I wouldn't call it a free lunch though. Very much the opposite. You're investing in the global market portfolio in order to avoid a potentially costly lunch (i.e. fees, trading costs, not keeping up with the market return, etc... I've stretched this analogy too far, I know)
With respect to US equities, the S&P 500 and the Russell 4000 have performed fairly similarly over the past 5 years; which has performed better depends on the time period you look at. The NASDAQ has been a little bit higher overall but, of course, it also had a bigger drop if you look at a longer horizon.
The upside of diversification is that your return simply get closer to the mean as opposed to varying wildly as it would if invested in a single company's stock. You basically get increased predictability at no cost.
Also, by all accounts the US (and specifically New York) is the financial center of the world. This is why the IRS has such immense power -- they can come after anyone, anywhere because a global bank simply cannot operate without a good relationship with US regulators.
My money (as a student that's not much) is invested in a fund that tracks the MSCI All Country World Index, which was the most diversified Index fund I could find.