> "People are treating Google like their most trusted friend. Should they be?"
> "I think judgment matters. If you have something that you don’t want anyone to know, maybe you shouldn’t be doing it in the first place. But if you really need that kind of privacy, the reality is that search engines, including Google, do retain this information for some time. And it’s important, for example, that we are all subject in the United States to the Patriot Act. It is possible that information could be made available to the authorities."
But that never got play back then, so we get the incomplete quote everywhere. It took Edward Snowden to make the tech blogs finally change narrative.
If Google don't track/store what I search for, what results I click through to, etc, it doesn't matter what the US government asks them for - they are technically unable to hand over data they don't have.
For example Google Analytics: if that product didn't exist the government couldn't just ask Google to install tracking scripts on half the websites in the world without anybody noticing.
You could argue that the government could force Google to create and market Google Analytics. But that just re-enforces the idea that we shouldn't be using Google Analytics - we don't even know if it isn't entirely a program created at the request of the US government (I don't actually believe this, but it's where you end up if you start worrying about the government forcing Google to change their business).
Which.... is true anyway, regardless of the potential for government-enforced data collection.
Schmidt (and Google) are extremely pro-privacy and against sharing information with the government. Google must have like ten lawsuits going on at all times on the entire planet trying to fight intrusive data request from governments. They spend hundreds of millions of dollars every year to prevent governments from gaining access to their data.
At least with Android being open source, they have a reasonable track record of transparency (obviously, that doesn't apply to their search logs, which are still proprietary).
Privacy doesn't mean "don't share my data with the government".
> They spend hundreds of millions of dollars every year to prevent governments from gaining access to their data
Funny how you say "Google are extremely pro-privacy" and then describe the vast amassed personal information of users as "their data", referring to Google.
It's not. Not at all.
If some private data of mine (including, but not limited to pictures of my genitalia) ended up someplace other than on a medium I own, that data is no longer private. I.e. it was a privacy breach.
They are suggesting that the Apple IR camera is good because it improves the user "experience by syncing with itunes to play a song with the right tempo as you dance" as opposed to the Google IR camera which will result in sun-burn cream ads. What the typical person would want is no IR camera at all.
Agreed.
I don't know if we are disagreeing. Or perhaps you disagree with the notion that the ideal situation for privacy is when no personal collection is done?
Privacy is seclusion. Ruffling through someone's dirty laundry, but keeping all the findings to themselves is not "pro-privacy".
You're going to run out of superlatives by the time you reach DuckDuckGo.
There may be other reasons, but the QA aspect is enough that Google would have to hit the OEMs, even if Google wanted to promote open source.
Yet google has spend years propagandizing that they are "open" while Apple is "closed" and that plays right into the latent desire to hate Apple from those who got a PC instead of a Mac when they were a kid.
Apple is different because for nearly 40 years they have been honest and forthright and treating people different. Google says "don't be evil" and then goes out and does evil. Apple doesn't say it, they just don't do it.
The idea that all these companies want private info and thus are all going to be evil is cynical.
And it ignores the fundamental truth: Apple's product is really nice software sold in a hardware box. Google's product is your private info.
The business models couldn't be more different.
"cynical: believing that people are motivated by self-interest"
In a free trade, capitalistic society, companies are by definition cynical, because the ones that are not go bankrupt.
> Apple is different because for nearly 40 years they have been honest and forthright and treating people different. Google says "don't be evil" and then goes out and does evil. Apple doesn't say it, they just don't do it.
I was with you until that last part. I would totally be on board with you if you say Google and Apple are both equally evil because they are looking after their own interest. The fact you think that google is doing evil and Apple is not makes me think you're a bit too far gone on the fanboy side.
Android ships far more units than OS X/iOS and their derivatives do.
[0] GNU's Not Unix
I think the distinction is pedantic, but I think we can agree that Android is the most widely shipped OS based on a Unix-like kernel.
[0] http://www.opengroup.org/csq/search/t=XY1.html
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SCO%E2%80%93Linux_controversie...
It is, but no more than that of the OP and you. It's ultimately irrelevant to this discussion.
If you remove all the Androidyness from Android, it's Linux which is quite stripped down....
It's like a project that has no purpose.
"Evil" such as serving you ads?
> Google's product is your private info.
Better ads targeting using your private info - not selling your private info to advertisers/governments. It's evident how much you distrust Google, but don't spread and allude to FUD.
Google and Apple behave similarly, as far as I can tell. TBH, I wouldn't call either company "evil," but they're both equally unfriendly to users, IMO. I'm curious why you think Apple is less "evil"?
> And it ignores the fundamental truth: Apple's product is really nice software sold in a hardware box. Google's product is your private info.
That's not a fundamental truth, and it's a false dichotomy. Apple's products are both software/hardware AND private info.
>Nobody can really tell what they are collecting, what they do with it and how much of it they share with third parties (including governments).
http://www.apple.com/apples-commitment-to-customer-privacy/
Yes, this could all be lies, but so could literally anything anyone says. Either you choose to live as a recluse in the woods with no technology, or you choose to trust at least some corporations. That might mean trusting your search engine, your cell phone company, your car manufacturer. Heck, you're trusting your ISP right now not to do a MITM attack on you. The natural conclusion is that you should use strong encryption in everything you do. At this point, there is one company spearheading this to get it into the hands of consumers who don't know any better.
Again, I realize Apple isn't blameless, but there's an awful lot about their recent actions to show they are making decisions based on what is best for the consumer. I think that's a good thing, and it's hard to imagine why someone would argue against it.
The companies he Tim Cook described, that offer "free" services and data-mine/aggregate/sell your personal information to fund the business? Yes.
Apple has a vested interest in not collecting, analysing, aggregating and using the vast amounts of private information other companies do: they're seen by many as a premium brand, where you pay a bit more and get a better product/experience. Part of that is not getting "maybe you'd like X" emails from the App Store, or "Hey do you need a new printer for that Mac you just bought on Apple.com" type shit.
> and we are all prepared to give them some of our private information if what we get in return is worth it.
You might be. "We" are not all prepared to hand over private information.
I use a fair variety of google products on a couple of different platforms and have for years. Google has never sent me a suggest-sell email. They don't hide the fact that they're in the advertising and marketing business, but they're not that unsubtle.
Perhaps other people get suggest-sell emails from Google, but it's not something I've seen (or heard people complain about).
Did I say it was Google doing this?
One of my pet hates is people who imply something, then use "but I didn't LITERALLY write the exact words that say that". You can play that game forever - for instance, where in my first reply to you did I explicitly mention that you did say it? I never said you did.
Isn't implication a wonderfully deniable building-block of human communication?
> I’m speaking to you from Silicon Valley, where some of the most prominent and successful companies have built their businesses by lulling their customers into complacency about their personal information
> where in my first reply to you did I explicitly mention that you did say it
You were the one who brought Google into the conversation. I said Apple don't send spamvertising emails based on App Store purchases, because that's a very easy concept to understand how apple could use the private data they do have (i.e. my purchase/download history of iOS apps) as a revenue stream.
I think Google should be avoided whenever possible, but I'm not stupid enough to think they're the only company with skeevy data collection policies at the core of their business model.
And just in case you are enough of a naif that you missed that 'subtext', if it can be called that subtle, the article even explicitly highlights that it was a swipe against Google and spends a paragraph explaining why. Cook was the one who brought Google into the conversation, not me. He just didn't say the word 'google'.
And besides, what kind of counter is "these were the literal words" to someone whose argument is "there is more to communication than literal words"?
But hey, "I never said you did".
Do you seriously believe that? They are doing this non stop. Not a month goes by without my iPad requesting my iCloud password so it can back up my entire tablet, even though I've repeatedly declined to provide it.
They are collecting and analysing PII data all the time. They need it because it's an arms' race. They will only stop if compelled to do so by governments or by a privacy scandal.
> "We" are not all prepared to hand over private information.
Unless you tell me you never, ever use a search engine (not just Google, could be Bing or Yahoo or whatever), I am pretty sure you are in denial about that compromise. You are giving away private information all the time, you just don't realize it, or you are okay with the fact that "Getting good search results for this query is worth Google logging my IP".
Apple prompts you to backup your data... so they must be analysing your data? Can I get whatever brand of space cakes you're snacking on?
> They need it because it's an arms' race
Google/etc are dependant on that information - without it they have almost no revenue at all.
Apple sells physical and digital products, and provides services. Almost all of these cost money to use, and the amount of data personal information required from the customer to provide those services is close to zero.
So tell me again why apple "needs" the data which they have repeatedly said they don't collect and don't want to collect?
> Unless you tell me you never, ever use a search engine
I refer you to https://duckduckgo.com/privacy & http://donttrack.us
It sounds like you have Settings -> iCloud -> Backup -> iCloud Backup turned on.
> They are collecting and analysing PII data all the time.
What sort of evidence do you have to support this?
http://www.imore.com/yosemite-ios-8-spotlight-and-privacy-wh...
Yes, they say they properly anonymize and location-scrub this personal information before they store, aggregate and analyze it (and I have no reason to doubt that they're doing that, at least for their own use), but they are clearly collecting it. And if you're going to talk about things like vulnerability to government surveillance, just collecting it in the first place is more than enough to open that door.
Settings -> iCloud -> Backup -> switch slider to off.
You don't need to supply any of it.
There's a big skip button.
Edit: This is a prerequisite for meaningful privacy. Plus having a pseudonymous account, funded by Bitcoins, for buying apps and stuff. Otherwise it's all based on trusting Apple, and so there's a single point of failure.
However, using ever-changing Tor exit IPs does trigger account locks, which require password reset. But that's arguably a feature, and not a bug.
But I do see https://giftoff.com/gift-cards/apple-store for buying Apple Store gift cards with Bitcoins.
I'll give it a go.
Edit: It seems legitimate: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=970780.0
I would suggest that this may be too small of a market to be commercially viable.
I'm sure that I represent a small market. But it's arguably a market that Apple must serve well for Tim Cook's claims about privacy to be credible.
If you google a bit, I bet you will find similar speeches from every single big company CEO these past years: "Privacy is our number one priority, blah blah blah".
If you think Apple is different just because Tim Cook has great speech writers, you're being naive.
All these companies are in it to win your private information, and we are all prepared to give them some of our private information if what we get in return is worth it. That's the game, simple.