So - people who were on Death Row that were then freed: The West Memphis Three [0]. In this case, it's been widely credited that the legal system was incredibly corrupt and a retrial just never could be done, since so many people made their careers off of it. It was a witch hunt. They sentenced teenagers to death. I don't see how that could ever be a good idea.
>So - people who were on Death Row that were then freed: The West Memphis Three [0]. In this case, it's been widely credited that the legal system was incredibly corrupt and a retrial just never could be done, since so many people made their careers off of it. It was a witch hunt. They sentenced teenagers to death. I don't see how that could ever be a good idea.
Isn't this addressing the symptom and not the cause? It sounds like the real issue is a potentially corrupt justice system. The death penalty if obviously worse, but you can't exactly give those kids the 15+ years of their life back either.
If you can propose an adequate remedy for the cause that negates the need to mitigate the symptoms, please do so.
Otherwise, yes, and so what?
> It sounds like the real issue is a potentially corrupt justice system.
Sure, one of the root problems is the fallibility of the criminal justice system (whether failures are do to corruption or other sources.) This is exacerbated when failures result in executions.
> The death penalty if obviously worse, but you can't exactly give those kids the 15+ years of their life back either.
Well, no, you can't give them the time they spent in prison back. You can give them the rest of their life that would have been taken away had the wrongful sentence been fully executed, and you can potentially give them some, even if imperfect, compensation for the part you can't undo.
Another possible reason is prevention of recidivism, and that certainly holds up.
Only as a micro-optimization. Prevention of recidivism doesn't bring a net benefit to society if it doesn't actually reduce the overall level of the crime it seeks to prevent being repeated.
Ceteris paribus, it would. However, there's no actual evidence that, with the death penalty, it does.
As summarized by the Catechism of Trent, a Christian religious text of historical importance:
"Another kind of lawful slaying belongs to the civil authorities, to whom is entrusted power of life and death, by the legal and judicious exercise of which they punish the guilty and protect the innocent. The just use of this power, far from involving the crime of murder, is an act of paramount obedience to this Commandment [against killing] which prohibits murder. The end of the Commandment is the preservation and security of human life. Now the punishments inflicted by the civil authority, which is the legitimate avenger of crime, naturally tend to this end, since they give security to life by repressing outrage and violence."
– Catechism of the Council of Trent, Part III, 5, n. 4 (1566)
For anyone unclear on this: the Catholic church vigorously opposes capital punishment.
Its a little more nuanced than that: the Catholic Church holds that capital punishment by the competent authorities of the state can be justified by certain circumstances, however, for quite some time, the dominant view of the hierarchy has been that the circumstances in which it is justified are never, or nearly so, present in the modern world, and that as such, while capital punishment is permitted in the abstract, it is never, or nearly so, justifiable in practice in the modern world.
I think another way to say this would be that the words "capital punishment" have two different meanings, and in the meaning we use for public policy discussions, the Church opposes it categorically.
I think it is a mistake to view the recent change as a change in the interpretation of the "only possible way", so much as a change in the understanding of what effective tools are available to the state. The opposition is generally not categorical in the way that, e.g., the opposition to direct abortion is categorical, but prudential in that it considers the actual conditions that obtain in the world and the options that are realistically available.
A good example of this is Pope John-Paul II in Evangelium Vitae (1995): "It is clear that, for these purposes to be achieved, the nature and extent of the punishment must be carefully evaluated and decided upon, and ought not go to the extreme of executing the offender except in cases of absolute necessity: in other words, when it would not be possible otherwise to defend society. Today however, as a result of steady improvements in the organization of the penal system, such cases are very rare, if not practically non-existent." (emphasis added)
Since 1980 (really, 1974), it's been the position of the US Council of Catholic Bishops that Catholics are called on not just to personally oppose capital punishment, but to militate for its abolition in the US. There's not much subtlety to it.
Correct (and corrected).
> Since 1980 (really, 1974), it's been the position of the US Council of Catholic Bishops that Catholics are called on not just to personally oppose capital punishment, but to militate for its abolition in the US. There's not much subtlety to it.
The subtlety, such as it is, is in the rationale for the opposition (that capital punishment is not a priori wrong, merely wrong in actual factual conditions that obtain -- relevant to the USCCB position -- in the modern U.S. [and, in the context of Evangelium Vitae and other similar pronouncements of the universal Church, more generally in the modern world].)
But, no, the opposition itself is not subtle.
But not all modern-day Catholics do so – as a Catholic, I do not.
Here is what Pope Pius XII had to say in the middle of the 20th Century:
"Even when it is a question of the execution of a condemned man, the State does not dispose of the individual's right to life. In this case it is reserved to the public power to deprive the condemned person of the enjoyment of life in expiation of his crime when, by his crime, he has already disposed himself of his right to live."
– Address to the First International Congress of Histopathology of the Nervous System (14 Sep 1952)[1]
See also Fr. George Rutler's article in Crisis Magazine, Hanging Concentrates the Mind (8 Feb 2013)[2], and Avery Cardinal Dulles' essay in First Things, Catholicism & Capital Punishment (Apr 2001)[3].
In short, there is more to the "Catholic view" than Evangelium Vitae[4], the 1997 Catechism[5], recent statements by Pope Francis[6], and statements by other Catholic writers and leaders repeating or expanding upon the same ideas[7] (all due respect being given to their persons and offices). The modern Catholic position, if you will, on the death penalty is something of an anomaly against the backdrop of what previous Councils, Popes, Doctors and Fathers of the Church have taught. As a matter of intellectual honesty, at least, I think it's important that Catholics "play with a full deck" when treating this difficult subject. Having dug into the matter, I concluded that the modern position is not sound, and so have adopted the Church's traditional view on the death penalty.
[1] https://www.ewtn.com/library/PAPALDOC/P12PSYCH.HTM
[2] http://www.crisismagazine.com/2013/hanging-concentrates-the-...
[3] http://www.firstthings.com/article/2001/04/catholicism-amp-c...
[4] http://w2.vatican.va/content/john-paul-ii/en/encyclicals/doc...
[5] http://www.scborromeo.org/ccc/p3s2c2a5.htm#2267
[6] http://visnews-en.blogspot.com/2015/03/pope-francis-death-pe...
[7] One example, there are many more: http://www.macatholic.org/sites/macatholic.org/files/assets/...
* (Deterrence/Protection) The modern state is more than powerful enough to prevent criminals from murdering people without killing them, absolving the state of the duty to kill in order to protect.
* (Restoration) Execution can't have any restorative value, because it's hard to restore any part of the spirit of a dead person.
* (Retribution) Retribution is a valid goal for punishment, but even for murderers, execution exceeds the justification of retribution and contradicts the teachings of Jesus Christ.
Everything the church has said since the National Council voted to oppose capital punishment seems to be in line with that statement, through four (very) different popes.
I'm not not Catholic and, like I think most people in my parish, I believe all sorts of things the church formally doesn't accept --- parity between same- and different- sex marriages, the right of women to freely make reproductive health choices, fundamental and universal equality between men & women --- and, similarly, you're free to oppose the church's teachings on capital punishment.
It is part of a larger plight of confusion rife in the modern-day Church. One of the wonders of the Internet is that it's not difficult to access even centuries old sources and compilations of Catholic teaching, and more recent ones as well. Sometimes a paper book is still quite helpful, e.g. the Enchiridion Symbolorum[†].
As a Catholic, I accept everything the Church teaches regarding human sexuality, artificial contraception, the priesthood, etc. More than that, I try to study those teachings and allow them to shape my understanding of God, the world and my fellow human beings. I think it's lamentable when that teaching is distorted, hobbled, or even disregarded and contradicted by those whose very mission it is to transmit it across space and time. Rather than get upset by such events, I see them as a call to action! The Catholic hierarchy, according to the Church's own understanding, is not the ultimate origin of teachings on faith and morals. Their "job" is to hand on and clarify what they've received. They can, for a season or two, fail (even spectacularly) to do so. The ship always gets righted after a time, but not without the prayers and efforts of those who recognize the problem.
Feel free to contact me if you would like to continue the discussion in a different venue.
[†] http://www.ignatius.com/Products/DENZ-H/enchiridion-symbolor...
No, its generally in line what previous Councils, Popes, Doctors and Fathers of the Church have taught on the fundamental moral question as to the role of the State vis-à-vis punishment.
To the extent it differs at all, it differs on the prudential question of whether the circumstances in which the death penalty is justified actually occur in the domain which each particular authority is addressing in their commentary (whether its the USCCB speaking specifically of the modern US, or Popes John-Paul II, Benedict XVI, and Frances on the conditions in the modern world more generally; this is something on which, in principle, Catholics may permissibly dissent from the view of hierarchy (since it is by definition not a matter of faith and morals, but of prudential judgement), and it is a matter on which the correct answer would be expected to change as the relevant facts change.
With respect to the teaching in Evangelium Vitae and the 1997 Catechism, the justification for the death penalty is essentially reduced to the defense of society from further physical danger posed by the condemned criminal. As such, it remains effectively silent on the retributive, vindictive, medicinal and expiatory dimensions of the death penalty, which have been expounded by the Church previously. In other words, a woefully incomplete argument is put forward which muddies the issue rather than make a compelling case for imprisonment as the better option.
In more recent years, Catholic commentators, bishops, and now even a pope have gone further and declared the death penalty to be "inadmissible, no matter how serious the crime committed ... an offense against the inviolability of life and the dignity of the human person", or similar. To make matters more confusing, such statements are often couched with others related to historical context and the "legitimate defense" ideas proposed in the sources referred to above. So which is it? Is the death penalty inadmissible based on perennial principles perhaps overlooked in the past? Or with respect to current conditions in (all?) modern-day nation states?
In all cases, the de facto "modern Catholic position" on the death penalty is unsound – either it is unnecessarily and confusingly incomplete, or it is downright contradictory to what has been taught previously. I do believe it will eventually clear up. Also, just to be clear, I do believe there is ample room for mercy, and the thought of people being executed saddens me.
That may be the case for "Evangelium Vitae and the 1997 Catechism", neither of which I've read, but it's not true of the US Council of Catholic Bishops statement, which I summarized downthread.
You might take a look at Cardinal Dulles' essay, linked in one of my previous comments.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3025718#up_3026567
Having that moment of execution seems to force us to check for errors in a way that life imprisonment doesn't.
[0] http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2015/apr/21/fbi-jail-hair...
But I guess since there is a tiny probability that we might exonerate someone sitting in jail until they die, we get to ignore that fact (even though the number of falsely convicted people rotting away is probably higher).
For the record, as a person who does understand probability, I'd much rather be wrongly convicted of a capital crime than a life imprisonment one.
I also don't believe for a moment that left wing anger at wrongful executions by electric chair will transfer to false execution by old age.
Interested third parties (say, the Innocence Project[1]) have gotten these cases overturned in the past. In any case, this chance existing is still better than the state executing its citizens.
Advocating the death penalty because it 'force[s] an appeals process' appears to approach completely the wrong end of the problem.
There are a lot of problems with our criminal justice system, not least of which is representation and due process. Eliminating the death penalty is one check that ameliorates (albeit does not solve) many other problems with the system.
> costs millions of tax payer dollars because of the long appeals processes
Well... yes, but the alternative is that you throw someone in prison for life (likely without parole). And since there is no upcoming "event" to force an appeals process (aka execution), it will just never happen. Is that really a better fate for someone wrongfully accused? If you are sentencing them to life in a cage, be honest and call it a death penalty.
So sure you can save some money by getting rid of the death penalty, but it is not likely to make Justice any better served, it will just make you feel better and leave people in prison forever without a guaranteed appeals process.