Re:Nebraska Abolishes Death Penalty
by mikeash on Wednesday May 27, 2015 @06:30PM
(#9614869)
True, but that argument is so bad that it hardly bears mentioning.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
You say that, but the retributive argument played a very important role in the recent NPR IQ2 debate on capital punishment. It clearly has some weight.
It's popular but it's still a bad argument. Cost, for example, is a good argument in itself, but just doesn't hold up against the facts in the real world. This contrasts argents which fall apart even before being presented with facts, like this.