News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My life after 44 years in prison by jacquesm on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @02:47PM (#10629173)
44 years for attempted murder of a police officer, I guess with such a benchmark the next police officer murdering a civilian will be sentenced to at least double that given that they're supposed to set an example. Incredible. What standard of sentencing would essentially take someone's life away for an attempt. Makes you wonder how big a sentence you'd get if you succeeded, more than a lifetime?
Re:My life after 44 years in prison by rayiner on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @03:33PM (#10629489)
In most states, the criminal laws are influenced by the Model Penal Code (MPC). The MPC punishes attempts as severely as completed crimes.

The MPC approach is logical. Criminal law punishes moral culpability, not bad outcomes. That's why the act of killing another human may be anything from murder to no crime at all depending on the killer's intent. A would-be murderer's moral culpability is not lessened by the fact that he is thwarted from actually accomplishing his objective.

Re:My life after 44 years in prison by peteretep on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @11:53PM (#10631340)

    > Criminal law punishes moral culpability, not bad
    > outcomes
That's untrue for (at least) many traffic violations. You'll get a considerably less harsh sentence for DUI than if you kill someone while DUI, where arguably the moral culpability is identical.
Re:My life after 44 years in prison by jolux on Thursday November 26, 2015 @02:11AM (#10631708)
But the prisons would be overflowing if we prosecuted all DUIs as attempted murder...wait they already are.
Re:My life after 44 years in prison by parennoob on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @03:41PM (#10629545)
Very good point. I thought of this by applying it to myself – if someone attempted to murder me, but did not succeed, would I want them to be put away for a very long time? You bet.
Re:My life after 44 years in prison by MrJagil on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @05:47PM (#10630265)
I get that you're trying to equate attempted and real murder but it sounds very short-sighted and it does not do any argument justice that you isolate such a serious incident from the countless factors that are surely involved (motive being prominent, but i feel a discussion of that would also turn simplistic).

For the sake of future discussions, just remember that these people are real, and there's mostly likely tremendous misfortune behind such a heinous act as murder.

No one gains anything from these 44 year long sentences.[0] He's been incapacitated for his entire life, and because of that, is seemingly going to be it for the rest of his life.

[0] Obviously if he's diagnosed as completely deranged there might be an issue of public safety.

Re:My life after 44 years in prison by avar on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @06:08PM (#10630383)
You're not really addressing the grandparent's point. Why shouldn't you purely punish culpability and ignore outcomes? It's seems way more logical and everyone recognizes this on some level.

If I shoot you purely by accident most people will agree that I shouldn't go to prison. It was an accident, I'm not a danger to society.

If I mean to murder you but my aim is off, or modern medical science manages to keep you from death, how is society better off exactly by keeping me in prison for a shorter time just because I wasn't successful?

The rational reason to put people in prison in the first place is because we consider them a danger to society. Am I less of a danger to society just because I was slightly incompetent on my first murder attempt?

Re:My life after 44 years in prison by scotty79 on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @06:38PM (#10630499)
> If I shoot you purely by accident most people will agree that I shouldn't go to prison. It was an accident, I'm not a danger to society.

That probably depends on how reckless you were. Stupidity combined with fondness for dangerous objects can be dangerous to society. Jail-time might be good idea.

> If I mean to murder you but my aim is off, or modern medical science manages to keep you from death, how is society better off exactly by keeping me in prison for a shorter time just because I wasn't successful?

Results surely must play some role. Let's imagine a world when tech is so advanced that murdering a person is really hard. Should all who attempt be punished same way as those that really put in the effort to get the job done?

Should a person be punished as if he murdered you if he was trying to kill you using voodoo magic or consciously trying to give you heart attack with insisting on you eating additional burgers?

Re:My life after 44 years in prison by avar on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @06:57PM (#10630564)

    > That probably depends on how reckless you were.
Let's assume the most generous interpretation possible. I.e. one where I'm at no fault whatsoever by any reasonable definition and pose no future risk to society.

My point is that most people do recognize the importance of intent and future outcomes.

    > Results surely must play some role.
The more I think about it I don't think they should.

Why do we put people in prison at all? Revenge is not an actual reason, which is where outcomes would matter. Future deterrence and security is a good reason. Killing someone isn't primarily a crime against /them/, but a crime against society made up by people who'd like to not live their lives surrounded by likely murderers.

If that's the goal it makes no sense to say "oh he stabbed that guy, but missed the heart by an inch, that's OK then". No it isn't.

    > if he was trying to kill you using voodoo magic
Now you're just entering the realm of the absurd. I'm talking about cases where actual people actually want to kill you (successfully or not) and what we should actually be doing about that. Let's stay on topic and not bring up silly contrived scenarios.
Re:My life after 44 years in prison by TeMPOraL on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @11:41PM (#10631305)
> The more I think about it I don't think they should.

And I agree. In a perfect world, justice would be only about intent. But we can't read people's hearts, and we can't explore all circumstances that would lead one to a punishable act. Worse, imperfect attempts at this can easily be abused by evil people to harm innocents. Therefore our legal system sticks to the only thing it can reliably measure - outcomes, sprinkling in some consideration for intent when the latter is obvious.

In a perfect world, we could probably also separate compensating victims from punishing the perpetrators. If I steal and wreck your car to save my wife who needs to get to the hospital ASAP, then in a perfect world I should go free and pay exactly nothing, but you should get a new car (or monetary equivalent) plus some reasonable opportunity costs compensation. Who would pay? The society, out of "shit happens" fund. But to work, this again would require probing intent, in order to avoid turning stealing cars into a replacement for taxi service. Since we can't reliably probe intent, we're stuck with punishing outcomes and creating incentive structures preventing such perversions from developing.

Re:My life after 44 years in prison by scotty79 on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @09:17PM (#10630932)
>> Results surely must play some role.

> The more I think about it I don't think they should.

Murder is very extreme example because it's very easy to kill a human if you decide to do it and even if you fail with a bit of luck things might have played out differently. Also murder is sharp. You can't kill a person just a little.

But consider theft. Someone who stole your insulin pump should be treated differently from someone who took some money or someone who tried to enter your house but couldn't open the lock and gave up. Or consider assault. Trying to hit someone shouldn't be punished same as hitting. I think mostly because you can hit someone to no effect (should be punished somewhat anyway) or you can kill with one hit. You'd have a problem to estimate what was attempted and what the punishment for attempt should be. ... you could have a rule that attempt is punished same as most harmless possible outcome.

...unless you are making a point just about murder and attempted murder. Then I'm inclined to agree that serious attempt and murder should be treated same if you can show that the attempt was to murder not just wound.

At least until we have technology that will make most deaths just temporary nuisances and there will be spectrum of how much you can murder someone.

>> if he was trying to kill you using voodoo magic

>Now you're just entering the realm of the absurd.

You are right. I just wanted to bring into focus some (very small fraction) of murderers that are so stupid that they attempt to use methods that couldn't possibly kill anyone and suggest that as technology progresses there might be more such people.

> Why do we put people in prison at all? Revenge is not an actual reason

That's the actual reason we put imprisoned people to death.

Re:My life after 44 years in prison by gnaritas on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @09:16PM (#10630930)
> Now you're just entering the realm of the absurd.

Which is a valid form of argument. He's showing you how absurd what you're saying is if applied literally. You don't get to duck out and claim he's off topic, you need to address his point which is perfectly valid. If intent is all that matters, then a superstitious person who believes voodoo works should according to you be charged with attempted murder; that's the logical outcome of your position, you owe him a real answer.

Re:My life after 44 years in prison by breatheoften on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @07:28PM (#10630663)
Culpability doesn't reveal the whole incentive structure. Suppose person A 'tries to kill' person B and fails but a situation arises where they have another chance to kill you but don't seize the opportunity.

To prove a moral equivalence between 'murder' and 'attempted murder' the law should have to prove that person A tried to kill person B and failed, and then also prove that they would've repeated their attempts until success if they hadn't been stopped by law enforcement ...

If I try to murder you, fail, and then stop trying to murder you, I've inherently done something 'less' than if I had succeeded in murdering you.

This would also avoid creating a legal incentive for Person B to take extra action to complete a failed murder attempt which they might otherwise not take. If the punishments for murder and attempted murder are equivalent, then a criminal should never stop until the victim is dead once reaching the point of 'attempting' murder -- the not-dead person can testify against them making it (in general) far easier for the law to successfully convict than it would be if the victim had died ...

Re:My life after 44 years in prison by thelastguy on Friday November 27, 2015 @06:16AM (#10636827)
>No one gains anything from these 44 year long sentences.

He attempted to murder a police officer, so why should benefit anything from it?

>He's been incapacitated for his entire life, and because of that, is seemingly going to be it for the rest of his life.

Of course. That's the point. That's the whole point of what a punishment is. You can't punish if you don't punish.

I understand. You don't want to punish criminals. You want to teach them how to become good. The thing about criminals is that they have no respect for nice people. So when nice peoples try to teach criminals to become good, the criminal feels like, "Why is this weak ass person trying to lecture me? I would break his neck if I am not in these chains. Talking as if he's holier than me."

Okay. You might say, "Well, if a criminal won't listen to a nice person, let's just have someone not nice teach a criminal how to become good."

Asshole: "Hey criminal, you need to be a good person." Criminal: "Fucking asshole, I'll break your neck."

Not gonna work either.

However, organized crime have found a way to do it (does not work guarantee to work 100% of the time).

The Boss: "Lowly criminal, I need you to be a good boy and not try to kill my family."

Lowly Criminal A: "No." The Boss's 30 henchmen kills him. Lowly Criminal B: "Okay. Fine. I will not try to kill your family."

Only death can deter a criminal, and that's not even guarantee to work 100% of the time (criminals back stabs their boss).

Anyway, as you can see, the above is even worst than our prison system.

However, if you feel you have a method of installing goodness into criminals, please feel free to share.

Re:My life after 44 years in prison by jacquesm on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @05:56PM (#10630324)
And in that case you'd be looking at hospitalization rather than jail. (Though the person would still not have freedom of movement it would be a whole lot better for them.)
Re:My life after 44 years in prison by cstross on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @03:05PM (#10629294)
His time served is actually twice as long as the average life sentence served for actual murder in the UK. (Some murderers are in for a "whole life" tariff -- ineligible for release on license -- but in general most are eligible for parole hearings after between 8 and 12 years and on average they serve roughly 20 years.)

Just in case anyone was thinking that 44 years for attempted murder is a light sentence.

Re:My life after 44 years in prison by runarb on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @03:17PM (#10629387)
In Norway Arnfinn Nesset served 12 years in prison and 10 years on parole for murdering 22 patients: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arnfinn_Nesset . He may have killed as many as 138.
Re:My life after 44 years in prison by lemevi on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @03:15PM (#10629376)
In Crime & Punishment Rodya only has to serve 8 years for the double axe murder of two women in the commission of a robbery. It's a fictional tale about justice in 19th century Russia, but still an interesting comparison I think of when reading about modern sentencing.
Re:My life after 44 years in prison by tosseraccount on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @03:57PM (#10629635)
Wasn't "8 years in Siberia" likely a death sentence?
Re:My life after 44 years in prison by juhanima on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:47PM (#10629949)
Not in the imperial time, no. Dostoyevsky's The House of the Dead is an interesting account of his time in Siberia, and it wasn't all that bad.

It was different in Stalin's time, though. Varlam Shalamov's Kolyma tales tells a very different story. But even he survived after having served 15 years.

Re:My life after 44 years in prison by jpatokal on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @11:17PM (#10631239)
The mortality rate in the Kolyma gulags was estimated at 27%/year, meaning the odds of survival for 15 years were <1%, and virtually zero for general work (mining etc). Shalamov survived because he managed to land a position as a hospital attendant.
Re:My life after 44 years in prison by resc1440 on Friday December 04, 2015 @02:10PM (#10678358)
This assumes that random people die each year. However, if you survive for a year, you are probably very tough, and your life expectancy might actually go up.
Re:My life after 44 years in prison by desdiv on Thursday November 26, 2015 @01:46AM (#10631639)
He got a reduced sentence for saving two kids from a burning house.
Re:My life after 44 years in prison by mcv on Thursday November 26, 2015 @08:25AM (#10632855)
In Netherland, I believe 20 years is the maximum, and with good behaviour, you could be out in 13. The murderer of Pim Fortuyn (in 2002 our first political murder in 400 years) was released from prison recently.
Re:My life after 44 years in prison by mmmBacon on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @09:47PM (#10630998)
I've had several colleagues from the UK bemoan the light sentences criminals receive in the UK. Each time I was suprised when the person referred to "proper" sentences in the US.
Re:My life after 44 years in prison by temuze on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @02:58PM (#10629254)
I think attempted crimes should get the same sentence as successful crimes.

Imagine two people stabbed identical twins in the same spot with the same intent at the same time. One dies, one lives. Should they get different sentences? It's just a roll of the dice.

Re:My life after 44 years in prison by derekp7 on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @03:10PM (#10629341)
What if you turn this around -- two people punch two identical twins in the face. One twin dies from his injuries, and the person who punched him now faces at least involuntary manslaughter, whereas the other person just has a light assault charge. Should both people get charged with involuntary manslaughter, or should they both just get the lighter assault charge?
Re:My life after 44 years in prison by kazinator on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @03:19PM (#10629408)
They should be treated differently because a fist is not considered a priori a deadly weapon. Punching someone isn't the use of lethal force. Death is almost certainly an unintended consequence of a punch.

Whereas, by contrast, the absence of death is the unintended consequence of, say, a shooting or stabbing (in any vital area of the body).

We can't go easy on an attempted murdered just because, luckily, the victim didn't die.

We also can't go easy on someone who killed using a punch just because death was unintended; the fact is that the victim died, and the fact is that not all punches are the same. They vary in intensity and area of delivery. A punch which kills (directly) must be quite a wallop, backed by a lot of rage.

[dead]
Re:My life after 44 years in prison by mahyarm on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:36PM (#10629879)
Long time ago, someone told me that assaulting someone as a trained black belt martial artist makes your assaults 'assault with a deadly weapon'. So they actually might of made the adjustment in those cases.

I was 10 years old when I was told this, so big grain of salt.

Re:My life after 44 years in prison by askafriend on Thursday November 26, 2015 @12:29AM (#10631433)
That's the point I was trying to make but I guess it flew over a bunch of people's heads. If you watch MMA, fists are absolutely deadly and can knock people out and severely hurt them in seconds.
Re:My life after 44 years in prison by bzz01 on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:58PM (#10630022)
Good point. One answer is that manslaughter is already a special case, as it doesn't require intent to kill anyway, only negligence.
Re:My life after 44 years in prison by dragonwriter on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @05:03PM (#10630058)
Crimes requiring some mental state other than specific intent are fairly common, not a special case (note that this includes murder of the depraved indifference sort.)
Re:My life after 44 years in prison by bzz01 on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @07:14PM (#10630630)
That one sounds fairly similar to manslaughter, no?

My understanding is that logically there's that basic framework of required specific intent, then there are a few crimes that allow prosecuting for negligence, then very few crimes with strict liability.

I'm originally not from US so I'm probably still getting used that the latter two categories are quite common in US law (and that strict liability is even possible).

Re:My life after 44 years in prison by chasing on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:38PM (#10629884)
Just to note, our society oftentimes makes penalties much worse when the crimes are against officers of the state. Like police officers. Or judges. Or the President. And it makes sense that someone shouldn't see killing a cop as a viable means of escaping arrest or what-have-you, just as they shouldn't see murdering a judge (or threatening) as a viable means to get a judgment in their favor.
Re:My life after 44 years in prison by theandrewbailey on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @03:53PM (#10629614)
> 44 years for attempted murder of a police officer... Makes you wonder how big a sentence you'd get if you succeeded, more than a lifetime?

Probably depends on the state, but where I grew up (Ohio), murder of an on-duty officer is one of the few crimes where capital punishment is possible.

Re:My life after 44 years in prison by redml on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:24PM (#10629811)
If someone attempted to murder you, what do you think would be a suitable punishment for that person? Honest question. If they were in jail for a short amount of time you'd probably be a bit worried that they would come find you after and finish the job.
Re:My life after 44 years in prison by jacquesm on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:45PM (#10629934)
I think after 44 years I'd feel pretty safe.

Attempted murder of a head of state, maybe 25 years or so? Assuming pre-meditation. Attempted murder of myself, 10 years at most, if not pre-meditated, otherwise if it was pre-meditated then some more, but with a chance of parole given good behaviour and maybe psychiatric observation.

Aggravating or other circumstances should be taken into account too, I'm sure that those judges would do their best.

44 years is excessive, by any measure. You're simply not talking about the same person any more. 22 -> 66, that's a life gone. Does the guy in that article look like a serious threat to you? To the officer he tried to kill? To anybody else?

All I see is an old guy who made a really bad dumb move when he was a lot younger, and probably a whole angrier than today. I also question the extra months after he served the many many years for a shoplifting charge when he was 17. That's just revenge, it has nothing to do with justice or having the best of society at heart.

Re:My life after 44 years in prison by redml on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @05:13PM (#10630099)
> Does the guy in that article look like a serious threat to you?

Well he's old now, that was probably the point of his sentence.

> I also question the extra months after he served the many many years for a shoplifting charge when he was 17.

He did allegedly try to kill a cop afterall, I have no doubt the judge was not kind to him for that.

He's rehabilitated now, but you're right that 44 years wasn't necessary. I'd also say 25, tops.

Re:My life after 44 years in prison by zanny on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @05:27PM (#10630170)
Except carte blanche sentencing on intent is not enough. The attempted murderer after 10 years may be incredibly vindictive and immediately seek revenge, possibly mass murder in retaliation for his incarceration.

Likewise, the 25 year sentenced individual might wholly repent after five years, and thus sit in prison for another twenty with no rehabilitative meaning, he just rots to serve as an example to others.

You need informed decisions in the process of removing people from society and when to reintroduce them. It is not something to write down on paper or try to set universal rules. You need extensive oversight to prevent exploitation of those given the power over the lives of others, but you need informed and intelligent decision makers with multiple opinions deciding when the dangerous are fit to participate again in society, not arbitrary number guessing.

And no, its not cheap. But its more expensive socially to have the redeemed rot and the vengeful run free.

Re:My life after 44 years in prison by jacquesm on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @05:42PM (#10630239)
> The attempted murderer after 10 years may be incredibly vindictive and immediately seek revenge, possibly mass murder in retaliation for his incarceration.

I'll take that chance. For every how many people that just spent a decade in jail do you think there will be one that manages to squeak by observation and hearings for a decade?

How many people would you be prepared to jail to save one life of an innocent person?

Re:My life after 44 years in prison by zanny on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @10:17PM (#10631066)
Thats the point. You cannot just assign a sentence and presume rehabilitation at the other side. Crimes along the entire violence spectrum that require removal from society all require case by case consideration of when, if ever, the criminal is suitable to reenter society.

A lot of them never should, that never repent and would always be a threat to others. But then you have those that rot in jail for decades after being completely rehabilitated by policies like mandatory minimums and extended sentencing like mentioned in this article waste their lives and our tax dollars on something that a board of active professional psychoanalyists should be able to see is a shut case.

It is easy to deceive an inefficient, corrupt, or lazy system when given per-case inspective authority. But it is not easy in the presence of a rigored well implemented system. Rather than try to simplify criminal justice to sentencing based on crime committed with fixed sentences taken from a textbook, we should appeal to reach the global maxima of justice, which includes curtailing the injustice of keeping those no longer dangerous behind bars perpetually.

Re:My life after 44 years in prison by throwaway2048 on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @07:07PM (#10630598)
there is a reason victims don't determine sentencing