News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads?

Since earnings via ads are rapidly decreasing I am looking for other ways to monetize my websites. My experience with donations have been disappointing at earlier tests, about 0.5% earnings of income via ads. But maybe I did it wrong, or choose the wrong donation channels (I used paypal, flattr, bitocin) Did anybody manage to get a non ridiculous amount via donations?
( 58 comments | 58 points | on HN )
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by reddavis on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @01:04PM (#10042625)
We went for a "pay what you want" model for my latest app. It's a real simple utility app but we were pleasantly surprised with what people paid. I gave a quick overview of all the numbers here https://medium.com/@reddavis/stand-app-9ee0fc3355c
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by tobltobs on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @04:06PM (#10043982)
This could be an idea. Before every conversion (or daily) ask for a payment, which could be 0. But without the possibility to make economical payments in the 10cent area this will not work.
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by Mz on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @06:47PM (#10044934)
Some of the discussion here might interest you as well: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10042368
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by nfd on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @06:45PM (#10044925)
Yeah, you'd basically need cash or cryptocurrency for that size of microtransaction (nanotransaction?). If I could pitch in 20-50 cents to a project I like in a few seconds, I would.
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by corysama on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @03:00PM (#10043528)
I don't know their numbers, but http://synergy-project.org/ is a good example of how to get donations.

It's a public, GPL project https://github.com/synergy/synergy You can either compile it yourself or you can go through the very smooth purchase process to get a lifetime subscription to pre-compiled binary installers for $10. It was much cheaper for me to just type in my CC# and move on with enjoying the program than to even investigate compiling it myself.

Both Synergy and Humble Bundle do the same thing: They make going through the checkout line a smooth, easy, natural process on the path to getting the software. The problem with donations is not really that people are so cheap. It's that they're so lazy. If you give them what they want up front and then ask that they come back later to go through some awkward process to give you money for something they already have... Well, what do you expect? It's too late. They've moved on with their day. They can't be bothered. But, if you make it very easy to give you money on the path to giving them the goods. Then their appreciation and generosity doesn't require much effort. That's the key.

Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by crazypyro on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @03:42PM (#10043790)
Synergy is a terrible model for supporting open-source projects. While the project is very useful, the lead devs basically begged the community for years trying to support full time developers on what honestly started as a very small tool (although the compatibility issues are many). They made to pay to put in bug reports or vote on which issues were important to you. The devs eventually got a bunch of donation money and then they wasted it all on an office and full-time employees with zero revenue. After using community donation money as seed funding for their new business, they decided to start charging for the installers. They also removed resources that aided distribution in an effort to get more people to pay them.

There are tons of open source projects that dwarf synergy both in scope and lack of funding, yet synergy somehow needs thousands of dollars, over and over. In my opinion, they are trying as hard as it can to close down the GPL project so they can make even more money.

Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by trestletech on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @03:29PM (#10043694)
+1 and I really like the idea of that model and wanted to support Synergy in particular, but I almost gave up when I saw I'd have to compile from source, then did give up once I started encountering errors building from source. I would have happily given them money if they could have proven that the product worked on my equipment first (free trial, etc.) but given that it didn't seem to work, I bailed.
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by crazypyro on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @03:42PM (#10043794)
They purposely make it difficult and even removed documentation on building synergy to boost sales. You can find nightlies here: https://synergy-project.org/nightly
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by corysama on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @03:47PM (#10043831)
I don't know anything about the history of the project.

Is this the documentation you were referring to? Or, was it something else?

https://github.com/synergy/synergy/wiki/Compiling

Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by crazypyro on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @03:57PM (#10043908)
I believe there was additional information that they removed, but maybe its all there now. That was a complaint I had read somewhere else, so I'd take that specific one with a grain of salt. Still, I think it would be silly to ignore the fact that the developers have a monetary incentive to making the project hard to compile and distribute. Maybe I'm just biased, but their site and github gives me a distinct impression that they would pretty quickly shutdown all open source aspects of the project and completely close the source if they legally could. They are hiring a CTO and another engineer. Why does an open source project with this size of scope need so much money and employees? Its clear their number one goal is to make money now, not create a quality open source project. Combine this feeling I get with how they have treated users and potential contributors in the past, I would dissuade anyone from using them as a model open source project.
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by mijustin on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @02:50PM (#10043463)
Another avenue is membership. Gimlet Media is experimenting with this right now:

https://gimletmedia.com/join-gimlet/

Members support their company at $5 / month, or $60 / year.

The challenge with all of this, is that no one has been really able to make a lot of money with the donation paradigm.

For example, 5by5, a hugely popular podcast site, has roughly $2,500 / month in donations on Patreon:

https://www.patreon.com/5by5

If you look on https://recurrency.us/discover, you can see how much bloggers there are making. Not much.

Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by ohitsdom on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @03:03PM (#10043547)
Arstechnica is another good example of membership. If you're a paying member, no ads. Otherwise, ads. Best of both worlds and you give your audience a choice in how to support you.
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by radmuzom on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @04:06PM (#10043976)
If you are using ad-blockers, how does it matter if you are a paying member or not? Am I missing something obvious?
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by OrwellianChild on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @04:49PM (#10044283)
The obvious bit is this: You are circumventing their revenue model. If you like/want to support their content, this is not an ideal way to show that support. Either turn off the ad-blocker or pay for membership.
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by tajen on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @04:36PM (#10050449)
Honest, lateral question: Now that I think about it, will DRM prevent the use of ad-blockers on a majority of websites? Could this be a sweepingly major side-effect of DRMs?
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by softwarerero on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @02:51PM (#10043466)
This is the monthly income for a news site with about 160 monthly articles and 143.000 monthly page views: Direct Ad Space: 170$, AdSense 50$, Sponsored Articles: 45$, Amazon: 4$, Donations: 0$
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by stephengillie on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @12:45PM (#10042456)
> My experience with donations ... about 0.5% earnings of income via ads.

So, to put it another way, you've made 200 times more (not just 200%) by advertising than by donation? For example, if you had received $25 in donations, then your ad revenue should be about $5,000.

df-offical has an unfortunately dead comment with some interesting and similar numbers:

> Ad-earnings in December 2014: $700, Affiliate Earnings: $200, Donations: $25.

So that would put them at $700/$25 = 28 times more (36 times more if you include Affiliate Earnings). There's an order of magnitude difference between your earnings:donations ratio and df-offical's ratio, but advertising income is definitely the greater share of the two.

Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by superasn on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @01:07PM (#10042644)
I would say that was my experience with donations too.

I had a site or side-project (featured on Techcrunch, Lifehacker, etc) but only made $40 in donations in it's entire lifetime. It was a small winamp/itunes/kmplayer plugin so I didn't expect a lot of donations but with nearly 500K installs that is a very very small number.

P.S. I never pestered my users for donation though. Never even optimized the donate button or anything like what I do with my business sites since that I made for fun purposes only on a weekend.

Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by tobltobs on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @12:49PM (#10042493)
Yes, 200 times more. But that was about 3 years ago. Since then the cpm dropped, so in the meantime and it should be closer to 100 times more.
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by stephengillie on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @12:51PM (#10042515)
How do you place your own donation ads in relation to your advertisers' ads?
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by tobltobs on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @12:56PM (#10042545)
There is just a donation point in the navigation.
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by monknomo on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @02:41PM (#10043411)
Has anyone tried a Humble Bundle approach, where users buy the software and have the option of entering $0? I suspect having a non-zero default payment and a guilt-inducing average payment would encourage people to donate, while allowing them the option to just get it for free.

I could put on my patio11 hat and say "Just charge for it"

Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by zhte415 on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @06:23AM (#10047016)
I've used this, as a 'buyer' (and have bought in several cases) for things like books and detailed articles written by independent people.

One extra benefit is 'please sign up for email updates' which while in almost all cases not mandatory, comes with text like "stay up to date" or "receive insights".

I usually do sign-up, and this keeps the person providing these updates with another potential customer for other stuff, and me with usually useful (as I've self-selected as being interested) and interesting updates.

Win-win.

Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by monknomo on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @08:53PM (#10051716)
That's a really good point about using a lightly locked gate as a way of collecting interested people's email. Even in the case of a totally marketing averse 'free as in beer and speech' open source project, an email list of users is useful.

You could tell them about updates, new projects or terrible bugs

Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by jackmaney on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @02:50PM (#10043462)
A neat idea, but I think that Humble Bundle mostly has bundles of games (or software directly related to games)...

Hmmm, making a more open Humble Bundle type shop could be a neat idea, and I see that openbundles.com is currently available.

Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by monknomo on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @04:52PM (#10044301)
Don't let me stand in the way of an opensource bundle promotion dealy-bopper, but all I meant was borrowing the concept that they use when you "buy" a bundle. Instead of letting a user directly download whatever free opensource widget you've made and hoping they donate, plant a big mean 'ole "are you going to buy that?" screen before the download link.

A free open bundle library would make this a lot easier, but if someone writes one, for the love of god, dogfood it! We can't have you starving in the streets while trying to make other altruistic developers money. ;)

Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by howderek on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @05:32PM (#10044562)
Yeah, ElementaryOS did that, I'm not sure what their numbers look like though
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by beambot on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @01:30PM (#10042852)
What type of website? For something with regularly-updated content, Patreon can be pretty compelling. For example, I know several YouTubers who earn as much via Patreon as they do from YouTube ads.
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by emerongi on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @03:05PM (#10043557)
I know YouTubers who couldn't live without Patreon. It's their only source of income. To make a living from YT you have to have a pretty huge number of viewers.

Fortunately, their viewers are hard-core fans and ~0.5% - 1.0% of their subscribers donate to them. Seems little, but it's actually a lot (consider that you have to view 1000 videos to "give" a Youtuber $1 via ads).

As a comparison: A certain Youtuber with 1.8M subscribers makes about as much from ads as another with 300K subscribers from Patreon.

Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by pornel on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @03:31PM (#10043716)
Sponsorship works for me. Companies got in touch with me directly saying they'd like to sponsor my project. I put on my project pages "This nice company sponsors my project". I ensure that's actually a company I can endorse, and my users aren't exposed to any nasty ad scripts.

Both donations and sponsorship pale in comparison with development/consulting fees. When a company needs a feature they're happy to pay a proper daily rate.

Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by tobltobs on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @04:10PM (#10044006)
Isn't sponsorship another name for link buying. I do get those offers but the amount people are willing to pay is minimal. It would make more than donations, but on the other side big G doesn't like link sellers and therefore it is not worth the risk imho.
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by pornel on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @05:43PM (#10044608)
The link is clearly labelled and I don't accept any spammy "buy cheap meds" links. I hope Google doesn't kill that. I think for users one vetted link is much better than regular ads, which on software-related sites tend to be fake download buttons leading to malware.
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by danneu on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @04:44PM (#10044255)
I've been running a forum since 2007 and Adsense was the boon that paid for my university and made me money.

I don't think I'll ever ask for donations again. Plopping a donation button on a website seems to do nothing but make users assume that other users must be donating.

I've never seen donations go anywhere without active hustling/fundraising which makes the website feel like a desperate church. Look at how much effort Wikipedia goes through to ask for donations. And after all that work you'll always make less than you would with ads.

Meanwhile, sticking Adsense code on a website makes you passive money that's less annoying to your users than a donation campaign.

Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by tobltobs on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @04:58PM (#10044333)
That have been my thought until yet too. However with a rapidly shrinking cpm and a a growing adblocker usage the easy times of adsense are coming to an end imho.
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by herval on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @02:25PM (#10043296)
I had a guestbook/guestmap site for almost 10 years. Ads never made me more than $200/month, whereas donations (you donate whatever you want to remove ads from your guestmap) really picked up some times of the year (I got a $150 donation on thanksgiving, among almost $2k in random donations on the same month - best month in the entire lifetime of the site). Ad revenue tapered off during the years, stabilizing at under $5/month in 2013, donations averaged $200/month until the end (average $12)
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by ytpete on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @08:17PM (#10045241)
That's not purely donations though. Paying to remove ads is more like a freemium model IMHO, since people get something (a nicer user experience) in exchange for their money.
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by herval on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @02:23PM (#10049613)
Indeed, it's "pay what you want". Should've been clearer.0, sorry!
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by Mz on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @06:26PM (#10044834)
I have always done better with donations than from ads, going back several years. I am currently researching Patreon as a possibility for the future. I have never had much traffic. I am working on that. My traffic is getting steadier and, after a whole lot of thought and research, here are some things I have done that are showing promise early on:

Post a well positioned note thanking people for supporting the site by white listing you on ad blocker "or" via tips. Reposition your donate button as a tip jar.

Stop using the word donations. Find language that signals that you are providing something of value and they are supporting your ability to continue making it available. So far, tips is the best word I have found. I am still doing research.

The word donations makes people view you as a charity case, not someone offering something of value who somehow needs to get paid for it.

Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by tobltobs on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @06:36PM (#10044872)
Thank you, that some good inputs. I will try "support us".
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by nugget on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @12:40PM (#10042419)
What kinds of websites do you have? I think monetization for different verticals is likely to diverge radically in the next few years.
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by tobltobs on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @12:47PM (#10042472)
Small online tools. No content pages, just some convert x to y or stuff like that. The problems you can solve with those pages are too small to ask for user registration or a fee.
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by petercooper on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @02:09PM (#10043192)
Run of the mill banner ads are probably the worst way to monetize things like that. From my POV there are two main options:

1) Build it up enough to have a premium tier with something people would be willing to pay for. This essentially makes you SaaS, however, with all that's involved with running a SaaS business.

2) Lead gen type sponsorships on the backend. Let's say your page is a * to PDF converter (as someone linked below), there are commercial PDF services, software vendors, etc, who would be keen to reach an audience requiring those services. Alternatively (again, depending on the service) there might be companies who have content that would appeal to such users and would pay a monthly fee to have a link to their content included on your finish/thank you page (this is common in the email newsletter signup world, related vendors like to be on those thank you pages as a next destination).

For my own part, depending on the tools in question, I might even be keen on sponsoring some, and I was recently speaking with a director of marketing at an incubator who advised me the companies they represent get a lot of value out of sponsoring tools in this way.

Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by hluska on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @01:43PM (#10042964)
You mentioned in another post that you have a donate page in your navigation. Have you A/B tested showing a call to donate along with the result?
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by briholt on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @12:51PM (#10042518)
Could you share what they are?
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by minhyeok on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @01:35PM (#10042905)
smallpdf.com
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by patio11 on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @03:40PM (#10043778)
I paid $50 for downloadable software once which did one of these things that I needed done for one single document, once. [+] You can certainly charge for these. (n.b. I got my start in business with software which turned a random number generator into PDFs. My sense of it is the market for your product is orders of magnitude greater than the market for mine.)

[ + ] There was a document holding up an insurance application holding up a $X0,000 consulting engagement. That's not the typical case in business, but businesses broadly speaking do have more money than you can possibly imagine to throw at solving real problems.

Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by briholt on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @03:22PM (#10043658)
That's a pretty sweet site. I'd vote a freemium option. You could do things like:

X conversions free per IP per month, upgrade for more

X Mb files are free, upgrade for bigger files

Do you have some stats on visitor loyalty? You probably get a lot of passer-bys, but the 1% that uses you weekly should be paying.

It's not too much work to set up a Stripe or Paypal subscription service and put up a little paywall.

It reminds me of https://www.url2png.com/ which I subscribed to for a while.

Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by HeyLaughingBoy on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @02:38PM (#10043389)
Are you kidding? Donation? This is worth real money: sell it.
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by cJ0th on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @02:22PM (#10043273)
I would imagine that your service can be turned into a SaaS. For example: a free service that allows x pages per ip address a day and a premium service with an "unlimited" amount of conversions.
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by tobltobs on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @04:04PM (#10043965)
Because the concurrence would happily take your users if you start asking for money.
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by tobltobs on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @03:51PM (#10043850)
This is NOT one of my projects, but it is a good example anyway. Making a Saas or whatever out of this will not work, as there is too much concurrence.
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by ryanSrich on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @03:37PM (#10043762)
ughh....why not turn that into a business. Seems super legit.
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by eli on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @01:25PM (#10042803)
Arguably, it's always been different. I can tell you first hand that there is a robust ad market for content that reaches executives and decision makers in various industries.
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by jacquesm on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @02:13PM (#10043220)
I put up a bitcoin donations link on reocities.com a couple of years ago, so far it paid ~$100.
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by megaman22 on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @01:54PM (#10043050)
I've made about $25 from donations, vs about $70 from AdWords and Amazon affiliate links, over the course of about two years. Of course, I actually got the $25 from the donations, whereas the ad revenue is still waiting to hit the minimum payment thresholds...
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by tajen on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @01:36PM (#10042917)
We need a patio11 person dedicated to donation-based software ;) Does it work better if the software is open-source, but the donation is mandatory in the original version of the binaries?
Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by patio11 on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @03:33PM (#10043727)
Would it be presumptuous of me to mention why that is not me? Because, in 10 years of doing this, I've seen one small business do decently well with the donation model. (It's Paint.NET. Rich asked me not to mention the numbers when he told me them, and I respect his wishes, but let's say "A quite happy result which supports a small team in a sustainable fashion.")

I have also seen many developers try it. Monks take a vow of poverty, because it can be spiritually fulfilling, but I do not believe many people would take a vow of poverty so that they can devote every waking moment to fixing the problems of for-profit companies. (There are individual people I'm thinking of while writing this. I won't mention their situations, for the obvious reasons, but I'm generally a quiet restrained guy and, after a coffee date with one of them, I nearly put my fist through a mirror out of vicarious frustration with injustice.)

There are so, so many better business models than taking donations. Let's move the conversation to those better models. "Charge money for goods and services" provides plenty of room for experimentation and has the desirable property of actually working.

Re:Ask HN: How much do you earn with donations vs. ads? by johnward on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @03:11PM (#10043592)
Maybe we don't have one because it's a poor business model?