Disclaimer: Microsoft employee working on the Windows 10 Start menu.
Sigh.
My current workaround is to lock the computer and unlock it again. This seems to work but it's really annoying.
It only occurs on my desktop PC and not my Surface (which has issues of its own).
Any clue if there's anything I can do here or should I just wait?
And just FYI, we do look at the stuff that gets submitted through the built-in Windows Feedback app.
The start menu is great code but mom and pop dev shop doesn't have hundreds of top devs available :)
I'm not going to debate this, but I'll just try to assign blame. It goes one place: X.
As long as they all build on X, things will be suboptimal and I can't wait for initiatives and projects like Wayland and Mir gain more traction.
If you doubt anything I say about X, please watch this youtube video which has one of the key X-maintainers complain about how bad it really is:
Safari on Mac OS is extremely smooth, from the looks of this blog it seems Microsoft has replicated that in Edge browser. Look forward to trying it.
It's the old CADT [0] monster still at work. Windows desktop is the same old explorer shell which has been there since 1995? Only addition is dwm, which provides the modern graphical facilities. And Windows team has been constantly improving this same codebase for 20 years now.
While on the FOSS side, desktop developers are busy with the sisyphean task of rewriting or porting desktop shells and base applications again and again. OH, they've released a new version of graphics toolkit and the old one is deprecated. We must port the desktop now. Oh we also have to port all the applications now. Some applications were so hard to port that we've abondoned them and rewrite them instead. Actually, why don't we also rewrite the desktop shell while we're at it? Promise it'll worth it. We ported old apps but they're not consistent with the new ux paradigms of the new desktop so we'll rewrite them also... And just few years later when things start to calm down, there's a new release of graphic toolkit which will eventually deprecate the old version, ... oh not again.
Notice that I'm not talking about fragmentation or lack of resources. I'm glad we have more than one major DE, and I don't think more resources or less fragmentation would change anything regarding the situation above. Even with lack of resources, linux desktops had long long time to create really high quality products but they can't, because the ground below them is always shaking. Windows team on the other hand has been vetting, fixing, improving the same codebase for 20 years. They don't change the underlying toolkit every 5 year. They don't rewrite basic applications or port them to new libraries over and over (except new metro things, but they're seperate so my point still stands). Imagine what we would have now, if Gnome devs continued to polish and improve Gnome 2 and KDE devs continued to polish and improve KDE 3, just by using the same resources they've poured into Gnome 3 and KDE 4/Plasma 5 and their applications, respectively.
Again I'll emphasize, I'm grateful for the efforts that went into linux DE's, and I don't blame their developers for shit they have to deal with (although some are partly responsible for it)
That was a long rant and thanks for listening.
Well, as far as I can tell, lots of Linux people are hipstery special little snowflakes and fork things because some small thing isn't exactly as they want it, and that's where most of the fragmentation comes from.
Assuming that's largely accurate, why would it not be a problem?
What if we had, say, three major Linux distros instead of dozens of half-assed ones? How many tinkerer-distros does the world need? -As many as it takes to prevent Linux from ever conquering the desktop, it seems.
But seriously.. Please stop.
My above statement was specifically about the desktop environments, and DEs actually fit into your scenario. There are only 2 major DEs which have most mindshare, followed by handful of smaller ones. So there is not a bad fragmentation in that area (at least historically, there is now more diversity compared to 5 years ago), and the major ones have been with us for many years, AFAIK since late 90's? That's not only plenty of time to turn both of them into kick ass desktops, but also create wonderful ecosystems around them with high quality applications. Yet all we see is rewriting or porting everything every few years.
PS: Linux is widely used everywhere except traditional 'desktops'. Existing mainstream DEs are pretty good (KDE5/Gnome 3.16/MATE 1.8) and provide a range of choice.
Beryl and Compiz? I beg to differ. Besides a bitch to get running, and get running well, they were not at all comparable to Vista with regards to "resource consumption" and "hardware support".
At some point, "they" started to rewrite compiz, and it went downhill, until it was so slow I could not use compositing anymore.
I mainly use Firefox, the Terminal, Gimp and Libre Office. No performance problems whatsoever. And I have pretty old machines. An over 5 years old lenovo laptop and a similarely old desktop machine.
The obvious answer to experience those problems is to setup your system the same way as the people experiencing the problems, same h/w, s/w config, etc. You can look at the configs of people reporting problems on forums, in bug reports, etc.
They are all known issues but shell developers blame proprietary Nvidia driver, maybe that's why you are more happy with gnome shell than I am :) (Though I still can't get how cpu usage skyrockets when dragging windows.)
The overall user experience is smooth and pleasant. I doubt if Windows 8/10 would install on this machine (although it came with Windows 7). I have several Thinkpads of this vintage for the keyboards, not needing super powerful processors.
I know that gnome successfully offloads work to the GPU when I drag the windows [1] because I can hear it [2].
I don't have kwin installed, so I didn't compare.
[1] Yes, I also did move them wildly, too.
[2] My graphic cards has serious coil whine issues.
So much this. I really admire how performance of Windows desktop is optimized. I can't compare it with OS X, but when compared to modern Linux DE's (Plasma, Gnome Shell, Cinnamon etc.), Windows desktop still has all the same modern bells and whistles (hw acceleration, effects etc.) yet it blows them out of water when it cames to both smoothness and resource consumption.
I say I admire the effort on optimization, because things weren't that good even on Windows 7. I remember constantly having slight stuttering here and there on Windows 7 but Windows 8+ is completely smooth on the very same machine (which is now getting close to its 6th year), and this anectode shows that they must have taken the optimization seriously.
P.S: I'm not complaining on Linux DE's, they just have different priorities, and they're good deals considering their price.