Consider that zoning laws in the UK make agricultural land incredibly cheap. This means people with means can basically wander around buying the countryside.
So even if the laws are ever repealed or changed, it doesn't matter - you've just given a windfall to those with wealth.
I have kind of always had this thought that the real world has to eventually turn into a late stage game of Monopoly in which some people just own everything. If you have the resources to buy a large portion of e.g. all property in London, you can basically set the market rental rate because it's inelastic. The only option people have is to move away and try to jump start another city.
I actually think that a reasonable way to think of inequality is that it is bad because it produces negative feedback loops.
Firstly, it's a lower competition environment; those with less money are generally not able to become landlords or business owners etc, so the original owners win more and more.
Secondly, the fact that this happens results in more inequality and results in... even less competition.
Hence there is no need to invoke moral arguments; inequality, at least beyond some reasonable level, is simply inefficient. It prevents markets from operating well and allows economic rent.
The "this" is the wealthy buying up all rentable property, and raising rents until disposable income is close to 0% for many people.
In the past, I had a jobs that entailed collecting rent from tenants--and I hated the job. This is what bother me the most; I hated going to the door, or unit(mini-storages), and asking for that huge chunk of money each month. In every case, the family, or person was at the complete mercy of the Landord. I never met a Landord who didn't look for a reason to raise rents.
These Landlords knew the pain their rate increases would cause, and would hire guys like me(poor and needed a job) to do their dirty work. I think what bother me the most is when market rates went down--so many Landlords let their property sit idle until the market picked up.
I don't know the answer other than Landlords should get morality implants? I didn't mean to high jack stegosaurus' comment--I just don't like to see this imprisionment taking place so nonshalonant, like it's just business? It's not just business. Your business is affecting people lives on a very personal level.
It comes down to I don't want to live in a society that's so bifurcated. I see it happening and I don't like it. The disparity of income is here; I just can't keep acting like making money off the struggling, and dependent is copacetic!
(I used the word copacetic because when I was in school, I worked at a mini-storage. My manager who lived on the premises, with his wife, was the nicest guy. I saw how he struggled financially. Copacetic was my manager's favorite word. Whenever, I use it I hope he is doing well. I remember the look on his face when he had to tell people being close homeless, the owner is raising rents again. I'm even in denial. There were many people living out of their cars, and putting their few possessions in the units--they were homeless. Anyway, stay out of mini-storages if you can. I saw so many people put their stuff in and never get it out. They couldn't part with their stuff, and became perpetual tenants. Those were the lucky ones. The unlucky ones were already homeless.)
Good night people!
Near London we're living in a world where middle earners just 20-30 years older than us were able to get property at resonable prices, sit on them, and now someone earning in the top 1% will struggle to buy anything decent.
Further to that, the only property taxes we have here are council tax. Remove all the funiture from your property and leave it empty and you don't need to pay this. I'd argue that's backwards and what we should really be doing is taxing on levels based on empty, rented and living in, with taxes being prohibitly expensive to sit leaving a house empty.
Of course, being 40 and above has had left you with ample oppertunity to milk the status quo, so you're not voting for this and neither are those who inherit from it.
We know from varying urban policy around the world that not raising rents is in many ways worse than raising rents. If the rent becomes too disconnected from market pricing, the shock of any dislocation is life ruining. Dislocation is always going to happen, buildings get sold, they need to get torn down, accidents render it uninhabitable etc. Better to have the rent raised gradually so people can proactively make decisions to alter their circumstances than for it to happen all at once.
Those landlords weren't suffering from a morality deficiency, they simply recognized that you're often confronted with hard choices in life and it's best to remain unsentimental about making the least bad one.
How can bailiffs live with themselves? 99.9% of the time their job involves taking from the poor to give to the rich. The justification is some shaky concept of 'legal ownership' which is often just codified exploitation.
I would rather end myself and my family than do that sort of job. You are a direct agent of evil. Your actions cause massive anguish towards the poor and barely even move the needle for the owners.
What led to you taking the job in the first place? Had to feed the family? (Another reason we need to institute a basic income - a system that can force people into doing bad things just to eat is broken...)
Won't work in a free market. People will figure out what you're doing, and the remaining property owners will raise their prices until the buyer can no longer pay. This is why Eminent Domain exists, otherwise one homeowner can block a freeway project. It's also why the Hunt Bros failed to corner the silver market.
The group of people that can afford to do this can do it. Prices are fairly inelastic so there's not that much competition.
You can't just double the rent one year, but rents across the board can move in lockstep (and are sort of forced to as people decide x% yield is normal).
http://www.standard.co.uk/home/who-owns-london-6308427.html
Large landowners have sufficient economic and political power to fight back against eminent domain - and likely even with the support of their local people - so that's not a done deal either.
The thing is that there is actually an awful lot of land, and in the UK it is very expensive - the capital cost to buy it all up would be enormous, and thanks to the market only get higher as supply reduces. You're then vulnerable to other market forces and competing with other cities or areas. Canary Wharf is a good example of the established rules being upended and a brand new corporate part of London being created.
The value of all London property is currently estimated in the £1.35tn range.
One possible motivation for this is indeed monopoly or collusion - if I own a significant percentage of the shopfronts, I can charge an unfairly high premium (and then I won't care if some remain empty).
If I own just a few shopfronts, and compete with other landlords, I should care a lot if my shop remains empty.
Yeah, it amazed me, too. However, the guy who explained it to me makes part of his living as a commercial landlord. I assume he knows the game.
I first read up on Zell when EQR took over my low-income housing in East Palo Alto a few years ago. It's clear that his investment strategy is so unethical it borders on despicable. Zell's entire fortune is built on exploiting the REIT tax loophole:
Equity Residential, a real estate investment trust (REIT), engages in the acquisition, development, and management of multifamily properties in the United States. As of December 31, 2007, it owned and invested in 579 properties in 24 states and the District of Columbia consisting of 152,821 units. The company qualifies as a REIT for federal income tax purposes. As a REIT, it would not be subject to federal income tax to the extent that it distributes at least 90% of its taxable income to its shareholders. Equity Residential was founded in 1966 and is headquartered in Chicago, Illinois. (sources: http://finance.yahoo.com/q/pr?s=EQR, http://finance.yahoo.com/q/pr?s=ELS)
So what happens to a community when all of its wealth is getting funneled out tax-free? To just a handful of ridiculously overpaid executives who get tax-free compensation?
IANATaxLawyer, but this seems like a misrepresentation. Those who own REITs do pay taxes on any income they receive from those. It's just that the REIT itself is not paying tax first. Are you actually objecting that REIT income is not subject to "double" corporate taxation about which tax reformers occasionally complain? This seems silly, in light of how many corporations arrange to pay "zero" income tax.
Should it be paid for in the form of another tax? Maybe, but that is not always efficient, as you pointed out. So how else could it pay? How about in direct shares given to residents of takeover properties in exchange for their rent or rent increases? I like that idea better. Because whether it's rent or shares... they're both going into the REIT's bankroll; this might actually make renting an appealing opportunity (and create the good kind of competition among landlords) if renters could (or had to be) paid a refund or rebate based on REIT dividends.
Maybe this is what Eisenhower originally envisioned.. it was the 1960's and the Interstate highway system was still being developed.
Let the wealth and assets of a city/community stay in the city. Residents with more disposable income (especially low-income) tend to spend it locally -- or let them save to be able to buy their way out of the slavery of renting.
And the REIT does pay taxes to EPA, property taxes. If they have employees based in CA, they pay payroll taxes as well. It's not as if some faceless Borg is siphoning out the good people of EPA's money without contributing anything.
That is not how investments work. No one is "due" anything. You seem to be saying strong-arm tactics are OK on vulnerable populations because profit is at stake.
That sounds rubbish.
So basically renting would be more appealing if....the rent was less? Well sure. Nearly all purchasers off goods would enjoy lower prices!
If they were a normal real estate company (not an REIT) and they were based in Palo Alto with properties in East Palo Alto, East Palo Alto still wouldn't see a dime of any non-property tax.
the key is that we cannot control our own government...
I am at my core anti-libertarian because I realize that man is a social animal. But if libertarianism were to truly be applied at the national level, then the fed govt would have little power, and the local govt is more amenable to control by the people. Which might make things a little better.
Another problem however is propaganda control of the masses via the educational curriculum, which has warped the worldviews of young americans. That problem will not go away for a long time. I speak here of fake leftism.
> The article does not mention it of course but the reason parks
> and apartment landlords are able to rip off the poor is
> because the zoning laws all over america have closed off the
> opportunity to build more mobile home parks
The article does in fact mention this, but it probably should have dwelled on it some more. > ... tells his students they can easily increase the rent even at
> parks that are already charging market rates, because there is
> so much demand for affordable housing and local authorities
> are very reluctant to grant permission for new parks.The media never busts a money scam of the overclass until there is no money left in it. After all, it is the money scams of the overclass that provide much of the media ad revenue.
Who cares if you get downvoted? Please share your insight.
I would think that investors could make a reasonable profit building a gleaming new city with thousands of affordable homes, not fancy or luxury but stand-alone structures with garage and yard, what used to be considered the American dream of home ownership, with retail and industrial zones to provide employment.
Inexpensive cost of living allows for modest salaries and wages, which allows for lower cost basis for manufacturers and other industries.
If I had the money, heck, I'd do it. Driving across Arizona, New Mexico, and Texas, I saw millions of square miles of vast, untapped potential. A hundred new cities housing 100,000 each and providing ample employment would go a long way to solving these difficult housing problems, not to mention adding millions of net tax payers to the rolls, providing vast new opportunities for construction and trades, box stores, small retailers, manufacturers, service providers, etc.
We need to think a bit outside the box, or in this case outside the fossilized cities that have become poverty traps for so many.
Water?
If you want to develop more or larger cities in the southwest, that requires a megaproject--several, actually. You burrow a tunnel canal from the Gulf of California into Laguna Salada. From there, you burrow on to the Salton Trough. And you create a similar tunnel canal from the Pacific into Death Valley. That's part A.
For part B, you build some new nuclear plants whose energy output goes entirely into creating artificial clouds on the shores of those artificial inland seas, along with Mono Lake, Lake Crowley, Lake Tahoe, Goose Lake, Pyramid Lake, Great Salt Lake, Utah Lake, Sevier Lake--anywhere that has enough volume that the cloud generators won't dry it up between rains. For the rains needed to keep the freshwater lakes filled, you will have also build evaporators on the ocean coast.
The point is to "bounce" that rainwater over the Rocky Mountains, so that the vast rain shadow east of them gets more precipitation. Though it sounds like an insanely expensive project (it would be), by far the cheapest way to move large amounts of water over long distances is to build a cloud upwind of where you want the water to be, and then collect it from the river for that watershed.
The second cheapest way would be to move your water very slowly through an existing aquifer. So for part C, you also pierce the caliche in several places over the Ogallalla aquifer. The rain "bounced" over the mountains can then partially drain into one end of the aquifer.
http://ponce.sdsu.edu/california_average_annual_precipitation.html
http://energyalmanac.ca.gov/electricity/total_system_power.htmlThe freshwater sources wouldn't necessarily need to deal with the phase change energy, but the saltwater sources would have to be desalinated. It would still be a huge, huge amount of energy. And it would have to be added to the water multiple times, for each time it rains out before crossing the mountains.
Much easier to just build the cities closer to where the water falls naturally.
Water usage by individuals, for cleaning and cooking and drinking, is often miniscule, in comparison to industrial usage.
As for food, meat and dairy doesn't need to be produced in water-starved environments (and probably doesn't need to be consumed at the rate that Americans consume meat and dairy). Again, industry gets a pass and gets to socialize environmental costs that they simply shouldn't be able to externalize. But, he who has the money and the lobbyists makes the laws.
This is the kind of thing that markets can actually solve pretty well, as they allow people to adjust their usage to prices. Naturally, prices must be in tune with actual costs.
That's the real trick. Building a new community is a two sided market: you either have to convince companies to go there without a local labor supply or people to go there without jobs.
But as others point out, water may be the limiting factor. I have to believe, though, that there are vast swatches of the country that are close by to rivers or other water supplies, that are economically feasible to settle, and there should be a way to get these going, perhaps by unlocking federal land, selling it cheaply to low income folks (many of whom will turn around and sell it to real estate sharks for a quick buck, but perhaps enough will actually want to live there).
The article does not mention it of course but the reason parks and apartment landlords are able to rip off the poor is because the zoning laws all over america have closed off the opportunity to build more mobile home parks and cheap apartments. The fact that over 50% of all voters live in their own homes means that the politicians are able to sell themselves out to landlords and create zoning laws that prevent developing land that would allow placement of mobile homes. It's all about driving up property values and exploiting those who are at the bottom.
America is not really about the american dream of capitalism and entrepreneurship. The american dream of about using the government to put the squeeze on the unprotected ones.
I would go further and comment on trailer park demographics, but I don't want to get downvoted.