News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Atlassian Sets Its I.P.O. at $21 by planetjones on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:16AM (#10709149)
$6.8 million profit last year and an initial valuation for the company of $4.38 billion. It truly is a crazy world we are living in. I was tempted to take a long position in Atlassian, but frankly I think the chosen price grossly overvalues them.
Re:Atlassian Sets Its I.P.O. at $21 by thoman23 on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:23AM (#10709178)
Not to mention they are no longer "cool". I hear younger developers talk about Jira like I might talk about Internet Explorer. Without Jira, the Confluence Wiki loses some luster. HipChat of course has been overrun by Slack...etc.

For the record, I'm still a big fan of the Atlassian suite, and also had thought about taking a long position once they were public, but I can't do it given the above conditions and this seemingly inflated price.

Re:Atlassian Sets Its I.P.O. at $21 by __derek__ on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:37AM (#10709209)
They don't have to be cool: they're enterprise. Jira is established as the de facto standard in Agile development/project management. Managers and above make the decision to purchase, and those with opinions on "cool" tools begrudgingly use the tools handed down all the while complaining about how uncool they are.
Re:Atlassian Sets Its I.P.O. at $21 by sqldba on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:40AM (#10709225)
The tie-in between their products is also their undoing in the Enterprise market.

I'm just an onlooker but I've seen Jira (the proper tool for a problem) was universally shunned by management because they specifically didn't want to be tied into the rest of the Atlasssian ecosystem.

I realise that it makes no sense, but it's partly because they want diversity rather than being strung over a barrel by one vendor, and partly because they are ordered to use some different components by the higher-up conglomerate managers; which is what Enterprise is all about.

I don't know what the integration options were with other systems but management struck it off the list from the get-go regardless. We were already using it internally successfully; but hey no let's try to shoehorn ServiceNow to do the same thing.

I'll leave the rest for your imagination.

Yes though, it sucks for us on the ground floor. We really don't give a crap WHAT gets used as long as it works, and all the different crappy products with zero integration absolutely doesn't work. Tell that to management though; they don't have to use it.

Re:Atlassian Sets Its I.P.O. at $21 by chx on Thursday December 10, 2015 @03:19AM (#10709529)
Tied? How so? I consult for a large department of a certain Fortune 100 company (think 30k users) and their JIRA is tied to an Enterprise Github instance for example, not Bitbucket. Developers are on a self hosted IRC network (yes, really) as IRC is still unbeatable when you work in a heterogeneous, massively distributed environment.
Re:Atlassian Sets Its I.P.O. at $21 by mstade on Thursday December 10, 2015 @05:53AM (#10709998)
I know at least three top tier banks that have pretty much this exact setup. Small world, huh?
Re:Atlassian Sets Its I.P.O. at $21 by chx on Thursday December 10, 2015 @07:01AM (#10710203)
Moral of the story: Hipchat and Slack are, well, ahem, hip but when push comes to shove, IRC is where it is. Somewhat it reminds of me CLI vs GUI...
Re:Atlassian Sets Its I.P.O. at $21 by mstade on Thursday December 10, 2015 @07:35AM (#10710305)
Sure, I was thinking of the JIRA+GHE setup as well though. As for IRC – they also use some weird clients (actually, might be the same one everwhere, just rebranded) to hide away the fact that it's IRC. Some people I know would just use Irssi or whatever.

I'm guessing the fact that IRC is used is that it's reliable, simple to set up, and works for a rather large audience even without any redundancy. Most extra functionality that the Slack etc. provide – integrations, notifications embedding things – are not really necessary (but possibly wanted) in that context. E-mail still reigns supreme for anything that can't fit in simple text, and certainly for more formal comms and sign-offs.

Re:Atlassian Sets Its I.P.O. at $21 by sqldba on Thursday December 10, 2015 @03:56AM (#10709654)
Because Atlasssian offers other products and so the impetus is to get them as well. It's not worth it to pay for Jira because why do that when you can just turn ServiceNow into... a development CMDB time tracking thing with a mere few tens of millions of effort.

Look, I didn't say management was smart. That's just the dumb way they look at it.

Re:Atlassian Sets Its I.P.O. at $21 by seren on Thursday December 10, 2015 @03:28AM (#10709563)
It is a matter of perspective. My company just deployed Jira & Confluence.

Before that we had a poor mediawiki install, and for task management basically nothing (or rather, awkward internal tool compatible with IE6...).

It is a blessing.

I guess if you have been using (and abusing) Atlassian tools for years, you will experience some tool fatigue, which is natural.

Re:Atlassian Sets Its I.P.O. at $21 by Stratoscope on Thursday December 10, 2015 @02:01AM (#10709286)
> I hear younger developers talk about Jira like I might talk about Internet Explorer.

Gosh, I'm 63, and I talk about JIRA like that!

Re:Atlassian Sets Its I.P.O. at $21 by semerda on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:53AM (#10709261)
So who are these younger developers talking about now?
Re:Atlassian Sets Its I.P.O. at $21 by girvo on Thursday December 10, 2015 @02:16AM (#10709328)
Nothing, honestly. JIRA has been painful to use as a developer in the trenches for the 7 years and 3 companies I've used it at, but there still isn't a proper competitor to it that seems to have traction. For what it's worth, we moved to breeze.pm, but the CTO decided to build his own "complete" business management service; project management, CRM, HR, etc. all in one system and integrated with Xero. We'll see how it goes. I'm keeping an eye on Tagia.io, but I'm waiting for the "Slack" to appear.
Re:Atlassian Sets Its I.P.O. at $21 by stephen_g on Thursday December 10, 2015 @02:36AM (#10709383)
Who set up those instances? The only Jira instances I have ever used were set up by developers and were really great, but I hear that it's a fatal mistake to ever let a project manager know there's such thing as the workflow editor.
Re:Atlassian Sets Its I.P.O. at $21 by amatix on Thursday December 10, 2015 @03:16AM (#10709525)
JIRA without spending the time to correctly set it up to match your workflow/approach/business is a complete waste -- for companies who do invest that effort upfront (and evolve it over time) then it usually works great.
Re:Atlassian Sets Its I.P.O. at $21 by UK-AL on Thursday December 10, 2015 @06:55AM (#10710176)
I have the opposite experience. The default JIRA Agile experience is great.

It become a problem when a PM gets his hands on it, included about 50 steps with manual approvals etc.

Re:Atlassian Sets Its I.P.O. at $21 by mgkimsal on Thursday December 10, 2015 @08:48AM (#10710548)
there's an evergreen issue of "do you run your business around the software (jira defaults in this case) or do you make your software operate like your business?"

There's arguments to be made on both sides, and there's never just one answer. Default JIRA flow for some people is probably a godsend compared to what they're coming from, and yes, for other operations, having it mimic what's already in place probably needs to be done.

Re:Atlassian Sets Its I.P.O. at $21 by mbesto on Thursday December 10, 2015 @10:44AM (#10711155)
Which is credence to the fact that this isn't an argument for tool choice, but against processes that developers don't have an appetite for understanding.
Re:Atlassian Sets Its I.P.O. at $21 by mywacaday on Thursday December 10, 2015 @08:26AM (#10710470)
minor correction https://taiga.io/
Re:Atlassian Sets Its I.P.O. at $21 by ansgri on Thursday December 10, 2015 @06:23AM (#10710082)
How Redmine is not a competition?
Re:Atlassian Sets Its I.P.O. at $21 by stephen_g on Thursday December 10, 2015 @10:28AM (#10711049)
Redmine is pretty good for what it is, but I don't think it's in the same league as Jira... It does a lot of things, but having used it for a while at work I didn't feel that it did anything amazingly well. We just kept hitting annoyances in the UI, various limitations in all sorts of things in the ticketing and wiki, the lack of good reports, etc.

I actually joined the company just as they were about to move to Redmine, and recommended Jira instead after playing around with the Redmine test instance for a while. They were worried about the cost though, and I didn't have much say yet, but in the end switching to Redmine was the best argument for getting Jira. I didn't even have to push for it - after a few months my manager came to me and said he'd already got the funds approved!

Re:Atlassian Sets Its I.P.O. at $21 by leonardinius on Thursday December 10, 2015 @04:33PM (#10713651)
Hi. Old time Jira user here. Used to use it heavily ... 5-3 years ago.

Last few years we use Redmine mostly. In the beginning I had mixed feelings about it. Now I'm OK with it.

We sometimes need to switch to Jira in our projects. It's always a pain nowadays. I used to love Jira time reports, now I just don't get them.

My perspective: Redmine covers the basics we need, don't have the feature creep problem and does reporting (time reporting) really really well.

Rant mode continued: In several projects we use YouTrack [0]. Initially I was very excited: e.g. great UX etc .. But! It's time reporting capabilities are just rudimentary.

In the end we do the following: created internal tool too fetch time reports from different systems and to push to our Redmine system (via REST API). Redmine serves our reporting needs well. Still, in some extreme cases also use excel via ODBC..

[0]: https://www.jetbrains.com/youtrack/

Re:Atlassian Sets Its I.P.O. at $21 by Grue3 on Thursday December 10, 2015 @07:28AM (#10710285)
Way less features. Worse UI as well.
Re:Atlassian Sets Its I.P.O. at $21 by saool on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:59AM (#10709281)
Those will be VC fueled and privately held till they need a sucker to hold the bag.
Re:Atlassian Sets Its I.P.O. at $21 by vecter on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:24AM (#10709179)
Profit isn't necessarily the most meaningful way to evaluate a company (n.b. Amazon). Usually for growth stage companies, YoY revenue growth is more important. I don't know what Atlassian's revenue numbers actually are, but I'd have to imagine they've been growing significantly in order for them to try to command such a valuation.
Re:Atlassian Sets Its I.P.O. at $21 by semerda on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:55AM (#10709265)
Profit is opinion but cash is a fact. They are pushing cash back into the business to create more opportunity.
Re:Atlassian Sets Its I.P.O. at $21 by whoInvited on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:22AM (#10709170)
only 644x earnings...
Re:Atlassian Sets Its I.P.O. at $21 by hoodoof on Thursday December 10, 2015 @01:23AM (#10709173)
Get all the cash off the table that you can.
Re:Atlassian Sets Its I.P.O. at $21 by jonknee on Thursday December 10, 2015 @09:58AM (#10710869)
A lot of IPOs don't have any profits, that's why they are out raising money.