News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by kmicklas on Thursday June 04, 2015 @04:51PM (#9661958)
Do these guys seriously not realize that "the terrorists" will use end-to-end encryption whether it's legal or not? This literally makes no sense to me unless "the terrorists" is code for "the local weed dealer".
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by Igglyboo on Thursday June 04, 2015 @05:02PM (#9662025)
Once you make it illegal to do/have/use ___, Only criminals will do/have/use ___. (guns, encryption, drugs, etc.)
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by Roodgorf on Thursday June 04, 2015 @05:09PM (#9662080)
I'll take tautologies for 400.
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by jdp23 on Thursday June 04, 2015 @05:14PM (#9662110)
If we outlaw tautologies, then only the outlaws will have tautologies!
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by remarkEon on Thursday June 04, 2015 @06:44PM (#9662695)
Like Omar Little?
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by smitherfield on Thursday June 04, 2015 @05:31PM (#9662237)
Only a Sith deals in absolutes.

Edit: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wgpytjlW5wU

Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by nathan_long on Friday June 05, 2015 @08:53AM (#9665170)
Whoops, you just made an absolute statement.

Whoops, so did I.

Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by shkkmo on Thursday June 04, 2015 @05:43PM (#9662325)
So... you're saying you're a Sith?
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by smitherfield on Thursday June 04, 2015 @06:19PM (#9662522)
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by worklogin on Thursday June 04, 2015 @05:25PM (#9662177)
It's an important one to know when the blank is something already ubiquitous or easy to obtain, like guns, drugs, and encryption (in the US).
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by felipeerias on Thursday June 04, 2015 @05:47PM (#9662352)
Of course they do: that's why simply running Tor qualifies you for extra attention from their side.

Remember that they decide who to murder using metadata. A world where only "evil people" used encription would be ideal: they would know who to bomb right away!

Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by josu on Thursday June 04, 2015 @05:54PM (#9662393)
Remember that it's pretty much impossible to decipher a message, but it's trivial to tell if a message is encrypted or not.

Once you outlaw encryption all encrypted communications will be illegal and the people that use them terrorists.

This is how it begins.

Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by woodman on Thursday June 04, 2015 @08:06PM (#9663058)
It isn't trivial actually. Detection would be a multipass process, the first pass would be a measurement of entropy, which would also flag compressed data (which would be very common). The second pass being magic number detection (file headers, can't be trusted). The third pass would likely be some sort of conformance test to every know compression format. The result of all this io intensive processing would not be a definitive answer.

If you want to get a taste of how difficult it would be to implement some method of detection, with a useful detection rate at scale, try to write some software that can detect localization encoding of strings on a binary stream. There is a reason why automatic translation of unknown localization doesn't really exist, there have been plenty of attempts, but nothing that results in a definitive answer.

I once wrote some software that would parse very poorly written csv files, it was one of the most frustrating projects I've ever done - and taught me the value of standards conformance. Basically, if the data source is non-cooperative, you aren't going to be able to reliably use the data.

Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by kryps on Thursday June 04, 2015 @06:02PM (#9662427)
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by staunch on Thursday June 04, 2015 @06:11PM (#9662473)
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by zyxley on Thursday June 04, 2015 @06:14PM (#9662497)
I imagine it wouldn't be too hard to take encrypted text and transform it into something indistinguishable from the already unintelligible spam emails that pass through global networks en masse every day.
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by spacemanmatt on Friday June 05, 2015 @08:54AM (#9665174)
Some say this has already happened.
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by click170 on Thursday June 04, 2015 @06:23PM (#9662552)
Do you have any supporting evidence?

I believe it may be incorrect because in my (limited) understanding, good encryption is indistinguishable from random sequences of characters.

How can you tell a string of random characters is simply random, or is an encrypted message, unless said encryption includes some kind of header or marker information?

I may simply be wrong but I'm curious about the answer too.

Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by ipsin on Thursday June 04, 2015 @07:06PM (#9662785)
You might say it's indistinguishable in a theoretical sense, but how are you planning on accessing this random sequence of characters?

Using software?

Why are you in possession of random data on a hard drive? A prosecutor will be happy to spin theories about what it might be.

How do you hide the possession of software you use to acess it? If you manage that, how do you hide the forensic evidence of "file access in random data consistent with evidence of hidden data or a hidden filesystem", in your OS or on your storage device?

I very much want to live in a world where these tools are legal. Otherwise, in the same sense as "lying to the FBI", they will be used as a weapon by law enforcement when none other is handy.

Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by click170 on Thursday June 04, 2015 @09:25PM (#9663331)
I see your point, and agree about the kind of world that I want to live in, but if I may be allowed to play devils advocate for a moment:

Just spitballing here but what if the software decrypted something as a side effect of doing something else like watching a movie. After all, buggy software is everywhere, perhaps that is just a bug.

What if that random file was a test input for a software fuzzing test. Is that not a plausible enough excuse?

What if the system periodically accessed data files [that had random data] to verify their integrity, you never know when data corruption might sneak in after all.

I totally agree that anyone trying to plead this case in court would likely fail miserably but the though experiment is interesting.

Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by indrax on Thursday June 04, 2015 @10:43PM (#9663576)
>Just spitballing here but what if the software decrypted something as a side effect of doing something else like watching a movie.

DRM movies are already encrypted. The DMCA does not seem to include an exception for law enforcement or intelligence gathering.

We just need an easy DRM format that allows content producers to licence and make available for viewing (but not arbitrary copying) custom content for specific viewers.

Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by cortesoft on Thursday June 04, 2015 @06:25PM (#9662568)
They will start making random strings illegal
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by josu on Thursday June 04, 2015 @06:56PM (#9662743)
As absurd as this sounds, I agree. Just look at all the 09 F9 controversy.
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by tripzilch on Sunday June 07, 2015 @12:11PM (#9675210)
Then we will use a different random string!
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by josu on Thursday June 04, 2015 @06:58PM (#9662752)
I was talking about a encrypted message vs. a non encrypted message, I wasn't taking into account random strings of text. But who would send random strings of text if not terrorists?
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by bigiain on Thursday June 04, 2015 @08:38PM (#9663164)
For some values of "random strings of text", you could include compressed video from porn sites and bittorrent.

How much would you bet against "the bad guys" already using those as steganographic comms channels?

Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by TazeTSchnitzel on Thursday June 04, 2015 @07:10PM (#9662808)
> but it's trivial to tell if a message is encrypted or not

No it isn't. Encrypted data is indecipherable from random noise.

Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by AngrySkillzz on Thursday June 04, 2015 @07:34PM (#9662929)
Yeah, but most unencrypted data doesn't look like random noise. If you run a few statistics on a packet/file/whatever and it looks random, you can comfortably assume its probably encrypted.
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by woodman on Thursday June 04, 2015 @08:49PM (#9663202)
> ... you can comfortably assume its probably encrypted.

Or compressed, so you'd need to be able to detect every compression format ever created. I imagine that any time somebody serializes a succinct data structure [0], you're going to have to add a signature for that as well. I'm not confident that even an organization with the resources of the NSA would be able to keep up with that, you'd have to make illegal the writing of data structure libraries. Of course, the optimistic bureaucrat would see this as an opportunity for the creation of another federal entity, like the patent office, where code can be submitted for registration and approval. The Department of Circumlocution™.

[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Succinct_data_structure

Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by drodgers on Thursday June 04, 2015 @07:33PM (#9662921)
> Encrypted data is indecipherable from random noise.

Which makes it noticeably different from all other (plaintext) communication.

Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by naveen99 on Thursday June 04, 2015 @10:39PM (#9663566)
Most communication is not plain text.
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by blfr on Thursday June 04, 2015 @05:07PM (#9662067)
Yes but it's unlikely that they'd be able to develop it. They rely on consumer products just like everyone else.
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by tadfisher on Thursday June 04, 2015 @05:17PM (#9662131)
Would this bill also remove all implementations of, say, RSA from the Internet?
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by hackcasual on Thursday June 04, 2015 @05:24PM (#9662169)
I'm going to make a wild ass guess, and say they haven't thought that far ahead.
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by oberstein on Thursday June 04, 2015 @05:38PM (#9662292)
The Arab world traditionally has had great mathematicians. I'm sure there is a bright young student in university right now who could write a good enough PGP implementation for the right price.
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by murbard2 on Thursday June 04, 2015 @06:03PM (#9662433)
Nitpick, but most have them happen to have been Persians, colonized by the Arabs.
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by skeuomorf on Thursday June 04, 2015 @06:20PM (#9662528)
Citation? Cause there has been plenty of Arab mathematicians https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Medieval_Arab_mathema...
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by murbard2 on Thursday June 04, 2015 @06:39PM (#9662664)
Oh for sure, but a majority of Persians during the Islamic Golden Age. I have no horse in that race, just a random fact I noticed while reading about each.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Medieval_Persian_mathe...

Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by Kalium on Thursday June 04, 2015 @05:01PM (#9662016)
As I understand it, real life terrorists are rarely competent enough to make this a major worry.
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by TeMPOraL on Thursday June 04, 2015 @05:26PM (#9662187)
That would be Hollywood terrorists, or media channel terrorists. Real terrorists are organized and will use whatever they need to further their goals. It's also known that terrorist groups are recruiting lots of engineers.

Moreover, organized crime groups, which in real life are much more serious problem, are quite adept with advanced technology. They set up their own radio communications networks and use aerial and submersible drones.

Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by dragonwriter on Thursday June 04, 2015 @05:28PM (#9662200)
> Moreover, organized crime, which in real life is much more serious problem

Well, sure, in that terrorist organizations are, by definition, a subset of organized crime, so that the problem they pose must be strictly less than that of organized crime more generally.

Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by TeMPOraL on Thursday June 04, 2015 @05:32PM (#9662242)
Technically yes, but in practice people (and media) usually consider them as a separate group from organizations like mafias and drug cartels. I think treating terrorism as something "special" and therefore "more evil" is very harmful.
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by StavrosK on Thursday June 04, 2015 @06:30PM (#9662604)
There are no terrorists, there are just enemies who aren't as well equipped as you.
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by pdkl95 on Thursday June 04, 2015 @05:49PM (#9662366)
> Real terrorists...

...get elected as politicians or use their cash for more productive uses such as regulatory capture.

> Moreover, organized crime...

...simply used their captured politicians to make their activities legal. Why use cloak-and-dagger tricks when it is cheaper and easier buy the organizations that get in your way?

Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by TeMPOraL on Thursday June 04, 2015 @05:55PM (#9662399)
Mayby I should have written "real-life amateur terrorists / organized crime". Crime professionals don't use drones for smuggling, they use them for enforcement.
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by chopin on Thursday June 04, 2015 @05:23PM (#9662164)
Here in Germany, we have banking trojans wehich are able to thwart two factor authentication by SMS. This requires considerable skill in synchronizing between the hacked computer and the hacked smart phone. I am pretty sure these guys can come up with decent encryption implementations if these are not available as open source any more. And the latter is pretty unlikely. In the 90's all but the US people had strong encryption after all. Open source projects working on crypto where just moving off-shore.

A ban of end-to-end encryption will need to be enforceable. What will LEO do, if I come up with it? Bust my house? That's unthinkable in Europe. Enforceability also means that all communcations must go unencrypted. This merely would kill all online commercial activity.

Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by new_hackers on Thursday June 04, 2015 @06:19PM (#9662525)
It would make it much easier to avoid DRM, and to cheat in online games for sure. I'm guessing online gambling would be out the window. Also, I don't know if I would want to do any banking online.
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by Joyfield on Thursday June 04, 2015 @10:22PM (#9663514)
Well that can "easily" be solved by giving you a private key to use for your banking and e-com usage. Then "they" can decrypt it with ease and you stay "safe".
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by noir_lord on Friday June 05, 2015 @06:26AM (#9664733)
Until the lowest bid contractor who built the key storage system gets hacked or an admin walks out with an external hard drive.

Then you have the massive cost of re-issuing all the keys.

Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by jfolkins on Thursday June 04, 2015 @05:12PM (#9662097)
Another nation state (russia, china, etc) would be all too happy to sell crypto if there was market demand.
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by TeMPOraL on Thursday June 04, 2015 @05:29PM (#9662213)
There is no need to sell anything. Even if suddenly the entire world banned crypto at the same time, they'll be plenty of mirrored OS projects floating around the torrent networks.
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by shitlord on Thursday June 04, 2015 @08:15PM (#9663086)
There's always a need for special purpose cryptosystems. Something that simplifies key management (e.g., for banks) will always be valuable, and it probably won't be sitting around on some random dude's hard drive.
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by superuser2 on Thursday June 04, 2015 @05:10PM (#9662083)
They probably do. Having only "the terrorists" using encryption would make them much easier to spot. Encrypted traffic from your IP could become probable cause for a search warrant.
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by sandmansandine on Thursday June 04, 2015 @05:47PM (#9662357)
As I understand it they don't exactly need a search warrant currently. http://www.forbes.com/sites/andygreenberg/2013/06/20/leaked-...
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by jules on Thursday June 04, 2015 @05:41PM (#9662310)
You can easily hide encrypted data in other data.
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by TeMPOraL on Thursday June 04, 2015 @06:15PM (#9662507)
I wonder if they could see through that given the inherent randomness of encrypted data. In such a world, "random is resistance".

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aE6RtzwVdHI

Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by tormeh on Thursday June 04, 2015 @08:19PM (#9663098)
How easy is it to tell encrypted and compressed material apart? There would be little structure in both, I think.
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by TeMPOraL on Thursday June 04, 2015 @08:30PM (#9663142)
You're right, I forgot about that.

Since you brought it up, I wonder if encryption and compression aren't both instances of a common mathematical phenomena. They seem very similar to each other.

Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by naveen99 on Thursday June 04, 2015 @10:35PM (#9663553)
No. You can have a general purpose encryption algorithm , but not a general compression algorithm. Encryption generally requires increasing data size. Compression requires decreasing data size and is not possible in the general case.
Re:FBI: Companies should help us ‘prevent encryption above a... by Lawtonfogle on Friday June 05, 2015 @10:27AM (#9665699)
>Encrypted traffic from your IP could become probable cause for a search warrant.

We might as well say that not consenting to a search is probable cause for a search warrant.