Re:My life after 44 years in prison
by scotty79 on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @09:17PM
(#10630932)
>> Results surely must play some role.
> The more I think about it I don't think they should.
Murder is very extreme example because it's very easy to kill a human if you decide to do it and even if you fail with a bit of luck things might have played out differently. Also murder is sharp. You can't kill a person just a little.
But consider theft. Someone who stole your insulin pump should be treated differently from someone who took some money or someone who tried to enter your house but couldn't open the lock and gave up. Or consider assault. Trying to hit someone shouldn't be punished same as hitting. I think mostly because you can hit someone to no effect (should be punished somewhat anyway) or you can kill with one hit. You'd have a problem to estimate what was attempted and what the punishment for attempt should be. ... you could have a rule that attempt is punished same as most harmless possible outcome.
...unless you are making a point just about murder and attempted murder. Then I'm inclined to agree that serious attempt and murder should be treated same if you can show that the attempt was to murder not just wound.
At least until we have technology that will make most deaths just temporary nuisances and there will be spectrum of how much you can murder someone.
>> if he was trying to kill you using voodoo magic
>Now you're just entering the realm of the absurd.
You are right. I just wanted to bring into focus some (very small fraction) of murderers that are so stupid that they attempt to use methods that couldn't possibly kill anyone and suggest that as technology progresses there might be more such people.
> Why do we put people in prison at all? Revenge is not an actual reason
That's the actual reason we put imprisoned people to death.
> The more I think about it I don't think they should.
Murder is very extreme example because it's very easy to kill a human if you decide to do it and even if you fail with a bit of luck things might have played out differently. Also murder is sharp. You can't kill a person just a little.
But consider theft. Someone who stole your insulin pump should be treated differently from someone who took some money or someone who tried to enter your house but couldn't open the lock and gave up. Or consider assault. Trying to hit someone shouldn't be punished same as hitting. I think mostly because you can hit someone to no effect (should be punished somewhat anyway) or you can kill with one hit. You'd have a problem to estimate what was attempted and what the punishment for attempt should be. ... you could have a rule that attempt is punished same as most harmless possible outcome.
...unless you are making a point just about murder and attempted murder. Then I'm inclined to agree that serious attempt and murder should be treated same if you can show that the attempt was to murder not just wound.
At least until we have technology that will make most deaths just temporary nuisances and there will be spectrum of how much you can murder someone.
>> if he was trying to kill you using voodoo magic
>Now you're just entering the realm of the absurd.
You are right. I just wanted to bring into focus some (very small fraction) of murderers that are so stupid that they attempt to use methods that couldn't possibly kill anyone and suggest that as technology progresses there might be more such people.
> Why do we put people in prison at all? Revenge is not an actual reason
That's the actual reason we put imprisoned people to death.