News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by clarky07 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @10:54AM (#9692637)
This article felt very weak and empty. The biggest complaint seemed to be that other people noticed she had it, and started small talk about it. Oh the horror. It's an article in search of minor reasons to not like the watch. I don't care if it wasn't life changing to you. Not newsworthy.
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by danso on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:02AM (#9692704)
Sure...but the other, implicit side of "I'm quitting it because of all the social awkwardness" is: "This device is not good enough to warrant tolerating all the social awkwardness". The iPad was the only Apple device that I've waited on opening day for and when I used it at subways or at the coffee shop for what seemed like the first two months, I always got questions. And it was fun at first, then kind of annoying. But I never felt the urge to "quit" the iPad because its form factor was just so damn useful. If I couldn't stand the public attention, I could always use it at home and feel like I got my money's worth. Apparently that's not the case with the OP and the Watch.
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by altcognito on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @12:22PM (#9693354)
It can't nearly be as bad as the social awkwardness around Glass.
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by danso on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @12:37PM (#9693455)
I've never used Glass, but what it has going against it besides social awkwardness, is physical design limitations and massive cost...substantially improve 1 or 2 of those categories, then it seems like an easy sell. And if it's the case that augmented-vision glasses don't ever make it to the public mainstream (imagine legislators passing sweeping regulations/restrictions)...I think it'd still be useful to wear for a wide variety of technical tasks...for example...instead of doing a DIY project and having to hold an iPad in one hand, with Glass and a specially designed app, have your field of vision augmented by the instructions.

It's possible to imagine an ideal Glass device (basically indistinguishable from normal glasses) and how that could be integrated into daily life. But it's hard to imagine how the ideal Watch, when it's finally implemented, would be drastically different than what it offers now; given its inherently small screen and its physical attachment to your wrist, what could a 5mm thin, 8-week-on-a-single-charge, heavily developer-supported Watch change how we use a watch-like device...and how would those changes compare in magnitude versus the changes brought by similar advancements in phone and eyewear technology?

Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by kleer001 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @12:47PM (#9693529)
Exactly right about Glass there. It blew my mind that Google dropped the ball so bad there. Why market it to drunk trustafarian boho douche bags that go hang gliding every day? Uh, there's a whole population of people that work with their hands for a living that could use an extra para-brain to do some light secretarial jobs like calling, taking a picture, texting, etc... I would say the working class is far more populous than the target audience in those original Glass-hole adds.
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by chc on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @02:09PM (#9694158)
I think the problem is that it was expensive, so they were kind of locked into marketing it toward people who go through money like socks — similar to why Tesla started insanely far upmarket and has slowly been working its way down to the ordinary consumer market, which is probably where the most benefit will happen.
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by kleer001 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @03:09PM (#9694571)
Expensive for an individual, but not for a group like a military (I understand if Google wants to stay away from that can of worms) or a big manufacturing company like aerospace or food or car repair, etc ...
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by clarky07 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @04:57PM (#9695320)
Glass was pretty terrible IMO. Lots of major issues, not the least of which was battery life. People complain about the battery on the watch (which i think is great fwiw, never get below 60%). Glass couldn't even dream of 1 day battery life. it was lucky to make it to 1-2 hours, less if you wanted to do the video (basically the only thing it was good at).
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by msabalau on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @12:45PM (#9693511)
That only means that products with more social awkwardness would need to deliver even more value. It doesn't change the cost/benefit calculation for the Apple Watch
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by nilkn on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:28AM (#9692913)
I don't agree with you. I think the complaint is completely legitimate, and it's the main reason I want to wait a year or two before taking the plunge with smartwatches.

I think the Apple Watch is really cool and I want one. But I'm very much like the author. I hate being ostentatious and I don't want to wear something that will be very noticeable.

The author was still willing to risk it in order to give it a try. There's nothing wrong with that.

(Also, for me the usually-off screen is sort of a dealbreaker, because it really harms the aesthetics of the watch when the screen is off.)

Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by schrodinger on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @12:16PM (#9693307)
FWIW, I've got the Apple Watch Sport in black, and I haven't been getting significant attention. I think in black, it doesn't really stand out that much.

I live in NYC

Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by xauronx on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @10:47PM (#9697160)
Agreed. I just used it to pay for my lunch at Panera today and it was the biggest response I've gotten so far, with an outrageous, over the top.... "heh, that's neat" as she grabbed my cup and continued with her day.
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by wffurr on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @01:34PM (#9693888)
Android Wear has an option to have an always-on watch face. When I wore one of the nicer looking ones with that turned on, nobody even noticed it wasn't a real watch until I did something wacky like scroll on it or talk to it.
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by edgyswingset on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @10:57AM (#9692655)
I think there's some substance here. My impression from reading it was that the watch was purchased as a fashion device, but it's still too much of a gadget to really be one.
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by zamalek on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:26AM (#9692887)
> too much of a gadget

I thought about it quite a bit before the launch and decided against it. The reason is the same reason I haven't gone for any of these: AW is putting all its effort into being something that it's not (a fashionable watch) instead of being the best of what it is (wearable arm tech).

The watch started out as a utility on the arm and evolved into the time masterpiece or fashion piece that it is today. These 'watches' are attempting to skip all of that evolution instead of defiantly re-evaluating what a modern utility on the arm could be.

I'm personally in agreement with the author but not for the same reasons. I think the AW, Android Gear and what-have-you are definitely going to fizzle out in face of some future revolutionary device, possibly before then: people are going to grudgingly realize that they have a phone in their pocket and that they don't need another one on their arm.

Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by wmeredith on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @12:01PM (#9693172)
I agree. I wanted a PiP Boy 3000[1]. Apple delivered another piece of wrist jewelry, of which there are far more compelling options in the market.

I'd have camped out overnight for something like this: http://toddham.com/blog/iwatch-concept/

1) http://fallout.wikia.com/wiki/Pip-Boy_3000

Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by roc on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @01:14PM (#9693737)
The problem of "more capability" is that everyone has a smartphone in their pocket. Any interaction that lasts more than 2-3 taps, or 2 seconds, is a failure because the user would have been better served by retrieving their phone. (niche "phone not accessible" situations notwithstanding)

The right answer to wearable tech is less interaction. The value has to be in the device presenting you the right 1-second functionality at the right time. (ala notification triage, Apple Pay, and the laundry list of Home Kit integration that's still TBD)

Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by zamalek on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @12:36PM (#9693447)
> I'd have camped out overnight for something like this

That's technology! Exactly the type of revolution I was implying.

Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by edgyswingset on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:31AM (#9692939)
Yeah, I feel the same way, too. The watches for iOS and Android really aren't anything more than an extra notification device for me ... my phone already does that, and arguably too much. My $24 Mickey Mouse watch still tells the time when I'm not staring at my phone, and it didn't cost me $400 like the Apple Watch would.
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by coryl on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @01:27PM (#9693833)
The best features on the Watch don't exist yet. They're the passive sensors, like the heart rate monitor. I think the best Watch is yet to come, if they can make these breakthroughs in body sensors like blood glucose.
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by matwood on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:11AM (#9692773)
A fashion item means the wears wants people to see it worn. If people are asking questions it means the watch did the job the user wanted.
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by pcurve on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:58AM (#9693154)
That's partially true. But it's also about how it makes you feel. Will most people be able to tell $250 Thomas Pink shirt from $25 shirt? Probably not, especially if the $25 one has good fit. But plenty of people plunk down $150-$250 for a shirt because they appreciate its feel, workmanship, fit, etc.
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by astine on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:34AM (#9692954)
If I brought my quadcopter to work and started flying it around, people would take notice and comment on it. Some might also want to try it out. No one would mistake it for a fashion accessory, however. That's because it is a toy; which is what people who aren't tech geeks think of gadgets: they're expensive toys. The author doesn't want to be perceived as the kind of person who has en expensive toy strapped to her wrist.
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by interpol_p on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:18AM (#9692823)
Well you can notice a nice ring, or a nice mechanical watch, and not feel compelled to ask about it or try it on.

Generally with jewellery you would expect someone to say something like "that's a nice ring," not "hey is that the new Apple Watch? Can I try it on?"

Of course the latter will fade with time. So if that's her biggest complaint then I imagine it won't exist in a few months.

Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by amelius on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:17AM (#9692820)
Perhaps there is more the wearer wants than just be noticed by others? For example, that it looks good.
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by knodi123 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:15AM (#9692805)
That's not just your impression, it's literally the last paragraph of the article.
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by JustSomeNobody on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:40AM (#9693004)
I am to the point where I try not to even read articles that begin "Why I broke up with...", "Why I no longer use...", "Why I quit...".

At best, they come off as immature ramblings.

Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by droidist2 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:56AM (#9693138)
Especially when the product in question has been out for like 2 months. Not really a huge break up. Now if you were breaking up with indoor plumbing, that'd be a headline.
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by mikeash on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @12:33PM (#9693423)
Exactly my thought. Oh, you tried it and you didn't like it? Big deal.
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by JustSomeNobody on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @12:09PM (#9693231)
Haha. Indeed! I would definitely read that one.
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by ionforce on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:55AM (#9693131)
"Why I no longer write informative article headlines..."
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by jusben1369 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:23AM (#9692862)
I kind of know what you mean. But I've noticed a strange thing with the Apple Watch. Going back even 5 years ago it wasn't "will I wear a watch?" but rather what watch will I wear? A digital one with big buttons said I was a triathlete, an elegant one with a simple face said I valued simplicity etc. But then many of us just stopped wearing watches. So now when I see an Apple Watch on someone I'm having two reactions i) Oh, they're wearing an Apple Watch and ii) It's actually so important to them to have an Apple Watch that they've gone and put a new thing on their body that wasn't there before. So it _seems_ more pretentious to me than it would have a few years back. (sorry I don't mean to say you're pretentious because you have an Apple Watch just that I'm viewing it as much more of a deliberate two part thing)

BTW I know 5 years ago many people didn't wear watches then. I'm talking about the relative trend of significantly decreased watch wearing and buying coinciding with the rise of the smartphone.

Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by xxdiamondxx on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:23AM (#9692865)
Well, to add some anecdotal evidence, it is my biggest complaint about owning one :P
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by jasonlotito on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:32AM (#9692943)
People think I'm joking, but yes. I've had people walk up to me in the store and ask about it. It's a flip on the old joke:

How do you know you are wearing your Apple Watch?

Everyone will ask you about it.

And they are all looking for me to tell them that it's great, that it's wonderful, and that it changed my life. And when I don't, they inevitably have a glint of disappoint in their eyes.

Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by JonFish85 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:25AM (#9692873)
The device that screams "I'm a nerd (with $600)" causes people to notice that you have it? The same one that required preordering that is just being finished now, months later? And on a product that is, by definition, meant to be seen in public. Yeah, who could have seen that coming?
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by xauronx on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @10:49PM (#9697166)
As soon as I realized it was posted in Fashion, I realized that it wasn't going to have any content that I care about. "It makes me feel this, people think that about me, etc etc" Hint: If you're going to buy products from the company with the strongest brand in the world, and you hate brands, you're going to have a bad time.
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by mc32 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:42AM (#9693022)
Exactly. If she really felt like not talking and that the watch was subverting her own being, she could have just said, oh it's a no name knockoff.

If I have something which catches attention I don't want and want to end that line of conversation, I introduce the conversation kill switch. I found it at a garage sale, I got it at jc pennys or tj max. I have no idea what brand it is.

No, she's actually doing the inverse of what she claims to want to do. She's calling attention to herself by announcing how she goes out of her way to not call attention to herself.

Reporters, as if their life wasn't about small talk and schmoozing.

Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by 7Z7 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @12:32PM (#9693420)
Maybe she isn't comfortable having to lie just to get by, when she clearly didn't find enough benefit from the device to continue through what she perceived as the social issues attached to it.
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by mc32 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @04:19PM (#9695017)
Ok, so then stop wearing it. Return it. Why make it so melodramatic. It's really not a big deal. People deal with so many more annoying things in daily life -coworkers, digestive tract, bad food, selfish people, inconsiderate people, disease, weather, etc.
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by pmelendez on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @12:27PM (#9693386)
> The biggest complaint seemed to be that other people noticed she had it

--"Granted, all of this would likely pale in importance if the watch were truly transforming my life, as my iPhone has"

--"And the small screen is simply too small to really read on ... when I saw a headline, all I wanted to do was find the rest of the story"

Those sounds like valid points to me.

Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by Someone1234 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:05AM (#9692731)
It is in the fashion section. In the technology section, yes, this is vapid but in fashion it is par of the course.
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by kumarm on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:24AM (#9692870)
Didn't Google Glass had the same issue?
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by Nicholas_C on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:37AM (#9692988)
I think Glass's main issue was that it was obnoxiously obvious and disruptive (in the bad way) and even a little creepy.
Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by jpreiland on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @12:07PM (#9693214)
Yes, Glass always garnered a bit too much attention for me. It's really awkward when people ask to try it on and you don't want to hand over your $1500 device to a stranger.

It suffered from the additional issue of negative social interaction - some people (luckily none that I've run into) are really opposed to face-phone (Glass) as opposed to in-your-pocket-or-hand-phone. I don't really understand why people think you're invading their privacy just because of an unusual device form factor.

Re:Why I'm Breaking Up with the Apple Watch by hondaz54 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @01:28PM (#9693842)
How can you not understand that? If you talk to something wearing google glass you are in the camera's viewport. A smartphone however is mostly kept in you bag, or you have it placed on a table and you are probably NOT in the cameras viewport.

So it's not about the form factor, but the fact that in case of google glass, the camera is pointing on your head!