It took a while before someone finally figured it out and word spread on Twitter. I'm sure hundreds of thousands if not millions of dollars of productivity were lost that day.
Helpful when 22 is blocked (train stations and such)
[0]: https://community.openvpn.net/openvpn/wiki/Openvpn23ManPage
The old dialup ISPs were allowed to resell internet service on the local provider's POTS lines. There was quite a lot of competition, and the service was generally excellent, even generally better than the carrier's.
There is no requirement for broadband providers like Comcast to allow resellers. The barrier to entry for laying other broadband lines is huge; Google is one of the few who can do it. So unless there's a quantum leap in wireless to the curb, there will be no meaningful competition to amoral corporations like Comcast; we're stuck and it will continue to suck.
[EDIT] Corrected wrong assumption that old AT&T was government owned.
I know Google fiber will never come to the East Bay (SF area). It would be so nice to have, though.
Basically imagine if someone owned the only bridge into San Francisco. They could charge whatever people were willing to pay. But you would think if they charge too much money or scream obscenities at everyone who drives through, then someone could build another bridge and steal their customers. The problem is that if anyone builds another bridge the bridge owner could stop screaming obscenities and lower his prices. Then the second bridge could not make the return on capital. The prospective business owner and current owner know this so the status quo of one expensive and crappy bridge remains.
The data caps you've recently put into place in my market are going to effectively double my account price per month. I look forward to the day that I have other choices.
That's been my experience, as well. In two instances (one business class, one residential), I had issues getting their construction department to actually do the work they promised until I was able to get through to the escalation department—once via Twitter, once (IIRC) on dslreports.com back when the Comcast direct forum was monitored. Once the escalation department was engaged, things moved very quickly, with them calling me almost daily with status updates.
There are clearly individuals at Comcast who care about customer service. Unfortunately, they don't seem to be the ones in charge of organizational policies and processes.
They do advertise that they spend millions of dollars on improving their customer support, but I've yet to see anything happen on their end. Amusingly, our Comcast business contract at work has at least a couple of issues every week, too. We only don't notice them if they are to happen over the weekend, but when CRON jobs that require internet connection haven't run over the weekend, it's easy to figure out who needs blamed.
Some listing of what the actual issue is would be kinda useful, even if you shove it in a collapsible div to hide it away.
I (and most people) are more likely to rage-quit and go do something else than try to navigate three layers of outsourced customer service that is designed and optimized to deflect people, waste their time, and only if they are sufficiently insistent, and border-line belligerent, maybe give them an answer more involved than "unplug your modem and plug it back in"
- If your modem is EOL
- If you modem's ethernet port is 100Mbps, and you have >100Mbps service
- If your modem is otherwise capable of providing your speed (i.e. number of DOCSIS channels)
- We check your signal levels to make sure they are in spec
- We check if you have been impacted by our Protocol Agnostic Congestion management system in the past 1 day or 30 days.
If any of these checks are triggered, we show it on the page. If nothing is triggered, we allow you to go straight to a chat.
We'll be adding more checks as time goes on, mostly around Wifi - MCS Index, Link rate, RSSI, etc.
EDIT: fixed! let me know if you see anything else out of place.
Same here. They are very aware that we have no other choices. They will continue provide the least amount of service for the greatest cost until this changes.
The biggest thing I liked, moving back to Iowa was decent internet provider.
>For a CMTS port to enter the Near Congestion State, traffic flowing to or from that CMTS port must exceed a specified level (the "Port Utilization Threshold") for a specific period of time (the "Port Utilization Duration").
>Given our experience as described above, we determined that a starting point for the upstream Port Utilization Threshold should be 70 percent and the downstream Port Utilization Threshold should be 80 percent. For the Port Utilization Duration, we determined that the starting point should be approximately 15 minutes
>Thus, over any 15-minute period, if an average of more than 70 percent of a port's upstream bandwidth capacity or more than 80 percent of a port's downstream bandwidth capacity is utilized, that port is determined to be in a Near Congestion State.
>For a user to enter an Extended High Consumption State, he or she must consume greater than a certain percentage of his or her provisioned upstream or downstream bandwidth(the "User Consumption Threshold") for a specific length of time (the "User Consumption Duration").
>we have determined that the appropriate starting point for the User Consumption Threshold is 70 percent of a subscriber's provisioned upstream or downstream bandwidth, and that the appropriate starting point for the User Consumption Duration is 15 minutes
> A user's traffic is released from a BE state when the user's bandwidth consumption drops below 50 percent of his or her provisioned upstream or downstream bandwidth for a period of approximately 15 minutes.
Its throttled until you've used less than 50% of what you pay for for at least 15 minutes.
That threshold is so low specifically so that a line doesn't end up cycling between throttled and not every interval if its 79% once then 81% the next, etc.
It seems obvious to me that Comcast et al are vastly overselling beyond their capacity.
They then market these strategies as methods to ensure quality to their customers, when their customers bought a service that was misadvertised as having enough capacity for them in the first place.
Just like airlines - they sell more tickets than they have seats, because they figure they can squeeze more profit out of the people who paid for a ticket but didnt show up, then when everyone shows up, someone has to get bumped.
Question #1: Is the CMTS Upstream Port Utilization at an average of OVER 70% for OVER 15 minutes?
Result #1: CMTS marked in a Near Congestion State, indicating
congestion *may* occur soon.
Action #1: Search most recent analysis timeframe (approx. 15 mins.)
of IPDR usage data.
Question #2: Are any users consuming an average of OVER 70% of
provisioned upstream bandwidth for OVER 15 minutes?
Result #2: No action taken.
Result #3: Change user's upstream traffic from Priority Best Effort
(PBE) to Best Effort (BE).
Question #3: Is the user in Best Effort (BE) consuming an average
of LESS THAN 50% of provisioned upstream bandwidth
over a period of 15 minutes?
Result #4: Change user's upstream traffic back to Priority Best
Effort (PBE) from Best Effort (BE).I would hope that someone with the resources and knowledge to make them pay for these shenanigans will....
That said, you could argue that data networks are mostly a natural monopoly because it's not feasible or efficient to roll out several redundant fiber/cable networks.
Even if there were no franchise agreements in place, very few companies (excepting ones that have other revenue streams) would roll out a second or third cable/fiber network in a city where there is already one in place. Even if you managed to split the market and get half of the potential customers, you'd need to account for the cost of digging trenches and laying cable (which cable TV companies have long since recouped). Makes it hard to stay solvent at such a disadvantage.
It's why a lot of people think the ideal situation is for a single physical network to be built and then service providers pay for access and compete on service to businesses and customers. With physical networks divorced from service providers, the company or municipality in charge of the actual cable/fiber makes their money from maintaining and improving capacity so they can sell access to more providers. Providers compete by offering the best services and customer support in order to profit and pay for more bandwidth on the physical network.
But yeah, it's more complicated (in terms of both business and networking tech) but it's an ideal that many would like to move toward.
But in the end, I'm not sure what's the best way to handle it. I just know that many would agree that the current methods are not optimum, and possibly detrimental.
This model was used regularly for rail and power networks in Europe, but these have all been privatised in the past few decades citing "cost reductions". The net result is that our infrastructure is deteriorating, consumer prices are rising way faster than inflation, and critical infrastructure is now in the hands of a few international power brokers (e.g. the Dutch national telephone grid is owned by Carlos Slim).
Tuesday we could not access VNC nor our remote database services from that location. All port 80 traffic was fine. I had one of the staff call, wait on hold for an hours.
Just as I suspected Comcast had implemented port blocking on a high priced business account. It took the guy a second to release it. It put our company down for two to three hours.
Also the speed of Comcast service drops to 15-20% of advertised from 2:30 to 5 PM when kids arrive home from school.
Once the contract is up we are moving the service to someone who understands "business class"