News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by donohoe on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @11:58AM (#9532666)
Disappointed in you Jeremy.

Its fair for many here to complain about some of the online advertising practices of publishers.

However the viable alternative it to pivot to some form of subscription model. Its a hard transition and many orgs are making risky changes to do better.

Extensions like these are a step backwards.

If you value the work you should support it.

See bio for usual disclaimers

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by jashkenas on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @12:21PM (#9532827)
Sorry to hear that, Michael.

Subscription models are great, and paywalls are great.

What's not so great is creating an internet where if you use our Trusted Corporate Partner™ you're allowed to view a public webpage, and if you come from anywhere less privileged on the internet, you're not. That's not sustainable. Lest we fall into a vortex where you're only allowed to browse the public web by logging in through Facebook. I wouldn't want to be online in that world.

This isn't a complicated extension, and it doesn't do anything fancy to subvert any paywalls — and it's not going to. It simply reloads the page as if you had arrived via Google. I think that's a fair thing to do.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by arielm on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @12:34PM (#9532927)
I think the real "issue" here is that those paywalled content publishers want to get paid but also want the free advertising that comes with having a well indexed site.

It's a pretty interesting subject in my opinion because I can easily see arguments for both sides, and if we compare it to the real world we have the exact same "issue.

I can read an article that's on the newspaper's first page when it sits in the newsstand but I can't open it and look for any other articles without paying for the paper.

I think the real solution has to come in the form of a better subscription model. I usually get to paywalled sites wanting to read a single article so a subscription is a bit too much for me. If there was a way for me to get what I want by paying quickly, maybe using some sort of a federated payment platform (much like downloading apps doesn't require subscribing) I'd be more inclined to pay.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by k-mcgrady on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @12:54PM (#9533086)
>> "If there was a way for me to get what I want by paying quickly, maybe using some sort of a federated payment platform (much like downloading apps doesn't require subscribing) I'd be more inclined to pay."

Isn't this what Flattr tried (and failed) to do?

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by icebraining on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @01:02PM (#9533150)
Flattr is more about donations, not payments. As far as I know, you can't detect if the person has flattred your page.
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by donohoe on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @12:29PM (#9532889)

  ... if you use our Trusted Corporate Partner™
No. Not like that. Basically, its Google saying publishes must do this or they won't send traffic their way (via search result / SEO)

Its not publishers saying use Google over Bing over Yahoo etc.

  Lest we fall into a vortex where you're only allowed 
  to browse the public web by logging in through Facebook
The other argument that this may hold water is similar exceptions when you come from social (Reddit, Twitter, FB, etc) where they often allow access. However not for the reasons you're suggesting. In that case its the publisher saying they don't want to cut them-self out of the conversation (who'd link to the NYT if it was alway a paywall or would immediately count against your monthly free views before you can determine whether you wanted to read it or not...). In such cases those exceptions are factored into the economics of whatever the 'free views' limit is.

  and it doesn't do anything fancy to subvert any 
  paywalls — and it's not going to
Really? You could make that argument. However the screenshots you choose for the extension in the WebStore are all sites that have paywalls or subscription requirements. So that last statement is being a big disingenuous.

   I think that's a fair thing to do
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by jashkenas on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @12:40PM (#9532983)
Who'd link to the NYT if it was always a paywall, indeed?

Of course I understand that the publishers don't want to cut themselves out of the conversation.

But why must "the conversation" be limited to powerful internet companies? Do we not converse about news articles in blog posts? Comment threads? Up and coming social platforms that don't have Facebooks media clout yet?

It's simply unfair to treat a visitor arriving at your site from Google differently to a visitor arriving at your site from anywhere else. It runs against the grain of the web. To that end, if I hadn't published this extension, someone else would have made it. If Google removes "Referer" privileges from Chrome extensions, someone will fork Chromium to allow them again. Let's build a better — a more fair — paywall.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by snowwrestler on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @02:39PM (#9533910)
So publishers should either block traffic from search engines, or not have a paywall at all. Neither seems economically viable to me.

It would not be hard for Google to append one-time, time-limited tokens to SERP links to get searchers from Google to NYT (or other big publishers). Google would just need to provide an invite-only API for the publishers to check the tokens against in real time. At their scale this would be pretty trivial. This would have the neat effect of breaking your extension, and locking in special treatment.

Google would not bother to do this right now, because the referrer trick largely benefits Google (the typical advice is "just Google the headline"), and is not widely abused. But if people start widely circumventing both Google and the paywall (with something like your extension), then the interests will align and Google and the publishers will act together.

Google executives have said repeatedly and publicly that they want existing news organizations to survive and feel a responsibility to help them do so.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by MichaelGG on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @05:51PM (#9535191)
So your proposal if to make Google say "hmm, I don't really think you searched for that, so the link is going to have missing content"? Otherwise how are they gonna differentiate between someone searching and finding the article "by accident" vs on purpose? Sounds like a crappy user experience.
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by whatsgood22 on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @12:47PM (#9533027)
>Let's build a better paywall.

and hasten the death of print journalism

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by amyjess on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @01:55PM (#9533595)
I'm honestly fine with that.
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by gambiter on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @02:04PM (#9533665)
Yes, please.
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by _lce0 on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @01:03PM (#9533152)
> No. Not like that. Basically, its Google saying publishes must do this or they won't send traffic their way (via search result / SEO)

Links published --anywhere, not just Google-- for content behind paywalls are called ads.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by yuncun on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @12:35PM (#9532928)
Makes sense from google's perspective. Why should they list sites that people can't access.
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by fixermark on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @12:51PM (#9533054)
Listing sites people cannot access does sound like a bad user experience.
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by patcon on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @12:13PM (#9532775)
Not a fan of the shaming...

If news orgs value their journalists and the future of the profession, they should experiment with more daring models, rather than ones that simply maximally enrich the org under the same old model

EDIT: imho a model that falls apart legally under a browser extension that fits in a 40-line gist is nothing on which to base the livelihoods of a bunch of people

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by donohoe on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @12:34PM (#9532917)
I agree - but to be fair you're assuming they haven't experimented. Micro-payments, dumb 'capthcha' based models, memberships, events, "premier access". All have been tried in various flavors. Some with limited success.

I'm not asking for you to dream up an alternative solution, but don't assume this is a problem that has not been given a lot of thought by many organizations.

This is partly why we are stuck with things like "native advertising" and pretty shit IAB ad units.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by mapgrep on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @12:52PM (#9533065)
Even people inside the NYT know the pricing for digital subscriptions is excessive. They're high because circ department won an internal war and inflated digital prices in a misguided attempt to protect print subs. The NYT has experimented but is still clinging to the past.

Which is why the "All Digital Access" subscription costs more than Netflix, Hulu, and HBO Now combined. Give me a break.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by OrwellianChild on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @02:03PM (#9533655)
This raised an interesting question for me - how much money is saved on a per-subscriber basis by sending the digital version vs. print (for the NYT)? Their pricing certainly doesn't reflect it:

  Web + Smartphone:    $3.75/wk  $16.25/mo  $195/yr
  Web + Tablet:        $5.00/wk  $21.67/mo  $260/yr
  All Digital Access:  $8.75/wk  $37.92/mo  $455/yr
  7-Day Home Delivery: $8.90/wk  $38.57/mo  $463/yr
There are multiple levels of insanity here:

  Web + Smartphone & Web + Tablet are identical except
    for device type but Tablet is 33% more.
  Web + Smartphone plus Web + Tablet cost as much
    *together* as All Digital Access (and are feature
    equivalent).
  7-Day Home Delivery *includes* All Digital Access and
    costs about the same. Paper is free?
None of these pricing strategies appear to be designed to maximize readership, broaden subscription basis, or grow brand penetration. They are structured to capture the most value possible from customers with high switching costs or price indifference. This is what a conservator in a dying market looks like.
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by NearAP on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @05:45PM (#9535155)
On the smart phone, you don't see the comments for an article but the Tablet version gives you the comments. I can't say if the comments are worth the 33% extra cost but I typically end up reading the web version because I find the comments on the article usually interesting. I ended up going for the Web + Smartphone version because I like reading NYTimes and this was the cheapest I could afford. I've also found quite a few people in this same position.
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by untog on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @04:54PM (#9534786)
The reason that print+web packages don't cost significantly more than web-only is because print advertising is still a lucrative business. NYT can a a absolutely justify giving away the paper to subscribers on that basis.
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by OrwellianChild on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @06:29PM (#9535424)
Except, if that were true, why not just make it a free paper? Presumably ad targeting... I understand the limitations of their existing revenue model. It just results in some pretty consumer-unfriendly offerings, at the expense of readership and penetration...

---

EDIT: Went back to look at the numbers... They have tons of online eyeballs - those eyeballs just don't make much money. They manage to double their digital revenue with the paywall. Even so, it's dwarfed by the print revenue.

This may shift as advertisers see the value of targeted online user groups... I could totally imagine the NYT of the future being a collection of blogs dealing in Tech, Biz, World News, Local News, etc. Ads on the Biz site would be targeted differently than on the World News site. This might give advertisers what they want in terms of a differentiated audience.

---

From the 2014 Annual Report:

  Average Paper Circulation in U.S. (Int'l)
    648,900 (219,500) for weekday (Monday to Friday)
  1,185,400 (220,500) for Sunday

  Paid Digital Subscribers
  910,000 as of December 28, 2014

  Monthly (Annual) Digital Readership
  31MM (372MM) unique desktop/laptop visitors (U.S.)
  42MM (504MM) unique desktop/laptop visitors (WW)
  28MM (336MM) unique mobile device visitors (U.S.)
Off these eyeballs, they made:

  $667.5MM from print subscribers
  $169.3MM from digital subscribers

  $483.5MM from print advertising
  $178.8MM from digital advertising
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by donohoe on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @03:05PM (#9534089)
Actually, thats not true. A broad amount of research wen tin to this (originally at least).

There is a method to this madness :)

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by kaybe on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @04:03PM (#9534471)
Please tell us more!
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by binxbolling on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @01:33PM (#9533431)
Almost thought you were joking, but wow... nearly $38/mo to read NYT's webpages.
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by donohoe on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @03:06PM (#9534095)

   The NYT has experimented but is still clinging to the past.
Yes and No. Print advertising is significantly worth more than web. Thats not "in the past' that is alive and well (but declining). Still high.
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by mapgrep on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @03:10PM (#9534127)
Ya but then isn't it pretty logical that people use a browser extension to get around buying subscriptions that are priced artificially high to protect a soon-to-be-obsolete revenue stream?
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by patcon on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @01:55PM (#9533594)
You're right. I was hoping to clear up my support of his extension with the edit, but it was still lacking. I realize I'm a peanut-gallerian, and both of you two are working harder than I on this.

I support him because it shows me there's someone inside who's pragmatic and not letting themselves be deluded by group-think. (I am genuintely not implying you are. I don't know you.)

Paywalls aren't going to work as-is, and I'm excited to see a clever wink to that sentiment internally -- it gives me confidence that something better might come from inside players

> I'm not asking for you to dream up an alternative solution

And not my idea, but just in case it's not on your radar: http://wiki.bitshares.org/index.php/Potential_DAC_Ideas#Asso...

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by gambiter on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @02:11PM (#9533717)
When have micro-payments actually been used in any meaningful way? I've only seen companies complaining that they aren't viable. They were certainly quick to make the choice for me.

Otherwise, if people saw truly unique content from you (and others), they would be paying in one or more of the options you mentioned. They obviously don't see the point, however, because very little on the web is truly unique.

This seems like more evidence of the thing we all already know... large news/opinion organizations, especially those who started in print and are trying to maintain their business models, have become irrelevant.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by donohoe on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @03:09PM (#9534119)

   ...have become irrelevant
Please read this article:

"Cuomo Orders Emergency Measures to Protect Workers at Nail Salons" http://www.nytimes.com/2015/05/11/nyregion/cuomo-orders-emer...

That response by a state governor was in due to an article in The New York Times from a week ago.

Also, do not underestimate the amount of original content that these orgs churn out that other sites repackage and repurpose.

Irrelevant? Do some measure of homework.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by gambiter on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @03:38PM (#9534307)
I think it's wonderful that the NYT made a difference, but that certainly doesn't prove your point.

> original content that these orgs churn out that other sites repackage and repurpose.

What percentage of their content are truly original, first-to-break stories? Really, be honest. Now how much of their content are fluff/opinion pieces, rehashes of the last month of stories, and info that has been 'repackaged and repurposed' from the internet? If you try to claim the larger percentage is the former, you're just being obtuse.

You're quick to defend traditional media, but you totally glossed over the other points I raised. It's obvious (based on your comments here) that you have a bone to pick with anyone who doesn't believe your employer (and others like it) are worth what they think they are worth.

Again, it's clear based on market force that the PUBLIC doesn't agree with you. If they did, you would have seen success in the methods you mentioned.

> Micro-payments, dumb 'capthcha' based models, memberships, events, "premier access"

Whether you personally agree with me or not, the public is speaking, and they are telling you that your business model isn't worth what you claim.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by untog on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @05:01PM (#9534835)
It seems like you're arguing about different things. donohoe took issue with you saying the NYT isn't relevant, and you are stating that people's unwillingness to pay equates with irrelevance.

I don't buy that. Many new media sites don't even have reporters in the field - just lots of writers in a room that rewrite what these "legacy" orgs do. So if they disappeared people absolutely would notice, the connection just isn't apparent yet.

News costs money. And a functioning media is important to society. That people are not currently willing to pay for it doesn't mean that it's irrelevant, just that the correct business model has not yet been found.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by gambiter on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @09:08AM (#9538569)
For the record, my original comment never mentioned the NYT. I said, "large news/opinion organizations, especially those who started in print and are trying to maintain their business models, have become irrelevant." donohoe responded with an article in the NYT that caused the NY governor to take action on something. At best, that illustrates that they wrote a good article. It does nothing to provide an answer to my original comment. So yes, I argued one thing, and he argued something totally different so that he wouldn't have to answer the tougher question.

> That people are not currently willing to pay for it doesn't mean that it's irrelevant, just that the correct business model has not yet been found.

Just like the MPAA and RIAA a decade ago, they have been fighting market pressure rather than taking the hint and changing their business models. They want to keep the same profits they received from their captive audiences of yesterday, and they don't understand that people don't need to pay historical rates for the vast majority of the information they offer.

If the NYT fits that description, then I would love to see a reason why my conclusion doesn't apply to them. They certainly aren't relevant because of their name alone, are they? So I would truly like to know what percentage of their content comes from the real NYT reporters in the field, versus internet research, AP feeds, rehashes of yesterday's news, etc.

Joe Q. Public certainly doesn't miss out when he avoids paywalls. He typically gets better (and faster) information through his RSS feed than he ever has by reading the NYT directly. They might offer a unique opinion, or an extra line from an interview, but it's rarely vital information. He's not going to pay monthly for the privilege of reading an article written by a 'distinguished journalist' when it's really all about the information, not the prose. So what does that leave? Exclusive photos? Infographics? Op-ed?

I really don't mean to imply that journalists who go into dangerous situations aren't worth being paid. They certainly are doing important work. But to imply that the ones employed by one news corporation are any better than the others is just silly. They are all witnessing the same event from different angles, and I now have the ability to see the situation from the eyes of ALL of them through multiple sites (often within hours), not just the one who graces my newspaper's front page every morning.

So in the end, they have built a business on being a person's sole channel for world news, but the average person has many many many more channels available today. If they don't change their business model (indeed, their entire way of thinking about news), they will become unnecessary, extraneous, pointless... irrelevant.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by mturmon on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @08:04PM (#9535858)
This does not come across as very well-informed. You are replying to someone who is talking about the NYT, which, whatever its limitations, is probably the best daily source of the thing we call "news" in the U.S.

You say that there is little unique content out there -- but this a false statement if we're talking about the WSJ and NYT. If you are talking about the web as a whole, then you've changed the subject, and you're talking about an unbounded thing.

Saying the NYT is irrelevant is also completely false. Endangered? Fearful? Sure. A mouthpiece for the establishment? Often. Caught in their own thought-bubble? Sometimes. But not irrelevant.

Information and quality analysis have value - this is obvious. Coming around the other way and saying that because publishers are failing to extract the value, that therefore the news has no value, is a fallacy. Markets can fail to price correctly for many reasons.

*

Clay Shirky's original 2009 essay on "Thinking the unthinkable" (http://www.shirky.com/weblog/2009/03/newspapers-and-thinking...) was plenty frightening for publishers, and it did not need to exaggerate to make the point.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by donohoe on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @03:12PM (#9534140)
Also, not my intent to shame. And I'll apologize to Jeremy next time I see him if it came across that way. Actually, as I write and re-read it, it does come across that way.

Sorry.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by manigandham on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @02:07PM (#9533686)
More daring models? It's easy to just say "do something else" when actively circumventing a system. I really wish people would generally stop with comments like this unless they have an alternative to propose, otherwise its just criticism without purpose because the people involved in this industry are trying their best to make things work.

What does the size of the "hack" have to do with anything? Simple execution doesn't make something ok by the fact of being simple to execute.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by jameshart on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @01:41PM (#9533496)
The model doesn't fall apart legally because it can be trivially circumvented. Any more than the model of renting bikes falls apart legally if people just don't bring the bikes back, or the model of selling software licenses falls apart legally because people can easily copy it. You can base the livelihoods of people on these things, provided the amount of circumvention remains low.
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by patcon on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @02:00PM (#9533632)
I see what you're saying, but I wasn't intending to stretch my thought that far. I was just assuming that changing the referral header couldn't possibly be illegal.
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by jgrowl on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @12:39PM (#9532973)
Guess what I do when I hit a paywall like this? I get annoyed and close the site. Just because I click a link doesn't mean I value it. I would be just as happy if no one ever sent these links to anyone.

As far as I'm concerned people that let google index their site and try to paywall everyone else are the ones abusing the system.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by gambiter on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @02:15PM (#9533737)
Exactly what I do too. I suspect it's pretty common. I've never felt that I missed out because I didn't read a paywalled article. If anything, I probably found more interesting info in the comments.
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by supermatt on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @12:35PM (#9532932)
This extension simply modifies the referrer, overcoming some strange problem with certain websites where it alters page content depending on the referrer header - i.e. it fixes URL uniformity on broken websites.

I'd be all for this extension not needing to exist if these website owners would simply fix this obviously broken behavior.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by meritt on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @12:06PM (#9532716)
Can you share any feedback on the demographics of subscribers who successfully convert via paywalls? I'm curious how well it works with the 18-25 and 26-35 demos. Obviously this is a bit of an echo chamber here but I think a lot of us become annoyed and mentally boycott those sites instead of succumbing to pressure and paying.

Have you ever considered doing cross-promotions through other channels, such as the ability to round-up my Starbucks purchases and have the excess go toward a subscription?

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by DanielBMarkham on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @01:06PM (#9533176)
I used to be a freelance writer. I love writing. I wrote for several magazines, a daily, and a weekly. I even consulted at a newspaper back in the 80s installing desktop publishing capabilities.

I love printed media.

Printed media is also dead.

I wish this were not the case, and I know lots of folks are trying really hard to prevent its complete destruction, but heck if I can see a way forward.

Google is not the magic gateway to the internet, and sites that treat it like it is will have this happen to them, just like the sun follows rain.

I do not enjoy pointing these facts out, and I worry tremendously about the quality of journalism, writing, and online discourse. But the facts are the facts. This has been a losing battle long enough for all of us to figure out how it ends.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by bdcravens on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @02:00PM (#9533637)
Problem is that Google, HN, "share" links etc is free advertising. Media says that certain discovery channels (Google) should be let in, while other (HN, emailed links, etc) shouldn't. This extension only equalizes that.

Perhaps a better extension would be to hide organic search results in Google for pay-walled content providers, while leaving AdWords links intact. In the interests of protecting profit-based interests.

Additionally, Facebook should require paywalled content providers to pay users that use their integrated comments or click a like button, as we certainly don't want free buzz, as that would violate the profit-driven flow of information.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by manigandham on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @02:21PM (#9533784)
Publishers are all for-profit, they just choose different monetization models. Whether it's ads or paywall, content is content.

Why should it be ok for Google to discriminate which content is shown by the host's business model instead of the relevance and quality of the content?

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by bdcravens on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @03:01PM (#9534072)
I'm cool with content providers charging. What I'm not ok with is some discovery channels getting free access to that content, while others don't.

As far as Google is concerned, they're a business, not a public utility. If a content provider can choose what and whom to show to, so can Google.

The ethical approach would be to not be indexed by Google, but rather, use a pure paid ads approach (or a revenue sharing model).

To not have a universal interaction model is deceptive. (I search on Google, see an article, click, and use your nifty sharing widget, but those I share with are prompted to subscribe, and now I look bad)

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by scrollaway on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @12:24PM (#9532847)
It's quite a bit absurd to complain about technical solutions which fullfill the needs of users. If a source of income revolves around annoying users into paying and for them not to find a way around such annoyances, don't expect it to last forever.

In this model, I consider the whole tactic to be publishers relying too much on Google's policy in the first place. If they change that policy, said publishers are screwed. Anything that depends on a third party is doomed to begin with.

These things are temporary income at best. Publishers should not just "take the win and go home"; keep looking for other, better solutions.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by eli on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @01:32PM (#9533419)
> It's quite a bit absurd to complain about technical solutions which fullfill the needs of users.

Nonsense. Users want everything for free, instantly and with no ads.

I would like my sandwiches from the shop downstairs to be free all the time. But it's not cool to forge stamps on a loyalty card.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by scrollaway on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @02:39PM (#9533909)
> Users want everything for free, instantly and with no ads.

And where's the source to that little strawman of yours?

I'm sure users also want hot threesomes and a million dollars.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by eli on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @03:59PM (#9534449)
I think we're perhaps talking past each other. You want a source that says people prefer getting things for free over paying for them?
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by manigandham on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @02:17PM (#9533753)
Life and business is all about 3rd parties and working with and against them. It's quite easy to say that things should just be better but it's not like all these publishers are stupid and just sitting around not trying to come up with better solutions. This is actually the best we have at this moment without a massive shift in how the web works.

The fact is that the internet makes things very easy to take without repercussions. Physically walking into a store and taking something has consequences but a quick hack on the browser is basically unnoticeable. The abilities and democracy of the internet architecture facilitates the extraction of content without compensation. Just because it's easy though, doesn't make it "right".

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by scrollaway on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @02:57PM (#9534039)
> Just because it's easy though, doesn't make it "right".

If something is both easy and rewarding for those who do it, don't base your business on trusting people not to do it.

Consequentially, don't base your morality code on a notion of "people shouldn't do it". They shouldn't do it because it hurts businesses, but it only hurts businesses because they're foolish enough to make the first mistake.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by manigandham on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @03:35PM (#9534292)
I believe your foundation for this argument is flawed and doesn't answer my statement: just because something is easy, does not make it right.

"People shouldn't do it" is the fundamental way laws and regulations work. You shouldn't damage property or steal items or assault people. But you can. Very easily. And depending on when/where/how you can probably get away with it. Does that make it ok?

Actions in the physical world have very lasting effects and, these days, leave a big trail which allows the proper authorities to catch the bad actor and dispense justice (the topic of what is proper justice being out of scope for this thread). The digital world is much harder with things happening instantaneously with very little if any trail. If publishers could catch you, they would. Realistically, they just can't. But this lapse in their abilities does not empower and justify your abilities to do what should not be done.

Business models are a completely separate topic and, yes, it's usually good to align the model with normal consumer action. However, human nature is to always take with the path of least resistance and in the case of "value", to acquire it for nothing in exchange if possible. Most businesses work because they can block any access to that value without a proper exchange. Internet publishing however is very unique in that the very structure of the web which makes it so open is also what makes it impossible to stop and effectively filter anyone. The paywall is one such filter but they have this opening for access to Google listings and let a few users be randomly awarded free content. If there was a way they could be listed on Google without losing their paywall, they would, and this whole situation would be non-existent.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by Karunamon on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @04:03PM (#9534469)
But just because something hurts a business doesn't make it wrong, either. And it's worth considering that businesses are amoral entities - given the chance, most of them will gladly screw you if it increases their revenue.

With that in mind, why should a rational human choose to apply morality to an entity that has no obligation to do the same in return?

(This is not a value judgement on WSJ in particular, more a general statement as to the way of the world)

The way I see it, there are two arguments for this plugin to not exist:

1) "What if everyone does it? If everyone does it, WSJ makes no money and goes away". The appeal to utility. Problem is, it carries the unstated and unsubstantiated assumption that enough people will use this plugin to actually impact their profits in a measurable way.

Because of that, I call this argument invalid.

2) "It goes against the wishes of the content providers". The appeal to morality - but as mentioned above, this is strictly a one way consideration, and it's subjective for each person. There's also the moral consideration that WSJ has chosen to make this content visible for Google users, but only because Google forbids showing different content to the spider and to the human. Then, you're left answering an objectively unanswerable question - is a person who googles for most of their news and ends up on the WSJ often doing something wrong? Or does it only apply when you install the plugin and circumvent the company's intent?

The net effect on WSJ's profit is the same either way.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by manigandham on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @04:14PM (#9534537)
It's not about hurting the business. It's not just "wishes". That's the legal framework, also laid out in their terms of service.

You're breaking the contract that the content "value" is provided in exchange for something, either attention on ads or cash, depending on the publisher. This is what makes it wrong.

The real issue is that the internet does not allow for effective policing and capture of contract offenders. It's wrongs being committed with no consequence, but this does not justify it being done.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by Karunamon on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @04:28PM (#9534622)
But if I'm on their site reading their content and linking to their other content and looking at their ads, how am I not fulfilling that "contract"? Attention is what they wanted, attention is what they got.

That contract I never was given a chance to read, or sign, or agree to in any way, mind. Given that, i'm not sure how you can say refusing to do something I never agreed to do in the first place is morally wrong.

This is my whole point - the distinction is entirely arbitrary because WSJ obviously values the attention more than they value the money, else we would be having this conversation right now.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by ryandrake on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @02:44PM (#9533949)
There's no taking going on here. Taking something implies a transfer of possession, leaving one party no longer in possession of that thing. My browsing a web page does not result in such an outcome.
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by manigandham on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @03:23PM (#9534214)
Taking is not zero-sum. Virtual existence does not disqualify ownership or rights. Content is intangible but still carries value, the same way millions of people can have a copy of a song but it is still property.

Receiving that value in the form of content without compensation, either by viewing ads or paying money, is still "taking" it against the wishes of the provider.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by PhantomGremlin on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @06:04PM (#9535281)
Reminds me of the very old joke about software:

   Software is like VD
   you can give it away and you've still got it
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by petemill on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @12:25PM (#9532860)
This is a positive thing has been made, and I too have worked at publishers. You can't control these things and this tool prevents a user from having to jump through hoops to use a feature which is publicly available. Well done. You want your geek customers to have some chance of once-again enjoying reading these sites so let them back on them.
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by donohoe on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @12:36PM (#9532947)
No, you can't control these things. All I'm saying is I'm disappointed to see yet another one.

However I would much rather spend my time building new features then having to find ways to ensure a paywall is not circumvented.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by herbig on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @12:36PM (#9532945)
I see you wrote a Chrome extension that cuts most of the ads from NYT.
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by donohoe on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @12:41PM (#9532988)
Yes. My guess is you're leaving that statement hanging to make a larger point?

If so I'd love to add that I'm annoyed by some of the tactics and lengths that publishers go to to monetize content ad the expense of user-experience and other costs.

The only path right now are ads, 'sponsored content', 'native units'.

I would much rather we have a subscription-based model that generated enough revenue to ween them off awful ad experiences.

Thats very much an aspirational goal.

My larger point is that having readers circumvent that, as opposed to supporting that, is disheartening to many of us who are working on the inside to push change.

BTW: And that extension was a redesign, of which ads were removed or moved. The NYT legal dept had Google remove it.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by austenallred on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @05:46PM (#9535163)
> I'm annoyed by some of the tactics and lengths that publishers go to to monetize content

> having readers circumvent that, as opposed to supporting that, is disheartening to many of us who are working on the inside to push change.

So what you're saying is that it's OK to circumvent the methods of monetization you don't support?

He doesn't like paywalls, so he circumvents them. You don't like ads, so you circumvent them. And then you say shame on you? This is absolutely the pot calling the kettle black.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by hire_charts on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @01:10PM (#9533221)
I support subscription content. But you can't have your cake and eat it too -- in other words, you can't put content behind a paywall and also have it publicly indexed by search engines.

Remove the trick where it's okay for Google searches to circumvent the paywall and this extension becomes useless.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by manigandham on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @02:27PM (#9533824)
Why not? So paywall content is not good enough? It's just a different business model by publishers: free access with ads or pay for access.

Why does that penalize the content itself and the discovery of it?

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by hire_charts on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @01:49PM (#9540667)
What's happening here is that it's not just "free access with ads or pay for access." It's "free access if you came from google, so that google can index our pages, but otherwise pay for access so that we can put the same content behind a paywall." It's less a business model and more an SEO trick that Google puts up with under certain conditions.
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by manigandham on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @02:26PM (#9533813)
I agree with most of your other posts on this thread but why is it ok to just remove ads from other competing publishers?

It's their choice to choose a business model, whether ads or subscriptions. If they serve ads and it's not the experience you want, shouldn't you just move on and not go back to that site?

The ad model actually works well for lots of sites and is the sole reason we have the long-tail of the internet. Someone working at an ad-based publisher would have the exact same comments about your ad disabling extension, why circumvent if they're trying to make it work?

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by jneal on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @12:36PM (#9532940)
I'm a bit curious. I was under the impression that changing your site to show different content to "Google" than "regular users" was against TOS and could get you banned from results all together. Do big companies pay to get around these restrictions or have there been rule changes in Google Search?
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by icebraining on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @01:07PM (#9533182)
Google is OK with it as long as you show the same content to a user going through Search as you do to the bot. They don't care if you show different things to users coming through other sources or directly hitting the URL.
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by fab13n on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @01:08PM (#9533197)
The paywall model is currently broken:

* not culturally integrated the way we don't mind paying for smartphone apps;

* not atomic enough (we want to pay cents for an article, not dollars for a website, nor tens of dollars for a long-term subscription);

* it raises convenience and trust issues;

* it competes against ad-based models, which adblockers have failed to bankrupt until now;

* paywall sites aren't taken into account properly by Google et al.

Relieving pressure from the currently broken paywall model won't help fix it. Making the situation untenable is the only way to make it change. The most effective move would be to kill ads as a business model. Of course, don't expect Google, an advertising agency, to help us do that. And how to pay author while keeping Internet searchable remains an open problem AFAIK.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by untog on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @05:06PM (#9534877)
we want to pay cents for an article, not dollars for a website, nor tens of dollars for a long-term subscription

Is that true, though? I think Spotify has proved that people prefer subscriptions to one-off payments for music, for example. Having to make a purchase/don't purchase decision for every news article you read doesn't seem like a good experience at all.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by PhantomGremlin on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @06:12PM (#9535322)
Yes it is true. For a single payment to Spotify you get access to music from all four major record labels.

OTOH paying for a subscription to a single newspaper is like subscribing separately to Sony, EMI, Warner Music Group, and Universal. Not gonna happen.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by robryan on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @10:38PM (#9536426)
I think they would be much better off with the Spotify model. I would happily pay a monthly fee for a collection of all the major newspapers.
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by PhantomGremlin on Wednesday May 13, 2015 @01:45AM (#9537011)
That depends on the price.

I just checked out WSJ and NY Times. After promo, WSJ is $29/month. That's whether or not you want actual paper or just digital access. NY Times has various plans, one of the cheapest is about $16/month. So that's just two newspapers.

I'd gladly pay $20 or even $30 per month for full access to all the major newspapers. But the big papers would never agree to that, because their individual cuts of the pie would probably be too small.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by glibgil on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @12:38PM (#9532962)
Why should I support the work? The work is given away for free on Google searches. I value a WSJ article very little unless it is free. I want to support their work with exactly zero dollars. Why is that a problem? I would prefer that everyone working at the WSJ were just doing something else with their lives. Is it okay for me to align my spending with my values?
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by fixermark on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @12:49PM (#9533037)
That's a tenable position, but this extension should not be useful to people holding that position.
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by makeitsuckless on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @02:04PM (#9533660)
The free-for-Google paywall is in many ways similar to online advertising: it's all bait-and-switch.

Anything that discourages such practices is a step forward.

It's time publishers start considering their readers as customers to be treated with respect instead of either dumb cattle or the enemy in a digital arms race.

What kind of a legit, respectable business tries to trick people into thinking their giving their product away for free? At the very least don't whine about the public tricking you back in return.

Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by amackera on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @12:17PM (#9532796)
If it's really so concerning, then perhaps the technology should be made a bit more difficult to thwart. This extension is simply changing the Referer request header.
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by yuncun on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @12:06PM (#9532721)
How do you feel about Adblock?
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by zem on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @01:43PM (#9533514)
how would you feel about an extension that simply removed hyperlinks to paywalled pages, or highlighted them in a different colour? (serious question; I've been tempted to make one simply because I feel that publishers are welcome to paywall their sites, but then I don't want them on "my" web.)
Re:Wait, Google Sent Me by darkstar999 on Tuesday May 12, 2015 @01:20PM (#9533323)
And we are disappointed in your crappy paywall model.