> In one of Gerald Weinberg's books, probably The Secrets of Consulting, there's the apocryphal story of the giant multinational hamburger chain where some bright MBA figured out that eliminating just three sesame seeds from a sesame-seed bun would be completely unnoticeable by anyone yet would save the company $126,000 per year.
> So they do it, and time passes, and another bushy-tailed MBA comes along, and does another study, and concludes that removing another five sesame seeds wouldn't hurt either, and would save even more money, and so on and so forth, every year or two, the new management trainee looking for ways to save money proposes removing a sesame seed or two, until eventually, they're shipping hamburger buns with exactly three sesame seeds artfully arranged in a triangle, and nobody buys their hamburgers any more.
http://www.joelonsoftware.com/items/2007/09/11.html
Short-term goals with little or no consequences are the problem.
Yep, definitely happens a lot outside the corporate world.
Taxation doesn't quite fit the pattern we're talking about here, anyway. If a TV channel increases its ads, the obvious failure mode is that viewers go elsewhere instead (and hence advertisers spend less and revenue falls). But inter-country mobility is small enough that even quite large changes in tax rates aren't likely to make a lot of taxpayers go elsewhere. You occasionally hear rich famous people threatening that if some potentially tax-raising party comes into power they'll leave the country, but they don't generally actually do it.
(That may be different for corporate as opposed to individual taxes. Large multinational companies may be willing and able to move their operations around to minimize the taxes they pay.)
I imagine someone there has figured out the inflection point where they can reduce the quality of their service without losing a significant number of customers. But perhaps that's giving them to much credit.
That is one benefit of the modern internet. As a customer that is quality-sensitive about many products, I can 'evangelize' to insensitive customers and attempt to bring them into the fold and start demanding better quality products, thereby increasing the quality I receive from the product myself.
"The simplest way to explain the behavior of any bureaucratic organization is to assume that it is controlled by a cabal of its enemies."
But doesn't that depend on a significant fraction of investors being rational and having pretty good information? And on markets not being "rigged"?
And I wonder whether the price of current stock market transactions adequately reflects the knowledge of all investors, including the long-term ones.
>And I wonder whether the price of current stock market transactions adequately reflects the knowledge of all investors, including the long-term ones.
That's sort of an odd way to put it. By definition the market transactions reflect the knowledge of all investors, unless you're postulating they don't apply knowledge when they trade. Do you mean the stock price is influence by people without knowledge other people do have? That's true.
But professional and institutional investors have the most influence, and they've got a pretty good idea when managers are eating the seed corn. It's an obvious strategy for executives, so professional investors are always on the lookout.
Do some executives get away with padding their bonuses through short term strategies? Sure. But I think it's rare.
When you put it that way, it does sound implausible. But it demonstrably happens, so lets consider how that explanation may be wrong.
You don't necessarily have to fool a lot of sophisticated investors, you have to fool people/firms with sufficient funds available to invest, who can be talked into the belief that they are taking advantage of opportunity the rest of the market is missing, perhaps one which is uniquely available to them because of synergies.
Often this can be one person or firm rather than a lot of investors (sophisticated or not) -- its not as if acquisitions where the acquirer pays above market price and ends up a few years later taking a huge charge when its expectations fail to pan out are unheard of.
And this makes sense. If firms can make foolish decisions in running their business which negatively impact the future of the company, one form this can take is buying some other business at an unjustified price where someone else had already made a foolish decisions that negatively impacted the future value of that business.
If you know of specific companies that have destroyed their future for a short term stock gain, you stand to make a fortune by short selling the stock.
One of the many reasons (alongside Sarbanes-Oxley) that some large tech companies appear to have chosen not to IPO.
Counter-examples I can think of include Google, FB, Twitter, Apple, Amazon, MS, ...
I like to look at it as a natural cycle of things rather than a pandemic of things - though the case can be made for either.
Hopefully, as it all decays and people get sick of it, the other side is reached, and the opposite becomes true... unless the government interferes and keeps bad businesses and industries afloat, or the industry colludes to maintain the status quo.
http://ogun.stanford.edu/~bnayfeh/plan.html
NSFW language of the form "_ happens", which is part of the ha-ha-only-serious joke.
/* ahh, the irony of using a NSFW-censor to describe this link */
Can you really call them con men when they admit this upfront by saying they have a MBA?
Also, this is what we get when companies only care about quarterly earnings reports. If a company only has a 3 month vision, it has to come up with schemes like this.
Computers are a great example, especially when Moore was still going strong, and advancement was obsoleting & retiring computers far more quickly than component failure.
Another (slightly less intuitive) example is automobiles particularly in regards to emissions. If old automobiles were not intentionally obsoleted by smog laws, they would have continued to "waste" air quality.
Planned obsolescence is when you artificially shorten the lifespan of something in order to increase the sales of the product or the next generation of the product in order to generate more revenue.
If you have a product with an active resale market. Any product with a noted higher quality will sell for a premium. At first you think that this is a boon to the seller. But the manufacturer can turn around and demand a premium. So what happens is, the manufacture gets to pull forward the secondary sale. If a use car sells for a $2000 premium on the used market, the manufacturer can probably charge $2000 more. And he gets to book that today, not five years from now when the first buy sells it.
There is a dismal reverse of this, if your product goes bad like yesterdays fish, the customer is going to demand and get a discount.
This interacts with the cost value curve for given products, meaning after a while you're just throwing money away trying to make the product 'better'. Similarly, not spending enough money results in an way crappier product than the cost of materials and labor would suggest.
The upshot is car brands like Toyota are on the premium side of the curve and it's not too hard for them to stay there. Chrysler is on the other side of the curve and is economically trapped.
The strategy, as originally articulated, meant companies should use marketing to move customers to new models for status/styling reasons. It worked, too, in the car industry (which was the subject). For years the Mad Men types were able to convince people to buy a new car every two years, long before the old one was worn out.
Artificially shortening the lifespan of a product isn't profitable because of the hit the manufacturer takes to its reputation.
Isn't this exactly what Apple does with its chargers all the time? They change them in the slightest manner in newer generations, so the older generation charger doesn't work with it. I don't think there is an actual legitimate reason to do this - such as improved design or functionality. It doesn't seem to hurt Apple at all though, their hardware is still top notch and above and beyond its competitors.
Works well for nVidia. Speculations that it's newer drivers destroying older cards' performance seemingly cannot be quelled.
You can get away with that if you can still create a superior product than your sole competitor and can even get away with deliberately lying to customers (See 3.5 GB of good memory instead of 4 GB on GTX970)
- let's fire the engineering staff to improve the profit figures
- let's slowly fill up content channels with so much advertising, consumers can't read/watch/listen to the media they're trying to access
- let's sell subscription access with a promise of no ads, then slowly introduce ads until the subscription payers are also earning significant money per ad
- let's reduce the quality of our product so we can improve the profit percentage
- if cars only last 5 years, consumers will have to buy new ones! (planned obsolescence)
- let's see how much we can carve out of this shrinking pie
- etc.
These kind of harebrained schemes seem so obviously stupid from the outside, but they keep showing up over and over again. It's like there's a population of con-artists who've managed to get into positions of influence in lots of companies, and will pitch and sell these ideas and make them happen, then everybody is aghast when the company tanks shortly after...meanwhile the "proven idea guy" goes on to another company and shows "improved profitability by 21% and revenue by $3mil/quarter blah blah" and slithers in to another decision making position where this happens again.