If you take away proof-of-work, then it's no longer a blockchain. It's just a unary Merkle tree, an idea which has been around for a long time. You can't surgically extract out the most fundamental and important part of a given idea and then call what remains the same thing.
Just because there haven't been any wildly successful block chain implementations doesn't mean that the technology can't be employed elsewhere. Many technologies are in play today that were once deemed as not being useful, and even though I'm critical of block chain, I can still think of a few validation use cases for big banks with it.
That's going to be changed fairly soon.
I suspect that a lot of people are just going to use the bitcoin blockchain out of inertia, just because it's easier to use a proven platform than something you build yourself.
Unless someone needs a feature that bitcoin doesn't provide, I don't see any competing blockchain taking its place.
In my view, anything using blockchain technology that isn't actually using Bitcoin's blockchain is a nonstarter. It's a fundamental misunderstanding of what Bitcoin's strengths are. It'd be like trying to come out with a new model of car that can't run on the existing roads (which actually has instructive parallels to the complete failure of earlier self-driving car attempts of the 60s that needed specialized roads).
If 10 m people used side chains (just for today), it would take some of their transactions up to 40 days to fulfill. If 10 m used it again (just tomorrow), it would take almost 3 months for some transactions to fulfill.
Most merchants will not wait that long for an I.O.U., especially with fluctuating BTC exchange rates, making side chains much worse and less competitive than ACH.
No, it's not. We have already seen four individual proposals to the network to increase the block size. Each requires a consensus by the miners and each was shot down.
The miners are incentivized not to increase the transaction rate, because they profit from the increased competition and fees from smaller blocks. By design, the decentralized control of bitcoin is actually what is preventing it from improving itself.
No they aren't.
The miners are rational actors and incentivized to do what's best for themselves, not Bitcoin. The entire network is built on the premise that the miners are rational, and it has been demonstrated four times already.
Bitcoin is an example of how Tragedy of the Commons applies to digital networks.