News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Back Door to Encryption Won't Stop Terrorists by Spearchucker on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @06:29PM (#10591517)
You nailed it, I think. If surveillance works, then Paris, Beirut, Bagdad et al wouldn't have happed. Realizing it's a pipe dream, I'd love to see a world accept that we the west have done so much damage that nothing will stop terrorism.

Accepting that means we can throw those wasted resources at things that have a better chance of working - throw the tech that detects copyright infringements at detecting pro-ISIL sites, and use DCMA-style tactics to take them down. Fund new research to put effective bomb and weapon detectors into every doorway. Because protecting borders doesn't work either (crunchy on the outside, soft on the inside). Build schools, instead of bombing them. Stop selling weapons to the very people that shouldn't have them. Teach politicians to value non-American lives as much as American ones. Stop honouring violent death, and honour the deaths of people who move humanity forward instead.

There's an endless stream of ideas of what we could do, if only we actually wanted it.

Re:A Back Door to Encryption Won't Stop Terrorists by prawn on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @11:01PM (#10592646)
I liked this comment on Reddit which I think is relevant in a discussion about combatting this form of terrorism:

"The problem is that we have forgotten the power of ideology and the way that you cultivate civilized discourse and expectations. In the Western world, we've spent the last 40 years shitting all over the best weapons we have to address ideology: philosophy, literature, poetry, art, music and religious discourse. We've marginalized the way to talk about the abstract elements of human experience, and now we find that we have nothing to say."

Re:A Back Door to Encryption Won't Stop Terrorists by vacri on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @06:57PM (#10591670)
It's not that "we have done so much damage", it's just that terrorism exists, full stop. Europe has a long history of home-grown terrorism - Paris in particular had a lot of various groups attacking it in the 80s, for example. The US has it's own home-grown terrorism as well, the stereotype being the KKK.
Re:A Back Door to Encryption Won't Stop Terrorists by thomasrossi on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @08:12PM (#10592035)
There are indeed plenty of third-generation Algerians in France. The ones I know are happy being in France though, I am not sure it is home-grown, it has been planned with local help, but the source was tracked in Turkey, then lost. I think they have a good protocol to handle communication outside internet.
Re:A Back Door to Encryption Won't Stop Terrorists by vacri on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @10:12PM (#10592510)
When I say European home-grown terrorism, I'm not thinking of recently arrived demographics, but groups like Irish and Basque separatists.
Re:A Back Door to Encryption Won't Stop Terrorists by criddell on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @08:59PM (#10592256)
> If surveillance works, then Paris, Beirut, Bagdad et al wouldn't have happed.

I don't think surveillance is very good at preventing terrorism, but I think it could be useful to law enforcement after the fact to round up co-conspirators. I bet that once the identity of the Paris attackers was learned, the NSA pulled up a graph several levels deep of everybody they communicated it or associated with. It could very well help them figure out who else is involved and should be watched.

For the record, I'm opposed to surveillance and would be even if it were shown to be very effective. Privacy is important and is worth more than the lives that have been or will be lost to terrorists and other criminals.

Re:A Back Door to Encryption Won't Stop Terrorists by pakled_engineer on Thursday November 19, 2015 @12:30AM (#10592920)
They found one of the terrorists phones dumped in a garbage can outside the theatre they attacked, and got the address of their hideout from the messages, so used just regular police work.

All these guys were already on watch lists for fighting in Syria and returning just nobody seems to ever watch the watch list.

Re:A Back Door to Encryption Won't Stop Terrorists by Canada on Thursday November 19, 2015 @01:11AM (#10593037)
If that phone was properly secured then those messages wouldn't have been accessible.
Re:A Back Door to Encryption Won't Stop Terrorists by junto on Thursday November 19, 2015 @02:50PM (#10597088)
You'd still have a telephone number. From that telephone number you could go to a judge and request a warrant for the telephone records. From there you could look at all the numbers dialed and received. Now you get a warrant for the addresses of the subscribers.

No bulk surveillance required, just honest police work within the confines of a valid and acceptable legal framework.

Re:A Back Door to Encryption Won't Stop Terrorists by mike_hearn on Thursday November 19, 2015 @05:39AM (#10593982)
True, I thought the same.

But then, if they'd used a CB radio, there'd have been no records on the device at all. You can go both lower and higher tech to avoid leaving a trail.

The fundamental issue our society faces is that the world people thought existed, pre-Snowden, wasn't all that bad. There are controls, a system of laws and warrants, judges have to approve requests for data, and companies hand it out only in cases where it's really justified. Terrorist used WhatsApp to send a message to his buddy before blowing up a football stadium? It is - literally - warranted.

Post Snowden we know that world didn't really exist, it was more a sort of theatre governments put on when they didn't care much about the outcome. So now the data is disappearing so nobody has it. It's not obvious that this is an improvement over restoring the world that was previously thought to exist, but that was apparently too unstable to survive.

Re:A Back Door to Encryption Won't Stop Terrorists by jacquesm on Thursday November 19, 2015 @02:21AM (#10593257)
That's roughly equivalent to 'if those documents had not been properly shred that data would not have been available'.

Each and every operation of this magnitude leaves a trail. The party perpetrating it will try what they can to erase that trail but that will always be an imperfect process.

Maybe next time the phone will be secured, they will scrub themselves of parking tickets, they will burn up their escape vehicle after a few minutes ride and so on. All the media has succeeded in doing is educate the terrorists about how to be more successful in evading capture and possibly being more successful in carrying out the attack in the first place.

Re:A Back Door to Encryption Won't Stop Terrorists by Khaine on Thursday November 19, 2015 @05:35AM (#10593966)
France has something like 11,500 on the extremist watchlist. I'm not sure its practical to watch and monitor that many people with the staffing levels of French Intelligence without acting like the stasi
Re:A Back Door to Encryption Won't Stop Terrorists by throwaway7767 on Thursday November 19, 2015 @06:16AM (#10594111)
That's precisely the point being discussed. The "collect it all!" mentality of the intelligence agencies just increases the size of the haystack and does not actually result in stopping these incidents, as they are now spread too thin.
Re:A Back Door to Encryption Won't Stop Terrorists by criddell on Thursday November 19, 2015 @07:50AM (#10594441)
> does not actually result in stopping these incidents

My point was that collecting it all isn't necessarily about stopping incidents, it's about instantly knowing everything about a terrorist once they are identified through other means. There's certainly value there and the debate is whether or not the cost is too high.

Re:A Back Door to Encryption Won't Stop Terrorists by Khaine on Thursday November 19, 2015 @08:07PM (#10598909)
My point was that the collect it all mentality is driven by the number of extremists on the list. It takes something like 20 agents to follow someone around the clock.

That means the DGSI would need 230,000 staff to follow all of the extremists all of the time

Re:A Back Door to Encryption Won't Stop Terrorists by jasonwatkinspdx on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @09:20PM (#10592343)
I'm opposed as well (I think big piles of personal info are radioactive), but it's worth pointing out that this usage, of finding folks after the fact, should be easy to do in a way that allows proper judicial review, even if the process is expedited. Working from an actual crime makes a lot of things more straightforward vs trying to justify surveillance of someone thought to be a risk, or connected to a risk of some hypothetical future crime.
Re:A Back Door to Encryption Won't Stop Terrorists by paublyrne on Thursday November 19, 2015 @02:40AM (#10593313)
Fund new research to put effective bomb and weapon detectors into every doorway.

I don't want to live in a world that has bomb detectors in every doorway.

Re:A Back Door to Encryption Won't Stop Terrorists by noamyoungerm on Thursday November 19, 2015 @03:09AM (#10593414)
I live in a country that has bomb detectors in every doorway. It's not that bad - at the very least, everybody preferrs a bomb detector to another suicide bombing.

I think that when terror is something that can happen constantly for months at a time, people learn to keep living their lives without fear, but also to take measurable actions that really prevent the next attack.