News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla battery storage will accelerate exit of coal genera... by jerf on Sunday May 03, 2015 @09:44PM (#9483904)
Not all electricity is consumed by homes or properties where "the amount of local energy resources" is within an order of magnitude of "the amount of power used by the facility". "Companies who provide lots and lots of electricity" aren't going anywhere; you're not going to run an aluminum smelting plant off of a local, plant-owned installation of solar panels, if for no other reason that it is a poor use of capital as a plant would not be able to invest to keep up in the changing landscape of energy generation.

While change is happening and change in inevitable I think you're greatly overestimating the rate of the change and badly misunderstanding the quality.

Re:Tesla battery storage will accelerate exit of coal genera... by toomuchtodo on Sunday May 03, 2015 @10:19PM (#9483981)
> you're not going to run an aluminum smelting plant off of a local, plant-owned installation of solar panels

You are probably going to move where the power is cheap though:

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-03-17/silicon-me...

In this case, Alcoa is performing aluminum smelting in Iceland precisely because of cheaper geothermal power generation available there.

Re:Tesla battery storage will accelerate exit of coal genera... by jerf on Sunday May 03, 2015 @10:35PM (#9484018)
"You are probably going to move where the power is cheap though"

Yes, as my pre-comment scan of the Wikipedia article on aluminum smelting (to double-check I had the right electricity-intensive industrial process) said in the second paragraph [1]. I didn't think it worth adding to the comment.

Of course aluminum plants move to where electricity is cheap, all else being equal... exactly what alternative do you think I was proposing?

Further, geothermal is significantly different for this use case, as geothermal can be used for base load applications where solar can not. Since such plants tend to run without regard for where the sun is in the sky, this sort of industry would be very difficult to run off of solar power without absurdly overprovisioning for power storage, which remains a significant problem at this scale. You are also not going to run your aluminum smelting plant for 18 hours out of the day on battery power!

[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aluminium_smelting

Re:Tesla battery storage will accelerate exit of coal genera... by saalweachter on Sunday May 03, 2015 @11:03PM (#9484078)
I don't know about aluminium smelters specifically, but I personally expect solar to invert the definition of off-peak electricity. Right now, electricity is cheaper at night because the demand is lower and coal plants have a minimum output, so anyone who needs a lot of electricity and can pick a time of day will use it at night. As solar becomes cheaper and more widespread, night-time electricity will become more expensive, because it is either stored in expensive batteries or generated from more expensive non-solar sources. So it seems likely to me that 10 or 20 years from now, electricity will be cheapest at noon and more expensive after dark.

Here's another fun thought: 6% of electricity is lost due to transmission costs. Will it be more efficient (in some cases, at least) to physically move charged batteries from solar fields to (nearer to) end users than to send it over the wire?

Re:Tesla battery storage will accelerate exit of coal genera... by brc on Sunday May 03, 2015 @11:15PM (#9484106)
>Here's another fun thought: 6% of electricity is lost due to transmission costs. Will it be more efficient (in some cases, at least) to physically move charged batteries from solar fields to (nearer to) end users than to send it over the wire?

No, not in this universe, anyway.

The most basic power distribution in the world is people with Ox and cart distributing lead/acid batteries to remote villages. Transmitting power this way is the least efficient way possible.

Re:Tesla battery storage will accelerate exit of coal genera... by saalweachter on Monday May 04, 2015 @07:28AM (#9485486)
I was thinking more like barges / rail cars that were essentially one giant battery, cycling back and forth. Even the most optimistic figure for current technology is still too high, about 0.03% / mile, so you only get about 200 miles (round trip) on a 6% budget. I suspect over-the-wire transmission losses are lower over that distance, but it's only a little impossible.
Re:Tesla battery storage will accelerate exit of coal genera... by mc808 on Monday May 04, 2015 @03:22AM (#9484784)
Regarding the 6% transmission costs, if you have 17 charged batteries and use 1 of them to power a self-driving vehicle with negligible maintenance costs (and in a future where all vehicles are electric), it would make sense to haul the other 16 within whatever distance the vehicle can manage on a charge.

It looks like a Tesla S battery pack is a little over 1,200 lbs. So for a rough estimate, consider the distance a Tesla S can tow 20,000 lbs. Probably not very far.

Unless I botched my reasoning somewhere, it looks like battery energy densities would have to increase by an order of magnitude or two for this to become a thing.

Re:Tesla battery storage will accelerate exit of coal genera... by joshvm on Monday May 04, 2015 @02:24AM (#9484616)
This has already happened somewhat in Germany. Solar panels have completely disrupted midday wholesale electricity prices. The effect is so strong that occasionally the spot price goes negative: if you're not producing renewable energy, you have to pay to put your energy into the grid.

http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/plugged-in/2014/10/07/en...

Re:Tesla battery storage will accelerate exit of coal genera... by lotsofmangos on Sunday May 03, 2015 @11:25PM (#9484132)
You are also not going to run your aluminum smelting plant for 18 hours out of the day on battery power!

Give it time.

In 2003, Alaska built the world's largest battery at 4.7MWh.

In 2012, China built the world's largest battery at 36MWh.

In 2014 Southern California Edison announced it was buying a 400MWh battery.

On that curve, we should be up to an 18GWh battery before all that long.

Re:Tesla battery storage will accelerate exit of coal genera... by dragontamer on Monday May 04, 2015 @12:25AM (#9484295)
In 1977, USA Built the world's largest "battery" at 30 GWh. That's right, 30 gigawatt hours. And yes, that's right, 1977... almost 40 years ago. It's not a chemical battery, but its a "battery" nonetheless in that it very efficiently stores electrical power.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bath_County_Pumped_Storage_Sta...

Pumped hydro electric storage ftw.

Re:Tesla battery storage will accelerate exit of coal genera... by ptaipale on Monday May 04, 2015 @01:17AM (#9484441)
Yep, those are nice - Bath Country is of course not the only one out there - but they don't come without their side effects. You need to construct a dam and sacrifice some area to be used as the reservoir. Those pesky environmentalists, you know...
Re:Tesla battery storage will accelerate exit of coal genera... by rimantas on Monday May 04, 2015 @05:43AM (#9485163)
Well, we are doing quite well for such a small country then: http://www.kruoniohae.lt/en/main/activity
Re:Tesla battery storage will accelerate exit of coal genera... by toomuchtodo on Sunday May 03, 2015 @11:50PM (#9484198)
Wow, that 400MWh battery is entirely lithium ion.

I would be shocked if Tesla Energy isn't assembling entire systems cargo container by cargo container in Reno and shipping them by rail across the country in the next 2-3 years.

Re:Tesla battery storage will accelerate exit of coal genera... by jaggederest on Sunday May 03, 2015 @11:53PM (#9484210)
Aluminum smelters already often have captive power plants, there's no reason why that trend won't accelerate.

http://www.vedantaaluminium.com/operations-cpp.htm

Re:Tesla battery storage will accelerate exit of coal genera... by brc on Sunday May 03, 2015 @11:25PM (#9484131)
Aluminium smelters typically sign long term power agreements at a fixed price anyway. They typically cannot take advantage of increasing production in times of cheap power because of their agreements.

Besides, an ability to increase production implies idle production capacity, which, as you state, is a poor use of capital allocation.

Lots of people see a few solar panels and tesla announcing sleek batteries, and think a new age is upon us. Not yet.

Re:Tesla battery storage will accelerate exit of coal genera... by Havoc on Monday May 04, 2015 @10:33AM (#9486337)
> think you're greatly overestimating the rate of the change

Take a look at Hawaii - the "rate of the change" is so big the utility pretty much stopped connecting people's PV panels because the grid couldn't deal with it.

As the percentage of renewables increases the fluctuations grow bigger. e.g. Germany already has 40GW of solar installed...so if its overcast then you need an entire fleet of nuclear plants to pick up the slack (sure it doesn't drop to 0GW but you get the point).

Those companies you mentioned that will still need power - not sure how that is relevant to the fluctuations? Or do you propose that they carry to cost for everyone?

Re:Tesla battery storage will accelerate exit of coal genera... by douche on Sunday May 03, 2015 @10:27PM (#9484001)
Do heavy industrial concerns with high power usage not already usually have an on-site gas or oil turbine to generate their own power and, often equally important, steam?

That's the situation I'm familiar with, but that may be a peculiarity of the under-developed grid in my area.

Re:Tesla battery storage will accelerate exit of coal genera... by fennecfoxen on Sunday May 03, 2015 @10:37PM (#9484022)
Turning bauxite into aluminum is an electrical process (they don't run on direct heat, steam, or mechanical power) and they use a lot of electricity (one reason aluminum-can recycling is such a big deal). Aluminum plants tend to end up in places with cheap electricity (especially hydroelectric) where they can absorb a lot of off-peak capacity as the power customer of last resort.
Re:Tesla battery storage will accelerate exit of coal genera... by brc on Sunday May 03, 2015 @11:28PM (#9484139)
Some do, but that implies on-site supply of gas (oil would not be used for aluminium production much).

Building smelters next to coal fields is a way of producing cheap aluminium. Coal is still the cheapest way to make electricity - it's only places where the government has explicitly made this not the case that coal is expensive.

Generally unfavourable government regulations simply moves production to places without the regulation - for no net change in production or coal consumption. Sometimes it's a net negative if the new location has lower local emissions standards and technology.

Re:Tesla battery storage will accelerate exit of coal genera... by olau on Monday May 04, 2015 @02:16AM (#9484596)
Please provide sources. This is not true for the country I live in for new generation. I read somewhere it's not true for Australia either.

People are sometimes fooled by sunk capital costs of old power plants.

Re:Tesla battery storage will accelerate exit of coal genera... by lotsofmangos on Sunday May 03, 2015 @10:36PM (#9484019)
If you have a good location for a hydroelectric reservoir, apart from it being remote from population areas and existing generation capacity, you might well stick a smelter and some solar next to it.