News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by da_chicken on Monday June 22, 2015 @09:35AM (#9758151)
While I certainly agree that self-driving farm equipment is revolutionary, I'd argue that Google's technological advances are in the field of being able to understand how to drive on a road which marked for humans to drive on, and which is simultaneously in use by human drivers as well.

I'm sure that there are problems and issues which arise from navigating a field and manipulating whatever equipment you've got for whatever task you're working on that I'm just not fully appreciating. However, I really question if that task is anywhere near as complex as safely navigating traffic while obeying all the laws of the road when you can't even be sure of the state of the road you'll be travelling on.

It's just a totally different problem being solved. This is apples and oranges.

Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by kbenson on Monday June 22, 2015 @12:45PM (#9759529)
I agree. A farm is a type of factory, and thus has fairly controlled conditions compared to a public thoroughfare. Any number of solutions could work for a farm that would be untenable for self driving cars, such as marking the expected area with sensors to define the working area, outlining the area on a GPS map, running the equipment over the area one or more times to teach it, etc. None of these work as a general purpose solution to a self driving car, and they might not even be progenitors to the self driving technology we end up with.

A solution to a highly constrained version of a problem may not be applicable to the general purpose problem in any way.

Edit: mean to say "may not be applicable" in last sentence.

Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by markbnj on Monday June 22, 2015 @10:16AM (#9758443)
Yeah, agreed. The overlap technologies of position fixing and mechanical control have actually been solved for a long time now. The current interest in self-driving vehicles is based on advances in sensors and processing to detect environmental conditions and hazards on roadways and in places where people commonly drive cars.
Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by SomeStupidPoint on Monday June 22, 2015 @12:01PM (#9759218)
You don't think farm equipment has to navigate unexpected hazards or coordinate with other moving equipment or people?

I'll agree that roadways have much more to do with avoiding traffic, but I don't think that the restrictions on vehicle operation or avoiding hazards on the terrain or having to understand and plan according to layouts devised by and primarily for humans is substantially different between the two, but rather, a difference of parameters. (Farm equipment maintains a lower speed and for a different reason, but still has to monitor and obey rules about maximum speed under various conditions, for instance.)

I think you're underestimating the degree to which the two tasks are fundamentally the same.

Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by emcrazyone on Monday June 22, 2015 @01:39PM (#9759894)
"You don't think farm equipment has to navigate unexpected hazards or coordinate with other moving equipment or people?"

Nope, they don't need to worry about those things. Self driving cars and tractors adhere to ISO-25119 and within that, tractors adhere to agricultural performance level which doesn't have the same risk. Self driving tractors are required to have an operator in the cab and they are not allowed on public roadways with "auto guidance" engaged.

I work for Case New Holland - John Deere competitor.

Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by msandford on Monday June 22, 2015 @01:58PM (#9760037)
It would seem that at 10mph all you really need are some sensors looking forward that have the ability to provide enough warning that the vehicle can stop before it hits an obstruction. Kind of like the auto-brakes that some cars have.

That's a lot different than having a car which can at 70mph successfully swerve enough to avoid a wreck while still not swerving so far as to cause another wreck.

Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by jessaustin on Monday June 22, 2015 @02:55PM (#9760413)
I agree with the larger point that robotractors have an easier job, but I really wonder how close we are to a robocar "which can at 70mph successfully swerve enough to avoid a wreck while still not swerving so far as to cause another wreck."
Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by Tloewald on Monday June 22, 2015 @03:17PM (#9760574)
I think there was some discussion about the ethics of the software in google's cars because they would solve driving problems with a view to minimizing harm to all involved, not merely the car's occupants. So I think this kind of thing is very much in development, and indeed more sophisticated than that (e.g. The car might swerve into another vehicle to avoid hitting pedestrians).
Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by msandford on Monday June 22, 2015 @03:43PM (#9760705)
Ah, forgive me. I wasn't suggesting that such a robotic car exists already. More that successfully navigating such a situation on a freeway would be an acceptance test that I would like to insist on before entrusting my life to one, and would DEFINITELY insist upon prior to purchasing one.

Were I in need of a self-driving tractor given the much lower speeds and whatnot I might be much more willing to accept a fairly primitive autopilot rather than something truly self-driving. Freeing me from needing to constantly be on the alert to keep a combine from straying from the optimal path is far, far more important that something that'll drive itself from the barn to the diesel pump and then onwards to the field. Were I wealthy enough to afford so much land to where owning such a vehicle was necessary then either driving it myself or hiring someone else to handle that would be entirely reasonable.

Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by NeutronBoy on Monday June 22, 2015 @11:24PM (#9762433)
> but I really wonder how close we are to a robocar "which can at 70mph successfully swerve enough to avoid a wreck while still not swerving so far as to cause another wreck."

Automated cars can already do this far more reliably than your average driver.

Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by markbnj on Monday June 22, 2015 @12:32PM (#9759437)
>> You don't think farm equipment has to navigate unexpected hazards or coordinate with other moving equipment or people?

Coordinating with other moving equipment I did not address, because that is too broad a description. As far as hazard avoidance is concerned I don't know the state of the art for farm equipment, but I don't think they are as focused on fully autonomous operation, which has been the goal on the transportation side for some time now. In any event, there is obvious overlap in a number of areas, but I simply don't think the premise of the posted article holds up. Farm equipment is not the "real revolution" in autonomous transportation. It's merely one area in which some of the dependent technologies have already seen the light of day.

Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by apendleton on Monday June 22, 2015 @05:19PM (#9761276)
Even if the tractor has to be aware of such hazards, the degree is totally different. The tractor may need to identify that something unexpected has occurred, but it doesn't need to know anything about it other than that, most likely; it can likely deal with all unexpected occurrences by stopping and waiting for someone to come manually fix it. Self-driving cars need to make complex decisions about hazards, because stopping in the middle of a public street is probably not an acceptable behavior, it may not be practical given the speeds, etc. That means the car needs to know a lot about the hazard in order to figure out what to do about it (swerve? honk? alter speed?).
Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by jonlucc on Monday June 22, 2015 @09:43AM (#9758226)
I think you're correct. I can vividly remember a local news story from at least 15 years ago that talked about self-driving cars being just around the corner. All it would take is putting sensors in every roadway and having dedicated lanes for them. I was pretty young and excitable, and I could not figure out why we weren't putting those sensors in as roads were replaced around the city. Google requires none of that insane retrofitting, and is therefore much more likely to be useful.
Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by netcan on Monday June 22, 2015 @10:47AM (#9758674)
I think this is a valid approach, in theory.

IE, find some limited use case for a self driving cab service in a city and try to make the problem more like an agricultural field.

OTOH, it would require a city or state to actively pursue this kind of a bleeding edge technology, make decisions and possibly even develop the technology. Maybe there are some municipalities out there with the competence for this, but not many. I'm not as down on government abilities as some on here, but I think you have to admit that making such a technologically innovative, blue sky project a public one seems like a recipe for disaster.

The self driving cars can just develop on the free market. If the cars are good enough to go on normal roads people will buy them. I imagine that if they are prevalent enough, cities will then gradually tailor the infrastructure for them.

Still, there must be someplace where the smarter infrastructure could take some of the hard problems away for self driving cars and get a nice demo going. Some small town, large army base, some specific city hoping routes?

Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by dworin on Monday June 22, 2015 @11:33AM (#9759007)
The vision of self-driving cars using special roads has actually been around since the 50s. Here's a commercial GM put together about it (admittedly using different technology at the time): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F2iRDYnzwtk
Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by walshemj on Monday June 22, 2015 @10:43AM (#9758640)
I can rember a local agricultural college in the UK (silsoe now part of cranfield) experimenting with self driving tractors back in the late 70's
Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by awor on Monday June 22, 2015 @12:50PM (#9759565)
In a somewhat tangentially related vein, Suncor Energy, one of the top Oil Sands mining companies in Canada, announced they're replacing their fleet of heavy haul trucks with automated ones[0] by 2020, in the artcle they interview a automated truck industry rep who basically calls the use-case 'simple':

>"Really, what the industry is doing here is picking the low-hanging fruit. It's a lot easier to design and operate an autonomous truck on private property like the oil sands than it is on a on a public road. And there are a number of motivations. Computers drive better and more safely and better than humans."

[0] http://www.cbc.ca/radio/day6/episode-238-charleston-s-ame-ch...

Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by bonestamp2 on Monday June 22, 2015 @01:20PM (#9759762)
Exactly. Self steering sailboats existed before self driving tractors, but again... keeping a sailboat on a specific bearing is far easier than turning a tractor with any number of attachments towing behind it. Nobody came along and said what Deere did with tractors wasn't original because sailboats could auto steer. What about autopilot on airplanes? The comparisons are endless.

It's an interesting article on its own, but any claim to inventing self driving cars on the farm is rather shortsighted... every invention borrows from the past and contributes to the future. The same is true for art, literature, industrial design, cooking, medicine, and almost any other creation.

Lets not discount the invention of the self driving tractor, but lets also not discount the leaps that have been made since then in AI and computer learning for understanding road markers, traffic behavior, traffic signals, routing, crash avoidance, parking assistance, etc.

Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by navait on Monday June 22, 2015 @10:49AM (#9758688)
There's something to be said for starting with a simplified version of a complex problem. Driving on a road vs. a field is apple and oranges, but I'm sure it was a useful starting point for building road vehicles.
Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by Pxtl on Monday June 22, 2015 @01:35PM (#9759862)
Exactly. Self-driving farm equipment is more in the category of the Roomba than it is in the category of self-driving cars.
Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by geon on Monday June 22, 2015 @02:46PM (#9760353)
A million dollar Roomba, but yeah.

More interesting is to compare the stakes. On a farm, you have a worst case of ruined farm land and equipment. On the road there are human lives.

Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by samstave on Monday June 22, 2015 @03:37PM (#9760674)
I really would love to see how a Google car would handle chaos of third world metros, like Mumbai, Manilla etc...
Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by JoeAltmaier on Monday June 22, 2015 @03:41PM (#9760692)
I imagine a total fail. The car is programmed with an expectation of fairness - it assumes folks stop at lights, observer lanes and take turns at intersections, at least most of the time.

In those other cities the locals would learn to game the autocars, taking the initiative from them at every interaction, leaving them impotently idling at a busy intersection waiting for somebody, anybody, to give them an opening.

Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by andygates on Wednesday June 24, 2015 @06:59AM (#9770776)
IIRC, they're working at "fair but not doormat" - yes, gameable, but not so supine as to wait until the rush hour is over before nosing forward to indicate a desire to turn.
Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday June 24, 2015 @05:32PM (#9774638)
Need to review films of rush-hour traffic in Delhi. Cars stream pell-mell through intersections as a living fluid. No such thing as nosing forward to indicate anything. Its a whole different world.
Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by ytdht on Monday June 22, 2015 @03:08PM (#9760506)
yeah but where can you buy a Google self-driving car? and how many other companies are also working on the problem? many.
Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by higherpurpose on Monday June 22, 2015 @09:58AM (#9758321)
This smacks of "Apple didn't invent tablets, Microsoft did!!" kind of thinking.

Who cares who invented it, especially if they were incapable of bringing the technology to the mass market themselves? The real heroes are those who make it useful for the mass market, not those who keep it on the 8th shelf in their "R&D Lab" or even those who manage to sell 10,000 units a year globally.

Also, as you say, there's a big difference between "self-driving farm vehicles" and self-driving road cars, just like there' a big difference between an unusable 2h battery life and $2000 XP "tablet" from the 2000 compared to the 2010 iPad. In other words, there was been a lot more "invention" added to the iPad since the Microsoft tablets appeared as well.

Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by vezzy-fnord on Monday June 22, 2015 @10:42AM (#9758628)
Who cares who invented it, especially if they were incapable of bringing the technology to the mass market themselves?

This would pretty much disqualify a large chunk of computing research (research in general, really) from being notable according to your criteria, as it wasn't brought to the "mass market".

The real heroes are those who make it useful for the mass market, not those who keep it on the 8th shelf in their "R&D Lab" or even those who manage to sell 10,000 units a year globally.

They're all important. The ones who keep it on "the 8th shelf in their R&D lab" are who laid the groundwork for the mass marketeers to prevail in the first place. The small-time sellers frequently come from hobbyist backgrounds who are attempting to distribute a more specialized (or more capable for complex use cases) product as opposed to tailoring for maximum units sold.

Those who bring it to the masses deserve praise in as much as the product has utility and how it improves over previous designs. All too often the result will necessarily have to be watered down so it can pass in widespread consumer circles.

Is Bill Gates a hero, but Gary Kildall a zero? Nonsense. Though that's what your logic ultimately concludes.

Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by ctdonath on Monday June 22, 2015 @10:28AM (#9758531)
Quite. Yes, John Deere did create self-driving tractors designed to follow strictly specified paths on vast open fields having controlled access (i.e.: other vehicles & people could be denied entry to the area &/| informed of the situation) and well-defined path markers; this is a necessary but not sufficient precursor to developing a vehicle for use on arbitrary universal-access roads. Likewise, I was using tablet computers created by Wang back in the 1980s, ungainly monsters 3" thick with low-res monochrome screens and short battery life; this was a necessary but not sufficient precursor to the iPad. "Necessary but not sufficient" meaning "yeah, they made something like X way back when but somebody else had to do a whole lot more work to make it the viable & popular product we know today."
Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by nmrm2 on Monday June 22, 2015 @10:14AM (#9758425)
John Deere does sell self-driving tractors to a fairly massive market. Just because you aren't in the target market doesn't mean that they haven't brought the technology to market.

While there is a big difference between farms and roads, the tablet analogy doesn't make any sense.

Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by kevin_thibedeau on Monday June 22, 2015 @12:04PM (#9759248)
The scope of hazard detection and avoidance is vastly different between a tractor in a field and a car on the highway. They solved a self-driving problem for sure but a different problem than the one of general purpose human transport.
Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by JoeAltmaier on Monday June 22, 2015 @12:08PM (#9759274)
Not the least of which is velocity. Tractors generally move under 12mph. And traffic density. The tractor is the only vehicle in the field, as a rule. And obstacles - there is absolutely nobody out in the field, usually. And noisy environment - a field is often table-top flat and empty of all obstructions. Kind of the definition of a field.

So the John Deere problem space was mostly dead-reckoning navigation to a matter of inches, to get crop spacing right. A very different problem from auto-driving cars.

Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by dtparr on Monday June 22, 2015 @12:37PM (#9759476)
> And noisy environment - a field is often table-top flat and empty of all obstructions.

Perhaps this is true in certain parts of the country, but certainly wasn't my experience growing up in the Southeast. The land there tended to be mostly rolling hills, basically no field was totally table-top flat. (And the 3rd paragraph in TFA mentions that the land there even in Kansas is hilly so he does the first pass).

Obviously you want few obstacles to maximize the useful land area, but fields often had ponds, creeks, patches of trees that broke things up, not to mention unknown obstacles like fallen trees or fences, wild animals, etc. that happen 'randomly'. I'm actually curious how much of this the software can handle on its own.

So it's certainly a different challenge, but to imagine most fields as perfectly empty, flat, continuous, homogenous spaces is to over simplify things.

Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by JoeAltmaier on Monday June 22, 2015 @12:46PM (#9759535)
Pardon my ignorance. I'm here in Iowa where many fields are most definitely empty, flat, continuous and homogenous. Not to mention very fertile, well watered and yielding among the best of any place in the world. Also the home of agricultural research including, I'm guessing, John Deere pilot projects.

Which biased my view. Interesting to know the technology can handle Kansas, which would be a challenge.

Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by vinay427 on Monday June 22, 2015 @10:12AM (#9758412)
Exactly, which is why people who claim that Apple invented tablets still deserve to be corrected.
Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by mwfunk on Monday June 22, 2015 @11:37AM (#9759042)
That's OK, I'm sure when you delightfully correct people about this oversight, you don't skim over things like the Newton or the Palm Pilot, or the prop from 2001 that was hugely inspirational, and that you go into great detail about all the technical and usability differences between iPads and early-2000s tablet PCs. I'm sure you give fair and equal coverage to all of these topics when you are correcting people, since you seem to care about history and stuff. Just giving you the benefit of the doubt here.
Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by shiftpgdn on Monday June 22, 2015 @11:55AM (#9759183)
I bought a Compaq TC1000 when I graduated highschool for $750~. It was one of the very first "Tablet" PCs. It received a LOT of very positive attention when I used it on campus in college. It was a great machine and was very usable even with limited OS support.

Microsoft had a marketing problem (they still do) and not a usability problem.

Re:Google didn’t lead the self-driving vehicle revolution, J... by mavhc on Tuesday June 23, 2015 @05:47AM (#9763568)
Did Apple invent the usable tablet OS with a decent amount of software?