News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The euro is a disaster even for the countries that do eve... by lispm on Monday July 20, 2015 @05:10AM (#9914810)
Lots of propaganda against the Euro. It's going on for a few years now. Especially it's coming from a country which recently caused a world-wide economic crisis.

Actually the Euro is doing a good job, given all these attacks.

Now we read daily about the problems of tiny Greece. Just 10 million people out of 334 million living in the Eurozone. A constant news stream about a tiny tiny problem.

Remember how Goldman Sachs tried to profit from Greece in the Eurozone both ways? Helping Greece to hide its debt, so that it can join the Eurozone and then betting that the outcome would be negative.

http://www.spiegel.de/international/europe/greek-debt-crisis...

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/greek-debt-cr...

Re:The euro is a disaster even for the countries that do eve... by adventured on Monday July 20, 2015 @06:00AM (#9914975)
The Eurozone has seen zero net economic growth for about 8 years, and has 11% unemployment (13% without Germany). GDP has just finally started to get back to where it was in 2007/2008.

Germany's GDP is where it was in 2008; France is where it was in 2007, with France having ~10.5% unemployment.

Finland has been in an eight year recession/stagnation combination, with zero growth. Their unemployment rate has gone from 7.5% three years ago, to 9.5% today. Their household income to debt ratio has doubled since 2000, to 120%.

Italy has seen three recessions in seven years, with an unemployment rate of 12%.

Greece has collapsed.

Spain has 23% unemployment, Portugal is 14% (and those aren't the U6 equivalent numbers, just the headline).

The Netherlands economy hasn't gotten any bigger since 2007, and they now have one of the highest household debt levels on earth, which will continue to crimp their economic growth prospects severely.

Ireland's household debt ratio is one of the five worst in the world. Their unemployment rate is nearly 10%, which is a six year low.

Austria, Estonia, Slovakia, Slovenia, Lithuania, Latvia have seen zero growth since 2007/2008.

Simultaneously most of the Eurozone countries have seen a significant expansion of household debt over 10 to 15 years, as they try to prop up their standard of living with debt.

The only bump the region has seen economically since 2007, has been via currency devaluation and debt monetization, which has chopped down the Eurozone standard of living by perhaps 20% in exchange for a brief burst of low growth.

I'm not sure by what basis one would judge that it's working well at all.

Re:The euro is a disaster even for the countries that do eve... by programLyrique on Monday July 20, 2015 @06:12AM (#9915011)
Is that because of the euro, or because the policies of austerities that were chosen at that time?

The problem with the euro is that it is considered as an economic issue, whereas it should be a political one (and it was when it was created, as the first step in an "ever tighter union"). If we European citizens want to keep the euro, we need to deepen the Union.

Re:The euro is a disaster even for the countries that do eve... by adventured on Monday July 20, 2015 @06:46AM (#9915118)
If they went with inflation instead of austerity, all you'd see accomplished is the nominal numbers would climb, while the real numbers would not. That's what we're seeing right now with the QE devaluation of the Euro; pretend growth via dropping the value of the Euro (if you have to drop your currency by 20% to get 2% growth, what you have is not growth).

Austerity and inflation accomplish the exact same outcome, the only difference between the two depends on how they're implemented, and the lies that the politicians get to spin to pretend one is better than the other (politicians in weak economies almost universally prefer inflation, because they can lie and show nominal growth, and tell their citizens that their wages and pensions aren't falling, when in fact they are in real terms).

Take Greece for example. They could exit the Euro and meet all of their domestic obligations - in a debased new currency, that wouldn't actually be meeting the obligations in real terms as the currency tumbled. They'd get to pretend everything was fine nominally.

Inflation instead of austerity is used to devalue the amount of debt held, which is a form of defaulting on creditors. It drops the standard of living, as it steals wealth from citizens by devaluing their real incomes and assets.

Re:The euro is a disaster even for the countries that do eve... by Sami_Lehtinen on Monday July 20, 2015 @07:41AM (#9915319)
"devalue the amount of debt held, which is a form of defaulting on creditors"

Which won't work well if the loans aren't nominated in your national currency. This is why currency loans are the real trap when devaluation hits.

Re:The euro is a disaster even for the countries that do eve... by lispm on Monday July 20, 2015 @06:46AM (#9915116)
> Germany's GDP is where it was in 2008;

GDP in 2014 3,852,556 million $, growth 1.6%, which is not bad, given that the population growth is negative.

GDP in 2008 3,764,675 million $

Balanced budget. Debt reduction. Record employment. Record exports. Record tax income.

Everybody picks the numbers he or she likes.

Re:The euro is a disaster even for the countries that do eve... by adventured on Monday July 20, 2015 @06:55AM (#9915147)
The 1.6% positive is actually negative if you account for even very low level inflation over those years. Also, the Euro just lost a ton of value due to QE, which will ultimately drop every Eurozone member's GDP by at least 20% in real terms. In dollar terms, Germany's economy has plunged since 2008 due to this effect.

It's the same effect the US suffered as US budget deficits hammered the dollar from 2001-2009 or so. If you look at any country's GDP priced in dollars, they all universally skyrocket at the exact same time, all courtesy of the devalued dollar (the US lost a lot of ground to the rest of the world over that time due to the dollar devaluation).

Population growth is not a requirement for GDP growth. It also doesn't always help, plenty of countries have historically shown vast population growth with mediocre economic growth.

Germany's population has hardly budged since 1970. Their economy has increased several fold in that time. Productivity / output gains are far more important than population gains.

Re:The euro is a disaster even for the countries that do eve... by lispm on Monday July 20, 2015 @07:03AM (#9915175)
> Population growth is not a requirement for GDP growth. It also doesn't always help, plenty of countries have historically shown vast population growth with mediocre economic growth.

In developed countries most GDP growth is linked to population growth. See the US. Not taking into account that the US has an artificial inflated GDP.

> Their economy has increased several fold in that time

Long ago, different situation.

Besides that, the limits of using the GDP as a useful number have long been shown. The Iraq war with its trillion dollar cost helped the GDP a lot...

Re:The euro is a disaster even for the countries that do eve... by misja111 on Monday July 20, 2015 @05:48AM (#9914935)
How is this propaganda? It seems to me that the article is just listing facts. These facts show a not very positive side of the Euro, but does that make the article propaganda?

Also, the article is not about Greece. It's about Finland and the Netherlands, and how they have been doing comparing to Iceland.

Re:The euro is a disaster even for the countries that do eve... by lispm on Monday July 20, 2015 @06:10AM (#9915003)
> It seems to me that the article is just listing facts.

How so? It starts with 'The euro might be worse for you than bankruptcy.'

This sentence is so vague that it does not make any sense at all. It 'might'? For 'you'? I live in the Eurozone, in Germany, and I fail to see how it is worse than 'bancruptcy.

How is growth related to `bancruptcy` of a tiny island?

`the results have still been a catastrophe` - low growth in the Netherlands is a catastrophe? Last I looked the Netherlands were a nice country, far form being a 'catastrophe'.

'Now, the normal way to make up for this would be to cut costs by devaluing your currency, except that Finland doesn't have a currency to devalue anymore.'

The 'devaluing' theory. Not again.

'since you have to fire people to convince them to take pay cuts.'

More theory. Look at Germany. Workers agreed to keep wages stable. Outcome: record low unemployment.

'Iceland' - Iceland has just 300k population on an island. Comparing it to the Netherlands, Greece or Germany is just wrong. Different size, difference situation, different banking system, ...

Re:The euro is a disaster even for the countries that do eve... by tonyedgecombe on Monday July 20, 2015 @05:59AM (#9914971)
It can still be propaganda whilst showing facts. I haven't read the article but pretty much everything I have read on the euro exaggerates some facts and ignores others in order to support the political leanings of the writer or their employer.
Re:The euro is a disaster even for the countries that do eve... by D_Alex on Monday July 20, 2015 @05:58AM (#9914969)
I wonder... "the banks" might not like the idea of the Euro, because a common currency eliminates the currency exchange business... how much does this affect their propaganda??
Re:The euro is a disaster even for the countries that do eve... by lispm on Monday July 20, 2015 @06:59AM (#9915163)
Just look what Europe would be without the Euro. We had that before. West Germany had the Deutsche Mark (DM). It was basically the anchor currency for most European countries. Germany changed it monetary politics? Everybody tried to follow. It was like the Euro, just with different currencies and a pact to keep the exchange rates stable. Main difference: the monetary policy was made by the German Bundesbank and not the ECB. Though both are in Frankfurt/Germany, the ECB is an European institution.
Re:The euro is a disaster even for the countries that do eve... by aliem on Monday July 20, 2015 @07:36AM (#9915294)
I don't see much of a difference. The only difference is the name and the very big constrains on the countries adhering to the union.

I would be for an union if the european countries were like the USA: very close to each other both in language and culture.