That's really the point: An unsophisticated investor should go with index funds over the alternatives. To beat the market regularly, you need non-public information or insight, and the market is large enough that having said insight consistently is something limited to the highly connected.
Your argument against index funds, from a market perspective, is really more about putting all that money in large cap indices. Taking index funds to their conclusion, the ideal situation would be to use broader indices. Startups will still have to deal with venture capitalists, but that's for good reason: High risk, high reward investments aren't exactly what your typical index fund investor is interested in.
I'm not really against index funds per se, I actually think they are a great way to invest if you identify a trend in a particular sector. And truthfully, I'm far from a trained financial expert, I'm just some dumb hacker that is rubbed the wrong way by the type of advice I outlined in my above comment.
Most retirement accounts also don't allow individual stock purchases (at least mine doesn't), so the options are fairly limited for most people.
Imagine I start a company and I get my friends to buy up the shares of it on the stock market. Now imagine the market cap is $10m the day before it joins the Russell 5000. The next day a seperate company goes bankrupt and my company is now 1/100000 of the Russell 5000, which means that ETFs that track that index are now buying roughly 20% of my stock, which raises the price to $15m. Next my friends can slowly sell out for the amount that they pumped, but they will never trigger a mass sell off, because I always had a controlling stake from the beginning.
Your big swings in share price are still going to be driven by HFT algo traders, activist investors, hedge funds, etc.
I do agree that companies in the S&P 500 have an oversized advantage in raising capital, but if you remove index funds from the picture, I think the mere existence of the index would have a similar effect (this could be researched historically, but I don't have the time/interest to do so). On the flip side, any stock in the S&P is going to have limited arbitrage opportunity due to the level of liquidity they get from index fund rebalancing, etc.; so algo traders looking at specific plays may want to find an asset with lower liquidity and fewer eyes watching it. As with anything in finance, there is a play available on both sides of the field and they tend to balance each other out.
HFT affect and take advantage of minor price swings[2], and their arbitrage is based on this. Long-term investments are the primary driver of (hence) long-term price movements. After all, HFT, by definition, have no long term interests in issues, so they are (usually) equally weighted in either (long or short) direction, thus cancelling their long-term effects out, even in a situation where there are no long-term investors.
1. This pertains your comment regarding HFT. Activist investors, which you also mentioned, are just long-term investors with a marketing strategy (put your money into something and then go tell everyone), and in some cases a lobbying strategy (e.g., Bill Ackman's notable short of HLF), and they have no place being compared with HFT.
2. It is true that, sometimes, minor price swings can cause a crossing of a tipping point (e.g., below a prior price support level, etc.), but even in these cases the long-term price will adjust for these swings based on intrinsic value.
http://www.bloombergview.com/articles/2015-07-07/can-you-rea...
Essentially, if the "front-runners" (not really a correct term, since nothing illegal is going on) weren't doing this, then the index funds would have to pay a huge premium to buy large amounts of stock on extremely short notice. The "front-runners" are actually reducing the index fund's overhead costs (and, yes, being compensated by the market for doing it). They certainly aren't cheating the index fund investors out of anything, because their investments will track the market, regardless.
I know for sure though that there are fast-money guys who obsess daily about weighting momentum and turning points and they do well quite consistently.
These are exactly the things that you generally minimize by buying an ETF (although obviously everything is in the same asset class by definition).
Mutual funds have their place (large, pooled plans like 401ks where there's enough money involved that fees can be negotiated come to mind); but they're probably not the best option for an individual investor. I always recommend newbie investors put most of their equity holdings in an S&P ETF for this reason; the returns on a mutual fund may be slightly higher in good years, but they'll almost always be worse in bad years.
My money (as a student that's not much) is invested in a fund that tracks the MSCI All Country World Index, which was the most diversified Index fund I could find.
I wouldn't call it a free lunch though. Very much the opposite. You're investing in the global market portfolio in order to avoid a potentially costly lunch (i.e. fees, trading costs, not keeping up with the market return, etc... I've stretched this analogy too far, I know)
With respect to US equities, the S&P 500 and the Russell 4000 have performed fairly similarly over the past 5 years; which has performed better depends on the time period you look at. The NASDAQ has been a little bit higher overall but, of course, it also had a bigger drop if you look at a longer horizon.
The upside of diversification is that your return simply get closer to the mean as opposed to varying wildly as it would if invested in a single company's stock. You basically get increased predictability at no cost.
Also, by all accounts the US (and specifically New York) is the financial center of the world. This is why the IRS has such immense power -- they can come after anyone, anywhere because a global bank simply cannot operate without a good relationship with US regulators.
More seriously, London may well be the banking center of the world, but NYC is most definitely the financial center.
No, it's definitely not. OP thinks that the argument for index funds "ignores transaction costs" when that's pretty much the entire crux of the argument: if a mutual fund won't do much better than an index fund, you should go with an index fund as it has substantially less costs.
That's exactly why mutual funds underperform. Given the EMH, it makes more sense not to spend so much time on 'asset management' like that.
If you believe the S&P is overvalued because too many people index to it, you can invest in broader index funds and, if you're correct, yield a higher return.
The question is: how much are you willing to bet on it?
P.S. In case you are wondering, I have bet a significant amount of money on the EMH being correct.
Also I'm not saying that the phenomenon in my above comment is something would be an efficient use of money to trade. Personally I'd much rather look at out-of-favor sectors like commodities than try to pick up pennies in front of a steamroller by attempting to arbitrage the S&P 500 and S&P 501+ (as you put it)
In any case, thanks for your comment it does give some important food for thought
Read what he wrote: he stated that if you believe what you wrote, you can collect the spread by shorting side you claim underperforms, and going long on the side you claim outperforms.
If what you said is true, it's extraordinarily low-risk arbitrage.
If what you said is false, you're best served to say a bunch of bullshit that 's unrelated and then not make the trade.
Oh... I see... so you know you're full of shit.
But if it makes you feel good to swear at strangers on the internet, you can sign up for anonymous accounts and say I'm full of shit, and I'll be glad that I could help boost your self esteem.
You can buy far out of the money options to limit those.
A better strategy would be to underweight S&P500, and overweight the companies that are the closest to being included.
My first response was intended more as a rhetorical question asking whether the poster is actually willing to bet money on their idea. I never really meant to enter into a discussion on the pros and cons of various trading strategies.
My point is just that seeing if someone is putting money behind their opinions about the long term isn't really telling, because "markets can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent" and you may not know just how long term it'll be.
I'll assume that you meant the opposite of this quote (, that the stocks being short-sold beat expectations, and their fair value went up,) as what you said would benefit the short seller.
You are right that the stock could take longer than expected to reach its eventual (lower) value, but this is why you would bet on a large number of stocks (i.e. S&P500), to reduce the risk of a single or few adverse events cancelling out the strategy. In addition, by purchasing the S&P501-750, with the money from short-selling, you would be fairly well protected against market upside risk (as it is unlikely that the S&P500 will be the only stocks to do well in a bull market). You could also purchase options to reduce the risk of the short, but a (simpler) alternative would be to take out a put option on the S&P500, which the better believes will go down; this is obviously somewhere between the portfolio bias approach, and the short approach in terms of risk (and reward if you believe in EMH).
I have bet a significant amount
of money on the EMH being correct.
How do you do that?Or, rely on EMH and just buy the index.
How is your bet structured and can you explain your opinion?
In light of that, I find it very hard to believe that a huge valuation discontinuity right between company # 500 and company # 501 is likely to stand for long.
Which isn't to say that I necessarily think the EMH is correct, but I do think even if EMH is incorrect there's still plenty of reason to believe that any major market distortion created by something as obvious as the popularity of index funds is unlikely to stand for long.
The Quantum Fund (started by Jim Rogers and George Soros) had a 3365% return in the 70's, while the S&P 500 returned 47% (http://www.streetstories.com/James_Rogers.htm). Rogers also bet against Black Monday in 1987, wrote about the housing bubble and 2008 financial crisis as early as 2004 in his book "Hot Commodities", and called the collapse of the gold price in 2012 as well as the recent epic dollar rally.
"Why do you think the same five guys make it to the final table of the World Series of Poker EVERY YEAR? What, are they the luckiest guys in Las Vegas?" (http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0128442/quotes?item=qt0379517)
You could be right and my understanding of EMH might be off base... but if all information was "priced in" I can't understand how such individuals could consistently be "right" when the broader market is "wrong".
Go is a popular strategy game. Strategies that work should be encoded into computer algorithms and "priced out". Yet computers can't beat the best human Go players. Are the best human Go players simply lucky: they have no true strategy, and it's chance when they win?
(Hint: not every strategy is easily encoded into a deterministic algorithm. Expert human insight and judgment, that finicky beast, is not yet replicable by machines.)
He takes a large enough position to have considerable influence over how his companies are run. That kind of clout isn't available to most of us.
Berkshire Hathaway has not beaten the market since before 2008[1], marking 8 solid years of alpha=0.
2) Nobody -ever- has said that an 'unregulated free market produces a level playing field and a meritocracy'
The facts are that a regulated and controlled market with freedom of economic action produces the best outcomes for a population as a whole, when measured in life expectancy, social mobility and and even environmental cleanliness. Every other system that has been tried produces far worse outcomes across all these measures.
There's a persistent adolescent thought pattern running these days which says something like 'free market? Huh? Where's my lamborghini? I got nuthin' but student debt and no job'
This kind of thinking should be avoided in order to make progress on the topic.
It seems like with a few, inexpensive tweaks, it wouldn't be too difficult to beat the index.
The numbers are even worse if it's in a taxable account. That means you need to beat both the management fee and the taxes because you'll end up paying taxes for all the turnover too.
The main differences between an index fund and active management is indexers reveal their portfolios and don't trade as much.
I know that companies don't necessarily benefit directly from an increasing stock price, but in reality it allows them to raise capital by issuing new shares with less dilution. Also it makes it costlier for smaller competitors to raise capital, crowding out competition. At the end of the day, the "antitrust" question is not about Apple v. Microsoft... it is moving more in the direction of "Apple & Microsoft" vs. anyone trying to claw and scrape their way into the game.