News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by blizkreeg on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @08:50PM (#10230939)
I'm glad Ahmed got all the support and encouragement he did but not one person of note/power, including Obama and Hillary Clinton (who offered their cute tweets) have talked of punishing, penalizing, or in the very least reprimanding the officers and teachers who put him through this. How is that?

It's criminal to handcuff and interrogate a 14-yr old in front of his entire class and school when they found nothing to implicate him. It's an unconscionable act. These people are not only stupid (look at that 'suspicious' device), they are abusing power with no repercussions.

"The student was handcuffed for his safety and for the safety of the officers". Are they out of their mind?

Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by guelo on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @09:07PM (#10230992)
Federalism means that the federal government doesn't have much power at the state or lower levels unless there are constitutional issues involved (you could argue 14th amendment but it's a stretch). If Obama tried to get the teacher fired it would be a massive abuse of power.
Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by MCRed on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @09:41PM (#10231101)
United States Code 18-242 makes it a federal crime (a felony if armed) to violate a citizens constitutional rights under color of law. There are several rights that I think were violated here, or appear to have been enough to make it indictable and possibly merit prosecution.
Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by rhizome on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @08:59PM (#10230965)
"Officer safety" is statutory language that supports a whole host of discretionary powers, from handcuffing to shooting dead.

It's criminal to handcuff and interrogate a 14-yr old in front of his entire class and school when they found nothing to implicate him.

It maybe should be, but isn't. However, what is illegal is questioning him without his parents or a lawyer present, which he requested multiple times to no effect.

http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2015/09/16/police-viol...

Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by blizkreeg on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @09:00PM (#10230968)
I meant criminal in a metaphorical sense.

But shouldn't they be prosecuted for questioning him without parental consent or presence, at least?

Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by rhizome on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @09:12PM (#10231004)
But shouldn't they be prosecuted for questioning him without parental consent or presence, at least?

No, because Civil Rights violations are generally established through civil suits, not criminal. More specifically, 42 USC 1983 is civil, 18 USC 242 is criminal. There is a telltale loophole in the criminal statute, "willfully," that provides wiggle room for the violator to play dumb.

Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by alien_robot on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @09:20PM (#10231027)
> These people are not only stupid (look at that 'suspicious' device), they are abusing power with no repercussions.

That's the part that bothers me the most - that they were too stupid to know what they were looking at. He was proud of his invention and wanted to show it off.

Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by Random_BSD_Geek on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @09:57PM (#10231156)
I understand and agree with your outrage. But isn't the attention and humiliation they are receiving enough? Elevating the dialogue was the graceful thing to do.
Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by GBond on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @10:11PM (#10231192)
Taking high road is best. The fear these authority had comes from ignorance. And the HNer types can help change that. Geeks can do a better job of presenting technology to normals in a way that is palpable.
Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by patrickaljord on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @09:04PM (#10230978)
Apparently there is such a law as anti-hoax bomb so it would be hard to prosecute officers. Another reason it's hard to prosecute bad cops is the same reason it's hard to fire bad teachers: powerful unions, which by the way Obama and Hillary support. These unions don't care about safety or education (in case of teachers unions), they only care about protecting officers and teachers jobs, no matter how bad or criminal they can act.
[dead]
Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by bigiain on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @09:34PM (#10231076)
Seriously? You think it's the _clock design_ that's absurd, and not the school and cop's ignorant reactions?

Should I be convicted of a "bomb hoax" for this? https://www.flickr.com/photos/bigiain/5162711688/

Note my description from five years ago shows somewhat more considered-but-not-carried-out intent than this kid...

I think you are 100% wrong. People who assume anything vaguely electronic that they don't understand must be "terrorism" are the problem here, not smart kids building things out of what they have at hand with whatever aesthetic they like. In my opinion, it's the school and the cops who were yelling "fire" in this movie theatre.

And this isn't the first time "the authorities" have go this just as badly wrong: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2007_Boston_bomb_scare https://boingboing.net/2007/09/21/mit-student-arrested.html

Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by hdctambien on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @09:50PM (#10231127)
Considering this[0] is what an actual bomb looks like, practically every student at every school could be carrying a bomb.

The teacher he showed the clock to in the morning is kicking himself for not telling the kid to leave it with him and pick it up at the end of the day. He knew what the administration/other teachers would think if they saw it.

What if it was a bomb. Or the timer for a bomb that was already planted? And the news today was "14 year old brings bomb to school, teachers save day"?

The situation was not handled well at all by any of the adults involved. But schools are a scary place. You've got a building with a generation of other people's children in it. And some times people do bad things in those buildings.

Someone should have looked at that clock and said "yeah, this is a clock. No big deal. It doesn't even look like a real bomb, but if it kind of looks like a TV Bomb, maybe don't bring it to school next time." and then everyone goes on their merry way.

Unfortunately, adult ego got involved.

[0] http://www.oddthingsconsidered.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/0...

Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by 001sky on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @11:10PM (#10231374)
Just a note--an IED in a backpack is what IED looks like...that's the whole point of an ied--strategic ambiquity, right? Your larger point is correct, tho, that adults should have sacked up and handled this thing immediately. Common sense being 20/20 in hindsight.
Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by informatimago on Thursday September 17, 2015 @02:15AM (#10231827)
Well, just writing "BOMB" on a card board, and boarding a plane with it, would be enough to get you arrested in the USA; we've seen examples close enough.
Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by 001sky on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @09:41PM (#10231104)
First,

go try joking about explosives in security line at the airport, or at the white-house, or the local federal courthouse. Its not the joke you are getting (going to be) arrested for, its not the absurdity, its not the freedom of speech you are exercising. Its also not racist or whatever...it is just not the context for jokes.

Second,

The <carrier-device> for the "timepiece" is straight out of a B movie. see, eg

https://www.google.com/search?q=what+is+a+gun+briefcase+look...

https://www.google.com/search?q=what+does+a+bomb+in+a+breifc...

Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by bigiain on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @09:53PM (#10231139)
First - he never mentioned, joked, or claimed anything about explosives (but the cops carefully framed that as him "not being forthcoming"). The only people talking about explosives were the "adults".

Second - when did it become "OK" to handcuff and question children without lawyers based on what b-grade movie makers choose to use as stereotypes?

(Sorry you're getting downvoted so hard - I disagree but would rather discuss and understand your position than downvote you to oblivion...)

Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by 001sky on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @10:58PM (#10231341)
Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by bigiain on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @11:15PM (#10231392)
Sure - Woz built a metronome - then realised it looked a bit like part of a bomb, and intentionally modified it to look like bomb, then hid it in a locker and purposely rigged it up to tick faster in the expectation that it'd be found.

That's a _lot_ further down the path of "intent to create a bomb hoax" than "building a clock".

(And personally, I'm of the opinion that putting a schoolkid in jail for what Woz did was ignorantly overreacting... Quite possibly because I was that same kind of schoolkid who'd make that same silly decision. Hell look at my Flickr photo's comment - I thought it would be hilarious to do that at 43 years old, it's just experience and perspective that stopped me building exactly what Woz made...)

Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by 001sky on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @11:46PM (#10231467)
point being that questioning a kid and releasing him are not that big a deall. perp walk is OTT. but stuff happens...look at woz...people do dumb shit like that...same thing as sarcasm in security theatre at the airport...justic is working OK when people get pulled aside...contrast to the way the police publicly execute black people for holding a toy or a telephone...those cases seem alot more egregious in many ways. I don't mind playing devil's advocate here...i think some discussion is warranted. no worries.
Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by DanBC on Thursday September 17, 2015 @02:44AM (#10231909)
> point being that questioning a kid and releasing him are not that big a deall

Depriving someone of their liberty, even for a few hours, is a big deal. That's why compensation for wrongful arrest runs to $5,000 - $10,000 per hour.

Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by 001sky on Thursday September 17, 2015 @10:50AM (#10233657)
this hinges on good faith and ignorance of the law. you can legitimately arrest suspects under the auspices of 'suspiscion' of a crime (eg, murder). Whereas false arrest is an arrest contary to known fact.

In cases of bomb threats and security breaches, qualified immunity is going to provide significant leeway when dealing with IEDs. Since most high-schools have strict anti-weapons rules, you can get arrested for a swiss army knife. Again, this is not the same thing as an apologia for a perp walk of a 14 year old. But if you want to see a "false arrest" look at what happened to the Blake last week in NYC. That was an unreasonable takedown of a private citizen with no effort made to establish identity; and a violent arrest for a non-fleeing suspect in a non-violent crime, etc.

In this case you are dealing with an "IED" vs an "Improvised Timekeeping Device", and since the former often includes the latter as a component part, its not completely baseless. This is why you cannot fly with liquid water on an airplane--the security forces cannot distinguish (on-sight) "legitimate water" in a clear bottle from several chemicals (aslo clear) than can be combined into an explosive IED that will puncture a pressure hull of an airliner. If you insist on taking your water through security you will get it removed or be arrested.

Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by Gigablah on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @09:50PM (#10231128)
Dude, it was the size of a pencil box. If comically tiny briefcases are such a cause for alarm... man, you guys are swept up in a culture of fear.
Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by vfclists on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @10:02PM (#10231169)
I don't suppose any of you have heard of the School to Prison Pipeline.

Lookup Dr Umar Johnson

Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by jcfrei on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @09:02PM (#10230971)
>I'm glad Ahmed got all the support and encouragement he did but not one person of note/power, including Obama and Hillary Clinton (who offered their cute tweets) have talked of punishing, penalizing, or in the very least reprimanding the officers and teachers who put him through this. How is that?

Maybe because the world has bigger problems than one police officer and a teacher acting out of line. It's a story the internet loves and perpetuates but frankly absolutely unimportant.

Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by dsugarman on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @09:06PM (#10230985)
Police culture is currently toxic and is a danger to all US citizens
Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by jessaustin on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @09:24PM (#10231045)
I would say to all residents of and visitors to USA.
Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by blizkreeg on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @09:04PM (#10230977)
By that measure, unless someone dies, nothing is important. Couldn't you conceive of a situation where he (let's say out of panic) acts weird and an officer shoots him dead on suspicion of a suitcase containing a bomb? Would that make it important enough?
Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by blakeja on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @09:14PM (#10231008)
Funny you should put it like that. Now that actual pictures of the "digital clock" are available, that is first time I have seen a clock built into a metal suitcase that, golly gee, somewhat resembles a bomb.

Ya'll are being absurd. That kid new what he was doing, I did stupid shit like that when I his age...worse in fact, these days I would have made national headlines if I had been caught. So I know what I am talking about here.

He may be be a smart boy, but you put that briefcase in any Hollywood movie or video game and they would call it a bomb. If he was really building a clock it would at least somewhat really resemble a clock.

Bear in mind, I am a strong opponent of the rising police state and slow creep of tyranny that I hope is becoming obvious to even the more ignorant sections of the populace. But this...come on guys, call a spade a spade.

Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by wpietri on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @09:22PM (#10231036)
Pssst: You do not live in a Hollywood movie or video game.

Here in the real world, he biggest recent terrorist incident in the US, the Boston Marathon bombing, used a backpack. But nobody is suggesting that kids be arrested for bringing backpacks to school.

And yes, the kid knew what he was doing: bringing in one of his hobby projects to show his teachers. Which is exactly what we want students to do. The problem is that the teachers didn't know what they were doing.

Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by Turing_Machine on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @09:30PM (#10231067)
"that is first time I have seen a clock built into a metal suitcase"

Pencil case, not a suitcase. When I was a kid, I used whatever case I could come up with for my projects. Cigar boxes, whatever.

I understand that Altoids tins are quite popular with the young tinkerers of today.

Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by Gigablah on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @09:16PM (#10231013)
"Metal suitcase"? "Briefcase"? It's merely the size of a pencil box. In fact, it IS a pencil box. Call a spade a spade.
Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by kitwalker12 on Thursday September 17, 2015 @03:48PM (#10235642)
I'm so annoyed that NO ONE is mentioning THIS fact. It's a pencil box people
Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by mikeash on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @09:40PM (#10231096)
In what way does it resemble a bomb, exactly?
Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by AjithAntony on Thursday September 17, 2015 @12:45AM (#10231619)
I was skeptical until i saw the picture. If there was no other context it looks pretty suspicious. If you left this thing unattended at bus stop you bet there would be a bomb squad on it.

But now that we are all familiar with pencil box clocks, one could easily mimic this design for a real bomb. A block of c4 would work nicely as the transformer core.

Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by wpietri on Thursday September 17, 2015 @09:48AM (#10233288)
It does not "look pretty suspicious". You suspect it. Suspicion is a process that happens inside your head, and is not intrinsic to the object.

We can agree that the device would look unfamiliar to many. But that people treat unfamiliar things as scary is up to them.

As I mentioned elsewhere, the biggest recent bombing in the US left a backpack behind. Others have used briefcases, trucks, and even a Christmas present:

http://townhall.com/columnists/johnhawkins/2013/04/16/the-10...

So if you are serious about security, then you should call the bomb squad for ordinary objects left behind at bus stops.

Of course, nobody getting the vapors about this incident is serious about security. If they were, they would not have carried Ahmed's device around the school building. If they thought it was a bomb, they would have stopped touching the device, evacuated the area, and called the bomb squad.

The actual problem here is not Ahmed's clock. It is teachers and administrators who think their irrational fears are far more important that kids' educations.

Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by mikeash on Thursday September 17, 2015 @09:51AM (#10233306)
Suspicious how, exactly?

I mean, you're right that if you left it unattended at a bus stop the bomb squad would show up. But the same is true of a cardboard box or a backpack. Nearly anything looks suspicious if you leave it sitting around. That's not a reasonable criteria for "resembles a bomb," especially when it wasn't left sitting around.

Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by ashwinaj on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @09:35PM (#10231078)
This unfortunate event is a microcosm of the society (in the US) we live in:

- Most people love to be PC and no one has the cajones to have a frank conversation about race issues as adults (especially in the red states).

- A lot of people love to spew out personal anecdotes and pass them off as the truth and anything opposing to that POV as an exception to their anecdotal belief

- The fact that none of them have apologized (at this point in time, even if they issue one, it's going to be fake) shows the disdain and bigotry against minorities, generally speaking

Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by Gigablah on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @09:14PM (#10231009)
Maybe this story is much more important than you think because plenty of people see it as a symptom of a larger problem than an isolated incident.
Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by moron4hire on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @09:04PM (#10230976)
Maybe we have more than enough resources to handle even the problems you deem trivial.
Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by gress on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @09:06PM (#10230990)
Are you suggesting an immediate pardon for any crime less serious than kidnapping or slander?
Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by jessaustin on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @09:25PM (#10231051)
For agents of the state, certainly!
Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by rralian on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @09:47PM (#10231119)
Really? That sounds like a solid step towards fascism.
Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by jessaustin on Thursday September 17, 2015 @07:56AM (#10232790)
Sorry, I forgot a smiley on that one. b^)
Re:Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf] by rralian on Thursday September 17, 2015 @01:53PM (#10234960)
Heh. It's difficult to tell. :-) That doesn't sound like a far-fetched sentiment outside of the HN community.