News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Launches a Developer Boot Camp, Promising Jobs for... by MangezBien on Thursday October 22, 2015 @01:12PM (#10433411)
This attitude, that I see frequently on HN, isn't very helpful. I taught myself to write code in a little under three months and immediately got a job as a Jr. Dev. I knew nothing about data structures or algorithms but I could write a Ruby program.

Now, three years later, I am taking online classes to learn about those issues. The more advanced I got, the more I needed those "basics."

Looking back at myself at 18, there is no way I would have made it through a CS course. I had no motivation for school. Now, I am doing really well and learning a ton.

Saying they are a scam ignores that the students are getting a marketable skill. None of the camps say you will be an expert with understandings of how the language works but you will have enough skill to be useful.

Re:Google Launches a Developer Boot Camp, Promising Jobs for... by LordKano on Thursday October 22, 2015 @03:10PM (#10434314)
I think it's akin to how a couple of days of training could prepare someone to work at one of those oil change places but it won't make him or her into a car mechanic.

These bootcamps can teach people the basics of programming and if they have the interest and aptitude, they can grow into mature, experienced developers.

Re:Google Launches a Developer Boot Camp, Promising Jobs for... by Apocryphon on Thursday October 22, 2015 @04:07PM (#10434704)
The eternal problem is that academia is meant to create theoretical physicists when industry needs more mechanics.
Re:Google Launches a Developer Boot Camp, Promising Jobs for... by edgyswingset on Thursday October 22, 2015 @05:38PM (#10435280)
I think a lot of it has to do with an academic identity crisis. My degree was a strange mish-mash of purely theoretical stuff and purely engineering stuff that felt more like a set of topics ABET wanted covered rather than a path towards either deeper Computer Science or Software Engineering.

What I'd love to see is schools begin to take on various career-track options for students. Like theory and want to go to grad school? Take the theoretical track. Interested in front-end and mobile dev? Take some in-depth classes that cover fundamentals in that area. Distributed Systems? That could have oodles of classes, too. This is the way many other engineering degrees are structured. Somehow we're in this weird position where we're making students take electives which are relevant to industry so they can go get a good job, but they still have to learn how to write turing machines on paper.

Re:Google Launches a Developer Boot Camp, Promising Jobs for... by sotojuan on Thursday October 22, 2015 @05:08PM (#10435090)
True, except we have a lot of degrees that produce "mechanics"β€”the various engineering degrees. And we have an organization (ABET) that makes sure schools teach the right stuff.

We just happen to not have one for programming.

Re:Google Launches a Developer Boot Camp, Promising Jobs for... by apendleton on Thursday October 22, 2015 @05:27PM (#10435209)
Accreditation organizations being the solution only holds if you accept the premise that a four-year degree with any course material is necessary to be a successful developer -- if that were true, figuring out what the right stuff to teach in that four years was would certainly be the challenge. But while I share a lot of people's skepticism of bootcamps, I personally haven't seen much evidence that that's true.
Re:Google Launches a Developer Boot Camp, Promising Jobs for... by sotojuan on Thursday October 22, 2015 @05:31PM (#10435237)
That's a good point, I had not thought of that. Personally I think two years of studying and projects is good enough, maybe one if it's a bit intense like a bootcamp. The problem is people's prejudice against anything that is not a four year degree.
Re:Google Launches a Developer Boot Camp, Promising Jobs for... by bigtunacan on Thursday October 22, 2015 @01:53PM (#10433701)
Saying "you will have enough skill to be useful" is naive if you are basing it on your own personal experience of learning to "write code in a little under three months and immediately got a job as a Jr. Dev".

+++ On My Personal Experience +++

I also learned to write code on my own and had a junior dev job with no college experience. I then attended college part time to get my CS degree because

1) There are a large set of potential employers that will not consider hiring if you do not have a degree; so in times of job scarcity your options will be limited.

2) The subset of employers that will hire someone without a degree is then further broken into a subset that will pay you less since they know you have less options not having a degree.

+++ On Dev Bootcamps +++

1) 12 solid intensive weeks of learning to write code may be enough to get someone an entry level job if they learn/retain enough to get through the interview process. Having this as a focused class room where assistance and guidance is provided is likely of benefit to some people; so they are not entirely useless.

2) In my experience bootcamps have either not published or have been deceptive with job placement numbers. As a for example; I know of a bootcamp that published a 100% job placement rate. This was deceptive since they did not publish that 1) More than 75% of the attendees did not complete the bootcamp and so they were not counted (only graduate placement was counted), but they still were out of pocket for tuition costs. 2) Being hired for ANY job was considered as a successful job placement, but only about 1/3rd of the graduates actually found jobs that were in the field, the other 2/3rd were counted as successes because they were employed (e.g. if you found a job as a waitress you would count towards the success metric.)

Re:Google Launches a Developer Boot Camp, Promising Jobs for... by aioprisan on Thursday October 22, 2015 @06:03PM (#10435434)
Did you really expect the people who chose to drop out to be counted in job placement rates? I believe the same standard is used when talking about placing graduates to jobs from colleges, so I don't find that misleading.
Re:Google Launches a Developer Boot Camp, Promising Jobs for... by bigtunacan on Thursday October 22, 2015 @08:47PM (#10436179)
I'm not surprised the numbers are being published that way, but it is certainly misleading. These things are being pitched essentially as "Why waste four years of your life and bury yourself in debt? You can have a six figure career, working from your home, in just twelve short weeks at a fraction of the cost! We have a 100% placement rate!"

Someone should be telling these students the truth. "This is going to be the most intensive, gruelling twelve weeks of hell on your life so far. Three out of four students will drop the program and will still owe the equivalent of one years (state university) tuition at a standard college. If you do finish then you still may not find a job in the field."

Re:Google Launches a Developer Boot Camp, Promising Jobs for... by koube on Thursday October 22, 2015 @04:20PM (#10434780)
For reference, what year was it when you got a job after three months of self study?
Re:Google Launches a Developer Boot Camp, Promising Jobs for... by MangezBien on Thursday October 22, 2015 @05:01PM (#10435039)
2012
Re:Google Launches a Developer Boot Camp, Promising Jobs for... by Ologn on Thursday October 22, 2015 @05:17PM (#10435153)
> I knew nothing about data structures or algorithms but I could write a Ruby program.Now, three years later, I am taking online classes to learn about those issues. The more advanced I got, the more I needed those "basics."

Data structures are not basics. Self-balanced binary tree graphs are not basics. More basic than that would be to learn what a graph is - Euler's bridges, Dijkstra's shortest path. More basic is the initial introduction to the concept of the graph and the set in discrete mathematics (as well as other discrete subjects like logic, combinations, probablility etc.)

Algorithms are not basics. Bresenham's line algorithm is not basic. More basic is theory of computation - Turing machines, lambda calculus, mu-recursive functions. Automata theory, complexity theory, computability theory. Basic does not necessarily mean easier, sometimes the abstractions can be harder to grasp. What is the complexity of your algorithm, what's the worst case big O notated case? How is big O notation determined? Can you even know what an algorithm is, or compare algorithms without knowing these things? Then more basic than these things is the math such as calculus you may to determine some algorithms.

Frankly, if when "looking back at myself at 18, there is no way I would have made it through a CS course. I had no motivation for school" , and then you study Ruby for three months and get a job and are now taking online courses - I would be very skeptical of how deep your knowledge is.

You're honest enough about what you did. There's also nothing wrong with being in a situation where you don't have the opportunity to study CS intensively for four years under professors and grad students who have published papers in the field (although "no motivation" sounds worse than "no opportunity at the time"). There's nothing wrong with being lucky enough to bootstrap yourself to your current situation, there's everything wrong with fooling yourself that in five years, that kid in his third year of CS right now, who is dedicated to studying the things I mentioned, and who will study it next year, and who will then get a job and work for four years. In five years he will be ahead of you. He has a foundation that you don't. He will have a confidence you won't. As an interviewer I will be able to tell this.

My advice would be to look at local public colleges and see if any are good. See what their CS programs are, how they deal with night/weekend students for CS majors (some required classes may be on a weekday at 1 PM) etc. See what the pre-requisite graph is. Then take one class a semester, at night or on weekends. It will be one or two nights a week. Maybe take an easy non-CS class first like art appreciation or something. Note they often put one of the hardest courses for CS (like Calculus 101) as an initial pre-requisite for all CS classes to weed out "unmotivated" people from burdening the school CS program. Keeping on the topic of the weed-out class though - if you struggle over Calculus 101 like we CS majors did, to where you're even thinking of dropping out - wouldn't that be a sign that we were learning things in school you didn't know? It's not a laugh a minute to do Cook Turing reductions of NP problems in order to show similar properties of problems - but it does help in understanding fundamentals of CS.

It is better to think about this sooner than later. People do these things when they're in there teens or early 20s because it's easier to do then. You really don't want to have this revelation after you have a child or two, and are having trouble finding good work because of no diploma and lack of fundamentals. One bonus is the diploma is not the only payoff - even halfway through school you'll be a better programmer, more attractive to some employers, will have met interesting professors and students (if you put yourself out there) etc. You get out what you put in - professors like students who pay attention and do well, and can be helpful.

Re:Google Launches a Developer Boot Camp, Promising Jobs for... by MangezBien on Thursday October 22, 2015 @06:16PM (#10435502)
I forget how much I hate Hacker News sometimes. Thanks for reminding me.

> (although "no motivation" sounds worse than "no opportunity at the time")

18 was ten years ago. I was playing college football, thinking I was going to go pro. I was an idiot, but I got a college degree.

I then went on to have a career in a different field, grew up a little and taught myself to code. I've been working in the industry for three years. I have a long way to go. I spend every evening either a) doing homework for an online course I'm taking from Rice (through Coursera), b) Going through a self-directed course I've made consisting of various text books/academic papers, c) actually writing code.

Seriously, fuck you for acting like the only way to become a respectable or successful developer is the path you picked.

Re:Google Launches a Developer Boot Camp, Promising Jobs for... by Ologn on Thursday October 22, 2015 @07:00PM (#10435736)
> Seriously, fuck you for acting like the only way to become a respectable or successful developer is the path you picked.

Can you name me the respectable, successful, known developers that did not get a college degree? I mean, I can think of a few who were in the math/CS program of a top-tier school, who started a company on the side that took off, and dropped out since they were already on a rocket ship. I can also think of a few like John Carmack who just dropped out, but would still fit that category. Although...Carmack has been very straightforward about what he knows, does not know, and is learning, and sometimes I'm surprised that he is just learning a topic I had already studied indepth as an undergraduate.

While people like this are few and far between, I can name many more successful and respectable programmers who have a college degree. Who are the majority.

I look at this equanimously, while you seem to take it very personally. In my experience, those who spent four years at college studying calculus, computational complexity, backtracking, 1st/2nd/3rd normal form, how floating point numbers are stored in memory etc. are usually better than those who have not. That doesn't mean someone who slacked through school for four years is always better than someone who did not go to school for four years. It just means more often than not, someone with four years study of foundational computer science is better than someone without it.

You said you've been at this for three years - so 2012 or so. The tech economy (and to a lesser extent the broader economy) has been booming, as can be evidenced from stories here on HN. You seem to be getting upset...over a comment on HN! Let's see how you do when the economy tanks like it did in 2008-2009. Let's see how you do when tech jobs crash with the dot-coms like they did in 2000-2001. When suddenly the few job postings which appear will say "BSCS required". Why wouldn't they, because in those times, they'll still be flooded with dozens of resumes with people with BSCS's. By then you may have a mortgage, a car, two kids.

Your argument is not with me. Here's a line from a job posting on SF Bay Craigslist - ( http://sfbay.craigslist.org/sfc/egr/5278943482.html )

"Senior Application Engineer @ Slack...Here are a few extra things that would lift you up a couple of notches in our eyes: * Academic background in computer science (BSc or MSc)"

That's the #1 thing they have on their "nice to haves" list. I can assure you - when we go from these go-go unicorn times to a 2000-2001 or 2008 recession, at a time when you need work the most, I can guarantee you that their #1 "nice to have" will move up into the required column.

When the economy takes a dive like it does every eight years or so, and you have a mortgage and two kids, and you're a fifty-something unemployed coder with no degree and gaps in his technical knowledge who refused to take the bull by the horns at a time when you could have (two night class a year over twenty years would get you a degree by the age of 48), you will look back in enormous regret that you did not spend 90 minutes twice a week going to night class to earn a BSCS.

Re:Google Launches a Developer Boot Camp, Promising Jobs for... by wyclif on Thursday October 22, 2015 @07:29PM (#10435881)
I've never seen much evidence that great software engineers always have degrees. In fact, the best ones I know don't have CS degrees.

You're acting as if your example of the 50-something engineer without a degree is starting his career. The more plausible scenario is that his days of needing a degree to prove himself were over decades ago. He's getting jobs based on the knowledge and experience he gained at work, and if he isn't, he's been doing it wrong.

Re:Google Launches a Developer Boot Camp, Promising Jobs for... by MangezBien on Thursday October 22, 2015 @07:08PM (#10435779)
Nope. My argument is with you. You are a dick.
Re:Google Launches a Developer Boot Camp, Promising Jobs for... by jqm on Thursday October 22, 2015 @09:55PM (#10436385)
Imagine you had spent years and a lot of money studying 1'st normative forms. You have a lot of pride in in this knowledge... it represents a significant investment in time and money and makes you feel special. Suddenly, a 3 month bootcamp is insinuating it can turn out developers making almost what you are. You may just get a little dicky.

But I would guess there are at least a few shop owning mechanics who make as much as the highly degreed engineers designing the parts they install. And no shortage of plumbers making more than people who have graduate level knowledge of Latin. It's not fair. Life isn't fair. But from what I see, life rewards practical know-how... which may or may not entail academic credentials and esoteric knowledge.

Re:Google Launches a Developer Boot Camp, Promising Jobs for... by lloyd-christmas on Thursday October 22, 2015 @10:41PM (#10436512)
Nobody is insinuating that they'll be competing with you. I had a class of 18, I'm one of two who ended up as a back end developer. It wouldn't surprise you much to learn that the two of us were both Math majors. The rest were design-y people who wanted to expand their job prospects and ended up as front end developers. I mean this in the nicest of ways to front end developers, but your algorithms mean jack-shit to them.

As one of those few back end developers, I would HOPE I'm not competing with you for a job, as that would then have been a waste of my time and money. That being said, 4 years down the road of real world experience, I doubt there will be any separation between myself and someone with a CS degree and 4 years of work experience. Real life converges. From my couple years post-GA, I'm perfectly capable of talking the talk with the CS majors who think the two letters give them superpowers.

Again, nobody is implying 3 months will match your 4 years. However, thinking that 3 months of immersion doesn't give you enough knowledge to gain the REAL knowledge on the job would be ignorant. I'm reasonably confident if you blindfolded me and dumped me in France, I'd be speaking french in 3 months. I doubt I'd be able to appreciate The Count Of Monte Cristo, but I'd be more than capable of navigating day to day life.

Re:Google Launches a Developer Boot Camp, Promising Jobs for... by learc83 on Friday October 23, 2015 @02:17AM (#10437088)
>That being said, 4 years down the road of real world experience, I doubt there will be any separation between myself and someone with a CS degree and 4 years of work experience.

That depends entirely on what you do in those 4 years. If you spend that time studying algorithms, data structures, graph theory, discrete math, and the theory of computation, then you may be right.

If you spend those 4 years making CRUD apps, then there will still be a large gap.

I speak from experience by the way. I was a professional programmer for 5 years before I went back to get my CS degree. There were so many things that I didn't know that I didn't know.

It's the difference between spending a week banging your head against a wall or spending 20 minutes realizing your problem is just a variant of a graph theory problem that was solved 50 years ago.

Re:Google Launches a Developer Boot Camp, Promising Jobs for... by Ologn on Friday October 23, 2015 @04:53PM (#10441234)
> There were so many things that I didn't know that I didn't know.

I think that puts it very well. It's not just what people know they don't know, it's what they don't know they don't know. That's where it really hits them.

Re:Google Launches a Developer Boot Camp, Promising Jobs for... by gotchange on Thursday October 22, 2015 @07:52PM (#10435969)
What about other related and close disciplines to CS like electrical or telecommunications engineering? What do you think of these degrees?
Re:Google Launches a Developer Boot Camp, Promising Jobs for... by oldmanjay on Thursday October 22, 2015 @08:52PM (#10436193)
I understand that you feel very strongly about your perspective, and notice that the arguments you make rely on your personal opinions and experiences. I wish to assure you, that you feel this makes your arguments compelling does not speak well for the college education you prize so strongly.
Re:Google Launches a Developer Boot Camp, Promising Jobs for... by Ologn on Thursday October 22, 2015 @09:05PM (#10436235)
> rely on your personal opinions and experiences

Here's an employment rate and weekly earnings chart from the US Department of Labor correlated by education level:

http://www.bls.gov/emp/ep_chart_001.htm

Re:Google Launches a Developer Boot Camp, Promising Jobs for... by oldmanjay on Thursday October 22, 2015 @09:14PM (#10436253)
This does not change my stance that your perspective on the necessity for a college education to program well is occluded.
Re:Google Launches a Developer Boot Camp, Promising Jobs for... by FLUX-YOU on Thursday October 22, 2015 @09:59PM (#10436401)
>As an interviewer I will be able to tell this.

Who cares? You're just another job among the hundreds out there. That CS grad could be working on very difficult problems... or he could be pushing web apps for the next four years because his interviewer promised him cool toys and tough problems and then bait-and-switched. Not all of the school programs are top notch. Not all of the students that pass those programs will remember half of what you mentioned in your post or even recall the solutions when a typical problem is staring them in the face. His confidence will be misplaced, and now you're back to where everyone else is: assessing actual skill instead of guessing with credentials.

Frankly I'm alarmed that you've placed so much faith in that credential. For America in particular it really doesn't mean that much on its own unless you went to a well-known school. Not all CS programs are created equal. I'm certainly not going to burn cash and time because of spooky predictions of developer armageddon. People with four years of actual experience will be just fine.

Personally I'd be more interested in security-oriented devs. That's more important than knocking a few thousand cycles off of your algorithm.

Re:Google Launches a Developer Boot Camp, Promising Jobs for... by kcole16 on Thursday October 22, 2015 @06:53PM (#10435701)
I know amazing engineers without CS degrees, and bad engineers with them. It's certainly nice to have one, but it's hardly a prerequisite for becoming a good engineer.