Re:Why can't America have great trains?
by cactusface on Monday June 22, 2015 @04:20AM
(#9756893)
I think population density is a factor. China and the US have the same area, but China has 4x the population. Consider also England and Japan, densely populated islands with great train service.
This is about the first time that I see "UK" and "great train service" together in one sentence ;)
Relative to USA it may be great, but i wonder about relative to Japan.
Re:Why can't America have great trains?
by cactusface on Monday June 22, 2015 @05:09AM
(#9757098)
Japan > England >> USA. Just being able to take the TGV from London to Paris is mindblowing.
I define great as it being generally possible to get where I want to go on the train (this is the most important factor) and then as a bonus it's usually competitive with driving, busing, flying, cycling, or walking in terms of comfort, cost, and convenience.
And therein lies the rub perhaps.
When people praise train travel it is largely long distance.
When people complain it is likely to be commuter lines in and around cities.
BTW, TGV is French...
Yea also China's population is way more packed onto one side of the country than the US is.
China is heavily trying to also connect its less populated areas to proper train services.
They just built a new highspeed train to the Xinjiang region which is a very sparsely populated area in the north east of China.
We might have had different experiences travelling by train in England.
The UK rail service is dire and has been for many years since privatisastion.
For more information: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-speed_rail_in_China
So the claim that "trains don't scale well in the USA" is false. Trains scale just fine to thousands of kilometres. The distance from Bejing to Hong Kong, which has a rail line capable of more than 300 kph (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Rail_map_of_China.svg) is just shy of 2000 km as the crow flies, which is more than the distance from NYC to Chicago and a bit less than the distance from NYC to Dallas.
And pointing out that LA is more distant from NYC than that is utterly, completely and totally irrelevant. The distance from NYC to LA has absolutely nothing to do with the inability of Americans to build a high speed rail link between various Eastern and Southern cities, and there is zero plausibility to any claim that NYC and Chicago (or Dallas) aren't commerical hubs of comparable importance to the US as Bejing and Hong Kong are to China.
So we can put that false claim to bed now, and never muddy the discussion with it again.
The more plausible reason is the other one you cite, at least by implication: the American economic and political system, uniquely amongst developed democracies, is unable to muster sufficient collective resources in the form of public or private investment to enable creators to build a fairly straightforward rail network that would serve American economic needs.
The US is not "the most technologically advanced coutry in the world". It is two countries, one of which is technologically advanced, the other of which is backward in almost every respect (and kept that way by policies set by the first.)
Until Americans figure out how to deal with their unique social and political deficits and inabilities they will continue to suffer under stub-standard conditions in almost every respect. They will continue to die earlier, live with higher crime rates, lousy railways, and dramatically lower economic efficiency than that enjoyed by citizens of almost any other advanced nation.
Canada also sucks with respect to passenger rail, and we are generally far better than Americans at solving our collective problems, so there may be more to it than that, but clearly size alone is not the issue, or China wouldn't have the amazing high speed rail network it does.