News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On Quitting by mathgeek on Thursday October 01, 2015 @09:57AM (#10311131)
You don't need to be single or a renter to save. You just need to make it a priority.

I'm the sole breadwinner with a wife and two kids, and we pack away 20% out of every paycheck. We own our home and both cars.

Do we live a garish lifestyle? Certainly not, but we travel a lot and adhere to our budget (thank goodness for remote jobs).

Re:On Quitting by johnward on Thursday October 01, 2015 @10:16AM (#10311284)
Not to be a dick but it sounds like you just make a lot of money. I'd consider owning a house and 2 cars to be pretty garish compared to the average middle class family. The luxury of being able to travel is something not many people have. Plus if you have ever had a parent help you with any significant expense you are much luckier than the majority of people. This sounds like one of those /r/personalfinance threads where the op finally paid off debt by cutting expenses, cooking at home, getting $200k windfall from a grandparent dying, etc.
Re:On Quitting by mathgeek on Thursday October 01, 2015 @10:24AM (#10311329)
> Not to be a dick but it sounds like you just make a lot of money.

I do not. I make just over $70k a year now (a lot more than a few years ago) and before we had kids, we cut back so that my wife's income at the time went entirely to paying off debts. Our home is worth ~135k (three bedroom in a nice cheaper US city), and our cars are nothing to write home about but they get us where we need to go. My total income now is higher than our combined income was then. Like I said before, planning goes a long way.

Your comment does come off as a bit dickish, by the way. You made a lot of assumptions about me that are not true.

Re:On Quitting by johnward on Thursday October 01, 2015 @10:26AM (#10311340)
Just for the record when someone says "not to be x" they are almost always about to be X. I was wrong. You are in a situation similar to me though. About the same income/housing price with a wife and first child on the way. There is no way I'm saving 20% in the foreseeable future though. I have two car payments though. One that will be paid off this year and the other I'd like to get rid of but I'm too upside down right now.
Re:On Quitting by mathgeek on Thursday October 01, 2015 @10:32AM (#10311385)
> There is no way I'm saving 20% in the foreseeable future though.

Absolutely understandable. We certainly went through a few years where we were just happy that we didn't have debt and could live off my income. Good luck with your own journey!

Re:On Quitting by redblacktree on Thursday October 01, 2015 @10:45AM (#10311475)
I have yet to pay off the house, but my wife and I (similar situation to the two of you) managed to pay off $47k in debt (credit cards, student loans, and car loans) in two years. In the months that followed, we saved a six-month emergency fund. We just stuck to a budget, and put every other penny on debt. We followed the Dave Ramsey plan. People poo poo him for not being sophisticated enough, but it's about changing behavior, not doing math.

Anyway, I just noticed that you said "no way," and I wanted to provide a counter example. Good luck!

Re:On Quitting by johnward on Thursday October 01, 2015 @01:06PM (#10312664)
I'm taking the snowball approach right now too. Maybe I will eventually get to where I can put away 20% but for now that extra money goes to paying down debt. Aside from $100 a month that goes into an emergency savings fund and 4% into my 401k.
Re:On Quitting by redblacktree on Thursday October 01, 2015 @03:33PM (#10314033)
When I started the snowball, I stopped contributing to the 401k, in an effort to be as focused as possible. I think that's one of the great strengths of Dave's plan. Being focused solely on one goal at a time gives you a quick feeling of accomplishment as you start racking up wins. If you spread your efforts out across too many goals, you may get discouraged when you don't seem to be making fast progress on anything.
Re:On Quitting by ConfuciusSay on Thursday October 01, 2015 @10:47AM (#10311485)
For what it's worth, you're in roughly the top 30% of earners globally. Whether that constitutes "a lot of money" depends on your definition, but we often forget just how little most people on this planet live on so I wanted to throw it out there.
Re:On Quitting by mathgeek on Thursday October 01, 2015 @12:26PM (#10312332)
I think we can safely restrict our sampling to much less than the global population when discussing someone quitting their job in SV.
Re:On Quitting by adevine on Thursday October 01, 2015 @11:35AM (#10311862)
Which is why I have a lot of sympathy for the majority of people on the planet. For the typical HN commenter, though, who is either highly compensated or at least in an industry with a lot of job security, I have to roll my eyes when people act so baffled as to how one can possibly save money.

I am well compensated now, but right after college I was making 15k a year (it was in the arts) and I still managed to save money.

Re:On Quitting by tomjen3 on Thursday October 01, 2015 @12:30PM (#10312379)
He also lives in a place that is far more expensive.
Re:On Quitting by mistermann on Thursday October 01, 2015 @10:00AM (#10311158)
> We own our home and both cars.

Whether that is possible depends a lot on where you live - from what I can tell, outside of a few major cities there are plenty of places in the US where you can buy a house for <$200k in the US, good luck with that anywhere in Canada.

Re:On Quitting by brianwawok on Thursday October 01, 2015 @10:07AM (#10311211)
But you choose where you live. I do not live in SF, despite the nice weather, because I am not willing to spend a million bucks for a basic house.
Re:On Quitting by mhurron on Thursday October 01, 2015 @10:19AM (#10311305)
> But you choose where you live

Given that it takes money to move, no, you do not always have a choice in where to live.

Re:On Quitting by Killswitch on Thursday October 01, 2015 @10:53AM (#10311526)
Bullshit. Nobody forces you to live in an expensive city. Nobody makes you buy a million dollar house. You chose your own destiny. Stop putting the blame on others.

I lived in Chicago on a $800/mo salary for a year and a half. Yes eight hundred dollars a month, in the city of Chicago. I had no money, but I made it work, then I moved back home to small town Iowa and make a lot more now, and live a better life. Nobody made me do either of those things.

Re:On Quitting by mhurron on Thursday October 01, 2015 @11:33AM (#10311842)
> Nobody forces you to live in an expensive city.

It takes money move, to or from any city. It's nice that you were able to make it work, and yes, it means others could as well but you wold look like a little less of an asshole if you would consider not everyone is in the same situation as you were.

Were you single

Did you have kids

Did you have any medical conditions that needed care

Did you use to have a better job before

That's just a few things that are part of everyday, normal life that can make the cost of moving and living on very little somewhat difficult.

> Nobody makes you buy a million dollar house

I don't remember saying anything close to that.

Re:On Quitting by Killswitch on Thursday October 01, 2015 @11:46AM (#10311964)
> Were you single

No.

> Did you have kids

Yes.

> Did you have any medical conditions that needed care

Not that I know of.

> Did you use to have a better job before

I moved to the city with a $100 loan from my step-father so I could afford gas to do the 4 hour drive taking nothing with me but what I could fit in my car, which took a 3rd of that $800/mo just to pay.

You know how I moved? I asked a friend, he came and helped me and packed his truck with what I couldn't fit in my car.

Excuses, excuses, excuses.

Re:On Quitting by mhurron on Thursday October 01, 2015 @12:06PM (#10312158)
You know that lack of empathy is a significant personality disorder.

> Did you have any medical conditions that needed care > Not that I know of.

Others do, it's often sort of important to handle them. It can also limit the cities you can live in.

> Were you single > No.

Right here I start thinking your now being disingenuous, second income?

> car, which took a 3rd of that $800/mo

So you lived in Chicago on 528 a month and saved enough to move. You are leaving things out. This was either 40 years ago, you were getting significant social assistance or something.

Lets go ahead and throw out another perfectly, though unfortunate, normal situation. You had parents to even move back in with.

Now then, I don't live in a particularly expensive city. The 'million dollar house' you want to keep throwing around as if everyone has is almost 10 times the cost of where I live. Yet I can still see that not every one is in the exact same situation I am in. Moving to another city would not be something I could do on a whim, though I've had to cover medical expenses this year that are more than what your supposed monthly income was.

Re:On Quitting by Killswitch on Thursday October 01, 2015 @12:29PM (#10312367)
> The 'million dollar house' you want to keep throwing around

I mentioned it once. You're the one who keeps bringing it back up.

> Right here I start thinking your now being disingenuous, second income?

No second income. My fiance has never, and will never pay anything for me.

> So you lived in Chicago on 528 a month and saved enough to move. You are leaving things out. This was either 40 years ago, you were getting significant social assistance or something.

Oh sorry, I left out the $600/mo the startup I worked for paid the owner of the spare bedroom I lived in. My bad. $1400/mo. And 40 years ago? I'm 30, I moved from Chicago in March of this year.

Re:On Quitting by lovich on Thursday October 01, 2015 @02:46PM (#10313601)
>Oh sorry, I left out the $600/mo the startup I worked for paid the owner of the spare bedroom I lived in. My bad. $1400/mo. And 40 years ago? I'm 30, I moved from Chicago in March of this year.

Were your SO and kids not living with you? I cant imagine putting 3+ people into a spare bedroom. If you guys did do that, its impressive but its certainly not within the realm of normal in the US. If you didn't have them with you, than saying you had 1400 a month to support yourself, your SO, and your kid/s is not an accurate accounting of your living expenses for Chicago

Re:On Quitting by brianwawok on Thursday October 01, 2015 @05:09PM (#10314739)
Agreed.

It's dumb to devolve this argument down to "But what if you have cancer and 7 dogs and 3 kids, how would you move?"

Because the average person reading hacker news with a tech job in the valley does not have 7 dogs and 3 kids and cancer. We can feel sorry for that person, but I am pretty sure we can blame all 200k software developers living in SF as having 7 dogs 3 kids and cancer.

Re:On Quitting by hammock on Thursday October 01, 2015 @05:16PM (#10314791)
I had a buddy that lived in a coffin apartment in Chinatown (Chicago) for <$200/mo. He was a struggling musician and I was impressed at his ability to make it work
Re:On Quitting by mistermann on Sunday October 04, 2015 @03:13PM (#10328463)
On an affordability (cost vs earning power) basis, houses are extremely expensive everywhere in Canada - we are on the same trajectory the US was with their housing bubble, but about 2 years behind - the difference is, ours never burst, and we have surpassed the peaks attained in the US.
Re:On Quitting by HeyLaughingBoy on Thursday October 01, 2015 @01:49PM (#10313025)
I realize that things have changed, but around 15 years ago, a friend of mine sold her ~$30,000 house in a city in Saskatchewan to move to a ~$20,000 house in the country.

Hard to imagine that housing prices have gone up 10x in that time.

Re:On Quitting by a-priori on Thursday October 01, 2015 @02:30PM (#10313452)
Here's a chart of housing prices over time in Canada, adjusted for inflation:

http://www.macleans.ca/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/Rabidoux_h...

In their index, housing prices were about 100 in 2000 and about 180 in 2013, so houses were about 80% more expensive in 2013 versus 2000. That is in real terms. You'd expect it to be more like 103% more expensive in nominal terms (assuming 2%/year inflation).

Here's a good source for recent housing prices in Canada:

http://crea.ca/content/national-average-price-map

It shows that the average sale price in Canada was $433k in August 2015. But there's tremendous variation within Canada. Vancouver was around $900k; PEI was $158k. It looks like Saskatchewan was around $253k, so a bit over half the national average, with Regina and Saskatoon being more expensive in the $310-320k range.

About 15 years ago you would have expected prices to be about half that in Saskatchewan, or maybe $125k. So no, house prices have not gone up 10x in the last 15 years and $20-30k were not typical house prices in Saskatchewan at the time.

Re:On Quitting by mistermann on Sunday October 04, 2015 @03:18PM (#10328478)
If you're retired or can work remotely, and don't mind missing out on all the culture and activities available in a city, sure you can move to a cheap house in rural Canada. The difference is, in the US you don't have to, you can have both in many places. Low affordability, like in San Fransisco, is an anomaly in the US, in Canada it is the norm.
Re:On Quitting by lovich on Thursday October 01, 2015 @01:58PM (#10313121)
How are you supporting 4 people with roughly 56k a year and own a house and 2 cars at the same time? Its not unbelievable if youve paid off those expenses over a long time and didnt have student loans. But even one bad car repair could be a couple percent of your total budget for the year. My student loans would be 8.5% of your 70k paycheck alone
Re:On Quitting by bluedino on Thursday October 01, 2015 @10:15AM (#10311277)
> 20%

Is that including retirement savings or not?

Re:On Quitting by mathgeek on Thursday October 01, 2015 @10:29AM (#10311363)
That's out of net, after IRA contributions.