It is however usually coupled with the ability to let go poorly performing workers -- something that socialist aren't keen on.
The problem is that there isn't one universal definition of fair. Conservatives, liberals, libertarians, socialists, they generally all (with individual exceptions of course) want a society that is fair, but with different, mutually incompatible definitions of fair.
Conservatives tend to preach that in a fair society, everyone gets what they deserve. Harder working, more talented? Then you deserve more. Socialists tend to preach that in a fair society, everyone gets what they need.
The group who need the most doesn't overlap with the group who is most talented and able to work hard, so conservatives and socialists will never agree on what is fair, or even that the other group believes in fairness.
The definition of fairness is subject to research under the name equity theory [0]
The three extremes are (AFAIR):
- equal distribution
- distribution proportional to contribution
- distribution proportional to need
The problem with extreme 1 and 3 is that they provide no incentive to increase your contribution which is why "capitalism" is superior to "socialism" in terms of productivity.
Gold is rarer, than oxygen and carbon. The market prices it higher. Does that mean it contributes more? Is gold more important than oxygen and carbon?
Sure, there needs to be an incentive to work hard. But there shouldn't be an incentive to being born in the lucky circumstances that leads you to becoming a surgeon, or the even luckier and more exclusive circumstances that lead you to becoming a CEO (white, male, relatively privileged). And why does a CEO who works hard 80 hours a week deserve more than a janitor working 3 jobs 80 hours a week just to keep her family afloat, to get her kid enough food and a safe place and help her get through the crappy public school that the CEO pays $30-60k a year (multiples of the janitor's salary) to keep his kid out of?
There shouldn't be an incentive to treat people as commodities. Does a surgeon deserve twice as much if for whatever reason there are half the number of surgeons this decade compared to last? Does a janitor deserve half the pay just because the birthrate increased and there are twice as many people to compete against? (I'm simplifying. It's not important whether doubling the supply halves the price.)
Right now wealth is distributed according to your rank. Rank unfortunately is nowhere near proportional to contribution.
You are free to design your own incentive system and compete with those you believe rely too much on rank.
Then again the alternative isn't too pretty either.
That may be true under normal circumstances (you will likely see overall productivity drop once the poor start to starve or freeze to death) but that still leaves the fundamental disagreement whether overall productivity is more important than meeting everyone's needs.
http://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21578665-nearly-1-bill...
Has global poverty dropped due to unchecked free market capitalism? Is there a place where such a thing is applied?
Global shift from centrally controlled economies to more free market economies -> fewer people that are poor -> fewer people that are starving or freezing to death
> will never agree (...) that the other group believes in fairness.
This is how a political gridlock develops, how wars start. Who is going to negotiate with a side that doesn't even want to be fair? I know I wouldn't, it would be pointless.
I also have no disagreement with the notion that higher paid employees will be more productive (though I've certainly seen individual examples where the opposite is true) but that doesn't mean it's affordable for the business owner in all situations. If I were paid $70,000/yr to bag groceries I'd be productive as hell but I'd also bankrupt my employer.
If it does end up working for him and he's more profitable and has happier employees and customers, wonderful. I don't understand why any free-market person would object to that, as long as it's his business decision and he's not being forced to pay what he pays. Clearly a $70,000 minimum wage would not work for any and all employment situations.
Sure higher value jobs require automation, which means their will be less jobs available but let's improve the quality of the existing jobs and figure out what we do, as a society, with all the unemployed.
I miss seeing the pride in workers eyes as they deliver me a product/service. Let's bring the pride back and figure out the rest later.
I feel that if we increase employment happiness, as a society we'd be better able to manage massive unemployment. Massive unemployment doesn't need to be a 'bad thing', labeled as 'lazy'. Instead, should be a pride thing in technology. Humanity doesn't need to work. Why must we force it to? We (humanity) can figure out how to manage the freedom of massive unemployment due to technology.
"Aldi (stylized as ALDI) is a leading global discount supermarket chain with over 10,000 stores in 18 countries, and an estimated turnover of more than €50bn."
We may have different definitions of what "small" is but I'd imagine most don't think 10k stores or €50bn turnover is "small".
It's also in no way related to an actual minimum wage. Letting companies do it on their own like this one is what makes the higher wage work.
Given that, as the article says, one actually complained to him about being ripped off on his salary, I'd say this was the case.
I agree with everything else you said. If an employer can afford to pay employees $70K and isn't coerced into doing so, more power to them. Such a salary isn't sustainable in all business. Market rate is most certainly not $70k/year to bag groceries.
Ironically what is unsustainable is not redistributing wealth towards labor. What is unsustainable is concentrating wealth towards a few people who contribute no work.
It's because it's hard and risky work to start a company. Your observation of the company owner not doing any work is a temporal discrepancy not a difference in overall risk and effort (IMO).
Then there's also owners who did a lot of hard risky work several decades ago, now insulated from that by layers of management, but don't contribute any more value to the company right-now than any project manager or warehouse supervisor.
Or ownership via nepotism which is a bit of a crap shoot. Sometimes sons and daughters work their ass off; some times they're just barely competent enough to not cause a revolt when given the keys.
If person A takes the risk, founds and grows the company and then sells their stake to person B, person B has purchased the claim that person A once held. If person A was entitled to the rewards for prior work without current effort, they can reasonably sell that claim to person B, whereupon B is entitled to those rewards (at the risk of the capital B put up).
In fact, being able to do so is critical to the current funding structure for many ventures (because it provides liquidity for person A, increasing the EV for A to originally start, because they can get liquidity later rather than having to hold the share for eternity to receive the value they created).
(I realize that not everyone will share this point of view, which is OK.)
If a laborer can accrue shareholder value over time. Non laborers should lose it with time.
When a founder forms a company he is not creating value. He is redeploying existing labor to do OTHER things. Whether that creates new value is a separate issue as said labor could create new value wherever it was before. Additionally, the founder is also creating a new corporate pyramid structure that funnels a lot of the redeployed wealth from this labor towards the people sitting on top: Whether that be himself or shareholders.
Let's say there are two companies. Company A and Company B. Company A is a established company and Company B is a startup. Lets also say there is one worker, named Chris. When Chris works for company A his work output is 20$ a day.
Let's say Chris changes his job and moves to company B. You're telling me that Company B by virtue of being a startup makes chris's work output suddenly equivalent to 100$? Tell me what magic makes this the case? What is it that makes it so new value is created out of thin air? It's not physically possible. In fact it's stupid to think that just by creating a startup you're creating value. You're just redeploying labor.
So where does new value come from if not just from a company by virtue of being a startup? The answer: When new technology or new innovations are created that fundamentally change the infrastructure of the economy so that it can be more efficient. It can happen from ANY company and it can even happen from government, it does not have to come from a startup. Examples: Apple: iphone, military: internet.
To tell you the truth, most startups amount to shit. If anything the majority of startups redeploy labor onto endeavors that amount to nothing. Usually big corporations more effectively redeploy labor. Could any random startup do what apple did to the phone industry? Probably, but waay less likely.
By "existing labor" voluntarily "redeploying" themselves, they are in complete recognition of that fact and want to partake in the additional value created.
What may appear as "utter nonsense" is actually deeper understanding. Real knowledge is to know the extent of one's ignorance.
shhh, you will upset the Founders are gods and we should worship at their Startup temples viewpoint that is the foundation of HN.
I could've waited for the rate limiter to expire but I responded hastily because I was highly, highly offended by you saying that my paragraph was "utter nonsense." You don't say these kinds of things to people in real life. I'm not sure if your post qualifies for a flag but I do know really negative comments like that are frowned upon by the moderators.
You never once mentioned startups. That is true. But you do mention the creation of a company. You're telling me that the creation of a company isn't a startup? Ok I now assume that the creation of a company isn't a startup. You're talking exclusively about split-ups, as that's the only other time I know about where company creation occurs without the creation of a startup: http://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/split-up.asp.
If a company splits up. The old company is destroyed and the new companies are the sum of it's old parts. No new value is created. Understand? Or is my assumption incorrect? Clarify if i'm wrong about what you're referring to by "sole creation of a single company."
Anyone who disagrees is still free to use their own money to pay their own employees peanuts from their mega-yacht.
With Gravity being the exception, this is not what happens in reality.
Personally, I'd observe that if "he has sold all his stocks, emptied his retirement accounts, and mortgaged his two properties—including a $1.2 million home with a view of Puget Sound—and poured the $3 million he raised into Gravity." actually translates to "all that was necessary to fuel this", then it isn't exactly out of line to complain that a grand unsustainable stunt being used for the purpose of trying to force this on everybody else is a very silly thing to do, and has little to nothing to do with the problem of "wealth inequality". Everybody already knows that if it were possible to just pull wealth out of thin air everybody could have more. The problem is precisely that it isn't.
If it does turn out to be sustainable, then of course more power to him, but I'll wait for that judgment when the millions of dollars have run out and either have or have not been replaced by revenue. Seriously. I will in fact wait for that. Paying people well doesn't bother me, and I doubt it actually bothers anybody. But I'm certainly skeptical in a way that, say, a report from left-wing Slate about how this didn't work would leave me less skeptical, because they'd clearly be reporting it against their will, and probably have examined it within an inch of its life.
And even through what I would consider substantial bias, the article's own text leaves a lot of room to be concerned about this maneuver. He's basically spending almost the entire profit of the firm on salary, then promising not to lay anybody off or cut salaries even if times turn bad. Well... guess what that translates to... if the company hits problems, he'll end up going out of business and these people will suddenly not have their jobs at all. Or his glittering promises that you're so excited about will turn out to only have been words. Or something that does not involve everybody keeping their jobs at way above-market pay in a company that can't make payroll.
He's welcome to do this experiment, but maybe we should all wait to make sure it succeeds before getting too excited about it, and demanding that anyone who thinks it likely to fail consider themselves bad people who should feel bad. All the best to him (again, no sarcasm at all), but the most likely outcome is that he goes out of business in the next recession.
On one note, there's a reason that some roles are paid $40k instead of $70k and it has nothing to do with the value of the person. It's that the role doesn't create enough value - sales, retention, growth - to make that make sense. It's feasible to make an employee a few percent more effective but nearly 2x? I'd love to see that.
On the other side, I'd love to know why the the sudden influx of cash. Was it just to get rid of his assets? (a divorce?) Or did the company need the cash? If they needed it and business was good, why not outside investors? If they needed it and business is poor, then he's just doomed his whole cause because of the "see, I told you so!"
Regardless, I'm looking forward to seeing what this looks like longer term.
But he didn't pull wealth out of thin air to do this, he reinvested existing wealth back into his business.
While not every business can do this, there are arguably plenty that can. Over the past 10 years, corporate profits are up and so are executive salaries, compared to medium income.
So it's not that people wish that wealth could be create out of thin air. It's that wealth is being created, it's just being distributed differently.
I think the most insightful comment from Dan was that he realized he was still managing his business in crisis mode, hoarding cash in case another huge financial meltdown hit--but that was unintentionally impeding his business growth by harming his workforce.
This arguably describes thinking of a lot of business executives, who are hoarding cash both personally and in the businesses they lead. It's possible that this is one reason we are seeing less than stellar economic growth right now.
An experiment that drastically raises low-end salaries can therefore be viewed as a big threat to those whose wealth depends on being able to get away with paying their employees low wages.
We can all argue endlessly about what constitutes a low wage, to what degree we should let the market decide, etc, etc - but the idea that "If there was more money available, we'd happily use it to raise entry-level wages instead of giving it to the top-tier employees" is demonstrably false. This is why this has everything to do with wealth equality.
A solution that can't be sustained isn't a solution. It is a category error to treat it as a solution merely because you like it, or it flatters your politics, or it makes you feel good, or it provides you a cudgel with which to hit your political opponents. None of those things will prevent the company from going out of business, if it does, and then nobody has a job.
> Paying people well doesn't bother me, and I doubt it actually bothers anybody.
To which I pointed out that it might well bother some groups of people.
You also asserted that:
> ... has little to nothing to do with the problem of "wealth inequality". Everybody already knows that if it were possible to just pull wealth out of thin air everybody could have more.
To which I pointed out that it does in my opinion have everything to do with wealth equality, sustainable or no, as this experiment is (IMO) primarily about where and how payroll gets distributed, not about how large payroll might be.
I read your post carefully, several times, before replying. Please do mine the same courtesy. Thanks.
[The __emphasis__ was mine].
jerf was saying that determining if "wealth equality" can be a solved problem depends on whether Gravity's strategy is sustainable and a ultimately proven as a success. jerf is looking beyond the salaries experiment and current media hoopla.
jfindley is saying that the mere existence of the experiment without consideration of whether it succeeds is itself a conversation about "wealth inequality".
You guys are talking about 2 different things.
He had enough excess money so he choose to give higher salaries to all his employees. He does what he believes the right thing to do. Plus side, giving higher salaries usually has a positive effect on your job after all, as long as you can afford it. It seems to work for him and hopefully it will lead some others to do similar things.
But just by looking at this and universally forcing higher minimum wages may create unwanted consequences (Such as Lay offs, increase in un-documented exchanges or tax evasion simply because employers with already razor thin profits cannot afford salaries anymore.). Especially for small and medium sized companies.
It doesn't matter if the right wingers are poor or struggling themselves: rather than envisioning a world in which they don't have to struggle as hard, they envision a world in which they have broken beyond their struggle somehow and are now being bled by the "taker" leeches as a result of left wing political goals being met. The sad side of this is that many of these people have zero chance of breaking beyond their struggle specifically because there is not wider political support for redistributing resources.
The fall into poverty is an act of justice in this perverse mindset. Poverty is the result of bad choices of the individual in their view. Of course we can dismiss this kind of simplification as childish (the result of an intentionally crafted propaganda campaign designed to cause people to vote against their interests), but there are millions of people who will have hateful fire in their eyes if you deny that poverty is avoidable for any person with the proper magical choices.
That, or leads to a repressive state and economic ruin. You can't pretend that Denmark is socialist but not many of the failed South American countries.
Paul Graham has an interesting perspective of inequality:
> Economic inequality is not just a consequence of startups. It's the engine that drives them, in the same way a fall of water drives a water mill. People start startups in the hope of becoming much richer than they were before. And if your society tries to prevent anyone from being much richer than anyone else, it will also prevent one person from being much richer at t2 than t1.
He acknowledges that people don't do things just for financial reward. People build products because they love building things. The things you have to pay founders for is doing the mundane operational support that is required for most projects. No one likes doing that.
He goes on to argue that inequality is the result of people being able to more effectively use their talents. The "10x programmer" isn't paid 10x as much, but few programmers could argue that he should not get paid a lot more than just an average programmer despite being much more effective.
I get that inequality is distasteful, but I would rather be richer in a less equal economy that be poorer but average.
there's no debate that anyone would choose to be the richer one in any situation. The question is whether you'd rather be the poorer one in a less equal economy, or the poorer one in a more equal economy.
The CIA had a lot to do with that. It instigated coups against democratically elected heads of state and supported repressive dictators in most of South America in order to protect American businesses there.
Suppose two people start at 10. One person finds a way to go to 20 and the other goes to 11. The inequality has increased and the wealth of both people has increased.
Technically, this is a social improvement. But egalitarians would say this is a terrible situation because the gap has gone from 0 to 9.
Massive pay disparity...
Profit sharing. What's fair?
The rhetoric about minimum wage is a distraction, used to obfuscate the simple fact that labor is getting its teeth kicked in.
If corporations (et al) weren't racking up record profits and warehousing cash, I'd be more sympathetic to their plight.
The criticism, mostly originating from Austrian based economic thought not right-wing groups (however most individuals on the right subscribe to the Austrian thought), was that the economics of the $70,000 wage was not going to end well for the company, not any suggestion of opposition to fairly paid society.
Comments varied between what the profit margin would be and the effect on role distinction. The main comments were how the effect would play out for those employees that the company had previously valued at $75,000 with a double pay differential from the $35,000 now having the individuals who performed the same task being given the $50,000 wage and phased up to the $70,000; eliminating the meritocracy of a $75,000 wage. Additionally, the internal machinations and reports bore out the Austrian point of view as valued employees quit citing unequal pay raise values for the lowest valued employees. [1]
To be fair, MarketWatch and Slate bring up a doubling in profits and revenues, but how much of this is based on an increase from the publicity and is it a long term sustainable idea.
Gravity Payments is profiting $2.2 million on $150 million in revenue. The Seattle Times article notes that payment processing services are razor thin margins.
Let's do the following financial analysis: * Gravity Payments has a 1.5% profit margin at its current rate of burn, $2.2 million over $150 million.
* Gravity at announcement time had 120 employees, of which a documented 25% would see a double in their pay, 30 employees who were making $35,000. Estimating the rest of the company's effected staff, estimate another 30 will be brought up to $50,000, another 20 brought up next year to $60,000 and then finally another 20 to $70,000, for a total of estimated 100 employees affected by this move.
* Costs have now increased for the 30 base salary employees to $1.5 million more, assuming a cost increase of $20,000 per person average for the remaining group of 70, you are an additional $1.4 million.
* After the full effect of the increase is factored in, the costs outweigh the current operating situation.
* The counter-argument of increases in business are offset by the companies need to hire additional staff to handle the increase. These individuals are brought into the existing cost structure and are not able to move the profit margin.
The company will be having some issues next year making good on its promise of wage increases and certainly in 2017. This basic analysis is why the finance person quit, she saw what I am showing.
[1] https://mises.org/library/what-happened-when-one-company-set...
[2] http://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/seattle-company-cop...
[3] http://www.entrepreneur.com/article/249313
[4] http://www.businessinsider.com/employees-reaction-to-70000-m...
And how much does it scale? Will it work when the company is forced to look into profit? Right now they seem to have revenue but no profits.
How will retaining employees work when someone who has to work over time to deal with bugs is getting paid as much as the person's job it is to hold meetings.
"right-wing backlash" - anyone who might suspect that this isn't sustainable and will probably end up going away in the long run. Sounds like a PR fluff piece.
Even dev salaries today isn't sustainable and will eventually crash.
I understand in this situation, that some of the previously higher paid employees got upset [and left].
> Only two employees quit—a nonevent.
You indeed have. $70k is the minimum salary. It is possible to make more.
Everyone getting paid the same is communism, and yes massively de-motivating that if you work harder you get paid the same. Massive pay disparity is the end result of unchecked capitalism, look at any country with low taxation, same result always. Socialism just works to get a happy compromise where you have the chance of making more through your efforts, but less people get a huge head start and fewer fall through into poverty. I'm not sure what there really is to fear here.
The difference between America's mean and median wage is quite shocking (and the worst amongst developed countries I believe). Clearly we see that this is what the right want to hold onto at all costs.
This guy should be lauded and applauded for having the balls to do such an amazing social experiment which benefits all his employees.