What are you talking about? A startup that sells Linux distros? There are A LOT more reasons we don't see people selling Linux distros than just this.
So what does this have to do with anything?
If your argument is that people don't use Linux in the start up world that's wrong too. Plenty of start ups use Linux and I'd say it's about 50/50 when it comes to share between OS X and Linux. We already know from stack overflow surveys that OS X and Linux are neck-and-neck when it comes to developer use, and we already know that Linux is almost always the choice when it comes to servers for start-ups.
Is your argument that people don't want to buy Linux software? There are plenty of people paying for Linux software (especially enterprise) and you can just look at the humble bundle for evidence that Linux users are more than willing to pay for software. I don't know many Mac only start-ups that are very successful.
It's a matter of marketing. Everyone knows it's based on Ubuntu, so they feel cheated when they're asked to pay for a free OS.
A marketing solution is to sell it as:
* base system $0 - VM with free download, no whines about "cheating". And the base VM gets you an Ubuntu image which boots to a shell prompt.
* Elementary additions: $$. The base system plus our less-filling, weight-loss inducing proprietary magic!
People are happy to pay money for linux application. Not many people, and for not a lot of money. But people do pay.
Having happy paying customers is a lot better than calling your potential customer base "cheaters". That's just stupid .
The point is right now, they are asking people to pay for a free version of Ubuntu. This annoys people.
They should change their pricing model to make it clear that the base OS is free. And that their additions are a product which should be paid for.
Easy point-and-click installer: $$.
Unless one hits jackpot a la RedHat, or is doing consulting/teaching/web paywalls, open source seldom pays bills.
But sadly this isn't true in the real world. When I think of a Chef I think of a great cook, someone who doesn't need someone else to tell them how to mix ingredients. It's a disservice to the chef to go and waste their time at McDonalds, but it's pretty rare you become successful a la Gordon Ramsey or something.
It's not a very smart decision to put all that time and effort into learning to be a master chef just to throw it away at some corporate place where no one appreciates you.
But hey if you need the money and your food isn't all that great anyway...
And I hope you can appreciate how demeaning it is to call your time contributing to open source a "phase".
I still work with open source tools and do contribute occasionally with bug reports, bug fixes, advocacy and money.
Just don't believe any longer that all types of business are possible with open source. Many just don't go along with it, at least for those that want to their their bills.
This attitude is why we don't see Linux startups -- just volunteer efforts, run on peoples spare time that they eventually get burnt out on and give up.
They are asking for $10. They aren't asking for a huge sum of money. $10 could be a very reasonable amount of money for the effort they've put into it.
Yes, it's built on free software... but when I (and many other people too) build their start up on free software and charge money.. we don't ask how much of that is going to Nginx, Linux, etc... we say, they're charging for the time/effort required to build that service.
And just like how many startups would be forced to charge higher prices if they had to redevelop nginx, etc... elementaryOS wouldn't be $10 if they had to duplicate all of that work.