News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by tomp on Friday July 03, 2015 @08:39AM (#9825144)
pg is a smart man, but this argument is ridiculously stupid.

"Crime is so obviously a good thing that you can measure how corrupt cities are by how hard they try to suppress it."

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by viscanti on Friday July 03, 2015 @08:48AM (#9825200)
Creating laws doesn't make something moral/normative. The fact that a law exists and whether it's "good" are two different things. Breaking a "bad" law might be a crime, but I'm not convinced that it's "bad".

This is a country that is doing everything it can to create laws which increase the cost of transportation and reduce the ability to get a ride. It's a law that makes things less safe (there aren't enough taxis to properly service late night bars so people are forced to drive drunk - people die because of the law to protect a monopoly). We can look at the law and the reason for the law and ask if the price for protecting a government granted monopoly is worth the price (lives and money from increased transportation costs) paid.

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by gambiting on Friday July 03, 2015 @08:51AM (#9825218)
"so people are forced to drive drunk - people die because of the law to protect a monopoly"

Jesus christ this is literally the stupidest thing I have heard all day, and I have been following what is going on reddit since early morning.

If anyone ever says they were "forced to drunk drive" by anything they deserve to be slapped and have their licence taken away, forever. If you go drinking, you don't bring your car with you!!!!!!

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by jarek on Friday July 03, 2015 @08:57AM (#9825250)
> This is a country that is doing everything it can to create laws which increase the cost of transportation and reduce the ability to get a ride.

Which country? The country Blablacar came out of?

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by mmarx on Friday July 03, 2015 @09:26AM (#9825425)
> people die because of the law to protect a monopoly

More like people die because they (or, quite possibly other people) choose to break the law against drunk driving?

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by dllthomas on Friday July 03, 2015 @01:04PM (#9826691)
More like people die because they (or, quite possibly other people) choose to drive drunk.

The presence of the law should help deter them from making that choice. But that doesn't establish that laws should always be followed or shouldn't be changed - it just supports the case that that law should be followed and should not be changed, which no one was arguing against.

Other things also help decrease drunk driving. Healthy social norms can have a big impact. Convenient alternatives also has a big impact. What we're discussing here is a particular, especially convenient alternative.

It is wrong to excuse people who put others' lives at risk because doing otherwise is inconvenient. But it is incorrect not to expect that some people will do so, and account for that as a part of the impact of laws.

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by phatfish on Friday July 03, 2015 @09:03AM (#9825284)
Im no fan of Uber and their tactics, and this pg guy doesn't sound very smart from that comment to me -- but there is a distinction to be made between the legal and illegal operations Uber run.

Using a mobile phone as an automated dispatcher for cabs is a fine idea, and improves the experience for the customer.

Breaking local laws relating to insurance, background checks, surge pricing, provisions for disabled passengers etc. is NOT fine.

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by mckoss on Friday July 03, 2015 @09:10AM (#9825344)
BTW, pg is Paul Graham, founder of y combinator and creator of hacker news. So, "this guy" is generally very well respected by the the users of this site.
Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by yardie on Friday July 03, 2015 @09:52AM (#9825563)
Yes he is the grand poobah and founder of YC. But in this instance, his tweet is very much wrong.
Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by throwaway12309 on Friday July 03, 2015 @10:41AM (#9825813)
yeah, but when he says something so stupid he should be called on it, just because it is pg doesn't mean he holds the absolute truth
Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by phatfish on Friday July 03, 2015 @10:38AM (#9825802)
Fair enough, he has a lot of karma to burn then ;)