News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by retube on Monday December 07, 2015 @11:36AM (#10690494)
The separation of "bitcoin" and "blockchain" is not only correct, but further more it's a good thing people/media are becoming aware of the distinction between the blockchain as a protocol and bitcoin as an application (one of potentially thousands) based on this protocol.

Big finance doesn't give a sh*t about bitcoin. They don't see it as a threat, it barely registers. What they do see is the enormous applications and potential cost-savings that blockchains could enable - in areas like settlements, transaction signing, new products and so on. Hence coverage is moving from "Bitcoin" to "Blockchain".

Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by zekevermillion on Monday December 07, 2015 @12:05PM (#10690738)
You can have a blockchain without bitcoin, but why is that useful or interesting? Isn't the Nakamoto distributed consensus the key innovation of bitcoin as a protocol? Without that incentive structure in place, we can't trust the state of the blockchain without also trusting the participants. This may work fine for banks, but so does ACH.
Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by detaro on Monday December 07, 2015 @12:29PM (#10690938)
> You can have a blockchain without bitcoin, but why is that useful or interesting? Isn't the Nakamoto distributed consensus the key innovation of bitcoin as a protocol?

What does the second have to do with the first? Just because bitcoin was the first to use it, doesn't mean everything that uses same mechanism suddenly is "Bitcoin", at least not in the commonly used sense.

Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by tlrobinson on Monday December 07, 2015 @01:25PM (#10691405)
Parent commenter answered that: "that incentive structure"

The "blockchain" works because all the mutually-distrustful participants' incentives are roughly aligned (in theory). You can't attack the network without spending a huge amount of money on mining hardware, and as long as you're financially motivated you'd be better off just mining (again, in theory)

You could have a "blockchain" without mining, but it wouldn't provide the same properties Bitcoin does, and solutions that give you similar properties to such a system have been around for a long time, and are probably faster and more efficient.

I think banks are now interested in the "blockchain" because of some combination of hype, FOMO, and fundamentally misunderstanding Bitcoin/blockchain.

Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by detaro on Monday December 07, 2015 @01:50PM (#10691659)
Yes, but there are tons of blockchains that have mining and the same incentive structure, but you wouldn't call them "Bitcoin"? from "simple variations" (Litecoin) to projects building additional features like Ethereum. Bitcoin is only one application using such a blockchain.
Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by tlrobinson on Monday December 07, 2015 @01:55PM (#10691702)
The implication when finance people talk about "the blockchain" is they want the properties (or at least the hype) of Bitcoin's blockchain without Bitcoin (or any other alt-coin) the currency.
Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by paavokoya on Monday December 07, 2015 @03:08PM (#10692288)
>they want the properties (or at least the hype) of Bitcoin's blockchain without Bitcoin (or any other alt-coin) the currency.

A blockchain without a currency or decentralized network is called a database. All banks currently use one already. There is no reason for any of this. Think of it like intranet (blockchain) vs. internet (bitcoin). Sadly, many do not realize this.

Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by CydeWeys on Monday December 07, 2015 @11:44AM (#10690553)
The blockchain is only useful if you need decentralization across pseudo-anonymous actors. This doesn't apply to Big Finance. The blockchain is also only useful with a large mining base, because security is achieved through having a large aggregate hashing power that cannot be overpowered by a bad actor. That is why almost all Bitcoin competitors are worthless -- they have nowhere near the hashing power, and are thus nowhere near as secure. The network effects here are huge. Having multiple blockchains is like running multiple competing power distribution networks across the country operating at different voltages. It makes more sense to standardize and have everything operate on one good one. And that's what Bitcoin already is.
Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by seanalltogether on Monday December 07, 2015 @12:10PM (#10690770)
This is like saying AT&T should have no interest in VOIP because they already have a PSTN protocols. Banking systems are full of very antiquated technologies hobbled together to allow them to work. They would be dumb not to investigate the benefits of blockchain type systems. Even if the system is limited to trusted parties and forgoes the whole mining incentive, there's still a lot of value there.
Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by CydeWeys on Monday December 07, 2015 @01:37PM (#10691524)
> Even if the system is limited to trusted parties and forgoes the whole mining incentive, there's still a lot of value there.

If you take away proof-of-work, then it's no longer a blockchain. It's just a unary Merkle tree, an idea which has been around for a long time. You can't surgically extract out the most fundamental and important part of a given idea and then call what remains the same thing.

Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by wmf on Monday December 07, 2015 @01:51PM (#10691664)
I guess it would be too embarrassing for banks to admit that they're just now getting interested in adopting 1990s technology.
Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by evgen on Monday December 07, 2015 @02:57PM (#10692202)
They will just point out that PoW incentive systems existed in the 90s along with Merkle chains; bitcoin marries the two but maybe its rise is simply revealing to banks how useful distributed consensus protocols could be for building private exchanges instead of these crypto primites remaining one among many in the huge collection of esoteric crypto protocols to arise in the crypto-Cambrian era of the 90s.
Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by aakilfernandes on Monday December 07, 2015 @03:31PM (#10692465)
I don't thonk thats a fair definition. We need some term to encompass PoS, round-robin, multisig, and not-yet-known consensus mechanisms.
Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by brighton36 on Monday December 07, 2015 @08:28PM (#10694177)
Subjectively true databases. If it's not objectively true - it's not a blockchain.
Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by bduerst on Monday December 07, 2015 @12:46PM (#10691093)
The bitcoin network isn't as mighty and powerful as you make it out to be. The hashing power you talk about is spent doing redundant work, and the network caps at 7 transactions a second (by design). Hashing power is moot when organizations can (and routinely do) bring down the network by spamming it with "stress tests".

Just because there haven't been any wildly successful block chain implementations doesn't mean that the technology can't be employed elsewhere. Many technologies are in play today that were once deemed as not being useful, and even though I'm critical of block chain, I can still think of a few validation use cases for big banks with it.

Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by empath75 on Monday December 07, 2015 @01:10PM (#10691282)
>the network caps at 7 transactions a second (by design).

That's going to be changed fairly soon.

I suspect that a lot of people are just going to use the bitcoin blockchain out of inertia, just because it's easier to use a proven platform than something you build yourself.

Unless someone needs a feature that bitcoin doesn't provide, I don't see any competing blockchain taking its place.

Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by CydeWeys on Monday December 07, 2015 @01:34PM (#10691479)
And thanks to side-chains, which Blockstream and others are working on, you can add arbitrary functionality on top of Bitcoin while still maintaining the benefits of having its large secure network.

In my view, anything using blockchain technology that isn't actually using Bitcoin's blockchain is a nonstarter. It's a fundamental misunderstanding of what Bitcoin's strengths are. It'd be like trying to come out with a new model of car that can't run on the existing roads (which actually has instructive parallels to the complete failure of earlier self-driving car attempts of the 60s that needed specialized roads).

Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by bduerst on Monday December 07, 2015 @04:27PM (#10692836)
Side chains are centralized I.O.U.s that still need bitcoin transactions in order to be fulfilled. They remove the benefits of using the decentralized bitcoin network while still using the network.

If 10 m people used side chains (just for today), it would take some of their transactions up to 40 days to fulfill. If 10 m used it again (just tomorrow), it would take almost 3 months for some transactions to fulfill.

Most merchants will not wait that long for an I.O.U., especially with fluctuating BTC exchange rates, making side chains much worse and less competitive than ACH.

Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by bduerst on Monday December 07, 2015 @01:30PM (#10691449)
>That's going to be changed fairly soon.

No, it's not. We have already seen four individual proposals to the network to increase the block size. Each requires a consensus by the miners and each was shot down.

The miners are incentivized not to increase the transaction rate, because they profit from the increased competition and fees from smaller blocks. By design, the decentralized control of bitcoin is actually what is preventing it from improving itself.

Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by CydeWeys on Monday December 07, 2015 @01:40PM (#10691543)
The miners are incentivized to do whatever is best for the value of Bitcoin, because that's what their block rewards and transaction fees are paid off in. Maximizing the block fee in a way that hurts Bitcoin itself would be myopic and irrational, and they aren't doing that. Most pools are on board with increasing the block size.
Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by bduerst on Monday December 07, 2015 @04:15PM (#10692761)
>The miners are incentivized to do whatever is best for the value of Bitcoin

No they aren't.

The miners are rational actors and incentivized to do what's best for themselves, not Bitcoin. The entire network is built on the premise that the miners are rational, and it has been demonstrated four times already.

Bitcoin is an example of how Tragedy of the Commons applies to digital networks.

Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by woah on Monday December 07, 2015 @12:48PM (#10691108)
Bitcoin can't handle more than 7 transactions per second. It's barely viable as a niche speculation currency.
Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by brighton36 on Monday December 07, 2015 @12:15PM (#10690797)
Nice work Cyde. @retube seems to think blockchains are for notarizating messages between trusted parties, instead of value transfer between untrusted parties.
Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by IkmoIkmo on Monday December 07, 2015 @02:07PM (#10691802)
The blockchain is nothing. It's just a database with some transactions which have a hash of the previous blocks... it's just a simple database in and of itself, no better than an ordinary (centralised) database.

The cool part is that it's decentralised, and you can only do that with bitcoin, or some equivalent decentralised value token (call it a currency if you want, doesn't matter but there has to be a token with value).

Big finance has very silly ideas about a bitcoinless blockchain. No other POW or equivalent protocol has a value token anywhere near the size of bitcoin, and thereby nowhere near the security. The blockchain is nothing without bitcoin, until it is usurped and there's zero indication of that happening.

There are lots of 'internal' blockchain ideas floating around right now, i.e. not decentralised, proprietary 'blockchains', which are really just ordinary centralised databases which have nothing to do with the concept 'blockchain' at all and are not novel in any way and have been around for many, many years, and Big Finance is eating that stuff up. It's nonsense really.

Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by zeeshanm on Monday December 07, 2015 @11:57AM (#10690670)
A blockchain is only as good as its network. And bitcoin happens to be on the biggest blockchain network to date.
Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by detaro on Monday December 07, 2015 @12:31PM (#10690960)
That you have to share with everybody else, with flooding attacks, ... For other categories of "good", the biggest network is not necessarily the best.
Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by CydeWeys on Monday December 07, 2015 @01:40PM (#10691551)
Can you provide some links to these flooding attacks? I'm curious. I'm not aware of Bitcoin having seriously been impacted in this manner.
Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by detaro on Monday December 07, 2015 @01:48PM (#10691632)
Re:Blockchain Challenge by Bank of England by CydeWeys on Monday December 07, 2015 @03:29PM (#10692444)
Interesting. It definitely sounds like it did some damage, but not a lot, and software has already evolved to handle it better. Plus, such an attack continues getting more and more expensive as the transaction fees you need to spend to keep it going get higher. Obviously I'm not saying this is a good thing for Bitcoin, but on the whole of things it seems like a blip. It's not like any of the fundamental algorithms underlying Bitcoin were seen to have vulnerabilities. And if I have to put up with increased transaction fees every so often during an attack in order to have a decentralized currency, well, there's worse things in the world.