News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My life after 44 years in prison by breatheoften on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @07:28PM (#10630663)
Culpability doesn't reveal the whole incentive structure. Suppose person A 'tries to kill' person B and fails but a situation arises where they have another chance to kill you but don't seize the opportunity.

To prove a moral equivalence between 'murder' and 'attempted murder' the law should have to prove that person A tried to kill person B and failed, and then also prove that they would've repeated their attempts until success if they hadn't been stopped by law enforcement ...

If I try to murder you, fail, and then stop trying to murder you, I've inherently done something 'less' than if I had succeeded in murdering you.

This would also avoid creating a legal incentive for Person B to take extra action to complete a failed murder attempt which they might otherwise not take. If the punishments for murder and attempted murder are equivalent, then a criminal should never stop until the victim is dead once reaching the point of 'attempting' murder -- the not-dead person can testify against them making it (in general) far easier for the law to successfully convict than it would be if the victim had died ...

There are no comments on this comment yet.