10, 2015 @06:41PM (#10714477)
Credit cards get skimmed by altered machines all the time, trusting the machine is the sketchy part. The nice part with mobile payments is you only have to trust your device. I'm pretty sure a mobster hasn't found my phone in the middle of the night and altered it. I am not so sure about a POS terminal at any random store. Target's POS got owned, why should I trust anyone else?

If someone hacked the terminal I use for an Apple Pay transaction what exactly would happen? It's a one time token that gets passed to the terminal and I immediately get a push update about the transaction.

Re:Walmart Pay by jessaustin on Thursday December 10, 2015 @04:24PM (#10713592)
If you don't, you're fucked anyway because who says a hacked machine will only charge as much as it says it will?

If a machine charged you too much, either it would say so on the receipt and you could protest immediately, or the receipt wouldn't match the charge so you could protest later. Sure, the first few customers might get fucked, but soon the bad machine would be caught. OTOH if the machine processed the current transaction correctly while sending all your codes to the bad guys, it could do so until the store noticed its bad firmware, which could take years.

Re:Walmart Pay by kalleboo on Friday December 11, 2015 @01:36AM (#10715734)
> OTOH if the machine processed the current transaction correctly while sending all your codes to the bad guys, it could do so until the store noticed its bad firmware, which could take years

Banks already correlate fraud reports to where customers have used their cards to track down offending stores that skim cards. They don't have to find the bad firmware, they just have to see "well 10 customers had their cards skimmed, and the only store they had in common was that one"

Re:Walmart Pay by Swizec on Thursday December 10, 2015 @05:21PM (#10713995)
So really it's just a matter of how sophisticated the hackers are. Add keylogger to get PINs. Add thug to get cards. Win.

There's no way around trusting the machine itself.

Re:Walmart Pay by tass on Thursday December 10, 2015 @07:10PM (#10714615)
If someone physically steals a credit card, it's quite obvious to the owner of the card, and they can have it cancelled.
Re:Walmart Pay by moheeb on Thursday December 10, 2015 @03:39PM (#10713279)
I've always had to enter my PIN when using my card...so I don't see it as any LESS secure.

I doubt it will take much for you to get past it.

Re:Walmart Pay by tammer on Thursday December 10, 2015 @03:14PM (#10713118)
I think the long plan here is what Tim Cook specifically said when announcing Apple Pay - eventually, the iPhone will replace your wallet and keys. This in turn will make iPhone an essential part of life - a necessary goal for a product so successful to continue growing. Expect an identity product in the near to mid future.
Re:Walmart Pay by bennyg on Thursday December 10, 2015 @03:40PM (#10713288)
That really sucks when you run out of battery then. Just don't understand the fascination to replace everything - maybe that's the Eagle Scout in me, but I'd rather have a backup plan, aka keys, wallet, etc on me than try and minimize pocket clutter.
Re:Walmart Pay by untog on Thursday December 10, 2015 @04:30PM (#10713634)
Sounds awful. What happens when I lose it, I lose my entire life? Battery dies? Drop it in the toilet?

Having all the important aspects of your life a little distributed isn't the worst thing in the world.

Re:Walmart Pay by eanzenberg on Thursday December 10, 2015 @04:42PM (#10713706)
The part of the iphone which includes "you" is stored in the cloud. You only lose/damage the hardware part, so get another one and backup from the cloud. Currently more expensive than when losing a set of keys or wallet but may not be in the future.
Re:Walmart Pay by untog on Thursday December 10, 2015 @05:03PM (#10713848)
...what? What makes you think that getting a replacement for iPhone hardware will be cheaper than buying a new wallet? Because I don't see it.

Plus, I'm now going to trust all of my sensitive data to Apple's cloud storage? No thanks.

Re:Walmart Pay by kalleboo on Friday December 11, 2015 @01:38AM (#10715745)
It's an actual selling point that Apple Pay stuff is only stored on the Secure Enclave on the device, and not in the cloud. I'm sure any house key type stuff Apple would implement would work the same way.

Lose your phone and you lose your payment instrument and your keys... no thanks.

Re:Walmart Pay by bennyg on Thursday December 10, 2015 @04:56PM (#10713790)
Meh - maybe. Imagine this scenario:

You're out at a restaurant, and you drove there. Your phone dies somehow, either dropped in toilet, or what have you. How do you do the following?

- Pay for dinner

- Drive your car, since your keys were in your phone

- Pay for a cab since you can no longer drive

- Pay for a phone replacement at an Apple Store

etc, etc.

Re:Walmart Pay by virusduck on Thursday December 10, 2015 @05:30PM (#10714054)
Same if your wallet falls out of your pocket
Re:Walmart Pay by untog on Thursday December 10, 2015 @05:51PM (#10714202)
But your wallet can't lose power or suffer water damage (to the cards at least).
Re:Walmart Pay by bennyg on Thursday December 10, 2015 @07:03PM (#10714586)
Yeah but then I still have keys to run home and pick up an extra debit/credit/cash I have and can continue with only minor hiccups.
Re:Walmart Pay by coldpie on Thursday December 10, 2015 @04:11PM (#10713496)
I'll never own an iPhone, so unless they plan to extend Apple Pay to other platforms, no, it won't be replacing my wallet or keys ever.
Re:Walmart Pay by imglorp on Thursday December 10, 2015 @03:49PM (#10713346)
I think it's as much about repeat customer intel as it is direct revenue. Like loyalty cards. Then if they get into the credit business, via app or otherwise, it's fees and fines and interest too.
Re:Walmart Pay by dionidium on Thursday December 10, 2015 @03:23PM (#10713178)
I have it and honestly have no reason to use it because credit cards just work.

This is exactly what I thought, but I started using Apple Pay, anyway, because Discover is offering 10% cash back on all in-store Apple Pay purchases through the end of the year. That's too good to pass up. Now that I've been using it for a while, I wish it were available everywhere. It's a small thing, but taking my phone out of my pocket is the most natural thing in the world. Subjectively, the process feels smooth.

Re:Walmart Pay by Retra on Thursday December 10, 2015 @03:51PM (#10713355)
Can you use Apple Pay without an Apple device? If not, then the only way it could see mass adoption is if Apple devices got quite cheap.
Re:Walmart Pay by saidajigumi on Thursday December 10, 2015 @04:04PM (#10713453)
No, you can't, but other NFC systems employing the contactless payment standards, notably Android Pay, also apply to this discussion.
Re:Walmart Pay by kstrauser on Thursday December 10, 2015 @06:57PM (#10714560)
I've had my debit card canceled for fraud three times in the last four years, after only dealing with vendors I'd think would be reputable. I LOVE Apple Pay and similar layers between vendors and my credit card.

On the same note, I will never, ever use something like CurrentC that gives those same vendors a direct line into my bank accounts.

Re:Walmart Pay by disillusioned on Thursday December 10, 2015 @06:05PM (#10714279)
Similar to how Coin and Plastc and all those stupid "aggregated cards" don't solve an actual problem that existed.

"Hey! How annoying is it that you have to carry AS MANY AS FOUR CREDIT CARDS?"

"Um, it's... not really..."

"Well how about CARRYING FIVE?"

"What?"

"Well, ours merges those together but... it doesn't really work anywhere so."

"TAKE MY $50!"

Re:Walmart Pay by Tushon on Thursday December 10, 2015 @06:20PM (#10714368)
FWIW, my personal experience has been about 90% success rate. They have a pretty specific case that they don't support, and it's almost always with old systems. My use case was rewards program based, e.g. a gas card. I now am able to carry a two slot wallet with my driver's license, Coin, health insurance card and my ATM card (which would also work on Coin, but they cautioned about machines with "auto" feeding. Obviously, YMMV and I'm in a major city, so it might not be as useful in the sticks.
Re:Walmart Pay by fluxquanta on Thursday December 10, 2015 @12:39PM (#10711955)
Very much what I was thinking. To add, the integration of mobile (itemized?) receipts is nice, but not nice enough for me to have to install and maintain an app on my device just for one store; an app that will undoubtedly hound me through push notifications about sales and other garbage.
Re:Walmart Pay by nickpsecurity on Thursday December 10, 2015 @12:47PM (#10712030)
Not just for one store: just for The Store. Walmarts the nations largest retailer with a momentum and presence that few stores have. They're putting that "not just any store" attribute to use here to break past that reaction in many potential users. It will work for many.

Like you, I'm skipping it, though.

Re:Walmart Pay by fluxquanta on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:01PM (#10712142)
>Not just for one store: just for The Store.

Fair point.

I live in a rural area where I'm sure a majority of people shop exclusively at Walmart. For someone like that, it would probably be a great app to have. I shop at Walmart too, but not as often as my local grocery store and specialty shops. I would much rather pay in one, standard way at all of them instead of some patchwork of differing methods: EMV card here, mag swipe there, NFC here, take a picture of a QR code there. It just adds hassle on top of the direct advertising platform(s) I would be voluntarily installing to my device. The benefits just aren't worth it.

Re:Walmart Pay by VLM on Thursday December 10, 2015 @07:53PM (#10714799)
fluxquanta is very close to the full answer. Note that my credit union "app" is just a wrapper for the website which also demands full access to my contact list and GPS and camera. For marketing reasons they want to know where I am and who I hang out with and what competing stores I visit.

Imagine your coordinates being determined to be the entrance of an OB/GYN office, and suddenly getting megs of push spam for your new baby. Or you appear to stand around the parking lot at the sportball field for hours every summer weekend, expect lots of push spam about charcoal, disposable grills, brats, picnic stuff.

What I don't understand is from a market dominance standpoint, why would walmart of all people want that data? Maybe they think they can market the data to other companies. Everyone has to shop at walmart sooner or later, maybe that means everyone will have their app sooner or later, so they'll have lots of privacy to sell to other companies.

Re:Walmart Pay by rblatz on Thursday December 10, 2015 @03:06PM (#10713061)
The store that is cluttered and has palettes of junk clogging every aisle. The store that has a terrible meat selection. The store that smells like the inside of a Subway. The store that has made subsidizing your payroll with tax payer funded food stamps common. The store that pivoted from proud to be made in America, to one of the main drivers of outsourcing manufacturing.

It's an awful system, just like the rest of their stuff. I'm sure it's going to be very successful.

Re:Walmart Pay by heywire on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:48PM (#10712470)
I was thinking the same thing until I realized that I use a dedicated Starbucks app for mobile ordering and payment...
Re:Walmart Pay by fluxquanta on Thursday December 10, 2015 @02:04PM (#10712587)
At least in the case of mobile ordering at Starbucks, that app sounds like it's adding real, additional value: It allows you to do something you otherwise can't do without the app.

Aside from the digital receipt thing (which, in my opinion, is really only useful if you are planning on returning an item or collecting receipts for tax deduction) where is the additional value with the mobile Walmart app?

Re:Walmart Pay by heywire on Thursday December 10, 2015 @02:07PM (#10712619)
The mobile ordering is a recent addition to the Starbucks app. I've been using it for payment for years -- mostly due to their rewards program, though that is available with a card too.
Re:Walmart Pay by baldfat on Thursday December 10, 2015 @12:46PM (#10712025)
> the whole goal of Apple Pay was to simplify things

I use Android pay and I still think it is harder to pay by phone. I have it in case I forget my wallet at home. http://www.forbes.com/sites/quickerbettertech/2015/06/01/why...

The hysterical thing is Apple Watch I saw this guy pay with it and then had to enter the pin and he was doing it through the watch interface. It took him FOREVER and I said "That was simple." He in return said "Simple as Brain Surgery." Don't they already have his finger print???

Re:Walmart Pay by JimDabell on Thursday December 10, 2015 @05:33PM (#10714074)
> The hysterical thing is Apple Watch I saw this guy pay with it and then had to enter the pin and he was doing it through the watch interface.

That's not how it works. You don't have to enter a PIN to pay with the watch. You just double tap the side button and hold your watch against the reader and the payment is made.

If you lock your watch with a PIN, then you have to enter the PIN the first time you use the watch after putting it on your wrist. As long as you continue to wear it, you don't have to enter that PIN again. If you take your watch off, then you have to put the PIN in again the next time you put it on and want to use it. It's so if somebody steals your watch they can't use it. Entering a PIN is something you tend to only do once when you put it on in the morning.

What probably happened was that he put his watch on in the morning, but didn't use it until he had to pay for something. Then he had to unlock his watch. In the vast majority of cases, the watch would already be unlocked and there wouldn't be any PIN to enter - the PIN isn't used during payment.

Re:Walmart Pay by eric_h on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:01PM (#10712145)
> enter the pin and he was doing it through the watch interface

I've never had to do this to use Apple Pay from my watch. Is this the flow for chip and pin cards (I've only got chip and signature)? If so - that's fucking terrible.

I love using apple pay from my watch, I don't even have to roll up my sleeve, just double tap the button and hold it near the reader.

Re:Walmart Pay by ardiem on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:28PM (#10712343)
It sounds like the watch may have been in a locked state (requiring an unlock by entering a PIN or unlocking a paired iPhone). If this were the case, the PIN entry is unrelated to using Apple Pay.
Re:Walmart Pay by meej on Thursday December 10, 2015 @04:53PM (#10713767)
I love it too. Way faster than chip & sign. Wish there were more places I could use it at.
Re:Walmart Pay by Bahamut on Thursday December 10, 2015 @12:51PM (#10712072)
Sadly, it's much easier to just pay with Apple Pay on the iPhone.
Re:Walmart Pay by pbreit on Thursday December 10, 2015 @12:55PM (#10712100)
Happily, it's much easier to pay with a credit card than all of them.
Re:Walmart Pay by jkelsey on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:16PM (#10712249)
That's your take. I find paying w/ Apple Pay on my iPhone very seamless and I far prefer it over dealing with a card. I'm sure there's others out there that share that opinion.
Re:Walmart Pay by azinman2 on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:24PM (#10712312)
When it works. im often having to do it multiple times and sometimes just switch to CC
Re:Walmart Pay by jkelsey on Thursday December 10, 2015 @03:33PM (#10713243)
I never have problems with it, and I use it every chance I get, but I certainly don't discount your experience. It sucks that you're having such a bad experience with it. If lots of folks are having the same experience, Apple's going to need to get those problems figured out if they want to win the war to replace cards.
Re:Walmart Pay by mikeash on Thursday December 10, 2015 @08:16PM (#10714907)
My own experience is that Apple Pay works well when it's available. The problem is playing the constant game of "Does this terminal/merchant accept Apple Pay?" It's not always easy to tell. For example, Home Depot for several months had terminals that claimed to support NFC, but got hung up authorizing and eventually timed out if you actually tried to use it.
Re:Walmart Pay by spearo77 on Thursday December 10, 2015 @10:15PM (#10715277)
I live in California, but went back home to Sydney for a few weeks this year.

I used my apple watch to pay in about 90% of transactions, including parking meters!

Almost all merchants support "Visa PayWave" (aka NFC) so moving my wrist up to the terminal to pay was a fun talking point.

Not one checkout clerk had seen the apple watch used before, because the Aussie banks haven't reached an agreement with Apple yet.

Re:Walmart Pay by mikeash on Friday December 11, 2015 @08:51AM (#10717062)
That's pretty cool. Of course I know that it's just standard NFC, but still neat to hear about it working that way.

Meanwhile in the states, some idiot retailers actually shut off their NFC readers because they didn't want to support Apple Pay.

Re:Walmart Pay by azinman2 on Thursday December 10, 2015 @11:53PM (#10715518)
For me I mainly use it at Whole Foods. I know they accept it. The question is, will it work this time (on the first try).
Re:Walmart Pay by pbreit on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:35PM (#10712385)
My take, and probably 80% of the population as well.
Re:Walmart Pay by a_c_s on Thursday December 10, 2015 @04:11PM (#10713488)
Not necessarily - for some stores, such as Walgreens (a US drugstore chain), the checkout flows look something like this:

Credit card: 1. Enter phone number (for loyalty card lookup) 2. Select "credit card" 3. Swipe card 4. Answer question about making a donation 5. Confirm credit amount 6. Sign 7. Confirm (This is from memory, but it is roughly correct - I actually fear I may have forgotten a step or two)

Apple Pay: 1. Enter phone number (for loyalty card lookup) 2. Wake iPhone and bring near POS terminal 3. Place finger on home button until it buzzes (~1 second)

The flow for Apple Pay could be a little longer if you need to select a different card, but it is still both far faster and far simpler than the regular credit card flow.

Re:Walmart Pay by Someone1234 on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:15PM (#10712241)
That will change when Chip & Pin are common. Instead of just swiping, yes, yes, done, it will be inserting the card into the reader, the reader fails to read the chip, spitting on it, then trying again, and finally entering the pin and yes, yes, done.

Don't misunderstand, chip & pin is something the US has long since needed. But the chips are unreliable and entering a pin on some terminals is annoying. A phone with NFC might be easier than that, just fingerprint to unlock, and then press a single button on the phone.

Re:Walmart Pay by riffraff on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:25PM (#10712320)
As a european who has always had chip cards, it has never happened to me[0] that the reader failed to read the chip. Granted, I don't use the card very often, but I would say in the last 10 ten years I have probably used it a few hundred times. Chip & signature, is usually slower.

OTOH, NFC credit cards are now also becoming more common in europe too, i.e. https://www.visa.co.uk/products/visa-contactless/ http://www.mastercard.com/contactless/

[0] EDIT: it might have happened and I can't remember it, which is effectively the same thing in context.

Re:Walmart Pay by Someone1234 on Thursday December 10, 2015 @02:01PM (#10712567)
You assume too much. I am from the UK, and the chip failing to read is a common occurrence, and some readers are well known bad (e.g. the cashier will be like "yeah it has been doing that all day" as you spit and polish the chip contacts).

But I do use my card(s) a great deal. So much so that the contacts on the chip are changing from gold to brown.

Re:Walmart Pay by diegomsana on Thursday December 10, 2015 @03:22PM (#10713168)
A gentle lady on the cashier once took card out of my hands and rubbed on her hair. It worked lol.
Re:Walmart Pay by asherkin on Thursday December 10, 2015 @02:50PM (#10712941)
Once you've worn the contacts away you can hardly call them contacts any more (and it's unsurprising they fail regularly). Cashiers will also say that even if they've never seen another card fail to read :P it's to make you feel better.
Re:Walmart Pay by Someone1234 on Thursday December 10, 2015 @03:12PM (#10713108)
> Cashiers will also say that even if they've never seen another card fail to read :P it's to make you feel better.

My mum is a cachier. It is a constant headache where she works. Some tills the staff avoid using until last because the reader sucks so bad.

But, to you, C&P is an infallible technology that doesn't comfort to our normal rules of physics, so I'm sure nothing will convince you.

Re:Walmart Pay by amyjess on Thursday December 10, 2015 @02:49PM (#10712936)
Yeah, thanks to your post, I'm not looking forward to chips becoming more popular in the US.

I've never had a problem with a card reader not properly reading swipes or the magnetic strip wearing down. Only times I've had a swipe fail has been when I mis-swiped the card, and that's entirely on my own klutziness, not any kind of mechanical failure.

The future shouldn't be worse than the present, but it looks like that's the road we're going down...

Re:Walmart Pay by jessaustin on Thursday December 10, 2015 @04:36PM (#10713675)
I've never had a problem with a card reader not properly reading swipes or the magnetic strip wearing down.

Although it seems less common over the last several years (perhaps because now physical cards are often replaced several times before they nominally expire?), this used to be a serious problem. The most common fix for a read failure was to put the card inside a plastic grocery bag, pull the bag tight, and then reswipe it. I have no idea how this fixed anything, but I witnessed it working many times.

Re:Walmart Pay by michaelcampbell on Thursday December 10, 2015 @04:06PM (#10713468)
If you can find them anymore (and care enough), the pink pencil erasers are good too; they are very slightly abrasive, but not so much as to remove a layer of metal.
Re:Walmart Pay by asib on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:37PM (#10712400)
Swipe is very rare in the UK - Chip & Pin is the norm, at least it used to be.

Contactless cards were introduced relatively recently, where you just tap and go - no verification required (as such there's a limit on the amount you can pay using contactless). These are very speedy, I think more so than Apple pay, and are becoming increasingly popular.

In London (and possibly other places in the UK, I'm unsure) they have actually integrated contactless card readers into public transport, meaning you can hop on a bus/tube and pay for the journey with your card. Essentially, you can carry around a single card to commute, buy your lunch, go shopping and everything else.

Re:Walmart Pay by Nullabillity on Thursday December 10, 2015 @02:14PM (#10712672)
Honestly, contactless cards, and this push to merge a few of the cards, kind of terrify me.

I already carry around my driver's license. I already carry around the access card to my school. I already carry around my student ID. I already carry around 3 different library cards. I already carry around my public transport card. I already carry around my debit card. I already carry around cash.

Even if you remove a few of those I still need to carry my wallet with me, so what difference does it make? I mean, other than the loss of separation of identities that comes with the territory. It's fine that my public transport card has low security, because you can't cash it out easily, and it only carries a very limited value anyway. Neither of those apply to my debit card.

Re:Walmart Pay by davnicwil on Thursday December 10, 2015 @03:07PM (#10713070)
But with a pretty low limit on daily spend with the contactless card, it effectively has limited value too - assuming you'd cancel it within 24 hours of it being lost or stolen in most cases - and is therefore difficult to 'cash out' on for a thief. So actually both do apply to your contactless debit card, really.

Actually there's likely more incentive to pickpocket a wallet for its cash contents, rather than the contactless card(s), given in a lot of wallets this will be both greater and, by definition of course, easier to cash out on! So it seems like carrying contactless cards doesn't add any particular incentive for theft above what has existed forever with carrying cash. Also, any other security vulnerabilities with the debit card, unrelated to contactless, still exist exactly as they do today.

So, it seems to me that merging cards, i.e. adding contactless and the ability to use it for transport, and other things, seems to just add marginal convenience with essentially no added risk of theft or fraud[1]. So yes, it's not a life-changing technology and it won't mean you no longer have to carry a wallet, but it represents a small win and certainly a step improvement for everyday convenience, so that's good right? I for one simply think the fewer cards I have to carry, the better, to be honest.

[1] though I have, to be fair, heard about the issue of thieves 'skimming' contactless cards in people's pockets, I don't know if that was always just a scare story or if it's actually a real exploitable vulnerability - but this seems likely to be a pretty far-flung edge case anyway.

Re:Walmart Pay by jaddison on Thursday December 10, 2015 @02:07PM (#10712615)
Chip & Pin and Contactless are commonplace in Canada as well at stores. Not all have it, but most get it as they upgrade their systems.
Re:Walmart Pay by Nullabillity on Thursday December 10, 2015 @02:09PM (#10712637)
In the 5 years I've had a C&P card I've had it fail approximately once.
Re:Walmart Pay by Someone1234 on Thursday December 10, 2015 @02:13PM (#10712667)
I've had it for 8-9 years in the UK and I've had it failed many many times. More than I can count on both hands. The chips wear out, the readers wear out, the two get dirty, etc. it is a common nuisance, just ask any cashier.
Re:Walmart Pay by Nullabillity on Thursday December 10, 2015 @02:44PM (#10712896)
Sounds like your card is about to expire then, anyway.
Re:Walmart Pay by Someone1234 on Thursday December 10, 2015 @02:45PM (#10712909)
I am talking about multiple cards. I had at least four in that time.
Re:Walmart Pay by ersii on Thursday December 10, 2015 @04:47PM (#10713737)
I use my bank/credit card often, which is Chip&PIN/EMV. I have never had a problem with any of my cards in that way, ie. the reader being clunky and failing to contact the card.

I have however worn out a card that has been in use for a couple of years.

I would beg to differ that the chips are unreliable. Other solutions might be easier, don't know about that though.

Re:Walmart Pay by amyjess on Thursday December 10, 2015 @02:40PM (#10712863)
> That will change when Chip & Pin are common.

Chip & PIN is not coming to the US. Chip & sign, yes, but no PINs.

Re:Walmart Pay by smackfu on Thursday December 10, 2015 @03:33PM (#10713245)
The readers I've seen in the US are a bit slow. And sometimes you run into ones where you insert your card and then the clerk says "that's not turned on yet", but that will shake itself out. Haven't seen any issues with bad reads.
Re:Walmart Pay by patmcc on Thursday December 10, 2015 @04:04PM (#10713449)
Canada has transitioned mostly to chip and pin (anecdotally, 95% of debit transactions I've done lately), and I've seen a really low failure rate on my cards. I can think of once in the last year I got chip errors on the reader.
Re:Walmart Pay by jholman on Thursday December 10, 2015 @05:28PM (#10714046)
I'm Canadian. I've never had a mechanical failure on chip&pin. A friend of mine seems to have failures constantly at a certain liquor store; dunno if it's the debit card she's using, or the store's reader, or both.

But back when we used mag stripes, I used to see failures all the time.

The anecdata in my life says chip&pin is FAR more reliable.

Re:Walmart Pay by pbreit on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:34PM (#10712373)
You might be right. Chip & sign is pretty bad. Chip & PIN is awful.
Re:Walmart Pay by Haul4ss on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:30PM (#10712360)
I've found that if you already have your phone in your hand, using Apple Pay is quicker than getting your wallet out. If you need to fish your phone out of one pocket, it's probably just as easy to fish your wallet out of another.

I like the idea of Apple Pay. It's not accepted at enough places yet to make it really worthwhile, but I could see contactless payments being a big thing in the future.

Re:Walmart Pay by heywire on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:37PM (#10712409)
I currently pay with Apple Pay for two reasons. Security and Discover double cash back. Definitely not convenience. I always end up screwing up the double tap to pull up the cards and people give me looks because I'm holding up the line. That said, there really just aren't many places nearby that are taking it yet.
Re:Walmart Pay by jlgaddis on Thursday December 10, 2015 @02:47PM (#10712919)
I had intended to use Apple Pay simply because of the Discover double cash back but hardly any retailers around me actually accept it so it's pointless for me.
Re:Walmart Pay by gergles on Thursday December 10, 2015 @06:03PM (#10714272)
You don't need to double-tap. Just touch (don't press) your thumb to the Touch ID sensor and put the back of the phone on the reader. The phone will wake up and automatically pay with your default card, as long as your registered finger is on the sensor.
Re:Walmart Pay by ultramancool on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:39PM (#10712411)
Seriously. Does the US not have tap-to-pay credit and debit cards or something?
Re:Walmart Pay by ctdonath on Thursday December 10, 2015 @05:33PM (#10714076)
Nope.

We have a VERY large network of point-of-sale registers, all built around the old swipe-to-pay (often requiring signature) credit card model. Replacing practically every POS register in the country is not a simple task; we're rolling out "chipped cards" and new registers to support them (that's a lot of effort & money), but doing so will take most of a year.

That's why Apple Pay is such a big deal, and why the fuss about large businesses trying to roll out their own specialized (and usually inferior) version: yes we're starting to move to chipped cards, but even those are proving slow to use in many/most areas; most of the new registers also support NFC, making Apple Pay's "double tap a button and wave your watch/phone nearby" desirable - IF the store turns on the NFC & infrastructure.

Alas, Walmart is trying to avoid Apple's fees by putting support into their own app, which will be annoyingly slow.

Re:Walmart Pay by ultramancool on Thursday December 10, 2015 @07:14PM (#10714625)
> We have a VERY large network of point-of-sale registers, all built around the old swipe-to-pay (often requiring signature) credit card model.

Yeah, well, I'm in Canada and we had about the same thing, yet in the last 5 or so years we've seen 2 major changes (chip and pin followed by tap to pay) and most business have kept up, I haven't used the swipe in 3 or 4 years and the tap I'm now able to use tap at most places.

Is there a problem with adoption in the US for some reason that doesn't exist in other places? Perhaps Interac has some special power here or something.

Re:Walmart Pay by ctdonath on Friday December 11, 2015 @09:53AM (#10717378)
It just seemed to stall out. Either the technology wasn't up to par, or (more probable) there wasn't the impetus to roll it out everywhere - failure to reach critical mass. For NFC, however, practically every card reader MUST be upgraded this year to support chipped cards, with NFC riding along as a given capability which Apple is leveraging with its "half the market" NFC-capable phones & watches. About this time next year I'd expect widespread availability of Apple Pay and other NFC services.
Re:Walmart Pay by crusso on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:55PM (#10712520)
Any payment method that doesn't use cryptography for payment approval is fundamentally flawed.
Re:Walmart Pay by jagerific on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:36PM (#10712398)
Its still faster than the chip reader in my experience. If magnetic strips are going to be a thing of the past i'd say phone payments will ultimately have the speed/convenience advantage.
Re:Walmart Pay by dajohnson89 on Thursday December 10, 2015 @04:10PM (#10713483)
> I have it in case I forget my wallet at home.

I have a sleeve attached to my phone, which holds my bank/credit cards. The only things I carry are my phone and my keys.

Re:Walmart Pay by rdudek on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:19PM (#10712274)
I bet you they don't take Apple Pay or Android Pay because of transaction fees. Them rolling out their own payment system probably saves them quite a bit on fees.
Re:Walmart Pay by ascagnel_ on Thursday December 10, 2015 @03:52PM (#10713364)
They're taking credit and debit cards, so they have to pay some amount of transaction fees as a built-in part of that. I see nothing where this is any more beneficial to the consumer other than 'it's Walmart' vs. Apple Pay/Android Pay/Samsung Pay/etc.
Re:Walmart Pay by jonknee on Thursday December 10, 2015 @03:59PM (#10713425)
No, they don't take Apple Pay or Android Pay because they don't have the POS terminals to support them and were part of CurrentC. Walmart wants the data and you can't get that when you don't know who the customer is. That's also why I use Apple Pay.
Re:Walmart Pay by joosters on Thursday December 10, 2015 @04:25PM (#10713594)
Apple Pay (and all other mobile payments) are an odd niche, IMO. They are great in the US, where the alternative currently is signing for a payment, and faster than PIN entry in countries that support chip+pin. But it's still more cumbersome than contactless payment cards.

Contactless is as quick as a payment will ever be: Hold your card near the reader for less than a second, and you're done. No need to wait for your phone to wake up and accept a fingerprint, fumbling around trying to hold the phone right, and then put it near the reader.

Once contactless cards become more prevalent, Apple Pay / Google Pay becomes pointless.

Re:Walmart Pay by sliverstorm on Thursday December 10, 2015 @04:32PM (#10713649)
Two thoughts:

1) Contactless uses (needs) the same terminal technology as Apply Pay & Android Pay. So all three are in the same boat, and benefit from the expansion of the others.

2) Just speculating, but Contactless will probably move towards a PIN or something of that nature. The whole payment industry is moving towards 2-factor. Contactless by itself is not 2-factor.

Re:Walmart Pay by joosters on Thursday December 10, 2015 @04:50PM (#10713747)
Point 1 is why I think Apple Pay & others will be more of a niche - until the terminals become common, you can't rely on them, but once they are common, contactless cards become just as useful.

I used to be skeptical of contactless cards because of the lack of 2-factor. I thought it would be a liability (if my wallet gets stolen, now the thief can use my cards). However, the UK banks are quite vocal about promising to repay you if this happens. I've never had to put this to the test, luckily.

Also, there is still an element of 2-factor auth. Occasionally, contactless will ask for a PIN confirmation (perhaps random, or perhaps if the bank thinks the payment seems odd). A new card of mine refused to work until I had made at least one PIN payment with it, for instance.

Finally, there are low contactless payment limits - £30 right now. But these have been steadily rising as banks become more confident with their fraud systems. So, it seems that the payment industry is happy with the system.

Re:Walmart Pay by jonknee on Thursday December 10, 2015 @06:45PM (#10714495)
> Point 1 is why I think Apple Pay & others will be more of a niche - until the terminals become common, you can't rely on them, but once they are common, contactless cards become just as useful.

Why is the extra thing you have to bring with you and probably use a PIN for "just as useful"? Mobile based systems are also interesting because you can just as easily use them for app based sales. Anything to reduce the friction of someone giving you money is going to be a welcome thing for retailers.

Re:Walmart Pay by joosters on Thursday December 10, 2015 @07:42PM (#10714761)
Because you almost never need a PIN, and you will already have it with you to use in less advanced payment locations...

As for app based sales, they exist today just fine with credit cards.

Re:Walmart Pay by BukhariH on Thursday December 10, 2015 @08:21PM (#10714929)
I really don't agree with your view at all.

I actually think that banks in the future will stop issuing physical cards altogether and will rely on virtual cards linked with Apple Pay, Android Pay or some other contactless based system.

Re:Walmart Pay by Symbiote on Friday December 11, 2015 @05:18AM (#10716269)
Contactless was introduced by the European banks well after Chip+PIN, to speed up low-value transactions. (5 years after in the UK, but more like 10 years to become popular.)
Re:Walmart Pay by spearo77 on Thursday December 10, 2015 @10:24PM (#10715294)
re: 2)

I think the apple watch is considered 2-factor, where you've already cleared the first factor by unlocking the watch with your passcode (or linked phone unlock)?

Re:Walmart Pay by erik on Thursday December 10, 2015 @04:32PM (#10713646)
I've never used it, but contactless payment from a watch seems like it would be an improvement over retriving a card from my wallet to make a contactless payment.
Re:Walmart Pay by sithadmin on Thursday December 10, 2015 @04:42PM (#10713703)
It is. If I have the option to use Apple Pay, I use my Apple Watch.
Re:Walmart Pay by joosters on Thursday December 10, 2015 @04:52PM (#10713761)
A watch would make it easier, certainly. But it's a big limiter - smart watches are not widely used, and it adds another battery worry. If my tepid watch battery dies, now I can't pay for stuff.
Re:Walmart Pay by natch on Friday December 11, 2015 @08:15AM (#10716871)
For people who do use watches, it works great. The battery hasn't ever died once on my watch, but if it did, like most people I also have a phone, so the situation you're afraid of doesn't arise.
Re:Walmart Pay by rjv on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:04PM (#10712162)
I try to use Android Pay when I can just for the security benefits of the one-use tokens. Sometimes it's easy, other times it takes forever.. particularly if my cell reception isn't great in the store. Once all stores truly make use of the card chip in the United States, I'll probably just use that because it's essentially the same thing. At this point probably 95% of the stores I shop at still want me to swipe the card rather than enable the chip receiver.
Re:Walmart Pay by gst on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:14PM (#10712234)
Same here. I don't care about the convenience, but mostly about the security benefits. In the past 4 years I had to get two credit cards and one debit card replaced after fraudulent charges / fraudulent ATM transactions. Yes - as a customer I'm not liable for those charges, but it's still annoying if it, e.g., takes a few weeks until your bank refunds you the hundreds of Dollars that someone withdrew from your checking account.
Re:Walmart Pay by pbreit on Thursday December 10, 2015 @12:54PM (#10712092)
Walmart is in a position to pull this off. The equivalent Starbucks "card" is a major success. Large merchants with loyal followings can do this successfully.
Re:Walmart Pay by olentangy on Thursday December 10, 2015 @07:12PM (#10714621)
The only reason I use the Starbucks "card" is that I get free drinks with it. Walmart will only succeed if they offered some similar type of kickback to the customer. I don't see it happening.