Far as intelligence agencies, they've not just failed: they've often tried to cover it up, mislead other authorities, or even destroy evidence. The result of incompetent organizations not capitalizing on what they have even when it's obvious should be a net reduction of power and increase of accountability. Instead, they always ask for and often get the opposite.
The technically literate of us following the details should just keep reiterating to anyone that will listen the key detail: almost everyone whose launched an attack did it while already being under surveillance. It doesn't work. End of story.
Note: If it did, they just go back to doing what pro's already are in using human go-betweens and other low-to-no-tech methods like Osama did for years to dodge NSA. They didn't get him until someone tipped them off for the bounty per Hersh.
How do I convince someone they should try to not feel fear if they strongly believe their fear is valid and that attempts to invalidate their fear are an insult.
I don't think that you'll find many exceptions to that.
> E.g. I know that there is almost no chance that I'll be the victim of gang violence. But that doesn't mean I have to just accept the existence of gang violence in my community.
So, as a member of that community you then have the option to go out and do something about it. You can also move out, you can pay someone else to do something about it (which you already do through your taxes, hopefully they do enough). You can also keep your eyes open if you see anything suspicious and report it. You can rally support for better pay for the police so the chances of corrupt police interacting with gangs goes down.
And finally, it may actually mean that yes, you will have to accept the existence of gang violence in your community if that community is incapable of changing from within.
Gang violence takes a while to establish itself, and it - even with the best of the best working to get rid of it - can't be gotten rid overnight. Problems of this kind usually take roughly as long to fix as it takes to solve them.
Note: The 100-1,000 years is to represent the fact that virtually nobody dies from terrorist attacks. It's so rare that bathtubs and bee stings kill more people each year in the U.S.. I'd imagine it's not a leading cause of death in France either despite the recent attack. So, for your gang thing with 100-200 people in a neighborhood, they'd go through many generations before one person died from gang violence. Sounds like the high risk that should keep them up at night, eh? ;)
Accepting that means we can throw those wasted resources at things that have a better chance of working - throw the tech that detects copyright infringements at detecting pro-ISIL sites, and use DCMA-style tactics to take them down. Fund new research to put effective bomb and weapon detectors into every doorway. Because protecting borders doesn't work either (crunchy on the outside, soft on the inside). Build schools, instead of bombing them. Stop selling weapons to the very people that shouldn't have them. Teach politicians to value non-American lives as much as American ones. Stop honouring violent death, and honour the deaths of people who move humanity forward instead.
There's an endless stream of ideas of what we could do, if only we actually wanted it.
"The problem is that we have forgotten the power of ideology and the way that you cultivate civilized discourse and expectations. In the Western world, we've spent the last 40 years shitting all over the best weapons we have to address ideology: philosophy, literature, poetry, art, music and religious discourse. We've marginalized the way to talk about the abstract elements of human experience, and now we find that we have nothing to say."
I don't think surveillance is very good at preventing terrorism, but I think it could be useful to law enforcement after the fact to round up co-conspirators. I bet that once the identity of the Paris attackers was learned, the NSA pulled up a graph several levels deep of everybody they communicated it or associated with. It could very well help them figure out who else is involved and should be watched.
For the record, I'm opposed to surveillance and would be even if it were shown to be very effective. Privacy is important and is worth more than the lives that have been or will be lost to terrorists and other criminals.
All these guys were already on watch lists for fighting in Syria and returning just nobody seems to ever watch the watch list.
No bulk surveillance required, just honest police work within the confines of a valid and acceptable legal framework.
But then, if they'd used a CB radio, there'd have been no records on the device at all. You can go both lower and higher tech to avoid leaving a trail.
The fundamental issue our society faces is that the world people thought existed, pre-Snowden, wasn't all that bad. There are controls, a system of laws and warrants, judges have to approve requests for data, and companies hand it out only in cases where it's really justified. Terrorist used WhatsApp to send a message to his buddy before blowing up a football stadium? It is - literally - warranted.
Post Snowden we know that world didn't really exist, it was more a sort of theatre governments put on when they didn't care much about the outcome. So now the data is disappearing so nobody has it. It's not obvious that this is an improvement over restoring the world that was previously thought to exist, but that was apparently too unstable to survive.
Each and every operation of this magnitude leaves a trail. The party perpetrating it will try what they can to erase that trail but that will always be an imperfect process.
Maybe next time the phone will be secured, they will scrub themselves of parking tickets, they will burn up their escape vehicle after a few minutes ride and so on. All the media has succeeded in doing is educate the terrorists about how to be more successful in evading capture and possibly being more successful in carrying out the attack in the first place.
My point was that collecting it all isn't necessarily about stopping incidents, it's about instantly knowing everything about a terrorist once they are identified through other means. There's certainly value there and the debate is whether or not the cost is too high.
That means the DGSI would need 230,000 staff to follow all of the extremists all of the time
I don't want to live in a world that has bomb detectors in every doorway.
I think that when terror is something that can happen constantly for months at a time, people learn to keep living their lives without fear, but also to take measurable actions that really prevent the next attack.
We have no idea how many attacks have been prevented (everyone likes to claim this is zero....but they do so without any evidence to support that, as relevant information is surely classified beyond Top Secret).
We have only the slightest, tiniest, smallest idea of what the NSA and other intelligence organizations are capable of.
British intelligence took how long to tell people that they cracked enigma? 50 years?
Out of the THOUSANDS of documents that Edward Snowden leaked to reporters, the public has access to what? on the order of 50?
Yeah....we know nothing...so saying one way or the other is kind of ridiculous at this point.
My point is entirely aimed at the linguistic use of "proves" than anything else.
The person I was commenting to, however, IS making a claim. Maybe your burden of proof applies to him?
This argument is actually subject to Russel's Teapot, if you cant prove or disprove anything the burden of proof is on proving the thing. I have yet to see any evidence.
We as a society do not have that power, and that should be obvious by now.
When a court decided what they were doing was illegal, less than a day later (probably the fastest anything has EVER happen in the legal system), another bench decided that what the NSA was doing was TOO BIG TO STOP. Like seriously, their argument for not stopping something UNCONSTITUTIONAL was that they were doing too much of it.
You and I, and every other civilian who actually understands what they're doing have ZERO power to stop them, so they have ZERO incentive to convince US what matters.
You know who they DO have to convince? The exact people that keep voting to KEEP THEM IN POWER.
I don't care what Obama and his administration claims, like I said, they have no incentive to prove anything to the American public.
"Is mass surveillance useless? Unless you can prove it, it's obviously useful. See Russell's teapot."
(Russell's teapot doesn't apply anyway, because the thing to prove is falsifiable: governments /could/ release information about thwarted attacks, in case there are any.)
Yes, we do. We know ALL of the FBI's high profile terrorism cases. Apart from the Tsarnaev brothers, it has been all cases where one or more fools got snared by a provocateur.
So unless you believe that there is a secret system of arrest, a secret court that hears terrorism trials, and secret prisons all operating inside the US, we know exactly how effective mass surveillance of the US population has been in preventing terrorism.
We already know there are secret courts that hear secret arguments that can't be refuted by defendants/targets. Oh, and if that court involved you, you're legally not even allowed to tell anyone.
We already know that the NSA/FBI/CIA/DEA uses parallel construction to actually prosecute crimes against US citizens.
How do we know this stuff? Someone with clearance risked his life, and gave up his freedom to tell the world. Oh, and the US said they MIGHT NOT waterboard him if he ever came back to the US to face his crimes.
And out of the thousands of documents he had, how many do we have access to? A few handful?
Sure...we know everything </sarcasm (as if you couldn't tell)>
Except that most of the recent terror attacks have involved at least one person known to the authorities. One of the Paris attackers even had an international arrest warrant out for him.
Edit: Some more on that: the best way to attack a high-tech society is using low-tech means and vv. We're totally blinded by our trust in technology.
We all know that while terrorism gives these initiatives fuel, they ultimately have little to do with terrorism and much more to do with governments wanting as much surveillance and control over their populations as possible. The odds of dying in a terrorist attack are approximately 1 in 20 million; for comparison, you are 25X more likely to die by drowning in a bathtub and 1,000X more likely to die in a car crash [1]. If terrorists are 1/25th as effective at killing people as bathtubs, how many of our civil liberties should we be willing to give up to stop them?
There are currently at least 3,278 prisoners in the US serving life without parole for non-violent offenses [2]. Perhaps we should stop terrorizing our own citizens before we worry about foreign terrorists that can't even keep up with bathtubs.
[1] https://reason.com/archives/2011/09/06/how-scared-of-terrori...
[2] https://www.aclu.org/files/assets/111813-lwop-complete-repor...
You are proposing that public spaces be fitted with some kind of system that can reliably detect bullets based on their "speed, size, and shape" profile.
How do you propose to do this without using a bunch of sensors?
> and much more to do with governments wanting as much surveillance and control over their populations as possible
Outfitting all public spaces with sound and vision recording/analysis devices seems like the very definition of mass surveillance and control.
> Anyway, generally you're referring to technical challenges, all of which could be readily solved.
Of course, we should not get bogged down in the technical implementation detail, but you can't just brush away these - very valid - technical criticisms of your idea.
You want to hash out the design of a complex idea in an HN comment thread?
There is way too much volume and noise to find threats in the hurricane of hay flying past to find the needles in real time.
But if you have someone specific to start targeting, you can quite easily take their whole life apart and find their friends and make all these connections after the fact.
The goal isn't to stop attacks, it's to ensure that nobody goes unpunished.
Another reason not to publicise their successes is that may give an indication of how they are tracking and if the terrorists know how they are being tracked they can change how they operate. For example perhaps they always call directory enquiries to get a number/address and if that is the way in it's in the interest of the spies to not let them know that so they can continue to use that chink.
If I was slightly more conspiratorial I would suggest that that is the 64 million dollar question.
In reality though, I think we are talking about two different types of knowledge here.
When I say knowledge is power, I'm talking about power over individuals. The type of knowledge that allows you to say "Hmm, those are some interesting emails you sent, Senator. Let's see if we can come to an agreement to make sure nobody else sees these." The type of knowledge that makes the average citizen think twice before making that Google search, or before posting a comment online.
Even with total info awareness, to stop attacks you need the ability to filter and flag the data you have to sound the alarm when needed. Fundamentally, that's a data processing problem and not specifically what I am talking about.
I think the response should be a careful, cursory action that acknowledges the public demand for retaliation, but all else put into the long game of building resistance to radicalised violence - working on education, poverty, etc amongst the communities where agitators source members. We should be encouraging people to find common ground rather than react aggressively, even if that is the gut response.
I am very irreligious, but there was a great comment on HN the other day about a fairly orthodox Christian finding that they had more in common with a fairly orthodox Muslim colleague than with other atheist co-workers.
Often the political and public reaction after an event like this is to focus on differences (language, clothing like burkas, etc) rather than things like a love of family, of food, sport, music and so on.
I live in Australia and our new prime minister is far, far better at this than the previous us-vs-them dog-whistler.
But let's take at face value that that's possible, you'd still have to assume that all terrorists have a) some rational set of demands; and b) even if they did, that we'd be willing to meet those demands.
What ISIS believes is incompatible with Western democracy. There is nothing we could do to eliminate their desire to attack us that wouldn't mean our own destruction, anyway.
No, the goal should be to improve the living conditions, infrastructure, access to education, etc of impoverished regions where terrorist sentiment typically appears and festers.
To give an extreme example, there is a reason the Saudi royalty aren't walking into the middle of a marketplace and blowing themselves up: they already have everything they want/need. I'm not saying we should make everyone royalty, but that there is a clear correlation between standard of living and terrorist sentiment.
Standard of living is a continuous curve which has absolutely nothing to do with mass murder. There is a binary switch which occurs separately from any experience which is measured in terms of 'standard of living'. Now maybe there are some experiences which can drive a person to commit terrorism, but I think more likely, this terrorism is not a consequence of some action, but rather, these are a group of people who use terrorism as a tool to wage war. Why are they at war with the West? It's not because of standard of living, I'm pretty sure it's because they hate everything the West stands for and wants it to burn.
You mean the United States of America, terrorizing Pakistanis for years now?
There's no binary switch. There are tactics effective for given goals and circumstances. Mass shootings and suicide bombings are a perfect strategy if you want to make a country destroy itself. The question is - why would you like to make that country destroy itself? The answer is not:
> It's not because of standard of living, I'm pretty sure it's because they hate everything the West stands for and wants it to burn.
That's not only bullshit but, if it were true, it would be the best argument to just ignore those attacks and treat them as any other murder done by organized crime. Because if they "hate our freedom", then by overreacting and turning ourselves into police states, we're doing their job for them - we're putting our economy and industry into dismantling everything the West stands for.
You look for a second at the people who actually carried out recent attacks, you will see what I mean. Who said anything about police state?
The thing which has impressed me is apparently this guy was a prolific attack planner. Known and poorly tracked. I'd say a major intelligence failure.
All those have a higher percentage of Christians in their populations than the US or anywhere in Western Europe, and they don't have the same level of anti-terrorism focus so are presumably easier targets.
Could it simply be that those countries haven't been bombing and invading places in the Middle East?
These countries have negligible numbers of Muslims.
There have been multiple Islamic terrorist attacks in Tanzania (which borders Zambia) and Kenya, both of which have significant Muslim minorities. Not to mention the frequent attacks by Boko Haram et al in Nigeria and the perpetual civil war in Somalia, which is overwhelmingly Muslim.
Even the threats and attacks against cartoonists, as mentioned by another commenter, go beyond the simplistic "kill all infidels just because they exist".
To put it more simply: when Danish cartoonists are threatened for offending Islam, is that also because of imperialism?
And why would you believe them? What they say on TV is also a weapon. People who don't come and negotiate but go straight to killing won't be posting their real goals on their website, they'll rather post something that helps further those goals.
It more or less proves (to me at least) that the government(s) and the various secret services have absolutely no idea who to monitor specifically. So instead of targeting their operations they want to monitor all of us, just in case something of interest pops out that then allows them to focus their attention.
It's a pretty scary thought: just imagine, all that money, all those resources and still they can't do anything other than to put their ear to the ground and hope that someone messes up in plaintext so they can then try to backtrack and see what they might have missed.
In all these attacks it never happened that everybody was under the radar. Always one or more of the attackers that were technically known or even already under surveillance. And yet the attacks happened anyway. Too many targets make for a very thinly deployed service, which then has to be automated to make it work at all.
It's a pretty sobering thought, it also suggests via yet another route that mass surveillance is indeed meant to attempt to 'keep us safe', and that it fails miserably. The road to hell is paved with the best of intentions.
Terrorists have it so easy, all they need to do is to be just a little bit unpredictable or simply old-fashioned (in person) and there won't be anything whatsoever that we can concretely do to stop them. The only thing that actually gives a bunch of actionable data is when an attack is executed or when an attack goes sour (or rather: sweet as in, it does not work) from which direct evidence of contacts or plans is gained. This will then lead to a relatively short lived number of arrests clustered around the people caught or implicated and then it burns out again where the data ends.
And so then we get to wait for the next attack...