News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by sopooneo on Friday June 05, 2015 @10:33AM (#9665736)
Could it be that actually getting things done in horrible environments requires interacting with, and paying off, some shady people? This is of course a charitable guess, but could it be that the Red Cross has made a decision to make morally questionable choices in the short term in support of the greater good, and they know they can't publish such truths and continue to exist?
Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by KingMob on Friday June 05, 2015 @11:04AM (#9665936)
Perhaps, but I have a friend who worked in water quality in Haiti after the earthquake, and it's possible to get things done even with corruption and graft present.

More likely, the Red Cross is one of many charitable organizations with low direct payout (combined with inexperience on the ground). This is a notorious problem, and was enabled by an earlier era of no-questions-asked donations. But in recent years, big investors have demanded much more accounting of the money, and some organizations aren't up to the increased scrutiny.

Check out http://www.charitynavigator.org/ for more.

Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by jimrandomh on Friday June 05, 2015 @11:14AM (#9665984)
No, don't go to Charity Navigator, go to Givewell (http://www.givewell.com). The quality of their research is much better, and they focus on the question that really matters: what effect your donation will have on the margin.
Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by ceejayoz on Friday June 05, 2015 @11:33AM (#9666106)
So now we need a Charity Navigator Navigator?
Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by mlrtime on Friday June 05, 2015 @01:17PM (#9666672)
Great, as if I didn't need more excuses not to give money. I think I stick to the local community soup kitchen/churches even though I'm not religious.
Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by jimrandomh on Friday June 05, 2015 @01:40PM (#9666797)
It's good to do things where you can witness and verify what's going on, but soup kitchens are many orders of magnitude less effective than distributing insecticide-treated bednets to combat malaria, or Givewell's other recommended charities.
Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by gajomi on Friday June 05, 2015 @02:19PM (#9667065)
soup kitchens and bednet distribution programs are trying to solve two different sets of problems, so I am not sure what you mean when you say that one is 'orders of magnitude less effective' than the other
Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by rwallace on Friday June 05, 2015 @06:29PM (#9668607)
The problem with all the talk about 'effective charity' is that it invariably focuses on magnitude while ignoring sign. The great thing about donating to local soup kitchens as opposed to interfering in other people's countries thousands of miles away where we know little or nothing about what's really going on is that there is a much better chance of being able to verify that all the activity is doing more good than harm.
Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by astrofinch on Friday June 05, 2015 @11:02PM (#9669445)
A priori, it seems quite plausible to me that Sub-Saharan Africans find insecticide-treated bed nets significantly helpful for guarding against malaria, and rather implausible that they find them significantly harmful. You can invent far-fetched stories about how anti-malaria nets are somehow harmful, but you can do the same for soup kitchens.
Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by cpr on Saturday June 06, 2015 @12:24AM (#9669662)
Apparently, they use them for fishing in some areas, which causes a lot of environmental damage given the insecticide-laden netting. You just can't win.
Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by astrofinch on Sunday June 07, 2015 @05:05PM (#9676363)
Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by yardie on Friday June 05, 2015 @04:29PM (#9667918)
Wait, are you saying that soup kitchens are ineffective at combating malaria (which goes without saying)? Or are they simply ineffective at the problem they are trying to solve, hunger?
Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by uxp on Friday June 05, 2015 @06:04PM (#9668488)
We're obviously Min/Maxing charitable giving. Why would you give to a local soup kitchen where you can see the effects, and even donate time and labor when the cost/benefit ratio is so much less than giving money to far away lands for cheap materials that protect against incredibly deadly diseases, which is obviously a better option?

Or, every one of us could do something different, instead of loading all our eggs in one Red-Cross basket? Sorry. I don't see a reason for this disagreement. Anyone that donates time and/or money to help other people, whether they are on the corner of the street they are standing on right now, or literally thousands of miles away, is a good person in my book.

Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by byjess on Friday June 05, 2015 @11:43AM (#9666173)
Charity Navigator Navigator is actually funded by Dow Chemical, FYI.
Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by skillachie on Friday June 05, 2015 @02:07PM (#9666983)
They are just lining their pockets hence their reluctance to be fully transparent.

1)Set up a few small projects 2)Take a few pictures 3)Create a few press articles to appear as if all funds are being sent to the people in need

Rinse and repeat when the next disaster hits.

All charity based organizations should have no problem being fully transparent. Do not make excuses for them

Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by sanderjd on Friday June 05, 2015 @05:22PM (#9668262)
And yet that doesn't speak to your parent's actual question, which is a good one: how does an organization balance transparency and the necessity to get things done despite potentially awful conditions on the ground? Certainly organizations doing longer-term work can afford to spend time finding ways to route around corruption, but that could be incredibly difficult in many emergency situations, and incredibly damaging for an organization's reputation when shady dealings come to light.
Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by skillachie on Friday June 05, 2015 @05:49PM (#9668401)
>>shady dealings come to light.

Most of the shady dealings that would come to light here will be within the organization. How much time have you spent in the Caribbean or the "third world"? Time and time again I see charities pop up but just to take advantage of donations.

Its always easier to point the finger in the opposite direction when time comes for accountability. Expose the shady dealings and set the truth free. Then you will see the "shady dealings" and yes if the organization is indeed corrupt exposing the truth should hurt them if not close them down all together. Let the donated funds go to a more effective and honest charity

DO NOT MAKE EXCUSES

All charity based organizations should have no problem being totally transparent. Failure to show the impact and details of what was done is indicative of an opportunistic organization that may be corrupt. “Money and funds without obligations and accountability?...Don’t mind if I do!" That is the apparent mindset

Sad but true for a large amount of charities

Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by sjg007 on Saturday June 06, 2015 @01:00AM (#9669767)
Possibly, but you can be sure the IRS and FBI will investigate.
Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by madaxe_again on Friday June 05, 2015 @12:03PM (#9666244)
Unlikely. Far, far more likely, according to a friend who is very senior in the British Red Cross, when I asked her about how they use their money, is one of two scenarios:

1) They misreported how much they collected. Apparently they regularly say they've collected more than they have in order to encourage people to give yet more, and to appear to be "the big magnet charity".

2) They've lost it. This apparently happens with alarming frequency - money just kinda vanishes, and they find themselves deployed to some godforsaken corner of the planet with inadequate materials and funding, end up coming back, spend a month waiting back in blighty, go out there, still nothing ready, fly back... oh, we spent all the money on flights and meetings and figuring out how to spend the money.

Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by djthorpe on Friday June 05, 2015 @12:22PM (#9666344)
Hi, can you confirm that the British Red Cross is a different organization and more transparent? Ideally they should confirm this on their webpage, but they don't.
Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by ics on Friday June 05, 2015 @01:51PM (#9666862)
The British Red Cross is a different organization which predates the American Red Cross by about a decade– both are roughly 150 years old.
Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by onion2k on Friday June 05, 2015 @10:43AM (#9665795)
If the only way they can exist is by doing things so morally reprehensible that they have to keep everyone ignorant of their actions then they shouldn't exist.
Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by scarmig on Friday June 05, 2015 @11:13AM (#9665980)
"Morally reprehensible," in this situation, could be something like "bribe a corrupt official." If it takes bribing a corrupt official to save lives, I don't think most donors would have a real issue with that.

However, admitting that publically would embarrass the official (if named), remove the efficacy of all future bribes (which are by nature secret), and could even open the organization up to legal action.

I don't, FWIW, think that's what's going on here, but it's a plausible enough line. Certainly better than "I already told you everything you need to know!"

Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by Alupis on Friday June 05, 2015 @11:59AM (#9666224)
> If it takes bribing a corrupt official to save lives, I don't think most donors would have a real issue with that.

Except in this case it seems they bribed so many corrupt officials that there was nothing left for actual aide...

I think it's far more plausible they just waste the money away on "Administrative" fees and project mismanagement at enormous scale.

This is a "charitable" organization which has run rampant and unchecked for a long, long time. Nobody has dared to question the organization before because of the stone wall of "charitable projects and relief" they've constructed.

The fact that they are a "not-for-profit" foundation that survives on donations (2.9 Billion USD in 2014) yet wont disclose financials really turns me off. I can't help but feel there is corruption within the organization leading to purposeful waste of income as well as possible embezzlement by high ranking executives.

Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by Lawtonfogle on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:33PM (#9667596)
When people expect you to pay far below market rates for management (and sometimes expect it to be volunteer only), it is inevitable that you will suffer massive mismanagement. Even organizations with great management make massive expensive blunders.
Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by reagency on Friday June 05, 2015 @11:19PM (#9669490)
ARC pays massive salaries
Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by Lawtonfogle on Monday June 08, 2015 @10:06AM (#9679114)
Compared to what the private industry would pay for the same set of skills? Massive doesn't mean much if it is still a fraction of what those skills would otherwise be valued.
Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by Alupis on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:15AM (#9692808)
The Red Cross is private industry...
Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by scarmig on Friday June 05, 2015 @02:19PM (#9667064)
Agree wholeheartedly.

Something about non-profits seem to make them sacrosanct. If you criticize them among friends, it's almost certain that someone will rip into you for being miserly and not caring about the poor $VICTIMS.

Cynically, I think the root of this tendency is the fact that many people don't care about the efficacy of a donation, as such, but only about how it indicates the giver is a morally superior being, over all those non-givers. Whether the organization blows the money on coke and hookers (or, more plausibly, ineffective staffing and programs) is besides the point.

Especially organizations with powerful brands, like the Red Cross.

Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by noonespecial on Friday June 05, 2015 @12:09PM (#9666272)
If I were a "big bad charity" I'd much rather spend my millions hiring Blackwater to go bust a few corrupt heads than pay them off. If we're going down the conspiracy theory path, at least make it exciting!
Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by scarmig on Friday June 05, 2015 @02:25PM (#9667116)
Actually, a charity devoted to rooting out corruption in developing countries would probably end up being one of the most efficient and effective for raising living standards.

Hire someone to offer the bribe. Target a well-known corrupt official, and gather lots of evidence to make it obvious that a bribe has happened. Publish the results, get a scalp.

On top of punishing the individual corrupt official, if every official knows that any bribe offered might be a trap, they'd be much more likely to turn it down. Certainly makes the cost of bribery for bribers a lot more expensive to account for the extra risk.

Hell, you don't even need to hire someone. Just have an open offer that if someone can prove they successfully bribed an official, you'll pay them three times the bribe amount.

Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by MichaelGG on Friday June 05, 2015 @02:56PM (#9667321)
I doubt it. Right now, in Guatemala, they have an ex president in prison. And the current tax admin under investigation. And the vice president resigning because she was stealing all over. And on and on. Same thing every 4 years. It's no secret, nothing happens or changes.

Busting lower level folks probably won't fix anything. You'll just get mired in their terrible slowness and endless rules, pointless paperwork and so on. At least bribing folks, you can get stuff done.

Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by KJasper on Friday June 05, 2015 @10:58AM (#9665903)
That's great in theory, but should the people suffer more of Haiti because of these individuals? I'm guessing that none of these organisations could exist without compromising things for the greater good.
Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by onion2k on Friday June 05, 2015 @11:23AM (#9666046)
This assumes that the Red Cross is the only organisation that could help in Haiti, and that their approach is the only one that could possibly work. Neither of those things are necessarily true. If they're bribing people then they should report that - not the details (although maybe they should), but they should at least be saying "We raised $500m, and spent $50m on bribes so we could get the job of helping people done. It sucks but that's what we're working with here."

Also, at what point does "compromising things for the greater good" become untenable? To go down the argumentum ad absurdum route, if we learned that the Red Cross were hiring contract killers to eliminate officials that were standing in the way of building homes for Haitians would that be something they shouldn't do, or that they should do but they should keep quiet about? At some point it is right to say "Let's not do that even if it means people will suffer." That's definitely before killing people, obviously, but is it before bribing people?

Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by fnordfnordfnord on Friday June 05, 2015 @01:22PM (#9666695)
You may be a bit too charitable to the ARC. This is not the first time that these kinds of questions have been raised about ARC disaster relief projects and gone unanswered.

>>$170 million providing shelter

>>the number of permanent homes the charity has built is six.

I know their primary mission is not housing, but that is a large number for some tents and a vanishingly small number of houses. Where did the rest of the money go?

Re:In Search of the Red Cross' $500M in Haiti Relief by cpeterso on Friday June 05, 2015 @04:06PM (#9667789)
If they need to bribe people, they could hide that in some "Administrative fees" budget item. They could still disclose how much they spend on projects and aid.