Gold is rarer, than oxygen and carbon. The market prices it higher. Does that mean it contributes more? Is gold more important than oxygen and carbon?
Sure, there needs to be an incentive to work hard. But there shouldn't be an incentive to being born in the lucky circumstances that leads you to becoming a surgeon, or the even luckier and more exclusive circumstances that lead you to becoming a CEO (white, male, relatively privileged). And why does a CEO who works hard 80 hours a week deserve more than a janitor working 3 jobs 80 hours a week just to keep her family afloat, to get her kid enough food and a safe place and help her get through the crappy public school that the CEO pays $30-60k a year (multiples of the janitor's salary) to keep his kid out of?
There shouldn't be an incentive to treat people as commodities. Does a surgeon deserve twice as much if for whatever reason there are half the number of surgeons this decade compared to last? Does a janitor deserve half the pay just because the birthrate increased and there are twice as many people to compete against? (I'm simplifying. It's not important whether doubling the supply halves the price.)
Right now wealth is distributed according to your rank. Rank unfortunately is nowhere near proportional to contribution.
You are free to design your own incentive system and compete with those you believe rely too much on rank.
Then again the alternative isn't too pretty either.
That may be true under normal circumstances (you will likely see overall productivity drop once the poor start to starve or freeze to death) but that still leaves the fundamental disagreement whether overall productivity is more important than meeting everyone's needs.
http://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21578665-nearly-1-bill...
Has global poverty dropped due to unchecked free market capitalism? Is there a place where such a thing is applied?
Global shift from centrally controlled economies to more free market economies -> fewer people that are poor -> fewer people that are starving or freezing to death
> will never agree (...) that the other group believes in fairness.
This is how a political gridlock develops, how wars start. Who is going to negotiate with a side that doesn't even want to be fair? I know I wouldn't, it would be pointless.
The definition of fairness is subject to research under the name equity theory [0]
The three extremes are (AFAIR):
- equal distribution
- distribution proportional to contribution
- distribution proportional to need
The problem with extreme 1 and 3 is that they provide no incentive to increase your contribution which is why "capitalism" is superior to "socialism" in terms of productivity.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equity_theory