I repeat, if the market were bad enough that these crashes actually wiped out your account over a 30 year period, nobody would make money in the market at all. Index funds are a low-risk, low-return investment with low management fees. They're a much better investment choice for a retirement account than algorithmically trading that money. And if you were good enough at algo trading to make solid returns over time, you might as well quit your day job and open a hedge fund or asset management shop.
I guess what I mean is, for an "index fund", crashes don't seem to be... permanent?
Perhaps that's small comfort for someone who's set to retire the month after one of these 30% crashes, but I guess that's what the whole "invest more conservatively as you get older" thing is supposed to help with?
The big index and mutual fund companies offer different allocations between stocks and bonds. You might start out with 80% of your account in an index fund (or other diversified basket of stocks) and 20% in a hedged basket of investment-grade, low-risk bonds. This percentage allocation would change over time as you got closer to retirement.
You're not going to get insanely rich off of this, but it is a decent replacement for the fact that savings account interest rates are effectively 0% these days.
The crash of 69 : 36%
The crash of 73: 48%
The crash of 87: 33%
The dotcom crash 2000: 50%
Housing Bubble 2007: 56%
[ source : http://traderhq.com/illustrated-history-every-s-p-500-bear-m... ]
The odds that at some point a portfolio of S&P 500 stocks will be 30% off a recent high is actually very high.
Wars. Panics. Depressions. Plagues. Recessions. Revolutions.
They still happen.