Re:Index Funds May Work a Little Too Well
by forgetsusername on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @08:57PM
(#10013994)
Nothing. In fact, some active managers invest in ETFs as part of their...ETFs.
Re:Index Funds May Work a Little Too Well
by gnopgnip on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @06:51PM
(#10013428)
The fees add up in the long term to reduce the overall returns.
Re:Index Funds May Work a Little Too Well
by pbreit on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @09:53PM
(#10014139)
Part of acting like an index fund would be keeping fees low.
Re:Index Funds May Work a Little Too Well
by adestefan on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @11:09PM
(#10014340)
Then just buy the index fund. I can buy an index fund that has fees of 0.2%. If the managed fund has fees of 1.2% that means it needs to beat the index by at least 1% to come out even. If you can beat an index by 1% while trying to replicate an index, then you're either a genius or cheating.
The numbers are even worse if it's in a taxable account. That means you need to beat both the management fee and the taxes because you'll end up paying taxes for all the turnover too.
Re:Index Funds May Work a Little Too Well
by pbreit on Thursday August 06, 2015 @02:32PM
(#10018416)
Well the idea is to beat the indexes on a net basis. The fees would be much lower (than 1.2%) because it would not be very active. It would be replicating the index (which lots of people can do fairly easily) but with a tweak or 2 like a slight change in weighting or trimming the 50 worst X or lopping off the 10 biggest caps. I've seen some back-testing on stuff like this that can get you that extra point or 2.
Re:Index Funds May Work a Little Too Well
by tobltobs on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @06:12PM
(#10013253)
Like only buy the ones whole will go up in price?
Re:Index Funds May Work a Little Too Well
by pbreit on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @09:56PM
(#10014142)
My guess is that if you back test a few simple filters that you could find a point or 2.
The main differences between an index fund and active management is indexers reveal their portfolios and don't trade as much.
It seems like with a few, inexpensive tweaks, it wouldn't be too difficult to beat the index.