Re:Superconductivity record sparks wave of follow-up physics
by idlewords on Monday August 17, 2015 @11:44PM
(#10077502)
H2S fun facts! It's more lethal than hydrogen cyanide, and despite its powerful stench at low concentrations (detectable by humans at half a part per billion), it becomes odorless (by paralyzing your sense of smell) right around when you need to start getting worried.
"A diagnostic clue of extreme poisoning by H2S is the discolouration of copper coins in the pockets of the victim"
Re:Superconductivity record sparks wave of follow-up physics
by beloch on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @12:10AM
(#10077562)
Safety procedure when working around sour gas wells (natural gas with H2S) is that, if you see somebody drop in front of you, you do not touch him, approach him, or anything else. You just get the hell outta there. If he's been dropped by H2S, trying to move him is just going to cause you to go down too. Besides being bloody lethal, H2S is notorious for being corrosive. H2S forms metal sulfides with any exposed metal it can access, and the hydrogen byproduct often diffuses through the metal and forms expanding holidays in positions of stress, potentially to the point that the metal will crack.
I've worked around high power free-space infrared lasers where a single stray reflection could instantly blind you permanently (and you can't see infrared light scattering off of stuff like you can with visible lasers). I'd rather spend years working with those than spend one afternoon in a lab with a sample of H2S at 140 GPa. I don't care if it's inside a diamond anvil cell inside a cryostat. High pressure H2S has got to be a freakin' nightmare to work with. I'm sure H2S has lots of funky properties nobody knows about because practically nobody wants to work with the stuff. Kudos to the PI who convinced a bunch of grad student peons to put their lives on the line... I suppose.
Re:Superconductivity record sparks wave of follow-up physics
by beloch on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @12:44AM
(#10077632)
Reading the arxiv preprint, they fed H2S into a DAC using a capillary. The size of the sample under pressure was 1um thick and 10 um in diameter, which is indeed tiny. So, that's probably not so bad. Anyone who thinks this would make a great room temperature superconductor in real applications had better smarten up though.
Re:Superconductivity record sparks wave of follow-up physics
by Turing_Machine on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @01:00AM
(#10077661)
"it becomes odorless (by paralyzing your sense of smell) right around when you need to start getting worried"
I don't know if this is still the case in this litigation-happy age (probably not), but when I was in high school it was a common beginner's chem class experiment to make small quantities of H2S.
My physics teacher once commented that he hated it when they did that, because he'd smell it for a while, then not smell it any more -- leaving him to wonder whether it'd just gone away, or whether people were going to start keeling over.
Re:Superconductivity record sparks wave of follow-up physics
by sleeping_pills on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @03:35AM
(#10077974)
Ah the good old days of worry free high school chemistry/physics classes. My chem teacher poured out a pint of mercury and allowed us to push our fingers into it to feel how different it was from liquids like water. Good times.
Re:Superconductivity record sparks wave of follow-up physics
by jgamman on Monday August 17, 2015 @11:16PM
(#10077445)
but still... 203K!? i remember the 90s when the last round of leap frogging superconductor materials were being developed - every conference even vaguely related to solid state chem/physics seemed to set a new record. And H2S? it's hardly an exotic material. maybe it's just the (near dead) chemist in me geeking out ;-)
Re:Superconductivity record sparks wave of follow-up physics
by cbd1984 on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @02:48AM
(#10077873)
> the (near dead) chemist
Work around enough H2S and it will take you the rest of the way.
My point is, it has enough problems with flagrant toxicity that containment of non-trivial amounts of it will be either massively expensive, totally inadequate (especially in the event of an earthquake, fire, fire caused by earthquake...), or both.
Re:Superconductivity record sparks wave of follow-up physics
by tlb on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @02:25AM
(#10077828)
I don't have a good mental model of solids at very high pressures. Temperature is a measure of kinetic energy, but because the atoms are squeezed closer together the stiffness of the lattice is higher, therefore the displacement due thermal vibrations at a given temperature is less.
I wonder if the displacement at 203K and 1.5M atm is similar to the displacement at which conventional BCS superconductors operate.
Re:Superconductivity record sparks wave of follow-up physics
by dunkelheit on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @04:20AM
(#10078060)
Actually in thermodynamic terms temperature is a measure of how entropy (disorder) increases when you increase internal energy. Not the most intuitive definition (you can't just go and buy entropyometer for example ;)) but it works even when quantum effects kick in. And for ideal gas this measure happens to be proportional to the kinetic energy of the particles.
Re:Superconductivity record sparks wave of follow-up physics
by jessriedel on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @06:04AM
(#10078327)
This is a really interesting framing. If it's the correct way to think about things, it would really put a damper on the importance of warm-temperatures/extreme-pressure superconductors.
Re:Superconductivity record sparks wave of follow-up physics
by mkoryak on Monday August 17, 2015 @11:46PM
(#10077509)
Is bringing a substance to 1.5 million atm cheaper than cooling it to under -70C ?
All the articles I read on the topic seem to imply that higher temperatures are much more important than a bit of super high pressure, but can someone explain why?
Re:Superconductivity record sparks wave of follow-up physics
by danarlow on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @12:01AM
(#10077539)
The big application for superconductors is wire, and it's much harder to compress a wire to a million atm than it is to cool it to -70 C. However, this result is important (if independently replicated) because it demonstrates that the established theory of low temperature superconductivity [1] has predictive power all the way up to these high temperatures and likely to room temperature, providing new motivation for theoretical chemists to dream up new materials that the theory predicts would superconduct under more accessible conditions. Practical room temperature superconductors would, in my opinion, change the world as much as the development of semiconductors.
Re:Superconductivity record sparks wave of follow-up physics
by Turing_Machine on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @01:10AM
(#10077677)
"Practical room temperature superconductors would, in my opinion, change the world as much as the development of semiconductors"
It would be huge, definitely. Even the most obvious application (reducing electric power transmission losses) would be worth billions. According to the Googles, ~4000 TWh generated annually, 6% transmission losses, $.09/kWh gives about $22 billion in annual savings in the United States alone (if I didn't mess up the arithmetic).
Re:Superconductivity record sparks wave of follow-up physics
by tedsanders on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @02:00AM
(#10077786)
Not necessarily. Even if we successfully developed a room temperature superconductor, there would still be huge commercial hurdles. Cost, mechanical stability, thermal stability, manufacturability, transportability, sensitivity to heat waves, reliability, critical field (which limits current), density, tensile strength, etc. Also, while $22 billion in annual savings sounds big, the grid is extremely capital intensive, and would take decades and trillions of dollars to upgrade.
Re:Superconductivity record sparks wave of follow-up physics
by andyidsinga on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @02:41AM
(#10077852)
really interesting!
question I have is: are there other areas with high losses that this could change the game for? For instance, large induction furnaces, or a space elevator?
Re:Superconductivity record sparks wave of follow-up physics
by Gravityloss on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @07:43AM
(#10078642)
Really high torque and power electric motors and generators in a small package.
That's why the US navy is heavily into this - for submarines and ships.
It'd also make very large offshore wind power plants potentially cheaper.
Electric / hybrid propulsion in aircraft is another. When your thruster is just a light fan, you can place it in the best aerodynamic / least noise generating position, then put the power generator and batteries where there's space and it makes sense for center of gravity. You could have rejuvenation of near city airfields again.
Re:Superconductivity record sparks wave of follow-up physics
by danarlow on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @03:08AM
(#10077912)
high current/field applications: magnetic energy storage, magnetic plasma confinement for fusion, particle accelerators, rail guns, magnetic levitation/bearings
extreme sensitivity applications: portable NMR spectrometers/MRI scanners, practical quantum computing, very fast and sensitive microwave processing, easy access to large scale fermion condensates for scientific research
Re:Superconductivity record sparks wave of follow-up physics
by xt00 on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @03:25AM
(#10077949)
The reason why this is so important is that simpler molecules are much easier to simulate and work with from the theoretical side to create a bulletproof model of how the high temperature superconductors work. All of the cooper pairs and all that stuff took years and years to figure out because the molecule was something like yttrium barium copper oxide.. which is complicated as all hell to figure out what the electrons are doing inside of it while in a crystalline form.. H2S is basically like "sulfur plus some protons" is so much more simple to simulate with something like molecular dynamics methods to figure out what is going on with it. What the researchers probably are hoping to come out of this is a recipe for superconductivity based upon a crystalline form of some material that can be made in a low-cost fashion that superconducts at high temp..
Re:Superconductivity record sparks wave of follow-up physics
by jkn on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @04:31AM
(#10078085)
Maintaining a low temperature requires continuous work as you can't stop heat transfer completely. This consumes energy and requires some machinery to produce or deliver the coolant.
Establishing and maintaining a high pressure on the other hand is a one time effort, for example screwing back the front of a ballpoint pen puts the spring inside under permanent pressure, and even gases can be contained at high pressure with no significant loss.
Re:Superconductivity record sparks wave of follow-up physics
by eddyb on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @05:21AM
(#10078211)
Every time I see news of sub-zero superconductivity I get reminded that this site exists http://superconductors.org/ and there's no debunking or confirming of anything on it.
You'd think that all these years, someone with the right equipment would at least have the least bit of curiosity and try out one of those crystal configurations.
If it doesn't work, make it public, maybe repeat the negative findings a few times and nobody would have to wonder "but what if?".
If it does work, well, the rest of the thread explains what would happen to technology in that case.
One odd theory I've come across is that he may be intentionally avoiding publicity just enough so that he can get patents filed for everything before any of this stuff starts being used in production.
While that's too much conspiracy for me, it's either that or "nobody knows (or cares) whether he's a charlatan or not" and it keeps bugging me until I forget about it.
Re:Superconductivity record sparks wave of follow-up physics
by delecti on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @12:46AM
(#10077639)
Well I'm not aware of any commonly accepted current theories of super conductivity that say a room temperature one is necessarily impossible, so I suppose implicitly yes.
Re:Superconductivity record sparks wave of follow-up physics
by mikeash on Monday August 17, 2015 @11:21PM
(#10077457)
I doubt the toxicity would do you much harm. There should be no risk of taking the gas into your lungs, as after the release of 150 gigapascals of pressure, you'll probably be nowhere near them.
"A diagnostic clue of extreme poisoning by H2S is the discolouration of copper coins in the pockets of the victim"
I've worked around high power free-space infrared lasers where a single stray reflection could instantly blind you permanently (and you can't see infrared light scattering off of stuff like you can with visible lasers). I'd rather spend years working with those than spend one afternoon in a lab with a sample of H2S at 140 GPa. I don't care if it's inside a diamond anvil cell inside a cryostat. High pressure H2S has got to be a freakin' nightmare to work with. I'm sure H2S has lots of funky properties nobody knows about because practically nobody wants to work with the stuff. Kudos to the PI who convinced a bunch of grad student peons to put their lives on the line... I suppose.
They probably have absolutely tiny quantities of the stuff under pressure. Not enough to hurt anyone even if it escaped.
I don't know if this is still the case in this litigation-happy age (probably not), but when I was in high school it was a common beginner's chem class experiment to make small quantities of H2S.
My physics teacher once commented that he hated it when they did that, because he'd smell it for a while, then not smell it any more -- leaving him to wonder whether it'd just gone away, or whether people were going to start keeling over.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mercury_poisoning
Work around enough H2S and it will take you the rest of the way.
My point is, it has enough problems with flagrant toxicity that containment of non-trivial amounts of it will be either massively expensive, totally inadequate (especially in the event of an earthquake, fire, fire caused by earthquake...), or both.
Massively expensive is not a limitation if the need is there.
I wonder if the displacement at 203K and 1.5M atm is similar to the displacement at which conventional BCS superconductors operate.
All the articles I read on the topic seem to imply that higher temperatures are much more important than a bit of super high pressure, but can someone explain why?
[1] a modified version of BCS Theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BCS_theory
It would be huge, definitely. Even the most obvious application (reducing electric power transmission losses) would be worth billions. According to the Googles, ~4000 TWh generated annually, 6% transmission losses, $.09/kWh gives about $22 billion in annual savings in the United States alone (if I didn't mess up the arithmetic).
That's why the US navy is heavily into this - for submarines and ships.
It'd also make very large offshore wind power plants potentially cheaper.
Electric / hybrid propulsion in aircraft is another. When your thruster is just a light fan, you can place it in the best aerodynamic / least noise generating position, then put the power generator and batteries where there's space and it makes sense for center of gravity. You could have rejuvenation of near city airfields again.
extreme sensitivity applications: portable NMR spectrometers/MRI scanners, practical quantum computing, very fast and sensitive microwave processing, easy access to large scale fermion condensates for scientific research
Establishing and maintaining a high pressure on the other hand is a one time effort, for example screwing back the front of a ballpoint pen puts the spring inside under permanent pressure, and even gases can be contained at high pressure with no significant loss.
http://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/full/2005/03/aa1695/aa1695....
You'd think that all these years, someone with the right equipment would at least have the least bit of curiosity and try out one of those crystal configurations.
If it doesn't work, make it public, maybe repeat the negative findings a few times and nobody would have to wonder "but what if?".
If it does work, well, the rest of the thread explains what would happen to technology in that case.
One odd theory I've come across is that he may be intentionally avoiding publicity just enough so that he can get patents filed for everything before any of this stuff starts being used in production.
While that's too much conspiracy for me, it's either that or "nobody knows (or cares) whether he's a charlatan or not" and it keeps bugging me until I forget about it.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magic_smoke
If this is true there will be a mini gold rush in this space in the next couple of years. Maybe the record will not stand for very long.