News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why can't America have great trains? by wyclif on Monday June 22, 2015 @03:44AM (#9756793)
Dear Europeans and East Asians: to paraphrase Douglas Adams, America is big. Really big. You just won't believe how vastly, hugely, mind-bogglingly big it is. I mean, you may think it's a long way down the road to the chemist, but that's just peanuts to an American.

I've been to Japan and been a passenger on the Shinkansen, and as the article says, I wept. I'm also well aware of the disconcerting contrast with the totally dysfunctional Amtrak—I've taken the Silver Star from NY to DC many times.

I tell my foreign friends the reason why the most technologically advanced country in the world has a third-world, Soviet-era train system is because Amtrak labour is expensive and incompetent, our government is so deeply in debt that they haven't invested enough in infrastructure for us to have a modern train system, and public transportation is a political football in the US Congress. After all, $117 billion USD isn't chump change. And if we weren't spending $664.84 billion per year on the DOD and military, we'd easily have enough for up to date trains. [1]

Also not helping trains is the fact that more than any other country on Earth, Americans love cars. Not a little. A lot.

This doesn't mean we won't have great trains someday. I hope that day is coming soon, but currently trains don't scale well in the USA.

[1] US military budget for the 2011 fiscal year.

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by felipeerias on Monday June 22, 2015 @04:22AM (#9756899)
Yes, the US is big, but a large part of its population is heavily concentrated. Trans-continental high-speed trains would be a waste, but better connections on very densely populated areas would be a great idea.

And the difference is not really that stark as you make it sound. Europe can be big too. While only 8 US states have a higher population density than France, there are 35 US states with a higher population density than Sweden.

https://en.wikipedia.org/?title=List_of_U.S._states_by_popul... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sovereign_states_and_d...

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by ctolsen on Monday June 22, 2015 @04:51AM (#9757026)
Sweden isn't very densely populated.
Re:Why can't America have great trains? by coldtea on Monday June 22, 2015 @04:28AM (#9756924)
>Dear Europeans and East Asians: to paraphrase Douglas Adams, America is big. Really big. You just won't believe how vastly, hugely, mind-bogglingly big it is. I mean, you may think it's a long way down the road to the chemist, but that's just peanuts to an American.

I've drove coast-to-coast like 10 times. It's bit but not that big when you compare it to East Asia (except if you mean "Japan" by that). The Trans-Siberian railway is 5,500 miles -- for comparison Chicago to LA is less than half that.

Heck, Ukraine to Portugal is the same distance as coast to coast US.

[EDIT] Let's put it this way: both China AND Russia, each by itself, is like 30% larger than the US.

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by yitchelle on Monday June 22, 2015 @04:06AM (#9756861)
> Also not helping trains is the fact that more than any other country on Earth, Americans love cars. Not a little. A lot.

Germany -> Car loving country with a highly efficient railway system, and a well serviced road system as well. So it should be achievable.

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by lgbr on Monday June 22, 2015 @04:38AM (#9756960)
> Germany -> Car loving country with a highly efficient railway system, and a well serviced road system as well. So it should be achievable.

Germany has a highly efficient railway system and the country is so small that I can cross the entire country in a day, and still, I take the car everywhere I go.

I think what some people miss is this: Trains are just worse.

They're slow, not because they don't have a high top speed, but they have to stop so much that their average speed is just worse than a car's. I think there's a couple city pairs (Berlin <-> Frankfurt) where if I was racing a train I would lose by some small margin to one of the non-stop trains, but not by much, and this would only be a true win if on my trip I was going from one city center to another city center, which I'm never doing.

They're still really expensive. Air travel around Germany is always cheaper, and so is the cost of fuel for most cars. You can sometimes find a discount on the train, but those travel at pretty inconvenient times and are quite rare anymore.

They leave only so often. So unlike a car, I can't just set off whenever is convenient for me. I have to find a train that leaves when I want and make sure I get to it on time. So if you live in Frankfurt and want to go visit family outside of Munich for the weekend, leaving after work at 18:00 on a Friday you're going to end up sleeping in a train station in Bavaria overnight as opposed to a car which can continue driving after 12:00 unlike a rural train.

And they never get where I want. For half of the places I regularly travel, when I get there, I need to have someone pick me up with a car or I need to rent a car. There just are no other choices. As densely populated as this country is, it's just still really difficult to get to a huge portion of the country with public transit.

I really find it no wonder the US does not have a decent passenger train system. Every single one of these problems is hugely exacerbated by its sparse population to the point where passenger trains just aren't feasible.

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by lorenzfx on Monday June 22, 2015 @05:02AM (#9757068)
No, they are not really expensive. Let's take your example of Frankfurt -> Berlin.

A 2nd class ICE ticket (without any reductions) is 123€ (1st class is 203€).

Going the 550km (Google Maps estimate) by car will cost 247€ (estimated by the ADAC, the largest German automobile club, for a VW Golf VII).

While you might want to argue that if you drive a lot by car, those costs per km will decrease, the same goes for travelling a lot by train.

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by lgbr on Monday June 22, 2015 @05:32AM (#9757183)
This 247 € factors in vehicle costs, taxes, maintenance, and insurance. Keep in mind that actual fuel costs for this stretch with a VW Golf VII would be 25.4 € (3.3 l/100km * 550km * 1.40 €/liter). So you're right. If you go out and buy a brand new VW Golf VII, insure it fully, and regularly drive this stretch, you're probably going to experience an average cost of 247 € for this stretch.

But there's two problems with this:

The actual marginal cost of the trip is still 25.4 €, plus let's give it a generous maintenance cost putting it at around 50 €. That's still less than half of the cost of the ICE. Add to this that you now have a car which can carry five people and the costs don't increase at all per person. A trip with 5 people is still going to cost you that 500 € instead of 615 €.

The second problem is that this is when you're buying a new car. Buying a used car would very easily bring your 247 € cost down below that 123 € even with the increase maintenance costs.

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by claudius on Monday June 22, 2015 @07:56AM (#9757628)
If you sink ~7000 Euro into a Bahncard 100 first class, you can go mostly anywhere for free. So by the logic of only counting marginal costs, it’s 25.4 € more expensive to travel from Berlin to Frankfurt by car as opposed to railway.

Berlin to Frankfurt takes about 4 to 5 hours. For the car, this is time spent driving. For the train, we may have to subtract about 30 mins waiting in Leipzig or Hanover for a connecting train, leaving you with 3.5 to 4.5 hours in the train. At a modest 15€/hour, your car trip is now 77.9 to 92.9€ more expensive than the train journey.

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by abrugsch on Monday June 22, 2015 @06:35AM (#9757360)
That calculation seems a little off... I don't know what ADAC takes into consideration for that calculation, but either of the cars in my family operate at around 16 Km/L on long distance, mostly motorway/autobahn (and neither will be as efficient as a Golf VII which may be closer to 20) and I don't know how much petrol/diesel costs in Germany right now, but it's probably not too far off £1.15-1.20 per litre in the UK at the moment (quick google suggests 1.43€, exchange rate of 1.4 so actually a little cheaper.) 550 Km/16 = 34.4 Litres of fuel at 1.43 a litre gives around 50€ per direction. I don't know what the tolls are like but I wouldn't cost in vehicle cost or insurance (both sunk costs) but maybe a portion of servicing costs (1/30th of a 15000Km service interval) so let's say worst case allow 20€. So actual cost of journey more like 70€ per direction, which is A LOT less than 247€ that ADAC is suggesting, and still 50€ less than the train.

I'm not trying to advocate for the car, (I much prefer train travel - especially on DB) but based purely on costs, it doesn't stack up... BTW, train prices are similarly stacked in the UK, with it rarely being more cost effective to take a train unless the convenience factor is a major part, like going to central London...

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by mozumder on Monday June 22, 2015 @06:06AM (#9757296)
Cars are slower because they have to deal with so many stoplights and traffic jams.

Also, cars are FAR more expensive than trains. How much do you pay a month for your car? $800/month? People in spend $116 for unlimited train/bus rides.

The biggest problem with cars, though, is that it requires manual labor to operate. You can't take a nap, or work on the computer, like you can on a train. You basically lose 2 hours a day because you need to drive.

Multiply this by hundred million people, and it becomes an drain on the US economy. That's 200 million man-hours wasted per day.

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by TheSpiceIsLife on Monday June 22, 2015 @04:51AM (#9757031)
Is there anywhere in the world where the train system is 'really good' for a majority of people? Trains need tracks and if you don't live near the tracks and need to go where the tracks go the train isn't much use to you.

So it follows that the US doesn't have a 'good' passenger train system because there is not such thing.

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by paganel on Monday June 22, 2015 @05:06AM (#9757084)
> Is there anywhere in the world where the train system is 'really good' for a majority of people?

I think Switzerland comes pretty close to this. Granted, I was only a tourist, but was really nice seeing how you could take a train from Geneva to any of the towns bordering Lake Geneva almost all night long, at pretty good intervals. And they were always on time, at the minute.

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by mozumder on Monday June 22, 2015 @06:09AM (#9757304)
What happens is that development happens around train/subway stops.

You can see this right now around the Washington DC area, where cities and sky rises have been popping up over the last 30 years, centered around individual metro stops.

You build the rail first, and the city builds around that.

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by yitchelle on Monday June 22, 2015 @04:53AM (#9757035)
I sought of agree with you. Car is definitely more convenient than train. I just returned for a weekend trip to Saarbrücken and I live in Köln. It is about a 3hour trip. Train would be have been great if I was staying in the centre of town, but car is much better as my accommodation is about 20mins out of Saarbrücken.

Having said that, I love the train because I can much less stressful, I can read, have an engaged conversation etc. Things I can't do while driving the car.

edit: clarity

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by wyclif on Monday June 22, 2015 @05:13AM (#9757122)
Good point about air travel. I didn't even bring that into the equation, but the efficiencies and economics are relevant. Particularly trans-continental flights between major cities, like NYC -> LA, or PHL -> Seattle.
Re:Why can't America have great trains? by fla on Monday June 22, 2015 @04:15AM (#9756883)
More than the love of cars, I think one other important factor is that US cities have been built and developed around car-first traffic for the last 80? years.

Which makes it much more optimal to drive around.

Now if you consider the economical ecosystem that was built around the road traffic, it's no suprise that the train network is having a hard time growing up.

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by Implicated on Monday June 22, 2015 @04:17AM (#9756887)
Land Size:

Germany | 137,847 mi^2 (square miles) United States | 3,719,000 mi^2 (square miles)

Paved Roads:

Germany | 400,784 mi United States | 2,674,830 miles

Not sure that's a fair comparison.

[1] https://www.cia.gov/Library/publications/the-world-factbook/...

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by tonyedgecombe on Monday June 22, 2015 @04:22AM (#9756903)
The population is far from evenly distributed across that larger area.
Re:Why can't America have great trains? by falcolas on Monday June 22, 2015 @09:04AM (#9757968)
True, but it tends to be concentrated at the four corners. The northeast gets Boston and NY, The southeast gets Miami and Atlanta, Then there's Seattle, California, etc. And if you don't live anywhere near these (a good portion of the population does not), or need to move between them, that means you have a long drive.

I live in Montana (tangentially - about the same size as Germany), and if I want to get to the closest population center, I can either ride the bus (yeah, no) or drive. The closest train station is across the state from where I am, and takes 4 hours longer than the drive (or bus) would (not including transit time to the station.

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by yitchelle on Monday June 22, 2015 @10:11AM (#9758408)
Not knowing much about Montana, I looked it on wikipedia and found the following snippet.

"Montana is ranked 4th in size, but 44th in population and 48th in population density of the 50 United States."

Population density is 2.65 per sq km. Man, that is very sparse. Remind me of outback Australia where traveling distances were measured in "number of beers" drank.

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by wyclif on Monday June 22, 2015 @04:07AM (#9756866)
I didn't say cars are the only reason. They're just one reason among many.
Re:Why can't America have great trains? by TillE on Monday June 22, 2015 @04:03AM (#9756850)
Again, the point that always needs to be made in these discussions: America's trains are lousy even in dense areas where they're heavily used. Case in point, the LIRR.
Re:Why can't America have great trains? by wyclif on Monday June 22, 2015 @04:04AM (#9756856)
But I grant that point, and so does the article. The problem is that most of the geography is not dense.

Here's a classic and recent example from someone who commutes on Amtrak out of NYC, the most dense metro region in the USA: https://twitter.com/greg_thornbury/status/610132981571801089

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by tormeh on Monday June 22, 2015 @04:45AM (#9756988)
Would it help if Amtrak didn't have to service anything else than the west and east coast? Wouldn't service get better if you cut out the areas that are uneconomical to service?
Re:Why can't America have great trains? by orf on Monday June 22, 2015 @04:46AM (#9756998)
> to paraphrase Douglas Adams, America is big. Really big. You just won't believe how vastly, hugely, mind-bogglingly big it is.

No, Australia is mind bogglingly big. America is big-ish.

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by profsnuggles on Monday June 22, 2015 @05:09AM (#9757099)
I'm confused by which metric Australia is bigger then America? Since America is like 25% larger in landmass and has more people in some of its larger states than the entire population of Australia.
Re:Why can't America have great trains? by orf on Monday June 22, 2015 @05:19AM (#9757139)
> has more people in some of its larger states than the entire population of Australia

Which makes Australia seem really really really big.

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by codesushi42 on Monday June 22, 2015 @05:43AM (#9757212)
Not when a mere fraction of it is actually livable.

Approximately 10% of Australia is habitable, compared to 40% of the US.

http://37propertygroup.com.au/real-estate/population-density...

The US percentage would no doubt be higher without Alaska.

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by wyclif on Monday June 22, 2015 @05:02AM (#9757067)
And how is Australia's continental train service, then?
Re:Why can't America have great trains? by orf on Monday June 22, 2015 @05:12AM (#9757116)
Acceptable (daily/twice daily trains between major cities), however I was wrong on my first point[1]. I guess the lack of people and the huge, impossibly large landscapes makes it seem larger than it is.

1. http://www.aboutaustralia.com/australia-size-compared-to-usa...

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by codesushi42 on Monday June 22, 2015 @05:09AM (#9757103)
Not really. It's big, but most of it is uninhabitable. And it has less than a tenth of the population of the US; 23m vs 318m.
Re:Why can't America have great trains? by dragop on Monday June 22, 2015 @05:32AM (#9757185)
The distance between New York and Washington DC is about 225 miles and takes just over 4 hours by car.

Assuming a dedicated high speed rail line based on highway distances, at the best TGV speeds[1] (173mph, includes start and stop, not just high speed running) that would take approximately 1 hour 20 minutes.

[1] http://www.railwaygazette.com/fileadmin/user_upload/railwayg...

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by tjradcliffe on Monday June 22, 2015 @04:14AM (#9756880)
False. China has high-speed trains that travel around 1000 km. China is also big. Really big. Also pretty poor. But it manages despite its ridiculous dictatorship to get a modicum of useful stuff done. Stuff that the US--uniquely in the democratic, developed, world--is unable to do.

For more information: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-speed_rail_in_China

So the claim that "trains don't scale well in the USA" is false. Trains scale just fine to thousands of kilometres. The distance from Bejing to Hong Kong, which has a rail line capable of more than 300 kph (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Rail_map_of_China.svg) is just shy of 2000 km as the crow flies, which is more than the distance from NYC to Chicago and a bit less than the distance from NYC to Dallas.

And pointing out that LA is more distant from NYC than that is utterly, completely and totally irrelevant. The distance from NYC to LA has absolutely nothing to do with the inability of Americans to build a high speed rail link between various Eastern and Southern cities, and there is zero plausibility to any claim that NYC and Chicago (or Dallas) aren't commerical hubs of comparable importance to the US as Bejing and Hong Kong are to China.

So we can put that false claim to bed now, and never muddy the discussion with it again.

The more plausible reason is the other one you cite, at least by implication: the American economic and political system, uniquely amongst developed democracies, is unable to muster sufficient collective resources in the form of public or private investment to enable creators to build a fairly straightforward rail network that would serve American economic needs.

The US is not "the most technologically advanced coutry in the world". It is two countries, one of which is technologically advanced, the other of which is backward in almost every respect (and kept that way by policies set by the first.)

Until Americans figure out how to deal with their unique social and political deficits and inabilities they will continue to suffer under stub-standard conditions in almost every respect. They will continue to die earlier, live with higher crime rates, lousy railways, and dramatically lower economic efficiency than that enjoyed by citizens of almost any other advanced nation.

Canada also sucks with respect to passenger rail, and we are generally far better than Americans at solving our collective problems, so there may be more to it than that, but clearly size alone is not the issue, or China wouldn't have the amazing high speed rail network it does.

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by cactusface on Monday June 22, 2015 @04:20AM (#9756893)
I think population density is a factor. China and the US have the same area, but China has 4x the population. Consider also England and Japan, densely populated islands with great train service.
Re:Why can't America have great trains? by vetinari on Monday June 22, 2015 @04:36AM (#9756949)
This is about the first time that I see "UK" and "great train service" together in one sentence ;)
Re:Why can't America have great trains? by digi_owl on Monday June 22, 2015 @04:45AM (#9756989)
Relative to USA it may be great, but i wonder about relative to Japan.
Re:Why can't America have great trains? by cactusface on Monday June 22, 2015 @05:09AM (#9757098)
Japan > England >> USA. Just being able to take the TGV from London to Paris is mindblowing.

I define great as it being generally possible to get where I want to go on the train (this is the most important factor) and then as a bonus it's usually competitive with driving, busing, flying, cycling, or walking in terms of comfort, cost, and convenience.

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by digi_owl on Monday June 22, 2015 @07:47AM (#9757597)
And therein lies the rub perhaps.

When people praise train travel it is largely long distance.

When people complain it is likely to be commuter lines in and around cities.

BTW, TGV is French...

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by chrischen on Monday June 22, 2015 @04:29AM (#9756928)
Yea also China's population is way more packed onto one side of the country than the US is.
Re:Why can't America have great trains? by hannob on Monday June 22, 2015 @05:21AM (#9757148)
China is heavily trying to also connect its less populated areas to proper train services. They just built a new highspeed train to the Xinjiang region which is a very sparsely populated area in the north east of China.
Re:Why can't America have great trains? by lorenzfx on Monday June 22, 2015 @04:38AM (#9756958)
We might have had different experiences travelling by train in England.
Re:Why can't America have great trains? by ionised on Monday June 22, 2015 @05:37AM (#9757198)
The UK rail service is dire and has been for many years since privatisastion.
Re:Why can't America have great trains? by dagw on Monday June 22, 2015 @05:43AM (#9757216)
It may be much worse than it's been, but it still mostly works and it's still much better than what's in the US.
Re:Why can't America have great trains? by mozumder on Monday June 22, 2015 @06:01AM (#9757275)
> Also not helping trains is the fact that more than any other country on Earth, Americans love cars. Not a little. A lot.

Americans don't love cars.

SOME Americans are forced to buy cars because of the infrastructure they live under, but they don't love them.

Most people prefer to go by rail if they can. Millennials especially.

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by wyclif on Monday June 22, 2015 @06:55AM (#9757423)
Sorry, but you're wrong. Americans love cars. Adore them, in fact. Everything about them. The sound, the paint, the polish, the leather, the tires. Everything.
Re:Why can't America have great trains? by mozumder on Wednesday June 24, 2015 @06:43AM (#9770738)
OK, but Americans hate cars. Everything about them. The sound, the paint, the polish, the leather, the tires. Everything.

But especially the costs.

http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/03/why-dont...

Since Americans hate cars so much, we have to build an economy without them.

Trains are a good way to do that.

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by pouetpouet on Monday June 22, 2015 @05:26AM (#9757159)
The North-East is as dense as France. The mid-atlantic is denser than France, slighty less than Germany. And yet those regions severely lack in the train department. The size of the USA as a whole is irrelevant. 2000 mile train rides are not the point. Regional corridors are.
Re:Why can't America have great trains? by makeitsuckless on Monday June 22, 2015 @04:41AM (#9756972)
That's just condescending exceptionalism.

The vast majority of trains in Europe cover short distances in densely populated urban areas of which the US has plenty.

Also, I don't buy the "Americans love cars" argument. Americans have an oddly obsessive relationship with owning cars, but it's definitely not "love". Wester Europeans are in general far more passionate and discerning about cars.

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by wyclif on Monday June 22, 2015 @04:51AM (#9757025)
First, you completely misunderstood my comment. American exceptionalism is the suggestion that the USA is better than other developed countries because it is intrinsically unique. But that's not what I said at all; in fact, I said the opposite: our transportation system is not only retrograde, but worse than in other countries.

I'm also going to have to say "nope" to your auto comment as well. Western Europeans may have more cars per person, but that's not the same thing as love. We're the country of Tesla Motors and Google self-driving cars. That was what my "not a little, a lot" jibe was about—we are all about ratings, blue books, discernment, reviews, specs, mechanics, all of that. There's a reason the song "Fun, Fun, Fun" by the Beach Boys ("And she'll have fun, fun, fun / Till her daddy takes the T-bird away") is such a cultural touchstone in the States.

Re:Why can't America have great trains? by makeitsuckless on Monday June 22, 2015 @08:51AM (#9757884)
Tesla and Google's self driving cars are recent development. In Europe, there is a much bigger culture around car engineering, innovation, racing etcetera. There's a reason why, unlike in the US, millions are poured into all forms of autosports. It's nothing abnormal for an ordinary suburban housewife to prefer a "sporting" car with manual gearshift. Brands like Ferrari, Aston Martin, Porsche etcetera exist in Europe because cars are seen as much more than just vehicles.

The American obsession with cars is different, but there doesn't seem to be an awful lot of "love" involved in the American car culture, at least not since the 50s.