Do they? I always saw them as an alternative to a traditional advisor which can be 1%+ of assets. Even Vanguard can be overwhelming for some people who have to make choices on allocation[1]. For someone who wants auto-rebalancing and a set it and forget it manager, .25% isn't all that much. Obviously if you want to manage the money yourself you can always open a TD account where most of the ETFs used by Wealthfront/Betterment can be purchased commission free. But then the user is left doing buys, rebalancing, etc...
[1] For a complete no-brainer solution open a Vanguard account and dump everything into one of their target funds. Some people want something between the target fund and managing their own though.
What's wrong with their Target Retirement 20?? funds if you don't want to choose your own allocation?
I inherited an actively managed Morgan Stanley portfolio which has fees around 2-3% annually. I initially looked at managing everything myself, but didn't want to have to worry about all the finer points of managing one's own account. I may be losing the additional half of a percent, but in my mind, I am gaining far more.
I work at a successful asset management fund, one that looks after Vanguard money. The vast majority of our staff's pension investments take exactly this strategy.
Yes, I realize they take fees (although I get a special deal for reasons despite having a smaller account). Yes, all things being equal, leaving my money in a Vanguard Target Fund would probably result in higher gains (heck, my 401k is still in a Vanguard Target Fund since it's set-and-forget).
But the Betterment UI makes putting in more money as simple as typing in a number and clicking two buttons -- so I feel compelled to save more ($50 here, $100 there). And that, to me, is worth the 0.15% fee that they charge.
So I guess they just compete purely for growth and that's it - like the commercials for popular drugs on TV, it's an industry 99% about advertising?
SV tech + extremely risk averse, mature, competitive space = doesn't seem to be a good fit.
There seems to be a strong belief in Silicon Valley that software is going to eat the fat margins in financial services and that there's all this potential for disruption.
The problem is that software's been eating financial services for the past 30 years and the fat margins aren't always as fat as they seem once you factor in things like compliance costs (or the demand curve is far steeper than you expect it to be).
A lot of that margin goes to the front line troops (whatever you want to call them-- brokers, advisers, planners, etc.) These are and have traditionally been charismatic people who were relatively high touch. If you think of them as providing a service to customers than they look like a massive cost center and the businesses that employ them ripe for disruption. But if you look at them as a sales force the picture becomes much clearer. Morgan Stanley wealth management has Bob who plays pickup basketball on the weekend with a bunch of doctors. What does Wealthfront have -- an ad on Yahoo finance?
My guess is that at some point these companies will pivot to trying to be the backend to a bunch of independents or small shops out there hitting the pavement. The customers will still end up with the 1-2% wrap, the robo-advisers will still end up with their .25% cut, but at least the customers won't be being put in high fee actively managed funds. So they'll be some improvement over the status quo.
I'm pretty sure the cost per conversion for your ad on Yahoo Finance is going to be a lot cheaper than Bob's 20k.
It is already happening. See: Betterment Institutional, Schwab Institutional Intelligent Portfolios, and Motif Advisor
>But again and again, Wealthfront tries without blinking to draw a straight line between tax alpha and cold hard cash. For example, they offer a chart titled “After-tax Price Return of VTI vs. Direct Indexing” that appears to show that if you had merely flipped on Direct Indexing in 2000, you would have earned ~2% compared to losing 9% with Vanguard’s ancient index fund technology! They appear to reach these numbers simply by adding the maximum possible tax alpha to VTI’s return.
What Wealthfront did not talk about is - with S&P500 component stocks changing, so will the portfolio. It would need to rebalanced and constituted causing brokerage and other charges. While in hindsight it looks great, the actual trades during live environment could have been different.
Even if they took 0.25% from the $1b they've got under management and they took 0.25% across all of it (which they don't), that's $2.5m. At $10b under management, they're making $25m - not exactly blowing the roof off from a VC point of view.
Now, the argument they make is "we will sell them other products and services" - but that, to me, is wishful thinking. Especially with the big boys like Vanguard and Schwab coming in in a big way.
I'd much rather not have 30%+ of my life savings wiped out in a single recession with the rest of the market.
In my humble opinion, thoroughly backtested trading algorithms based on hard statistics is the only rational way to participate in the market. The market is fundamentally an irrational entity, and investors should be looking for ways to systematically protect themselves from the market's irrational mood swings.
Check out Quantopian:
https://www.quantopian.com/home
Even a trivial moving average crossover algorithm like the one I currently have deployed can give you surprisingly robust protection against severe downswings, and outperform the overall market significantly over the long term despite the small losses caused by false positives.
You do realize those two statements contradict each other?
During a recession event the 30% loss isn't real until you close your position, with trading algorithms the time to hold is so low that any losses are very quickly realized.
Your algorithm can predict the past.
Congratulations.
Or buy annuities, setup a bond ladder, or hold dividend stocks, but these have their own, related issues.
Early in the accumulation phase, however, I completely agree with you -- you're making the central argument for a long-term buy-and-hold strategy.
I recommend reading "The Evaluation and Optimization of Trading Strategies" by Robert Pardo.
Really surprising how so few amateur traders understand this fundamental principal. Scientists too.
That's a truism. I could say the same thing about algorithmic trading.
The fact of the matter is that the median hedge fund manager has negative alpha. It is extremely difficult to pick winners via any strategy. In fact, it's so difficult that for people who can do it, the resulting lifestyle and compensation is so great that the asset management shops that they work out have almost zero attrition.
Moreover, the whole point of passive investment is that the odds of that kind of a market-wide crash affecting your money over a 30-year timespan are infinitesimal. If the market actually were to devolve like that, nobody would make money in the market, regardless of strategy.
> Investors should be looking for ways to systematically protect themselves from the market's irrational mood swings.
Yes, it's called diversification.
I won't harp on the backtesting point, but what I will say is this: I'm sure that you understand the risk-reward tradeoff. It would be impossible to participate in any sort of finance and not know this concept. Quite frankly, the probability of 30%+ of your life savings being wiped out in an index fund is unbelievably low. You eat some return at the expense of lower volatility, but we're talking about a 401(k) here. We want that kind of expected stability.
The crash of 69 : 36%
The crash of 73: 48%
The crash of 87: 33%
The dotcom crash 2000: 50%
Housing Bubble 2007: 56%
[ source : http://traderhq.com/illustrated-history-every-s-p-500-bear-m... ]
The odds that at some point a portfolio of S&P 500 stocks will be 30% off a recent high is actually very high.
Wars. Panics. Depressions. Plagues. Recessions. Revolutions.
They still happen.
I repeat, if the market were bad enough that these crashes actually wiped out your account over a 30 year period, nobody would make money in the market at all. Index funds are a low-risk, low-return investment with low management fees. They're a much better investment choice for a retirement account than algorithmically trading that money. And if you were good enough at algo trading to make solid returns over time, you might as well quit your day job and open a hedge fund or asset management shop.
I guess what I mean is, for an "index fund", crashes don't seem to be... permanent?
Perhaps that's small comfort for someone who's set to retire the month after one of these 30% crashes, but I guess that's what the whole "invest more conservatively as you get older" thing is supposed to help with?
The big index and mutual fund companies offer different allocations between stocks and bonds. You might start out with 80% of your account in an index fund (or other diversified basket of stocks) and 20% in a hedged basket of investment-grade, low-risk bonds. This percentage allocation would change over time as you got closer to retirement.
You're not going to get insanely rich off of this, but it is a decent replacement for the fact that savings account interest rates are effectively 0% these days.
As you know, backtested results with carefully tuned magic numbers can potentially mean nothing.
joking aside, i've played with quantopian way back, and think its a fun/cool concept
It is, on the other hand, entirely possible for an average investor to learn basic technical analysis concepts and apply them visually to charts. At a minimum, for instance, if you can draw a trend line on a price chart and identify when price breaks important trend lines, you can easily avoid losses from major declines without having to write a single line of code or spend more than 5-10 minutes a day checking on your portfolio.
A decent book in this vein is The Visual Investor[1].
[1] http://www.amazon.com/The-Visual-Investor-Market-Trends/dp/0...
Long-term value investing performs best, low cost index funds perform well, Wealthfront will underperform due to fees, and technical analysis will turn even a billionaire into a millionaire.
Instead of creating a straw man argument, let's discuss something simple: trend lines. And let's discuss the most fundamental truth about trend lines: it is absolutely impossible for the current trend to reverse without key trend lines being broken.
Don't take my word for it. Pull up a chart of the S&P 500. The bull market that ended in late 2007 was easily identified by the breaking of long-term trend lines. And the bear market that ended in 2009 was easily identified by the breaking of trend lines as well. Just by use of trend lines alone (and no other technical indicators) you could have identified key turning points in the market.
How you act upon this information, if at all, is your choice. But that has nothing to do with technical analysis. That's investment/trading strategy.
Trends are broken in periods surrounding major market corrections, indeed. How many false positives are there in between, in which you're turning over your portfolio for no reason?
Depending on where you are in a trend, the breaking of a short-term trend line, for instance, could set up an opportunity to add to an existing position when the trend resumes.
Also, forgetusername's point on false positives remains critical. Breaking trend lines is only a useful if it's right most of the time.
My advice to anyone who wants to be an enterprising investor (i.e. put more time into investing and try to achieve higher returns) is to read Ben Graham's The Intelligent Investor. Instead of trading based on the emotions in the market, invest by choosing great companies that are bargains.
As for false positives, nobody reasonable will tell you that they don't exist. But again, there's a difference between short, intermediate and long-term trend lines. Even under the most unfavorable scenarios, anybody with a modicum of knowledge of trend lines would have been out of the market before the 2008 crash and back in the market by early 2010 because major trend lines were broken. Incidentally, I was one of those people.
As for your advice: there's nothing wrong with fundamental analysis. Although many people fail to make money using it (just like technical analysis), it's worth noting that quite a few savvy professionals use fundamental and technical analysis together.
Support: a price which a significant number of market players have decided is probably the least amount the stock could be worth. That is, if the price drops to that point, they will buy. They might be wrong, but it will require an even larger number of people who think the stock is definitely worth less to make them wrong.
Resistance: the flip side of support: a price at which a significant number of market players will sell.
Momentum: the tendency of price to continue in the direction that it's going until it encounters support or resistance. Many traders attempt to profit from the short-term price swings caused by momentum. By doing so, they tend to cause the price to continue to go in that direction.
Trending: what happens when changes in the economy are reflected in the prices of stocks. Such changes don't happen instantaneously; they take time.
Momentum and trending are obviously similar, but I distinguish them in this way: momentum is mostly caused by the flow of information within the markets; trending is caused by changes in the fundamentals.
If you understand these concepts, you can see everything a long-term investor needs to see when looking at a chart.
one of my favorite quotes:
"Here it is: If you open a retirement account, and you invest some of your paycheck each month into a Vanguard Target Retirement Fund, and you just…leave it…you just leave it right there until retirement…
…you don’t do anything when the folks on CNBC announce that the sky is falling; you don’t do anything when Cousin Eddy calls from a secure underground bunker in the badlands and says that the fed is printing money and it’s time to liquidate and ammo up; you don’t think it’s a sign that your parrot said “fuhgeddaboutit” but you thought she said “get a nugget” and surely that must mean a gold nugget? and you looked online and noticed that the price of shiny yellow metal was crashing and wait your parrot is also yellow and I’ll be damned if that isn’t a sign to buy…
… no, if you just leave it there to compound over decades…"