News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Donate to Chelsea Manning's Legal Defense by humanrebar on Thursday July 16, 2015 @07:20AM (#9896499)
> How can this be considered normal?

It's not acceptable, but nobody has any better ideas.

Re:Donate to Chelsea Manning's Legal Defense by sambeau on Thursday July 16, 2015 @07:50AM (#9896593)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legal_aid

A better idea is common throughout the world.

Re:Donate to Chelsea Manning's Legal Defense by roel_v on Thursday July 16, 2015 @09:47AM (#9897111)
Please show me one country where there is 'legal aid' to the tune of 200k where the legal case is basically 'yeah so I totally did what I was charged with, law is totally clear but I should still receive a lesser sentence because <political reason>'.

Look, I'm fine with people advocating through the judicial process, but all things considered, of all people who are 'disadvantaged' in their legal proceedings and should 'deserving' of receiving government-sponsored legal aid (because there already is legal aid in this case, to the tune of <however much this amount in OP says right now>), this case's (and defendant's) scorecard looks pretty weak.

Re:Donate to Chelsea Manning's Legal Defense by dragonwriter on Thursday July 16, 2015 @08:39AM (#9896790)
Legal aid (which the US has) does not fix the problem in all cases, though it mitigates it somewhat.
Re:Donate to Chelsea Manning's Legal Defense by olalonde on Thursday July 16, 2015 @08:18AM (#9896704)
That article says the US has legal aid...
Re:Donate to Chelsea Manning's Legal Defense by Coding_Cat on Thursday July 16, 2015 @07:41AM (#9896562)
Socialized legal defense? Government funded legal defense, with a private choice of the law firm to reduce pro-government biasses. Similar to how certain socialized healthcare systems work.

Of course, there are some glaring issues here, such as the fact that unfortunately there's a strong correlation between socio-economic status and the odds of you needing legal counsel... Something which also occurs in healthcare but to a much lesser degree I'm inclined to believe.

Re:Donate to Chelsea Manning's Legal Defense by Shivetya on Thursday July 16, 2015 @08:04AM (#9896646)
You are provided counsel when defending yourself if you cannot afford it. It is when you lose and do not accept a court's verdict. Even plead guilty to a good number of the charges and was given a sentence lower than requested by the prosecution.

there is a reason why non automatic appeals are not free, else those convicted could simply keep their cases open at cost to the tax payer when guilt had been properly assessed.

Re:Donate to Chelsea Manning's Legal Defense by dragonwriter on Thursday July 16, 2015 @11:15AM (#9897716)
> there is a reason why non automatic appeals are not free

Neither are automatic appeals, or this whole thread wouldn't be happening. The appeal here is automatic.

Re:Donate to Chelsea Manning's Legal Defense by JoshTriplett on Thursday July 16, 2015 @08:00AM (#9896624)
In the US, you're already entitled to an attorney for your defense. That doesn't necessarily mean you'll get a good attorney.
Re:Donate to Chelsea Manning's Legal Defense by bhickey on Thursday July 16, 2015 @08:13AM (#9896688)
Gideon v. Wainwright established that indigent defendants are entitled to free legal representation. There's no such right for non-indigent defendants.
Re:Donate to Chelsea Manning's Legal Defense by kefka on Thursday July 16, 2015 @08:44AM (#9896806)
Not even when the price of legal representation is above my means to pay?
Re:Donate to Chelsea Manning's Legal Defense by pc86 on Thursday July 16, 2015 @09:19AM (#9896949)
If you need an attorney and cannot afford one, one is appointed. If you can afford one, you can't really say "I'd rather not pay that."

In this context "afford" typically means you can still keep your home/apartment and go grocery shopping.

Re:Donate to Chelsea Manning's Legal Defense by gknoy on Thursday July 16, 2015 @12:01PM (#9898029)
Note that "Cannot pay" is often interpreted to mean "Has already mortgaged the house and liquidated all things", not "has an empty checking account".
Re:Donate to Chelsea Manning's Legal Defense by bhickey on Friday July 17, 2015 @08:06AM (#9902309)
States establish indigence standards. Generally if your income exceeds 200% the federal poverty line, you aren't entitled to a court appointed attorney. Even then, if you're above 125% the poverty line, you can be forced to pay for your court appointed attorney. You can claim financial hardship, but the court isn't obliged to accept your claims.
Re:Donate to Chelsea Manning's Legal Defense by DasIch on Thursday July 16, 2015 @08:12AM (#9896686)
That's why you should be able to chose the court appointed attorney within reason.
Re:Donate to Chelsea Manning's Legal Defense by JoshTriplett on Thursday July 16, 2015 @01:50PM (#9898758)
You'd need to pretty carefully define "within reason", though; it's not reasonable to select without regard to cost.
Re:Donate to Chelsea Manning's Legal Defense by DasIch on Thursday July 16, 2015 @08:07AM (#9896663)
That's not an issue at all, if the government just acts as a lender to whoever is going to lose.

That also has the added bonus of making people think twice about engaging people in civil suits and prevents people and bad prosecutors from using the legal system for blackmail.

Re:Donate to Chelsea Manning's Legal Defense by Coding_Cat on Thursday July 16, 2015 @09:03AM (#9896877)
Well, if you go with a "loser pays" system you run into the issue of false convictions and economic-disparity again.

If I were to barely break even at the end of each month, and was tried for a crime I didn't commit I might still consider pleading guilty because the actual punishment would be less than the results of the financial penalty incurred by defending yourself and losing. If I were rich enough to easily pay the fees should I lose, I would risk it.

Re:Donate to Chelsea Manning's Legal Defense by dragonwriter on Thursday July 16, 2015 @11:57AM (#9897986)
For criminal cases, that probably depends on the interest and repayment terms. If its means-contingent repayment without usurious interest, the incentive to plea guilty to avoid the cost of defense would be minimized, though the public expense would, correspondingly, be greater. OTOH, the expense would be going to assure that the guilty, and only the guilty, were punished and the government was less able to get away with punishing the poor-but-innocent to prevent a public image of dealing with problems while failing to actually get the guilty, so there is a public benefit (in addition to "protecting the rights of the accused") that comes from that public expense.
Re:Donate to Chelsea Manning's Legal Defense by DasIch on Thursday July 16, 2015 @09:55AM (#9897161)
That's certainly a problem but it's a problem that would impact society overall negatively. Therefore I think it would be reasonable to weaken the "loser pays" system slightly, so that a balance between actual punishment and financial penalty is reached that prevents the latter from becoming an incentive to plead guilty. This could simply be done by having the government pay in these cases.
Re:Donate to Chelsea Manning's Legal Defense by higherpurpose on Thursday July 16, 2015 @08:10AM (#9896676)
What's causing the prices to be so high? Is it the complexity of U.S. law? Would it help if you had 5 pages laws instead of 500 pages laws, or would that make things worse? (more room for loopholes) I'm inclined to believe simpler laws would help, though, because a lawyer wouldn't have to know tens of thousands of pages of laws by heart (or close to it), or at least wouldn't have to research tens of thousands of pages.

Would having to pay if you lose help, too? I imagine there would be fewer lawsuits then. I don't have any data to back it up, but it feels like the U.S. has the most lawsuits/capita. Other countries where you have to pay if you lose don't have that many.

Anyway, it definitely doesn't feel fair that you need hundreds of thousands of dollars for a good defense. That's why most people tend to take the plea deal even if they are not guilty of the charges they bring, or if they are "guilty" but only through some twisted interpretations of the law and the prosecutors, which could be invalidated in a Court, but they can't risk it (especially when the prosecutors tend to charge them with 10 different offenses and 30 years in prison for the least violent of crimes just to scare them into taking the 6 months in prison plea deal).

The U.S. prosecutors seem to be acting exactly like patent trolls - or the mafia: "We won't take you to Court if you just pay this small sum - or go to prison for this small amount of time."

Re:Donate to Chelsea Manning's Legal Defense by roel_v on Thursday July 16, 2015 @10:06AM (#9897247)
120k ~= 100 days of work for a reasonably skilled attorney who know about the (very niche) topic, including office costs (which in turn include the salary of the secretary, stamps etc). Or 150 days of work if it's split between a lawyer and some paralegals.

At this point one might object that lawyers make too much money, but then I'd like to say that most everybody on this site working for a big company, or working for their own, costs this much or charges this much (or should charge as much, if they're 'professionals' and not 'I can set up Wordpress'-style workers).

Also, let's say that there are no expenses, i.e. only lawyers who live close to wherever the cases are heard (no plane tickets, no hotels), that all proceeding are in the same location, that the defendant is held somewhere close as well, that everybody working the case drives cars that run on air etc.

So then we have ~ 6 months, for a single person with some part-time help to do the menial stuff, to research the case, prepare all briefs, do all trial prep work (I don't know anything about this case but let's say you want to call 3 character witnesses. That's a week right there just selecting them, convincing them to come, prepping them, filing the paperwork etc.); to do the PR; to work with other stakeholders; the actual proceedings (which might span several court sessions - motion for this and that, pre-trial hearing(s), the actual trial, etc. I think it's clear that a single person can't do all of this in 6 months.

It's just what things cost in the real world. But hey, it could have been worse, you could've gone to court in Europe - in which case you'd get to pay between 15 and 25% VAT on top of it (probably not in all European countries, before someone jumps on that).

Re:Donate to Chelsea Manning's Legal Defense by roel_v on Thursday July 16, 2015 @10:12AM (#9897293)
Well look at that after I hit 'reply', the top post is 'estimate cost for your apps'! It looks like one can buy a legal defense for a highly complex case with world-wide attention for the cost of 2 medium-sized iOS apps, with only 'basic' level of finish, and no more than some simple sign up and in-app purchase functionality!
Re:Donate to Chelsea Manning's Legal Defense by netheril96 on Thursday July 16, 2015 @08:17AM (#9896699)
From my limited understanding, the US has rather simple statutory laws. In other words, the legislature only promulgates 5 pages of law. But given that reality is complex, these laws cannot cover all the cases. So the judicial branch makes certain decisions themselves, and these decisions become binding to later and lower courts (a.k.a precedents). These precedent based laws are very complicated and amount to 500 pages.

So, I guess your idea won't work. Either the legislature thinks up front and publishes 500 pages, or the courts have to fill in the blanks between page 5 and page 500 themselves.

Re:Donate to Chelsea Manning's Legal Defense by JackFr on Thursday July 16, 2015 @10:38AM (#9897459)
It's not the pages of laws, the common law renders relevant the judgement in thousands of prior cases. In many cases what you're paying for is not rhetorical and theatrical flourish (to sway the jury), but the specialized knowledge and application of prior rulings (to sway the judge).
Re:Donate to Chelsea Manning's Legal Defense by dragonwriter on Thursday July 16, 2015 @08:42AM (#9896801)
What causes the prices to be high is supply and demand driven by a combination of wealth inequality and frequency of legal action. There are people with enough money, and enough at stake, to offer the best attorneys lots of money, therefore quality legal services are quite expensive.