News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by tgflynn on Monday August 31, 2015 @06:04PM (#10149364)
There used to be the notion in this country that after a person was released from prison they had "paid there debt to society" and should therefore be able to go on with there life. How did we get to a place where no one seems to believe this anymore ?

I would think that a punishment for a crime that includes forced destitution for life independently of the nature of the crime would be considered cruel and unusual. But the Bill of Rights doesn't seem to be taken seriously anymore either.

Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by csense on Monday August 31, 2015 @06:22PM (#10149466)
> How did we get to a place where no one seems to believe this anymore?

It's technology's fault. Before the advent of widespread computers capable of indexing large amounts of data, in order for someone to know a person had a felony, they would have had to know where you were convicted, travel to the courthouse in that county, and go through stacks of dusty paper files.

This struck a good balance between making court records public (anyone can look at them), and the privacy of individual defendants (few people bothered because it's time-consuming and inconvenient, therefore expensive).

Of course software's eaten this market, there are companies that have digitized and indexed all those public records, and now you can run background checks on people with a few mouse clicks and a few bucks on your credit card.

Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by toomuchtodo on Monday August 31, 2015 @07:13PM (#10149702)
> It's technology's fault.

Its our fault, not technology's. Technology is just a tool; we've failed to properly address how it should be used.

See: Drones, NSA spying, etc as well.

Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by m_mueller on Monday August 31, 2015 @08:15PM (#10149930)
Anything that can be done, will be done, to whatever degree people can profit from it, as long as it isn't regulated. If a majority of people are against these privacy violation, then it's simply a failure of the political system to come up with a solution.
Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by CyberDildonics on Monday August 31, 2015 @07:55PM (#10149841)
True. We're still broadcasting most of our internet traffic in the clear for fuck's sake.
Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by ovi256 on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @05:51AM (#10151494)
Tools shape society just as much as society shapes tools.
Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by _delirium on Monday August 31, 2015 @07:20PM (#10149723)
Traditional tort law also put some barriers in the way of doing various negative things you could imagine doing with the public information. For example photocopying a bunch of public records about someone you don't like, and then mailing them to the person's employer, flyering the neighborhood with copies of them, etc., or following the person as they go apply for employment and handing a copy to the prospective employer, would all fall afoul (in some jurisdictions) of economic torts and anti-harassment law. But running an "information service" that does this systematically for everyone doesn't have the same element of targeted harassment, so avoids these torts, while still harming the person in question.
Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by x0x0 on Monday August 31, 2015 @06:50PM (#10149603)
It's clearly technology's fault. Just like police never assaulted black/brown people before everyone had video cameras on their persons 24/7. And ufos stopped visiting.

On a serious note, you're running perilously close to google and the right to forget. I strongly agree with you, but it's the google party line that there's no difference at all between (1) the ability to conduct a background check on someone as long as you're willing to spend tens of thousands of dollars, and (2) the ability for anyone to conduct and publicize a background check for free. You'll note also that asshole Eric Schmidt simultaneously suggested people should change their names if they want youthful indiscretions not to follow them for the rest of their life while using his billions and lawyers to erase his mistresses' stories from the internet.

Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by plorg on Monday August 31, 2015 @06:11PM (#10149402)
If my local politicians are any indication, the ones who were in office during the 'tough-on-crime' era, particularly of the 80's and 90's, tend to speak as if the convicted are reprobate, can never fully 'repay' their victims, and are destined for a life of crime. I suspect some of this rhetoric bled into their perceptions of the point of criminal penalties, leading to much more retributive and much less restorative/redemptive sentencing practices and laws.

But it's hard for me to separate that all from the general Calvinist/religious culture of the area where I live.

Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by Kinnard on Monday August 31, 2015 @06:42PM (#10149574)
> How did we get to a place where no one seems to believe this anymore ?

I think for some groups in this country, we're not just getting to this place, this is where we've been for a long time. It's just that the masses are better able to access information about it now.

Blacks being killed by police with indiscretion did not start in 2013. I'd guess in fact that that the past 5 years were way better for black live than the 5 years before them. People just happen to be paying attention now.

Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by Retric on Monday August 31, 2015 @08:13PM (#10149917)
The Black lives matter movement was catalyzed as a marketing campaign by companies that sell police cameras that went viral. http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html
Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by guelo on Monday August 31, 2015 @08:36PM (#10150031)
That is absolutely not true.
Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by Retric on Monday August 31, 2015 @08:42PM (#10150044)
I am in no way suggesting the original conversation was markiting. But, if you look at the timeline there was a marketing push right before that phrase took off.
Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by guelo on Monday August 31, 2015 @09:11PM (#10150131)
You can read about the activists that coined #BlackLivesMatter here, they work for social justice nonprofits. http://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/2015/03/04/alicia-garza-b...

What is the name of the police camera company that you are talking about?

Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by Retric on Monday August 31, 2015 @10:36PM (#10150387)
I am not suggesting there is a direct connection. It's an amplification effect, Rodney King's beating was arguably a much more agregious spark, and there are plenty of for worse trigger events to spark things. Looking at the actual triggers you could argue it's a straw that brakes Yada yada, but that not not seem to fit how sticky the story was.

IMO, it's trigger, news story, more news stories, response to all the news, news stories about the movement, self sustaining movement. with more news being the fake bit.

Without people actively trying to sell things there are far more important issues, but a little media judo can shift perception and policy.

Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by UnoriginalGuy on Monday August 31, 2015 @08:26PM (#10149987)
Do you have a citation or is that just your personal theory?
Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by Retric on Monday August 31, 2015 @08:36PM (#10150030)
A marketing guy working for one of those companies mentioned pushing the story in an NPR interview. It was not 100% clear if they where waiting for an event to capitalize on, or noticed the story get traction and then started pushing it.
Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by anigbrowl on Monday August 31, 2015 @09:12PM (#10150136)
That's interesting but it's such a startling claim I think you need to back it up with something better than 'i heard it on the radio,' otherwise you're just going make a lot of people feel offended and write you off as a conspiracy theorist. Like at least hit NPR.org for an hour or two and track down a URL.
Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by mcphage on Monday August 31, 2015 @09:21PM (#10150167)
I'm not sure that a camera company encouraging a movement (clearly they did not actually start it) is particularly relevant. Is it a good movement? Yes? Then let every company push it, whether they profit thereby or not.
Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by Kinnard on Monday August 31, 2015 @08:58PM (#10150082)
I can't say that I see anything unethical about a police sousveillance company catalyzing the Black Lives Matter Movement
Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by imaginenore on Monday August 31, 2015 @07:49PM (#10149825)
And what's really crazy we force sex offenders (which includes the people who got caught peeing in a public place) to announce themselves, not allow them to live within X feet of schools, and there's a public database of them.

But we don't do the same with kidnappers or murderers.

How insane is that?

Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by UnoriginalGuy on Monday August 31, 2015 @08:29PM (#10150004)
Not that it matters, but most "kidnappers" are actually parents (or other close family members) and most kidnapping victims are actually children involved in child custody disputes.

This doesn't change your point at all, just wanted to point out that putting "kidnappers" on the list might not be very effective.

Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by mburns on Monday August 31, 2015 @08:47PM (#10150056)
>just wanted to point out that putting "kidnappers" on the list might not be very effective.

Not unlike how putting all "sex offenders" on the list is not effective.

Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by Ntrails on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @07:29AM (#10151705)
All crimes of the same name are not equal.

The 17 year old having (nominally) consensual sex with a 15 year old. The drunken liaison where one party was not able to consent (doesn't remember consenting, didn't, or otherwise). The breaking and entering to rape at knife point.

I do not consider these equal crimes, and whilst I've no objection to legal intervention in each I think the key on is to appropriately manage the risk of re offending. Making someone's life nigh on impossible after serving time only makes them resent the system and interferes with proper re-integration into society. That's the only meaningful goal. Or it should be in my opinion.

Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by harshreality on Monday August 31, 2015 @07:55PM (#10149842)
I suppose society gets restless if it doesn't have some class of people it can very publicly brand, so if needed it makes one up semi-arbitrarily. Modern day scarlet letter.
Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by anigbrowl on Monday August 31, 2015 @11:26PM (#10150555)
Quite - look at the increasingly ludicrous proposals for building walls thousands of miles long, rounding up millions of people and deporting them and so on. There are some unrealistic proposals from the left too, but they tend be more boring ones like jacking up taxes on incomes and swingeing tariffs on imports - economically foolish but logistically quite easy.
Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by vidarh on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @11:34AM (#10153058)
It reflects an idea of risks of re-offending and perceived danger.

It may not be perfect, and there are very real issues with making it harder for people to resume a normal life after getting out, but this is actually one of those areas where actions are more in line with actual risks than a lot of policies relating to how past offenders are treated.

Murderers are highly unlikely to carry out another murder - most murders are "one of a kind" heat of passion, not sociopaths killing for the entertainment value or similar. The nature of the victims of murders and the low risk of re-offending makes it relatively low risk to live near someone who has carried out a murder in the past.

Sex-offenders are much more likely to be an ongoing risk to society after being released, and sex-offenders who have previously targeted children are extremely likely to target based on level of access (e.g. parents and close relatives top the list, but other people with close access to a child rank high, such as e.g. a neighbour that manages to become friends with the parents of a child), which is a particular impetus for people to worry about where they live.

Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by DanBC on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @04:15AM (#10151267)
Public urination is unlikely to involve sex offender registration. Only three US states have the law needed (arizona, california, and georgia) and two of those (arizona and georgia) also require either repeat offences or the presence of children.

There is a total of about 5,00 people in the US on the register for exposure - and obviously not all of those are there for public urination.

Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by Frozenlock on Monday August 31, 2015 @07:59PM (#10149862)
Interesting...

This means I can prevent a school from being built near my house by peeing in a public place... :-)

Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by sitkack on Monday August 31, 2015 @08:14PM (#10149924)
I assume they would make you move, or have you fired, or both.
Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by eru on Monday August 31, 2015 @08:23PM (#10149968)
No. They will force you to move.
Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by the_ancient on Monday August 31, 2015 @09:04PM (#10150098)
No they will likely announce the school and before it is even built arrest you and lock you away for many many years
Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by a3n on Monday August 31, 2015 @10:50PM (#10150434)
As an individual, I would be cautious about hiring a former convict, but it's not out of the question.

Intuitively (I'm not an actuary), it seems that insurance companies get away with charging you more if you've had a prior accident. It seems a person who has broken the law may be more likely to break it than the average person.

I think it stinks that this local govt can tell a business to fire a felon though, that just compounds the problem of re-entry. I smell a Supreme Court case in the future.

Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by fweespeech on Monday August 31, 2015 @06:59PM (#10149637)
I think this is a case of local crazies doing something crazy.

The courts will shut it down when challenged, I'd hope.

Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by comrh on Monday August 31, 2015 @06:58PM (#10149627)
Take away a person's right to vote and in a democracy they're no long part of society.
Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by knodi123 on Monday August 31, 2015 @07:09PM (#10149677)
society: the aggregate of people living together in a more or less ordered community.

There's a lot more to american society than standing in a voting booth. I agree it's a steep price, but there's no need to exaggerate.

Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by baudehlo on Monday August 31, 2015 @07:37PM (#10149779)
So you're fine with suffrage in general, or just for people who have paid their debt to society?
Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by eru on Monday August 31, 2015 @08:25PM (#10149981)
Just be charitable in your interpretation. Knodi123 probably wants ex-cons treated well, but doesn't believe that they are not part of society, even without voting rights.

Kids have no voting rights either. Or legal aliens. Or visiting diplomats. Etc.

Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by baudehlo on Monday August 31, 2015 @08:35PM (#10150022)
I said nothing about being part of society (whatever that means - it's a very vague statement). I asked a specific question about suffrage.
Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by lotharbot on Monday August 31, 2015 @09:01PM (#10150087)
Putting a question mark after a seemingly-accusatory statement doesn't make it a question.

If you were genuinely curious, "what's your opinion on voting rights for convicted criminals?" would be a better way to ask.

Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by baudehlo on Monday August 31, 2015 @09:36PM (#10150218)
Sure, I could have asked more nicely, but when someone is seemingly ok with oppressing one part of society I would appreciate an explanation. It's surprising that (some/most?) Americans are ok with this situation, and yet understand that not giving women or minorities the vote was a huge deal.
Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by lotharbot on Monday August 31, 2015 @10:14PM (#10150319)
> "I would appreciate an explanation"

Asking nicely makes it more likely that you will get one.

People are much more likely to answer a question when it seems like you're interested in a genuine answer, than when it seems like you've already passed judgment and the question is a mere formality.

Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by lsaferite on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @08:41AM (#10151922)
Should they bow before asking nicely as well?

They were not asking in a pleasant manner, but they were also not being outright rude. Not every interaction has to be sunshine and lollipops.

Passive-agressive outrage at the apparent lack of concern for the disenfranchisement of a fairly large population group seems... ok in the grand scheme. No name calling, no yelling, and no 'please sir, will you answer me this' is required.

Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by lotharbot on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @12:00PM (#10153305)
I'm merely noting something learned from a lot of arguing on the internet -- if you "ask" in an accusatory way, or a passive-aggressive way, or a way that makes it seem as though you've intentionally hidden something in your question, people are less likely to give you a genuine response. People are naturally conflict-avoidant, and the way the above question was asked makes it sound like someone is itching for conflict. Even if the OP had a good answer, it can be exhausting to phrase such an answer in a way that defuses points of conflict for an already-hostile conversation partner.

This advice parallels one of the Hacker News guidelines: "avoid gratuitous negativity". Asking questions in a gratuitously negative way doesn't usually make for good conversation.

Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by knodi123 on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @12:19PM (#10153499)
I stated no position on the issue, so your hostile tone is unnecessary. In fact, I'm okay with suffrage for every adult of established citizenship. What I'm against is breathlessly hyperbolic exaggerations
Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by NoCulturalFit on Monday August 31, 2015 @06:26PM (#10149495)
My theory is that people are dissatisfied with what the "debt to society" is. How can you blame them. If you have loved ones who were attacked, how would you feel if the criminal only got 180 hours of community service for sexual assault?

http://www.stoppa-pedofilerna.se/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/...

Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by ploxiln on Monday August 31, 2015 @06:39PM (#10149555)
Well in the US, "sex offenders" (including public urination and some people not actually convicted of doing what is alleged) are marked for life and need to inform their neighbors of their shunned status whenever they move. (On the down side, some people like me don't take "sexual offender" status seriously because it's so often mis-applied.)
Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by kevin_thibedeau on Monday August 31, 2015 @06:56PM (#10149622)
Murderers get better treatment after release than low level sex offenders who committed victimless crimes. A sad reflection on a society that consumes violence for entertainment but is deathly afraid of all sexual matters.
Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by the_ancient on Monday August 31, 2015 @10:42PM (#10150409)
That is because in todays society Violence is Acceptable, Sex is not.

Porn is icky, disgusting, and distasteful

A movie with torture, graphic violence, and gore is a fun friday evening.

Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by lsaferite on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @08:44AM (#10151926)
In the US.

Go to some place like Germany and notice they are very anti-violence and more sexually open. You see nudity on German broadcast television but not graphic violence. I'd say their priorities are much better in that regard.

Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by tgflynn on Monday August 31, 2015 @06:48PM (#10149593)
Not to mention that many (maybe even most) felony convictions are for victimless "crimes" like drug possession or for property offenses where no one has suffered any kind of irreperable harm.
Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by seanflyon on Monday August 31, 2015 @08:44PM (#10150047)
> not actually convicted of doing what is alleged

Do you mean "not actually guilty even though they were found guilty" or do we put people on sex offender registries without due process?

Re:Government officials in Amherst, VA can now require emplo... by ploxiln on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @10:51AM (#10152713)
I was wrong about that. I thought there were cases where accusation + not (yet) being proved innocent was enough to get on the list. But a look at wikipedia shows that some kind of conviction or guilty plea is always involved.

But there is this about the UK: "and unconvicted people thought to be at risk of offending" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sex_offender_registry#United_K...