News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by arturhoo on Friday July 03, 2015 @08:32AM (#9825107)
pg nailed it yesterday on Twitter: "Uber is so obviously a good thing that you can measure how corrupt cities are by how hard they try to suppress it." https://twitter.com/paulg/status/222462460978937856

Edit: actually I meant this tweet from yesterday: https://twitter.com/paulg/status/616683543830339584 which had the other one embbeded

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by aidanf on Friday July 03, 2015 @08:44AM (#9825168)
This is nonsense. Taxi services are regulated for good reason. Many cities and countries have well-regulated transparent taxi industries.

Uber often seems to seek to bypass that regulation because, eh, disruption. I would expect any city to do something when faced with a private corporation attempting to flout their laws for profit. Doing so is in no way correlated with any measure of how corrupt that city is.

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by arturhoo on Friday July 03, 2015 @09:37AM (#9825494)
Well, as a brazilian, his statement sounded very true to me. I'll try no to generalize as much as he did and tell the story from our perspective.

Taxi drivers and politicians in Brazil are fighting Uber because they are losing slices of a pie that is deeply corrupted. A single person (most of them are politicians or friends with city councilmen) hold hundreds of Taxi Plates and "rent" them to ordinary drivers that obviously can't have their own plates because they're not fairly distributed and even if they were, would be prohibitively expensive. So these ordinary drivers start their working days owing R$200 to the plate holders, resulting in a service that has the customer safety, comfort, etc as the last priority.

We do have laws and regulations but it'd be naive to think they benefit the passengers. One of them requires the cars to be inspected every six months, which would be a nice thing, except these inspections are only another way for the abovementioned politicians/government have more money to be diverted - some cars are ridiculously filthy and poor maintained.

When Uber arrived last year it was indeed a disruption: polite drivers, well maintained cars, fair service. The so called inspections happen in real time through in app reviews by the people who are supposed to be protected after all - the passengers.

As the only city councillor to vote in favor of Uber in Sao Paulo well said: "it was a massacre", corruption is so evidently high that not even a discussion took place about how the things Uber does right could be incorporated into the existing Taxi ecosystem. And pg's statement fits right in: politicians fought so ferociously to ban Uber (faster than many other agendas that are crucial to Brazil) that it becomes a picture of how corrupt they are.

To complete, I think that services that try to disrupt existing services are good to take us to the opposite side of a sine wave - they come to draw our attention of to things we were probably overlooking. Honest cities and politicians will take the opportunity to bring the good things into discussion, corrupt ones will ferociously try to suppress it.

Although a disproportional comparison, I remember when I visited one of the post offices in my city as a kindergarten student in the late 90s - the manager that was taking us through the guided visit was very anxious of how emails were driving the telegram usage down.

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by slowmotiony on Friday July 03, 2015 @09:36AM (#9825479)
In warsaw, about 90% percent of the drivers will try to fuck you. Be it by refusing to give you a receipt, taking longer ways, asking a price taken out of their arses or just straight up lying to you to get your money, especially if you're a foreigner.

Most of them drive like complete idiots and break numerous rules even during a simple 10 minute ride.

So my question is what does taxi regulations do exactly? Because it seems like it's not working.

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by bobcostas55 on Friday July 03, 2015 @09:46AM (#9825538)
>Taxi services are regulated for good reason.

You can't just leave us hanging, what reason is it? Why does the taxi driver cartel deserve economic rents at the expense of everyone else?

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by prostoalex on Saturday July 04, 2015 @01:24AM (#9829333)
If you were to design a taxi system from scratch you'd probably want to have

* increased levels of insurance to cover passengers and their belongings

* rigid maintenance requirements on the vehicles that do get more wear & tear through commercial usage

* background checks on drivers, not as much as molester/criminal type that the press likes to sensationalize, but just driving record - obviously someone who keeps running red lights, gets speeding tickets, gets into road rage and runs over people should spend less time on the road, not more

* once you've figured those requirements out, a third party needs to enforce the rules and be able to shut off the offending drivers

Most likely candidate for a third party is a government agency. Most likely process for approving/forbidding someone from entering the field of commercial transportation is licensing.

If there are better ideas that would lead to increase in public safety and decrease in bad guys abusing the system just to turn a quick buck, those are certainly worth discussing.

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by mckoss on Friday July 03, 2015 @09:04AM (#9825291)
Taxi services are primarily regulated at the behest of the existing taxi companies to keep out competition. The public interest of the regulation is just a cover story.

We just returned from Paris, and I can tell you that people in Paris are not happy with cab drivers (overpriced, and often refuse riders based on too many people, too many bags, or too short of a trip).

This smells like a campaign of a greedy and corrupt union hiding behind a law to protect its poorly performing industry.

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by mhw on Friday July 03, 2015 @09:27AM (#9825429)
> The public interest of the regulation is just a cover story.

It's a single data point, but crimes committed by the drivers of unlicensed cabs in London are a big enough problem for there to be awareness campaigns like this one: <https://tfl.gov.uk/campaign/be-cabwise>. Example of the kind of criminal activity that regulation is trying to deter: <http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-22998900>.

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by ousta on Friday July 03, 2015 @08:55AM (#9825241)
taxis services are regulated for good reason yes. but it doesn't mean the regulation is efficient. when you pay for a service that provides you exactly the same experience than a discounted service like Uber then there is no sense for this service.

Taxi drivers in france is expensive and drivers are uneducated, rude, unpolite. Compare this to drivers in england and japan where they respect the customer and provide a good service and then you will understand why uber disrupting french taxis. because the regulation is only based about how much money you need to put to buy a license while the regulation should be about having a proper formation and learn about customer service.

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by jacalata on Friday July 03, 2015 @08:58AM (#9825253)
So if Uber is disrupting French taxis because the drivers are rude and English taxi drivers are polite then why is Uber catching on in England too?
Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by ousta on Friday July 03, 2015 @09:33AM (#9825461)
Actually i have limited experience in UK but better on Japan where i lived long. Still I do not think it is the same population in UK using taxis and ubers. I am almost certain that the people using Uber in UK are people who almost never used taxis in their life. I don't see why would someone would change from taxi to Uber in countries such as England or Japan. if you take a taxi that means you can afford it either you would take public transportation in 90% of the cases. Uber in UK is just a totally different service than Taxis. as long as taxi drivers are well trained professionals with a sense of providing quality service then they don't compete with Uber.

It is same with amazon and librarians. Librarian assume they just have to sell books. Since amazon they have to provide a service , help the customer , advise him, instruct him, guide him. Those things amazon can't do and those things will save the librarians. it is the same for cab drivers.

Uber is a good for us customers. Obviously it won't be a good thing when they will be on a monopoly situation where they will increase prices after having destroyed concurrents but who cares?

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by goldfeld on Friday July 03, 2015 @08:47AM (#9825189)
"Uber is so obviously a good thing (for the broken US system as well as for the US startup scene, the industry with which I line my pockets)". His statement reads like a joke to me, a parody of himself.

Uber might offer a better service to people today, but what's the long term (and the really long term) price of allowing this monopolizing corporation into your city? Do you sell out? In portuguese we say "barato sai caro", meaning cheap/easy options may turn out expensive in the long run.

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by JoeAltmaier on Friday July 03, 2015 @09:16AM (#9825388)
You could look at the data, cities where Uber operates, and decide for yourself. Its not necessary to speculate. Also, its not a monopoly - competition exists already. Get the city out of the business of selling access - let the free market provide.
Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by dllthomas on Friday July 03, 2015 @01:06PM (#9826699)
If it is not a monopoly, then it is necessary to speculate about what happens if it becomes one. That said, I think that's something we can address as (and if) it comes up.
Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by goldfeld on Friday July 03, 2015 @09:22AM (#9825409)
I don't like to let the "free market" (that is, big investor money) provide for a basic need such as transportation. See my other comment regarding "monopoly".
Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by JoeAltmaier on Friday July 03, 2015 @11:40AM (#9826152)
Pessimist. Again, look at cities where the free market provides transportation. No need to speculate.
Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by vasilipupkin on Friday July 03, 2015 @09:07AM (#9825324)
why would it be a monopolizing corporation? There are competitors such as Lyft and Singaporean GrabTaxi. The monopolizing corporation is actually the cab companies. Think about it!
Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by goldfeld on Friday July 03, 2015 @09:21AM (#9825403)
I think of it as being monopolizing by virtue of being a startup with network effect and economies of scale. It's a winner take all market, like Google and Facebook do monopolize most of the world's communication and browsing. Maybe it's not the best use of the word monopoly. Colonizing would be far better, but that reeks of american imperialism, oops.
Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by vasilipupkin on Friday July 03, 2015 @09:29AM (#9825443)
sorry, now you are just not making sense. I think to have these debates, we need to agree to think clearly about the problem. Colonizing? They are providing a service. Nobody is forcing anybody to use the service. There are three issues here

a) many ( not all ) of the regulations that make cabs scarce and expensive are unnecessary

b) it is not fair to people who paid for the licenses to allow a competitor to operate without licenses

c) Uber is good for consumers.

Somehow, a reasonable compromise must be found

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by goldfeld on Friday July 03, 2015 @09:37AM (#9825492)
Nobody is forcing anybody in the strict sense, yes. If you ignore the network effect, even more so. How can I connect with friends without Facebook when everyone else is on there (there or on instagram and whatsapp, also FB property). How can I not use Uber in the future if they root out and kill off taxis, and even public transportation is left wanting when everyone is just happy to use Uber? And just because everyone's happy to use it (it's cheaper even) doesn't mean it's good in the long run, which is my point.
Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by vasilipupkin on Friday July 03, 2015 @01:53PM (#9826941)
ok, but we don't really know for sure what is good in the long run. That would require perfect foresight about the long run. If it is cheaper and more convenient and people like it, then great ! in order to mitigate your concerns, society needs to remove barriers to competition not add more barriers
Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by srj on Friday July 03, 2015 @09:36AM (#9825486)
The existing taxi industry is a protected monopoly. In a hypothetical future where uber has displaced the competition any other company could spring up and take their business.
Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by goldfeld on Friday July 03, 2015 @09:41AM (#9825509)
Just like a retailer sprang up and took Amazon's lead in the ecommerce business, right? Right?

Some corporations become too big to fail, like Google or Facebook--they keep buying off other companies and buying laws too. America is a lobby nation. How can you honesly expect anyone else to displace the trillion-dollar company that Uber will eventually become? Unless you actually mean companies will spring up, present a threat, then get acquihired by Uber^. Money talks!

^ If you expect an enterpreneur to face Uber head-on despite multi-billion dollar offers on the one side and immense legal hindrance on the other, you expect a hero. We should expect a democratic society, not american heroes.

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by tomp on Friday July 03, 2015 @08:39AM (#9825144)
pg is a smart man, but this argument is ridiculously stupid.

"Crime is so obviously a good thing that you can measure how corrupt cities are by how hard they try to suppress it."

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by viscanti on Friday July 03, 2015 @08:48AM (#9825200)
Creating laws doesn't make something moral/normative. The fact that a law exists and whether it's "good" are two different things. Breaking a "bad" law might be a crime, but I'm not convinced that it's "bad".

This is a country that is doing everything it can to create laws which increase the cost of transportation and reduce the ability to get a ride. It's a law that makes things less safe (there aren't enough taxis to properly service late night bars so people are forced to drive drunk - people die because of the law to protect a monopoly). We can look at the law and the reason for the law and ask if the price for protecting a government granted monopoly is worth the price (lives and money from increased transportation costs) paid.

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by gambiting on Friday July 03, 2015 @08:51AM (#9825218)
"so people are forced to drive drunk - people die because of the law to protect a monopoly"

Jesus christ this is literally the stupidest thing I have heard all day, and I have been following what is going on reddit since early morning.

If anyone ever says they were "forced to drunk drive" by anything they deserve to be slapped and have their licence taken away, forever. If you go drinking, you don't bring your car with you!!!!!!

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by jarek on Friday July 03, 2015 @08:57AM (#9825250)
> This is a country that is doing everything it can to create laws which increase the cost of transportation and reduce the ability to get a ride.

Which country? The country Blablacar came out of?

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by mmarx on Friday July 03, 2015 @09:26AM (#9825425)
> people die because of the law to protect a monopoly

More like people die because they (or, quite possibly other people) choose to break the law against drunk driving?

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by dllthomas on Friday July 03, 2015 @01:04PM (#9826691)
More like people die because they (or, quite possibly other people) choose to drive drunk.

The presence of the law should help deter them from making that choice. But that doesn't establish that laws should always be followed or shouldn't be changed - it just supports the case that that law should be followed and should not be changed, which no one was arguing against.

Other things also help decrease drunk driving. Healthy social norms can have a big impact. Convenient alternatives also has a big impact. What we're discussing here is a particular, especially convenient alternative.

It is wrong to excuse people who put others' lives at risk because doing otherwise is inconvenient. But it is incorrect not to expect that some people will do so, and account for that as a part of the impact of laws.

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by phatfish on Friday July 03, 2015 @09:03AM (#9825284)
Im no fan of Uber and their tactics, and this pg guy doesn't sound very smart from that comment to me -- but there is a distinction to be made between the legal and illegal operations Uber run.

Using a mobile phone as an automated dispatcher for cabs is a fine idea, and improves the experience for the customer.

Breaking local laws relating to insurance, background checks, surge pricing, provisions for disabled passengers etc. is NOT fine.

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by mckoss on Friday July 03, 2015 @09:10AM (#9825344)
BTW, pg is Paul Graham, founder of y combinator and creator of hacker news. So, "this guy" is generally very well respected by the the users of this site.
Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by yardie on Friday July 03, 2015 @09:52AM (#9825563)
Yes he is the grand poobah and founder of YC. But in this instance, his tweet is very much wrong.
Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by throwaway12309 on Friday July 03, 2015 @10:41AM (#9825813)
yeah, but when he says something so stupid he should be called on it, just because it is pg doesn't mean he holds the absolute truth
Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by phatfish on Friday July 03, 2015 @10:38AM (#9825802)
Fair enough, he has a lot of karma to burn then ;)
Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by ianstallings on Friday July 03, 2015 @08:52AM (#9825224)
This is exactly why Twitter sucks for discussion. You couldn't possibly illuminate a viewpoint on any matter using it so you end up making broad statements that get trounced by reality. Particularly an issue with such nuances.
Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by vasilipupkin on Friday July 03, 2015 @09:06AM (#9825308)
It is obviously a good thing, but it is also unfair to a) pass a law that says you must buy a 100k license to be a cab driver and b) allow a company to operate which makes your 100k investment worthless.

True, this law is unnecessary, but it's not hard to see why taxi drivers who paid for their licenses fair and square are upset

At least in Chicago, Uber and cabs seem to coexist pretty well. The main difference is, cab drivers seem to have a bit more clue as to the layout of the city and more efficient at knowing directions etc

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by mrweasel on Friday July 03, 2015 @08:49AM (#9825207)
Uber has it's share of issues. Just because the alternative is just as bad or worse doesn't automatically make Uber good.

Not all laws are in place to mess with Uber or suppress competition, some of them are actually to the benefit of the public. Requiring insurance or having the driver registered as self-employed doesn't seem unreasonable.

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by vasilipupkin on Friday July 03, 2015 @09:10AM (#9825343)
why doesn't it seem unreasonable? I mean, why can't it be up to the person using the app to call that driver or not? The app has the person's name, their rating from other customers, etc. Why can't the individual consumer decide what to do with that information ?
Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by mmarx on Friday July 03, 2015 @09:24AM (#9825413)
>> Not all laws are in place to mess with Uber or suppress competition, some of them are actually to the benefit of the public. Requiring insurance or having the driver registered as self-employed doesn't seem unreasonable. > why doesn't it seem unreasonable? I mean, why can't it be up to the person using the app to call that driver or not?

How could it possibly be reasonable to leave it up to the person using the app to decide whether the driver requires insurance or not, when an accident may easily lead to a third party having claims against the driver?

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by vasilipupkin on Friday July 03, 2015 @01:51PM (#9826934)
muddling the issue. At least in Chicago, drivers are already required to have insurance. Why do they need to have special additional insurance if they are Uber drivers? But, again, in Chicago, the city and state worked this out with Uber and came to a compromise.
Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by mmarx on Friday July 03, 2015 @11:51PM (#9829109)
If insurance is required in any case, there's no choice left for the app user to make, so why should it be left to them? That said, I very much doubt that the required insurance covers comercial transportation of passengers (which uber certainly is), so that explains why they need “additional” insurance covering that.
Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by vasilipupkin on Saturday July 04, 2015 @10:33AM (#9830248)
as I said in other comments, insurance here is red herring. because the real difference in cost comes from requiring the license for hundreds of thousands of dollars and the city only issues a limited number of licenses
Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by mrweasel on Friday July 03, 2015 @09:41AM (#9825508)
I don't believe that you as the customer should be responsible for checking the drivers insurance, or if the car is in working order. I'm not qualified to do either of those things.

Similarly I would like people who accept my money for services to be well do the proper paper work for the tax authorities. If you're self-employed in any other business you need to register that, why should Uber drivers be excepted? I can accept Ubers argument that their drivers are "independent contractors", regardless of how stupid I believe it is, but then they should be registered as such.

I don't disagree that many of the rules around taxi services are obsolete or hinder competition, but I also don't condone Uber just breaking all rules using that argument. "Disruption" can't be an excuse to pick and choose which laws to follow. There's a pretty good business case to be made for breaking the speed limit as well (They could call it UberHyperDrive, for people in a rush), but you wouldn't accept that either.

Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by vasilipupkin on Friday July 03, 2015 @01:55PM (#9826954)
Insurance argument is a red herring because people who drive cars are already required to have insurance, irrespective of Uber. We are talking about some special form of insurance on top of that. Uber can actually either self insure drivers or get very very cheap insurance for them because they know who the good drivers are.
Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by pratyushag on Friday July 03, 2015 @09:12AM (#9825353)
Somebody should make a graph about this to agree or disagree with this hypothesis.
Re:Uber announces suspension of UberPOP in France by chinathrow on Friday July 03, 2015 @09:36AM (#9825478)
That tweet is from 2012.