My point is entirely aimed at the linguistic use of "proves" than anything else.
The person I was commenting to, however, IS making a claim. Maybe your burden of proof applies to him?
This argument is actually subject to Russel's Teapot, if you cant prove or disprove anything the burden of proof is on proving the thing. I have yet to see any evidence.
We as a society do not have that power, and that should be obvious by now.
When a court decided what they were doing was illegal, less than a day later (probably the fastest anything has EVER happen in the legal system), another bench decided that what the NSA was doing was TOO BIG TO STOP. Like seriously, their argument for not stopping something UNCONSTITUTIONAL was that they were doing too much of it.
You and I, and every other civilian who actually understands what they're doing have ZERO power to stop them, so they have ZERO incentive to convince US what matters.
You know who they DO have to convince? The exact people that keep voting to KEEP THEM IN POWER.
I don't care what Obama and his administration claims, like I said, they have no incentive to prove anything to the American public.
"Is mass surveillance useless? Unless you can prove it, it's obviously useful. See Russell's teapot."
(Russell's teapot doesn't apply anyway, because the thing to prove is falsifiable: governments /could/ release information about thwarted attacks, in case there are any.)
Yes, we do. We know ALL of the FBI's high profile terrorism cases. Apart from the Tsarnaev brothers, it has been all cases where one or more fools got snared by a provocateur.
So unless you believe that there is a secret system of arrest, a secret court that hears terrorism trials, and secret prisons all operating inside the US, we know exactly how effective mass surveillance of the US population has been in preventing terrorism.
We already know there are secret courts that hear secret arguments that can't be refuted by defendants/targets. Oh, and if that court involved you, you're legally not even allowed to tell anyone.
We already know that the NSA/FBI/CIA/DEA uses parallel construction to actually prosecute crimes against US citizens.
How do we know this stuff? Someone with clearance risked his life, and gave up his freedom to tell the world. Oh, and the US said they MIGHT NOT waterboard him if he ever came back to the US to face his crimes.
And out of the thousands of documents he had, how many do we have access to? A few handful?
Sure...we know everything </sarcasm (as if you couldn't tell)>
We have no idea how many attacks have been prevented (everyone likes to claim this is zero....but they do so without any evidence to support that, as relevant information is surely classified beyond Top Secret).
We have only the slightest, tiniest, smallest idea of what the NSA and other intelligence organizations are capable of.
British intelligence took how long to tell people that they cracked enigma? 50 years?
Out of the THOUSANDS of documents that Edward Snowden leaked to reporters, the public has access to what? on the order of 50?
Yeah....we know nothing...so saying one way or the other is kind of ridiculous at this point.