News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gravity Payments' Revenue and Profits Doubled After $70,0... by ams6110 on Monday October 26, 2015 @08:37AM (#10450950)
I'm pretty conservative, but I don't object to him doing this in any way. I also highly doubt it will be sustainable. Unless all along he really was paying below market for the work his employees are doing.

I also have no disagreement with the notion that higher paid employees will be more productive (though I've certainly seen individual examples where the opposite is true) but that doesn't mean it's affordable for the business owner in all situations. If I were paid $70,000/yr to bag groceries I'd be productive as hell but I'd also bankrupt my employer.

If it does end up working for him and he's more profitable and has happier employees and customers, wonderful. I don't understand why any free-market person would object to that, as long as it's his business decision and he's not being forced to pay what he pays. Clearly a $70,000 minimum wage would not work for any and all employment situations.

Re:Gravity Payments' Revenue and Profits Doubled After $70,0... by heimatau on Monday October 26, 2015 @09:24AM (#10451204)
You might bankrupt your grocery store employer at 70k but I don't see why they can't double grocery store workers 2x (from close to min wage to closer to 40k yr). Fresh produce (and meats) come with high margins to offset waste. Aldi's and Costco come closer to a better model for their industry of grocery stores. Costco could improve it's value to employees if it went private like Aldi.

Sure higher value jobs require automation, which means their will be less jobs available but let's improve the quality of the existing jobs and figure out what we do, as a society, with all the unemployed.

I miss seeing the pride in workers eyes as they deliver me a product/service. Let's bring the pride back and figure out the rest later.

I feel that if we increase employment happiness, as a society we'd be better able to manage massive unemployment. Massive unemployment doesn't need to be a 'bad thing', labeled as 'lazy'. Instead, should be a pride thing in technology. Humanity doesn't need to work. Why must we force it to? We (humanity) can figure out how to manage the freedom of massive unemployment due to technology.

Re:Gravity Payments' Revenue and Profits Doubled After $70,0... by cableshaft on Monday October 26, 2015 @09:43AM (#10451321)
My father dropped out of college because at the time, grocery stores paid good enough wages compared to other jobs that you could feasibly make a career out of it. That seems almost unheard of nowadays.
Re:Gravity Payments' Revenue and Profits Doubled After $70,0... by whatok on Monday October 26, 2015 @09:39AM (#10451287)
Most grocery stores do not operate at the scale that either of your examples do and most cannot charge a membership fee either.
Re:Gravity Payments' Revenue and Profits Doubled After $70,0... by heimatau on Monday October 26, 2015 @11:14AM (#10451966)
I also mentioned Aldi. They are small and without fee.
Re:Gravity Payments' Revenue and Profits Doubled After $70,0... by whatok on Monday October 26, 2015 @12:37PM (#10452508)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aldi

"Aldi (stylized as ALDI) is a leading global discount supermarket chain with over 10,000 stores in 18 countries, and an estimated turnover of more than €50bn."

We may have different definitions of what "small" is but I'd imagine most don't think 10k stores or €50bn turnover is "small".

Re:Gravity Payments' Revenue and Profits Doubled After $70,0... by heimatau on Monday October 26, 2015 @06:32PM (#10454965)
Aldi's isn't everywhere. Costco is more ubiquitous than Aldi, hence small.
Re:Gravity Payments' Revenue and Profits Doubled After $70,0... by matwood on Monday October 26, 2015 @09:03AM (#10451088)
I'm more libertarian leaning and agree with you. It's a private business doing what it wants with its money. I imagine it helps the business find the best employees up and down the chain and ends making people super loyal. Turnover can be a huge expense because the cost to hire and brain drain.

It's also in no way related to an actual minimum wage. Letting companies do it on their own like this one is what makes the higher wage work.

Re:Gravity Payments' Revenue and Profits Doubled After $70,0... by whatok on Monday October 26, 2015 @09:31AM (#10451247)
Over enthusiastic press without observing the effects of something like this years down the road absolutely affects the debate over minimum wage though.
Re:Gravity Payments' Revenue and Profits Doubled After $70,0... by matwood on Monday October 26, 2015 @10:58AM (#10451864)
The debate sure. But the reality of it is that right now this company has a competitive advantage because it is the only one or one of few that pay more than the others. It is likely swamped with resumes and can pick and choose the best of the best in nearly every position. If an actual minimum wage was mandated by the government at this level, the advantage falls apart and it likely no longer works.
Re:Gravity Payments' Revenue and Profits Doubled After $70,0... by whatok on Monday October 26, 2015 @11:29AM (#10452062)
It has a competitive advantage in hiring right now, absolutely. Whether that translates down the road to an overall sustainable competitive advantage for the overall business remains to be seen. Agreed on gov mandate.
Re:Gravity Payments' Revenue and Profits Doubled After $70,0... by gglitch on Monday October 26, 2015 @12:04PM (#10452284)
It's of course not the responsibility of the business to manage the debate in the press, though.
Re:Gravity Payments' Revenue and Profits Doubled After $70,0... by xlm1717 on Monday October 26, 2015 @11:13AM (#10451957)
>Unless all along he really was paying below market for the work his employees are doing.

Given that, as the article says, one actually complained to him about being ripped off on his salary, I'd say this was the case.

I agree with everything else you said. If an employer can afford to pay employees $70K and isn't coerced into doing so, more power to them. Such a salary isn't sustainable in all business. Market rate is most certainly not $70k/year to bag groceries.

Re:Gravity Payments' Revenue and Profits Doubled After $70,0... by crimsonalucard on Monday October 26, 2015 @09:33AM (#10451260)
It's not about 70K minimum wage. It's about a more fair distribution of wealth. Why funnel profits towards shareholders or owners who usually do no work when all that extra wealth can be redeployed back to the people who actually run the business: employees.

Ironically what is unsustainable is not redistributing wealth towards labor. What is unsustainable is concentrating wealth towards a few people who contribute no work.

Re:Gravity Payments' Revenue and Profits Doubled After $70,0... by sokoloff on Monday October 26, 2015 @09:42AM (#10451315)
If being an owner is so low-effort and low-risk, why not just found a company instead of working for someone else?

It's because it's hard and risky work to start a company. Your observation of the company owner not doing any work is a temporal discrepancy not a difference in overall risk and effort (IMO).

Re:Gravity Payments' Revenue and Profits Doubled After $70,0... by Avshalom on Monday October 26, 2015 @09:54AM (#10451400)
There's owners and then there's owners. With a publicly traded company 'owner' is any one with enough cash lying around to buy a share.

Then there's also owners who did a lot of hard risky work several decades ago, now insulated from that by layers of management, but don't contribute any more value to the company right-now than any project manager or warehouse supervisor.

Or ownership via nepotism which is a bit of a crap shoot. Sometimes sons and daughters work their ass off; some times they're just barely competent enough to not cause a revolt when given the keys.

Re:Gravity Payments' Revenue and Profits Doubled After $70,0... by sokoloff on Monday October 26, 2015 @07:00PM (#10455107)
IMO, even the owner of a share of common stock is merely a one-for-one replacement of the person(s) who originally put up the capital and took the risk originally, so they get the same standing in my book.

If person A takes the risk, founds and grows the company and then sells their stake to person B, person B has purchased the claim that person A once held. If person A was entitled to the rewards for prior work without current effort, they can reasonably sell that claim to person B, whereupon B is entitled to those rewards (at the risk of the capital B put up).

In fact, being able to do so is critical to the current funding structure for many ventures (because it provides liquidity for person A, increasing the EV for A to originally start, because they can get liquidity later rather than having to hold the share for eternity to receive the value they created).

(I realize that not everyone will share this point of view, which is OK.)

Re:Gravity Payments' Revenue and Profits Doubled After $70,0... by crimsonalucard on Monday October 26, 2015 @09:48PM (#10455744)
risk taken 4 years ago is not worth the same as risk taken today. If they want to make it fair, share value should slowly bleed and be distributed to labor over time.

If a laborer can accrue shareholder value over time. Non laborers should lose it with time.

Re:Gravity Payments' Revenue and Profits Doubled After $70,0... by whatok on Monday October 26, 2015 @10:02AM (#10451453)
In your second example, the company literally would not exist without the founder. If you divide up the "value" the act of creating a company provides over the lifespan of the company, it will likely eclipse the value a project manager or warehouse supervisor presently provides.
Re:Gravity Payments' Revenue and Profits Doubled After $70,0... by crimsonalucard on Monday October 26, 2015 @10:17AM (#10451570)
The company is the sum of it's parts: The employees. Employees exist without the founder or the company. Thus, the value still exists within the economy, it is just the distribution is different as said employees are producing value in other sectors of the economy.

When a founder forms a company he is not creating value. He is redeploying existing labor to do OTHER things. Whether that creates new value is a separate issue as said labor could create new value wherever it was before. Additionally, the founder is also creating a new corporate pyramid structure that funnels a lot of the redeployed wealth from this labor towards the people sitting on top: Whether that be himself or shareholders.

Let's say there are two companies. Company A and Company B. Company A is a established company and Company B is a startup. Lets also say there is one worker, named Chris. When Chris works for company A his work output is 20$ a day.

Let's say Chris changes his job and moves to company B. You're telling me that Company B by virtue of being a startup makes chris's work output suddenly equivalent to 100$? Tell me what magic makes this the case? What is it that makes it so new value is created out of thin air? It's not physically possible. In fact it's stupid to think that just by creating a startup you're creating value. You're just redeploying labor.

So where does new value come from if not just from a company by virtue of being a startup? The answer: When new technology or new innovations are created that fundamentally change the infrastructure of the economy so that it can be more efficient. It can happen from ANY company and it can even happen from government, it does not have to come from a startup. Examples: Apple: iphone, military: internet.

To tell you the truth, most startups amount to shit. If anything the majority of startups redeploy labor onto endeavors that amount to nothing. Usually big corporations more effectively redeploy labor. Could any random startup do what apple did to the phone industry? Probably, but waay less likely.

Re:Gravity Payments' Revenue and Profits Doubled After $70,0... by whatok on Monday October 26, 2015 @10:26AM (#10451630)
Your second paragraph is utter nonsense. A productive business absolutely creates value. History is littered with examples of entire brand new industries birthed by the sole creation of a single company. The pie literally grows larger. This doesn't create value?

By "existing labor" voluntarily "redeploying" themselves, they are in complete recognition of that fact and want to partake in the additional value created.

Re:Gravity Payments' Revenue and Profits Doubled After $70,0... by crimsonalucard on Monday October 26, 2015 @03:43PM (#10453909)
Additional value by virtue of being a startup? Joining a startup doesn't make someones labor output suddenly increase.

What may appear as "utter nonsense" is actually deeper understanding. Real knowledge is to know the extent of one's ignorance.

Re:Gravity Payments' Revenue and Profits Doubled After $70,0... by serge2k on Monday October 26, 2015 @05:21PM (#10454578)
> Additional value by virtue of being a startup? Joining a startup doesn't make someones labor output suddenly increase.

shhh, you will upset the Founders are gods and we should worship at their Startup temples viewpoint that is the foundation of HN.

Re:Gravity Payments' Revenue and Profits Doubled After $70,0... by whatok on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @07:15AM (#10457323)
The parent poster completely altered his post after I responded to it so I would take that into mind when reading things. Also, throughout this thread I have never once mentioned anything about startups but assume away.
Re:Gravity Payments' Revenue and Profits Doubled After $70,0... by crimsonalucard on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @09:14AM (#10457741)
Nope. Parent Poster added to the explanation so you could be less ignorant. The second paragraph you referred to is still there, it is just expanded upon with more paragraphs for greater detail and clearer explanations. The reason this was done was because I reached my post limit. Not like anyone else is looking at this anymore anyway. I can move the additional explanations to the responding post if you want, as that's where I intended it to be at first.

I could've waited for the rate limiter to expire but I responded hastily because I was highly, highly offended by you saying that my paragraph was "utter nonsense." You don't say these kinds of things to people in real life. I'm not sure if your post qualifies for a flag but I do know really negative comments like that are frowned upon by the moderators.

You never once mentioned startups. That is true. But you do mention the creation of a company. You're telling me that the creation of a company isn't a startup? Ok I now assume that the creation of a company isn't a startup. You're talking exclusively about split-ups, as that's the only other time I know about where company creation occurs without the creation of a startup: http://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/split-up.asp.

If a company splits up. The old company is destroyed and the new companies are the sum of it's old parts. No new value is created. Understand? Or is my assumption incorrect? Clarify if i'm wrong about what you're referring to by "sole creation of a single company."

Re:Gravity Payments' Revenue and Profits Doubled After $70,0... by giltleaf on Monday October 26, 2015 @09:52AM (#10451387)
I think he was referencing more shareholders and owners like Lucas (who was given "menial tasks"). Absentee owners is absolutely a common thing in all walks of business.
Re:Gravity Payments' Revenue and Profits Doubled After $70,0... by mariodiana on Monday October 26, 2015 @10:39AM (#10451725)
You could, of course, funnel profits towards expanding the business; unless, of course, you lack the acumen to do so.
Re:Gravity Payments' Revenue and Profits Doubled After $70,0... by rgrieselhuber on Monday October 26, 2015 @09:53AM (#10451394)
Founders and shareholders take on risk and create value by providing sweat equity and capital.
Re:Gravity Payments' Revenue and Profits Doubled After $70,0... by crimsonalucard on Monday October 26, 2015 @09:53AM (#10451391)
Right, this is your opinion, and I applaud it. Except it is a stark contrast to the backlash this company is getting from right wingers in general. Does the general conservative population actually support the free market or do they just support letting themselves be rich and their workers be poor?