News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by smaili on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @10:50AM (#9692587)
Anybody else feel a little nervous when a free language tool is valued in the hundreds of millions?
Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by mbesto on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:15AM (#9692801)
So you might ask “how can you make money giving away a learning app?” This past week DuoLingo answered that question with the commercial release of the DuoLingo Test Center.

The DuoLingo Test Center is currently free but it won’t be for long. Give it a try if you’d like to see how it works. Once the DuoLingo Test is accepted at schools and employers, the company plans to charge $20 to take its test.

There’s an established incumbent (monopoly) in this market called TOEFL. If you’ve come to the US to study, you’ve probably taken this test. It’s a lot more expensive than $20 per test and DuoLingo is out to prove it can do this testing less expensively and better.

[0] - http://avc.com/2014/07/freemium-in-education/

Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by rkrzr on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:26AM (#9692883)
I hope they succeed in taking away some market share from TOEFL. The TOEFL test is ridiculously overpriced for what they provide and your results expire (no joke) after 2 years. Since clearly you will have forgotten everything you knew about that language in 2 years time... Go Duolingo!
Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by Grue3 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:41AM (#9693018)
>Since clearly you will have forgotten everything you knew about that language in 2 years time...

They are not wrong. I passed Duolingo Spanish course (it might have been extended since then) and barely remember anything now. I was also studying German in school, and later French by myself to the point where I could even speak with native speakers a little. Hardly remember anything either. English is the only foreign language that I haven't forgot because I use it constantly. But if you're not using a foreign language, after passing the test you will completely forget it in 2 years.

Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by raverbashing on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:57AM (#9693140)
This, to me, is very telling

I spent a lot of time barely using certain foreign languages (+ than 2 years). Of course you get 'rusty', but far from forgetting everything.

And it came up back quickly

This tell me Duolingo doesn't make you learn it, but rather memorize their game.

Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by freehunter on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @01:49PM (#9694008)
There is no way to permanently learn a language if you're not using it. I have known coworkers who grew up in the US for the first 20-something years of their life and then moved to other countries and have begun the process of forgetting English. Their first language. The one they were taught as babies.

Remember this: everyone is taught their perfect grammar and spelling and quizzed on it for years in school. How many people can say what a past participle is, or even what an adverb is? How many people who passed geometry can still do that level of math from the top of their heads?

Of course you can't permanently learn something. You have to keep it in practice.

Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by bayesianhorse on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @04:07PM (#9694930)
That's not true. Memorization is the most efficient way of learning a language, but it often comes in forms which aren't as obvious. For example you can look at reading foreign texts as a kind of repetition for every word you encounter.

It's hard to master and complete a Duolingo course without getting a grip on the language. You'd have to pretty much ignore the "Strengthen your skills" button and never repeat anything.

Even after finishing a course you should use the repetitions for weeks and months to keep refreshing your memory. That's the only way it may stay forever.

Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by Someone1234 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @12:37PM (#9693456)
And while that may be the case, it is ultimately a free Rosetta Stone. So if it fails to work you're only out just time, with Rosetta Stone you're out time and also hundreds of dollars.

I'd love to see a independent study into its reliability/retention. But even if it is completely useless, it is still no more wasteful than any other mobile game people play daily.

Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by bayesianhorse on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @04:25PM (#9695077)
There is one referenced on their homepage. On average, 34 hours of study in the Spanish course would be equivalent to a full semester of language education in college. For me that would be about a month of practice.

I have seen the effects myself. After a month or so, even though I had learned some spanish before, native speakers suddenly slowed down (in my perception).

An important clue: Use the "Strengthen your skills" button frequently to keep the tree golden. Duolingo itself doesn't nag you enough to do that, but it's essential for mastery of the language.

Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by rkrzr on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:56AM (#9693132)
"But if you're not using a foreign language, after passing the test you will completely forget it in 2 years"

You usually take this test because you will have to speak this language, so the case where you take the test and then do nothing with it seems pretty unlikely. Also, I disagree with your assumption that you will completely forget another language in 2 years (even when not used). I cannot confirm this from my own experience.

Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by bayesianhorse on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @04:03PM (#9694908)
The trick is to keep repeating the exercises for at least a few weeks after you have finished the course.

I can guarantee you that you didn't forget everything. If you completed the Spanish course, your brain has been rewired for Spanish...

Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by S4M on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:47AM (#9693058)
When I took the TOEIC (it was mandatory to get my diploma), the people in charge of the exams said that the TOEIC score is only valid one or two years (can't remember which) and if we spend some time in an English speaking country it was advised to take a TOEIC again as our score would be likely to increase.

I was thinking at the time (it was in 2005) that they were really out of touch with common sense, and right now I wonder if anybody outside academia gives some credibility to the TOEIC or the TOEFL.

Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by Coding_Cat on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:26AM (#9692894)
I don't know about the US, but internationally it's not a monopoly by TOEFL. When I was looking at foreign uinversities for my Master's several programs were accepted. For Sweden it's: TOEFL, IELTS, Cambridge Michigan Language Assessments, Pearson PTE Academic, University of Cambridge ESOL Examinations and possibly more (I got accepted with an old IB A2 degree).
Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by mattmanser on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:26AM (#9692881)
A non-profit with a cool $1 billion in turnover according to this dodgy looking site:

http://www.guidestar.org/organizations/21-0634479/educationa...

Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by melling on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:08AM (#9692744)
They have a business model where they sell translation services to CNN, etc.

I don't have a business model but I'm trying to bootstrap an iOS language software company. Duolingo is really good but I think language learning is difficult enough that there are other good ideas worth pursuing.

Anyway, if anyone is learning another language, I'd appreciate any feedback on my apps. Here's my Spanish app:

https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/h4-spanish-lite/id388918463?...

Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by jfoster on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:11AM (#9692774)
From the article:

> As a company spokesperson told me, the company actually tabled its ambitions around translations about a year and a half ago and hasn’t scaled the businesses or accepted new clients (it’s still working with CNN, though).

Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by organsnyder on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:33AM (#9692952)
That makes sense to me. Automated translation software has made huge strides in the past decade, so Duolingo's crowdfunded approach (as cool as it is) will likely be obsolete in the fairly near future anyways.
Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by melling on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:27AM (#9692901)
Well, that gives me a little hope. Consumers don't part with their money as easily a business does. People want technology to change education but they don't want to spend any money.
Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by nols on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:12AM (#9692785)
I don't think they rely on translations anymore, now their income comes from certified exams.
Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by jasondc on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:01AM (#9692695)
Rosetta Stone, which seems to be the current leader in language training made $261 million last year.

The funny thing is Duolingo is now valued higher than Rosetta Stone: https://www.google.com/finance?q=RST

Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by DannoHung on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:08AM (#9692749)
Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by charlesism on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @02:38PM (#9694376)
Having used both Duolingo and Rosetta Stone, that seems about right. Rosetta Stone will probably survive, but not by selling directly to end-users.
Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by rubyrescue on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:12AM (#9692784)
Rosetta Stone's DVD based revenue model is crumbling.
Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by therobot24 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @10:57AM (#9692662)
Nah, they definitely provide value. Have you used it before? For someone who only took a few years of a foreign language in high school, it's a great refresher. If they could also structure the lessons to teach in a similar way to the classroom (e.g., actively showing different conjugations instead of just assuming you'll remember or pick up on it yourself) then they'll be golden.
Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by jfoster on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:09AM (#9692752)
They've found an effective solution for self-study. Anything contextually different (eg. for classrooms) might need a vastly different solution.

Suppose they even managed to come up with that classroom solution for language learning. How does what they currently have help them? Teachers, schools & government education departments make the purchasing decision for classrooms, so what students use in their time outside class isn't especially helpful in driving more sales of a classroom solution.

If they came up with something good for classrooms, they might as well axe or install paywalls into their existing stuff.

Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by therobot24 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:40AM (#9693005)
> How does what they currently have help them?

It helps the user better understand the language, which I believe is their goal to begin with. For example, their current approach presents a conjugated word in the context of a provided sentence or phrase. When I'm refreshing a language this isn't a big deal, but if I'm starting from scratch I don't have the foreknowledge to understand exactly when and why the word appears as such. I don't really need to argue that learning the language structure is much easier than memorizing a large list of words and phrases.

More simply a better tool for learning, is a better product on their end. They don't have to sell it to schools, but if teachers see that it can work in tandem with their curriculum then it will translate to more users.

> If they came up with something good for classrooms, they might as well axe or install paywalls into their existing stuff.

You're only looking at monetizing and forgetting about growth.

Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by jfoster on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @09:05PM (#9696775)
> You're only looking at monetizing and forgetting about growth.

Because of the valuation size, and because I think they've succeeded at growing quickly and becoming the most well-known language learning solution. Everything else about Duolingo looks really good, but the monetization side of things seems to be the elephant in the room.

What I'm also pointing out is that the growth among language learners cannot be easily translated into growth in institutions. To grow in institutions they will still need sales teams, and their consumer userbase doesn't necessarily gain them much of an advantage in that game.

All that said, in this article they hint at having plans beyond the $20 certification they've announced. To achieve the valuation they've now got, I think it's fair to say they do have a solid plan that they just haven't made public knowledge yet. It's probably something that will be a bit controversial among their userbase, like paywalls.

Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by organsnyder on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:36AM (#9692978)
Same here. I took two years of Spanish in high school, and two semesters in college. I never put much effort into those classes, as I knew I couldn't commit the time to becoming fluent (I was taking them to fulfill core requirements at the liberal arts college I attended). Now, I'm finding myself slowly reactivating and building on that knowledge using Duolingo, to the point that I should be able to strike up basic conversations fairly soon.
Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by bdcravens on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:05AM (#9692728)
It's worth less than some companies that provide even less value.
Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by rokhayakebe on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @06:50PM (#9696189)
Not really. The course can be free, but the certification paid. If every year 1% of the user base pays $50 to $100 for certification, that is worth $50M to $100M in revenue. I know there was a time I would pay $100 to get an English certification (before coming to the US for school). I also "help" teach French in college and privately. If they required a certification, I would not have minded paying $200 at that time to get a certificate.
Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by jfoster on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:22AM (#9692857)
I agree with your sentiment. There's no denying that they are a valuable tool for language learners, but they do not have the monetization figured out yet.

Originally they were going to provide translation services, which hasn't worked out. Now they're trying to provide certifications for people who pay a fee. Will that work? Maybe it will. What feels odd is that the valuation is so high for a company that hasn't yet figured out a reliable way to make money from what it does.

If all else fails, they could install paywalls, but a substantial portion of their users might abandon them at that point.

Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by daniel-levin on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:02AM (#9692707)
>> Instead, the company is now using its Test Center certification program as a revenue source (the tests cost $20) and says that it has other plans to monetize.
Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by rawnlq on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:54AM (#9693119)
Duolingo is started by Luis von Ahn who invented reCAPTCHA. He pioneered the field of human computation: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tx082gDwGcM.

He can monetize this in a similar way. Crowd sourced translation service where the more advanced language learners translate books or something. It will be higher quality than google translate for sure.

Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by thraxil on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @12:13PM (#9693278)
The article explicitly states that Duolingo moved away from this model though:

"As a company spokesperson told me, the company actually tabled its ambitions around translations about a year and a half ago and hasn’t scaled the businesses or accepted new clients"

Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by wan23 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:59AM (#9693162)
Good guess, but the article explains how paid translation wasn't working so well for them. It seems unclear how they are going to make enough money to justify this valuation.
Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by jgalt212 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:50AM (#9693085)
Not to be trite, but they can (not saying they do) make good coin selling all sorts of personal data about their users to the highest bidder.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7698130

So it's not free in the free beer sense.

Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by hmate9 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @10:54AM (#9692630)
They provide official language exams right on your mobile device for $20.
Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by Someone1234 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:02AM (#9692706)
What does "official language exams" mean?
Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by ianstallings on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @01:12PM (#9693727)
Have you used it? It's much more than that. It's actually quite a good learning tool for more than just languages. The system is smart.
Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by philipjoubert on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:04AM (#9692718)
They also monetize with a paid translation service. The service is exposed as challenges to users and in effect they crowd translate stuff.
Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by jfoster on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:10AM (#9692764)
Read the last part of the article. They still do that for CNN, but are not taking on new customers for that service.
Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by talideon on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:00AM (#9692687)
Not at all, because the free language tool is just half of what they do. The part that actually makes the money is crowdsourced translations, which are done by more advanced students as practice.
Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by cshimmin on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:11AM (#9692778)
Actually from the posted article, it sounds like they've been phasing out the translation-as-a-service part of their business for over a year now. Their reasoning is that "eventually businesses tend to pay more attention to the parts of the company that are profitable," and they want to be an education company, not a translation company.

Evidently they're planning to make money from paid certification tests and they have "other plans to monetize".

Re:Duolingo Raises $45M, Now Valued at $470M by jamisteven on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @10:52AM (#9692609)
Indeed.